Clustered brachiopod Hox genes are not expressed collinearly and are associated with lophotrochozoan novelties

Significance

Hox genes pattern the anteroposterior axis of all animals that have left and right body sides. In many animals, Hox genes are clustered along the chromosomes and expressed in spatial and temporal order. This coordinated regulation is thought to have preserved the cluster through a developmental constraint. Our study of the genomic organization and the embryonic spatial and temporal expression of Hox genes in sessile marine animals called lampshells (brachiopods) shows that along with having a broken Hox cluster, they lack both temporal and spatial collinearity. Furthermore, we present molecular evidence that the hard tissues (chaetae and shells) of segmented worms, mollusks, and brachiopods share a common origin that dates back to the Early Cambrian.

Abstract

Temporal collinearity is often considered the main force preserving Hox gene clusters in animal genomes. Studies that combine genomic and gene expression data are scarce, however, particularly in invertebrates like the Lophotrochozoa. As a result, the temporal collinearity hypothesis is currently built on poorly supported foundations. Here we characterize the complement, cluster, and expression of Hox genes in two brachiopod species, Terebratalia transversa and Novocrania anomala. T. transversa has a split cluster with 10 genes ( lab, pb, Hox3, Dfd, Scr, Lox5, Antp, Lox4, Post2, and Post1), whereas N. anomala has 9 genes (apparently missing Post1). Our in situ hybridization, real-time quantitative PCR, and stage-specific transcriptomic analyses show that brachiopod Hox genes are neither strictly temporally nor spatially collinear; only pb (in T. transversa), Hox3 (in both brachiopods), and Dfd (in both brachiopods) show staggered mesodermal expression. Thus, our findings support the idea that temporal collinearity might contribute to keeping Hox genes clustered. Remarkably, expression of the Hox genes in both brachiopod species demonstrates cooption of Hox genes in the chaetae and shell fields, two major lophotrochozoan morphological novelties. The shared and specific expression of Hox genes, together with Arx, Zic, and Notch pathway components in chaetae and shell fields in brachiopods, mollusks, and annelids provide molecular evidence supporting the conservation of the molecular basis for these lophotrochozoan hallmarks.