Carotenoid biosynthesis is highly conserved and well characterized up to the synthesis of beta-carotene. Conversely, the synthesis of astaxanthin from beta-carotene is less well characterized. Regardless, astaxanthin is a highly sought natural product, due to its various industrial applications and elevated antioxidant capacity. In this article, 12 beta-carotene ketolase and 4 beta-carotene hydroxylase genes, isolated from 5 cyanobacterial species, are investigated for their function, and potential for microbial astaxanthin synthesis. Further, this in vivo comparison identifies and applies the most promising genetic elements within a dual expression vector, which is maintained in Escherichia coli. Here, combined overexpression of individual beta-carotene ketolase and beta-carotene hydroxylase genes, within a beta-carotene accumulating host, enables a 23.5-fold improvement in total carotenoid yield (1.99 mg g(-1)), over the parental strain, with >90% astaxanthin.