Schizophrenia is a multi-factorial disease characterized by a high heritability and
environmental risk factors (e.g., social stress and cannabis use). It is the combined
action of multiple genes of small effect size (Owen et al., 2005) and a number of
environmental risk factors (McGrath et al., 2004), which causes the development of
this mental disorder (Mackay-Sim et al., 2004). This is conceptualized in the “Two-Hit
Hypothesis” of schizophrenia, which predicts that genetic and environmental risk factors
interactively (GxE interaction) cause the development of the disorder (Bayer et al.,
1999; Caspi and Moffitt, 2006). GxE interactions occur when the expression of an individual's
genetic predisposition is dependent on the environment they are living in or when
environmental influences on a trait differ according to an individual's genome (Tsuang
et al., 2004). Human studies have confirmed that nature and nurture are both important
in the development of schizophrenia: the concordance rate in monozygotic twins is
only around 50% (Tsuang et al., 2001) and genome wide association studies fail to
identify major genetic candidates for schizophrenia (Sanders et al., 2008) suggesting
an important role of environmental factors in the development of this disorder.
Research into GxE is starting to produce valuable new animal models and has revealed
novel insights into the pathophysiology of schizophrenia. This work will help advance
our understanding of the molecular pathways involved in this mental disorder and will
lead to more specific treatment avenues. Furthermore, understanding GxE interactions
will guide the development of new preventative measures (i.e., people genetically
predisposed to schizophrenia will be able to minimize exposure to critical environmental
risk factors). However, these outcomes are a long way ahead and the complexity of
this multi-factorial line of research has also caused difficulties in data interpretation
and comparison. Thus, this research topic is intended to cover past and current directions
in research dedicated to the understanding of GxE interactions in schizophrenia, the
molecular, neurobiological, and behavioral consequences of these interactions, and
potential mechanisms involved.
Animal models can incorporate highly standardized genetic and environmental risk factors
at critical stages of brain development. These models thereby attempt to mimic the
etiology of schizophrenia and help elucidate relevant interactions between GxE and
the underlying mechanisms. In this Research Topic, Cash-Padgett and Jaaro-Peled outline
how either early immune activation (i.e., PolyI:C treatment) or forms of social stress
(i.e., social isolation, chronic social defeat) influence the development of schizophrenia-relevant
phenotypes in a number of genetic mouse models for the schizophrenia susceptibility
gene Disrupted in schizophrenia-1 (DISC1). Their review concludes that animal models
can be instrumental in linking the relevance of GxE interactions to a particular neuropsychiatric
disorder. Furthermore, “environmental interaction profiles” can be developed for major
risk genes such as DISC1 (Cash-Padgett and Jaaro-Peled, 2013). Karl as well as Chohan
and co-workers focus on the role the schizophrenia susceptibility gene neuregulin
1 (NRG1) might play in the context of GxE interactions. Karl's review overviews a
raft of evidence supporting Nrg1 as a key player in the vulnerability of mice to environmental
(risk) factors such as stress, cannabis abuse and housing conditions (Karl, 2013).
Following on from recent published work (Chohan et al., 2014a), Chohan et al. describes
research in which partial genetic deletion of Nrg1 modulates the effects of adolescent
stress on N-methyl-d-aspartate receptors (NMDAR), with the Nrg1-stress interaction
tending to decrease NMDAR binding in the medial prefrontal cortex (Chohan et al.,
2014b). This is significant as NMDAR is decreased in brains of schizophrenia patients
and implicated in the pathophysiology of the disorder. In another research paper,
Klug and van den Buuse investigate the effects of young-adult cannabinoid exposure
on BDNF deficient mice and find no interaction in this GxE model on learning and memory
later in life. Their research highlights that not all GxE models produce interactive
effects and that the role of BDNF in conferring vulnerability to the actions of cannabis
may be sex-dependent and only evident after pre-exposure to the drug (Klug and van
den Buuse, 2013).
