6,644

views

6

recommends

- Record: found
- Abstract: found
- Article: found

Joel H. Pitt^{1},
Helene Z. Hill^{*}^{,}^{2}

22 January 2016

ScienceOpen Research – Section: SOR-STAT

Statistical Forensics, Data Fabrication, Tissue Culture, Triplicate Colony Counts, Terminal Digit Analysis, Radiation Biology, Cell Biology

Scientific fraud is an increasingly vexing problem. Many current programs for fraud detection focus on image manipulation, while techniques for detection based on anomalous patterns that may be discoverable in the underlying numerical data get much less attention, even though these techniques are often easy to apply.

We applied statistical techniques in considering and and comparing data sets from 10 researchers in one laboratory and three outside investigators to determine whether anomalous patterns in data from a research teaching specialist (RTS) were likely to have occurred by chance. Rightmost digits of values in RTS data sets were not, as expected, uniform. Equal pairs of terminal digits occurred at higher than expected frequency (>10%) and an unexpectedly large number of data triples commonly produced in such research included values near their means as an element. We applied standard statistical tests (chi-square goodness of fit, binomial probabilities) to determine the likelihood of the first two anomalous patterns and developed a new statistical model to test the third.

Application of the three tests to various data sets reported by RTS resulted in repeated
rejection of the hypotheses (often at *p*-levels well below 0.001) that anomalous patterns in those data may have occurred
by chance. Similar application to data sets from other investigators was entirely
consistent with chance occurrence.

This analysis emphasizes the importance of access to raw data that form the bases of publications, reports, and grant applications in order to evaluate the correctness of the conclusions and the importance of applying statistical methods to detect anomalous, especially potentially fabricated, numerical results.

- Record: found
- Abstract: not found
- Article: not found

Richard van Hillegersberg (2011)

- Record: found
- Abstract: found
- Article: not found

Holly Carlisle (2012)

- Record: found
- Abstract: found
- Article: not found

Uri Simonsohn (2013)

SOR-STAT

ScienceOpen Research

ScienceOpen

2199-1006

22
January
2016

(ID: 8aa0f248-2bad-44c6-adfd-42816c14c272)

: 0
: 0

: 1-22
3526:XE

10.14293/S2199-1006.1.SOR-STAT.AFHTWC.v1

© 2016 Pitt et al.

This work has been published open access under Creative Commons Attribution License
**CC BY 4.0**, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided
the original work is properly cited. Conditions, terms of use and publishing policy
can be found at **www.scienceopen.com**.

Figures: 2, Tables: 3, References: 28, Pages: 22

Original article

ScienceOpen disciplines: | Medicine, Cell biology, Statistics, Radiology & Imaging, Life sciences |

Keywords: | triplicate colony counts, terminal digit analysis, cell biology, data fabrication, tissue culture, statistical forensics, radiation biology |

Stephanie DeGraaf wrote:

2017-01-31 17:25 UTC

+1Stephanie DeGraaf wrote:

2017-01-31 17:18 UTC

+1Stephanie DeGraaf wrote:

2017-01-26 21:17 UTC

+1Stephanie DeGraaf wrote: