Suture tape augmentation of the lateral ulnar collateral ligament increases load to failure in simulated posterolateral rotatory instability

Recurrent posterolateral rotatory instability of the elbow is an apparently undescribed clinical condition that is difficult to diagnose. We treated five patients, ranging in age from five to forty years, who had such a lesion and in whom the instability could be demonstrated only by what we call the posterolateral rotatory-instability test. This test involves supination of the forearm and application of a valgus moment and an axial compression force to the elbow while it is flexed from full extension. The elbow is reduced in full extension and must be subluxated as it is flexed in order to obtain a positive test result (a sudden reduction of the subluxation). Flexion of more than about 40 degrees produces a sudden palpable and visible reduction of the radiohumeral joint. The elbow does not subluxate without provocation. The cause for this condition, we think, is laxity of the ulnar part of the lateral collateral ligament, which allows a transient rotatory subluxation of the ulnohumeral joint and a secondary dislocation of the radiohumeral joint. The annular ligament remains intact, so the radio-ulnar joint does not dislocate. Operative repair of the lax ulnar part of the lateral collateral ligament eliminated the posterolateral rotatory instability, as revealed intraoperatively in our five patients.

The number of throwing athletes with ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) injuries has increased recently, with a seemingly exponential increase of such injuries in adolescents. In cases of acute proximal or distal UCL insertion injuries or in partial-thickness injuries that do not respond to nonoperative management, UCL repair and augmentation rather than reconstruction may be a viable option.

The long-term results after treatment of simple dislocation of the elbow in fifty-two adults were evaluated with regard to limitation of motion, pain, instability, and residual neurovascular deficit. All patients were treated with traditional closed reduction, but the duration of immobilization before commencement of active motion varied. Goniometric, photographic, and radiographic data were compiled for these patients, who had an average follow-up of 34.4 months. Despite the generally favorable prognosis for this injury, 60 per cent of the patients reported some symptoms on follow-up. A flexion contracture of more than 30 degrees was documented in 15 per cent of the patients; residual pain, in 45 per cent; and pain on valgus stress, in 35 per cent. Prolonged immobilization after injury was strongly associated with an unsatisfactory result. The longer the immobilization had been, the larger the flexion contracture (p less than 0.001) and the more severe the symptoms of pain were. The results indicate that early active motion is the key factor in rehabilitation of the elbow after a dislocation.