Blog
About

225
views
0
recommends
+1 Recommend
3
shares
    • Review: found
    Is Open Access

    Review of 'Exploring the hydrological impact of increasing urbanisation on a tropical river catchment of the metropolitan Jakarta, Indonesia'

    Bookmark
    5
    Exploring the hydrological impact of increasing urbanisation on a tropical river catchment of the metropolitan Jakarta, IndonesiaCrossref
    Urbanisation and its hydrological side effect
    Average rating:
        Rated 5 of 5.
    Level of importance:
        Rated 5 of 5.
    Level of validity:
        Rated 5 of 5.
    Level of completeness:
        Rated 5 of 5.
    Level of comprehensibility:
        Rated 5 of 5.
    Competing interests:
    None

    Reviewed article

    • Record: found
    • Abstract: not found
    • Article: not found

    Exploring the hydrological impact of increasing urbanisation on a tropical river catchment of the metropolitan Jakarta, Indonesia

      Bookmark

      Review information

      10.14293/S2199-1006.1.SOR-UNCAT.AOAUZH.v1.RDVJLL

      This work has been published open access under Creative Commons Attribution License CC BY 4.0, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Conditions, terms of use and publishing policy can be found at www.scienceopen.com.

      Review text

      Review report

      Title: Exploring the hydrological impact of increasing urbanisation on a tropical river catchment of the metropolitan Jakarta, Indonesia

      Authors: Federica Remondi, Paolo Burlando, and Derek Vollmer

      DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2015.10.001

      The full paper in PDF can be downloaded 

      Introduction

      This paper explains the current situation (in 2015) of urbanisation and its impact to the hydrology of Ciliwung river. The authors tried to simulate the hydrological discharge of the river and identify its possible relationship with land use change, in which reflects the rate of urbanisation. The simulation was based on three water gauge stations in the Ciliwung river.

      General comments

      The paper shows land use change from the 1970’s until 2015. The red zone (settlement) had rapidly developed. This situation corresponds with the hydrological balance according to the analysis. The problem with the simulation, which had been mentioned also by the authors, were the lack of gauge stations, compared to the basin area of 385 km2 with very different topographical features. The government should give more attention to this issue, since many water management program would rely on the simulation like the one described in this paper.    

      This paper, along with other similar paper, should give a straightforward direction for the government to deal with flooding problems every year. One key point is for the government  

       

      Specific comments

      However for future research, I may suggest the following:

      • The term urbanisation should have clearly defined, because land use change would not have to be caused only by urbanisation. The intra-city-migration would also be one that have to be taken in to account. As the land and housing price increases in the mid city area, many people migrate to the suburban, and probably to the riverbank. 
      • The future research should also connect the hydrological condition with the change of socio-economic status in Jakarta area. A  be multi-disciplinary research should be conducted to deal with this matter.

      Closing

      More parties should present the results to the decision makers. This paper can be used as one argument to propose a consecutive water management plans.      

      Comments

      Comment on this review