104
views
1
recommends
+1 Recommend
0
shares
    • Review: found
    Is Open Access

    Review of 'Metal-assisted polyatomic SIMS and laser desorption/ionization for enhanced small molecule imaging of bacterial biofilms'

    Bookmark
    5
    Metal-assisted polyatomic SIMS and laser desorption/ionization for enhanced small molecule imaging of bacterial biofilmsCrossref
    Average rating:
        Rated 5 of 5.
    Level of importance:
        Rated 5 of 5.
    Level of validity:
        Rated 5 of 5.
    Level of completeness:
        Rated 5 of 5.
    Level of comprehensibility:
        Rated 5 of 5.
    Competing interests:
    None

    Reviewed article

    • Record: found
    • Abstract: found
    • Article: not found

    Metal-assisted polyatomic SIMS and laser desorption/ionization for enhanced small molecule imaging of bacterial biofilms

    Mass spectrometry imaging (MSI) has become an important analytical tool for many sectors of science and medicine. As the application of MSI expands into new areas of inquiry, existing methodologies must be adapted and improved to meet emerging challenges. Particularly salient is the need for small molecule imaging methods that are compatible with complex multicomponent systems, a challenge that is amplified by the effects of analyte migration and matrix interference. With a focus on microbial biofilms from the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa , the relative advantages of two established microprobe-based MSI techniques—polyatomic secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) and laser desorption/ionization—are compared, with emphasis on exploring the effect of surface metallization on small molecule imaging. A combination of qualitative image comparison and multivariate statistical analysis demonstrates that sputtering microbial biofilms with a 2.5 nm layer of gold selectively enhances C 60 -SIMS ionization for several molecular classes including rhamnolipids and 2-alkyl-quinolones. Metallization also leads to the reduction of in-source fragmentation and subsequent ionization of media-specific background polymers, which improves spectral purity and image quality. These findings show that the influence of metallization upon ionization is strongly dependent on both the surface architecture and the analyte class, and further demonstrate that metal-assisted C 60 -SIMS is a viable method for small molecule imaging of intact molecular ions in complex biological systems.
      Bookmark

      Review information


      Review text

      ● If the objective is clear

      ● It is clear what the study found and how it did it.

      ● The title is informative and relevant.

      ● Are the references:

      ● Relevant

      ● Recent

      ● If mentioned correctly

      ● Appropriate key studies are included in the

       

      ● Whether it is clear what is already known about this topic
      ● Clearly defined research question
      ● For this topic, if the research question is justified

       

      ● The subject selection process is clear.
      ● If the variables are adequately defined and measured
      ● The study methods, if they are valid and reliable.
      ● Whether there are enough details to replicate the study

       

      ● Data is presented appropriately
      ● Tables and figures are relevant and clearly presented.
      ● Appropriate units, rounding, and number of decimal places
      ● Titles, columns and rows labeled correctly and clearly.
      ● Categories grouped appropriately
      ● The text of the results is added to the data.
      ● It is a statistically significant result.
      ● It is a significant result in practice

       

      Whether the results are discussed from multiple angles and placed in context without overinterpreting them
      ● If the conclusions respond to the objectives of the study
      ● The conclusions, if they are supported by references or results
      ● Are
      opportunities to inform future research

       

      It is adequate to answer the objective
      ● Added more interest than was already known about this topic.
      ● Defects of this article, it is brief.
      ● If it is coherent in itself

       

      ● If the objective is clear

      ● It is clear what the study found and how it did it.

      ● The title is informative and relevant.

      ● Are the references:

      ● Relevant

      ● Recent

      ● If mentioned correctly

      ● Appropriate key studies are included in the

       

      ● Whether it is clear what is already known about this topic
      ● Clearly defined research question
      ● For this topic, if the research question is justified

       

      ● The subject selection process is clear.
      ● If the variables are adequately defined and measured
      ● The study methods, if they are valid and reliable.
      ● Whether there are enough details to replicate the study

       

      ● Data is presented appropriately
      ● Tables and figures are relevant and clearly presented.
      ● Appropriate units, rounding, and number of decimal places
      ● Titles, columns and rows labeled correctly and clearly.
      ● Categories grouped appropriately
      ● The text of the results is added to the data.
      ● It is a statistically significant result.
      ● It is a significant result in practice

       

      Whether the results are discussed from multiple angles and placed in context without overinterpreting them
      ● If the conclusions respond to the objectives of the study
      ● The conclusions, if they are supported by references or results
      ● Are
      opportunities to inform future research

       

      It is adequate to answer the objective
      ● Added more interest than was already known about this topic.
      ● If it is coherent in itself

       

       

      Comments

      Comment on this review