The p-methoxy-substituted pincer-ligated iridium complexes, (MeO-(tBu)PCP)IrH(4) ((R)PCP
= kappa(3)-C(6)H(3)-2,6-(CH(2)PR(2))(2)) and (MeO-(iPr)PCP)IrH(4), are found to be
highly effective catalysts for the dehydrogenation of alkanes (both with and without
the use of sacrificial hydrogen acceptors). These complexes offer an interesting comparison
with the recently reported bis-phosphinite "POCOP" ((R)POCOP = kappa(3)-C(6)H(3)-2,6-(OPR(2))(2))
pincer-ligated catalysts, which also show catalytic activity higher than unsubstituted
PCP analogues (Gottker-Schnetmann, I.; White, P.; Brookhart, M. J. Am. Chem. Soc.
2004, 126, 1804). On the basis of nu(CO) values of the respective CO adducts, the
MeO-PCP complexes appear to be more electron-rich than the parent PCP complexes, whereas
the POCOP complexes appear to be more electron-poor. However, the MeO-PCP and POCOP
ligands are calculated (DFT) to show effects in the same directions, relative to the
parent PCP ligand, for the kinetics and thermodynamics of a broad range of reactions
including the addition of C-H and H-H bonds and CO. In general, both ligands favor
(relative to unsubstituted PCP) addition to the 14e (pincer)Ir fragments but disfavor
addition to the 16e complexes (pincer)IrH(2) or (pincer)Ir(CO). These kinetic and
thermodynamic effects are all largely attributable to the same electronic feature:
O --> C(aryl) pi-donation, from the methoxy or phosphinito groups of the respective
ligands. DFT calculations also indicate that the kinetics (but not the thermodynamics)
of C-H addition to (pincer)Ir are favored by sigma-withdrawal from the phosphorus
atoms. The high nu(CO) value of (POCOP)Ir(CO) is attributable to electrostatic effects,
rather than decreased Ir-CO pi-donation or increased OC-Ir sigma-donation.