Jiang and coworkers provide an excellent review outlining the potential mechanisms
behind established GxE interactions using mice with conditional knock down of NMDAR
in cortical and hippocampal interneurons during early postnatal development. They
suggest that NMDAR hypofunction and social isolation stress interact to disturb parvalbumin-positive
(PV) interneurons via oxidative stress mediated by the transcriptional coactivator
peroxisome proliferator activated receptor γ coactivator 1α (PGC-1α) (Jiang et al.,
2013). Reductions in PV expression have been noted in schizophrenia brain and may
help explain asynchrony of neuronal networks (Lewis and Gonzalez-Burgos, 2006). Showing
that oxidative stress is responsible for PV interneuron dysfunction resonates with
the recent interest in antioxidants such as fish oil as new treatments for mental
disorder, particularly prior to disease onset. Extending on the idea of early intervention
treatments as the key to treating schizophrenia is the research paper of Van Vugt
and colleagues who show that a lack of early maternal care exacerbated schizophrenia-relevant
phenotypes in a pharmacological model of the disorder (Van Vugt et al., 2014).
Girardi and coworkers also utilize maternal deprivation to investigate another aspect
of the “Two-Hit Hypothesis” of schizophrenia, namely, environment x environment interactions
(ExE). They report that maternally deprived rats are vulnerable to the effects of
a very mild stress procedure (i.e., saline injection) on corticosterone levels and
social behaviors (Girardi et al., 2014). This study is important for studies into
GxE interactions, as researchers must be aware that even a relatively minor intervention
such as an i.p. injection can modify the stress response in an established environmental
model of schizophrenia. Thus, ExE (as well as GxExE) interactions exist and could
have a significant impact on established GxE model systems. Within this context, Turner
and Burne point out that housing conditions and genetic background both impact on
cognitive behaviors of rodents. As cognition is an important domain for the evaluation
of face validity of rodent models for schizophrenia, rodent strain and housing conditions
must carefully be considered when developing novel model systems for GxE (Turner and
Burne, 2013). The last two studies are in line with what is discussed by Burrows and
Hannan. Their opinion paper outlines the need for more accurate and sophisticated
GxE animal models of schizophrenia and the impact “unexpected” housing conditions
can have on genetic mouse models. Environmental factors with clinical relevance should
be manipulated to broaden the relevance of preclinical research beyond “standard laboratory
housing” and to understand how a decanalized brain produces suboptimal phenotypes'
(Burrows and Hannan, 2013).
Godar and Bortolato review evidence suggesting that gene x sex interactions (GxS)
are also evident in schizophrenia as well particularly when focusing on genes involved
in dopamine pathways. They outline that genes encoding enzymes that regulate dopamine
levels, such as catechol-O-methyl transferase (COMT) and monoamine oxidase, are sexually
dimorphic and the impact of sex hormones on their regulation may play a significant
role in shaping the course of schizophrenia (Godar and Bortolato, 2014). This is particularly
relevant seeing males tend to manifest the disorder earlier than females. Sexual dimorphism
also influences GxE as highlighted above in the work of Klug and co-workers (Klug
and van den Buuse, 2013) and as noted in various studies reviewed by Karl (2013) in
this Research Topic. Importantly, COMT has been shown to be a good candidate for GxE
interactions as the gene interacts with adolescent cannabis abuse (Caspi and Moffitt,
2006). Finally, Miller assessed the impact of photic cues on the development of schizophrenia.
Her argument for a role for photic cues in the disorder is made more compelling given
that single nucleotide polymorphisms have been found in genes relevant to schizophrenia,
which are modulated by photoperiod and sunlight intensity (Miller, 2013).
GxE interactions appear to be complex and sensitive to a number of subtle variables,
but do exist and justify the need for future research in this area (Van Os et al.,
2010). Animal researchers should focus on models with significant relevance to schizophrenia
such as cannabis abuse, maternal immunization, or early life stress and consider a
number of genetic candidates for GxE interactions. Importantly, some of the articles
of this topic suggest that valid GxE animal models will be very sensitive to the laboratory
environment, which demands a high level of transparency and standardization of test
conditions as well as thorough consideration of housing conditions across research
sites. Furthermore, it should be mentioned that there are discussions about the appropriate
statistical modeling of GxE interactions, which influence both animal and human research
(Zammit et al., 2010).
To conclude, animal models have provided compelling evidence for GxE in schizophrenia
based on the greater experimental control possible and the ability to manipulate specific
genes and environmental factors. While such studies cannot reproduce the entire complexity
of schizophrenia, they do provide simplified multifactorial models of aspects of the
condition. These, in turn, allow new molecular and neurobiological insights to be
gained and novel drug targets to be discovered.
Conflict of interest statement
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial
or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.