Elucidating three-way interactions between soil, pasture and animals that regulate nitrous oxide emissions from temperate grazing systems

Highlights

• •

  Urinary nitrogen concentrations were lowest on animals consuming high sugar grasses.

• •

  However, soil under high sugar grasses recorded the highest N ₂O emissions.

• •

  Synthetic urine generated N ₂O emissions inconsistent with locally collected urine.

• •

  Differences in emissions amongst systems were explained by gene abundance ratios.

• •

  Results indicate the importance of soil-pasture-animal-microbiome interactions.

Abstract

Pasture-based livestock farming contributes considerably to global emissions of nitrous oxide (N ₂O), a powerful greenhouse gas approximately 265 times more potent than carbon dioxide. Traditionally, the estimation of N ₂O emissions from grasslands is carried out by means of plot-scale experiments, where externally sourced animal excreta are applied to soils to simulate grazing conditions. This approach, however, fails to account for the impact of different sward types on the composition of excreta and thus the functionality of soil microbiomes, creating unrealistic situations that are seldom observed under commercial agriculture. Using three farming systems under contrasting pasture management strategies at the North Wyke Farm Platform, an instrumented ruminant grazing trial in Devon, UK, this study measured N ₂O emissions from soils treated with cattle urine and dung collected within each system as well as standard synthetic urine shared across all systems, and compared these values against those from two forms of controls with and without inorganic nitrogen fertiliser applications. Soil microbial activity was regularly monitored through gene abundance to evaluate interactions between sward types, soil amendments, soil microbiomes and, ultimately, N ₂O production. Across all systems, N ₂O emissions attributable to cattle urine and standard synthetic urine were found to be inconsistent with one another due to discrepancy in nitrogen content. Despite previous findings that grasses with elevated levels of water-soluble carbohydrates tend to generate lower levels of N ₂O, the soil under high sugar grass monoculture in this study recorded higher emissions when receiving excreta from cattle fed the same grass. Combined together, our results demonstrate the importance of evaluating environmental impacts of agriculture at a system scale, so that the feedback mechanisms linking soil, pasture, animals and microbiomes are appropriately considered.