8
views
0
recommends
+1 Recommend
0 collections
    0
    shares
      • Record: found
      • Abstract: found
      • Article: found
      Is Open Access

      Evaluation and Comparison of Contemporary Energy-Based Surgical Vessel Sealing Devices

      research-article

      Read this article at

      Bookmark
          There is no author summary for this article yet. Authors can add summaries to their articles on ScienceOpen to make them more accessible to a non-specialist audience.

          Abstract

          Introduction: We evaluated and compared five currently available energy-based vessel sealing devices to assess typical surgical metrics.

          Methods: We tested Caiman 5 (C5), Harmonic Scalpel Ace Plus (HA), Harmonic Ace +7 (HA7), LigaSure (LS), and Enseal G2 (ES) on small (2–5 mm), medium (5.1–7 mm), and large (7.1–9 mm) vessels obtained from 15 Yorkshire pigs. Vessels were randomly sealed and transected. We recorded sealing and transection time, charring and carbonization, thermal spread, and bursting pressure (BP). Specimens were sent for histopathologic evaluation of seal quality and thermal spread.

          Results: A total of 246 vessels were evaluated: 125 were arteries and 121 were veins. There was no difference in BPs for small size arteries. For medium arteries, C5 provided the highest BP (proximal and distal jaw), followed by HA7, ES, LS, and HA [1740, 1600, 1165, 1165, 981, and 571 mm Hg, respectively, HA<C5-D(<0.001); HA<C5-P(<0.001); HA<ES(0.002); HA<HA7(0.002); HA7<C5-P(0.026); ES<C5-P(0.026); LS<C5-P(0.001); LS<C5-D(0.014)]. For large arteries, C5 and LS provided highest BP followed by HA7, ES, and HA [1676, 530, 467, 467, and 254 mm Hg, respectively, C5<HA(<0.001); C5<HA7(0.006); C5<ES(0.006); C5<LS(0.012)]. There were no bursting pressure failures for C5, HA7, and LS up to 9 mm vessels. For medium and large size arteries, HA had bursting failure of 20% and 40%, respectively. The ES was significantly less efficient with small, medium, and large arteries with bursting failure rates of 10%, 40%, and 80%, respectively.

          Conclusions: In this study, C5 outperformed all other devices. However, all of the devices provide a seal that was superphysiologic in that all burst pressures were >250 mm Hg.

          Related collections

          Most cited references16

          • Record: found
          • Abstract: found
          • Article: not found

          High-burst-strength, feedback-controlled bipolar vessel sealing.

          The inherent tedium of intracorporeal knot tying has stimulated greater interest in energy-based and mechanical alternatives for hemostasis. Three hundred thirty-one arteries and veins were sealed by application of precisely controlled electrothermal energy and physical pressure, allowing for brief cooling in compression, in experimental animals and fresh abattoir vessels. These seals were compared for bursting strength with occlusions by ultrasonic and bipolar coagulation, surgical clips, and ligatures. Ultrasonic and bipolar occlusions were significantly less likely to have burst strengths greater than 400 mmHg as compared with seals, clips, and ligatures (p < 0.001). Seal competence could be visually assessed by its translucence. Precise energy control with physical compression, including a brief cooldown, produces a distinctive, translucent seal of partially denatured protein that can typically be transected after a single application. These seals have bursting strengths comparable to those of clips and ligatures and resist dislodgement because they are intrinsic to the vessel wall structure.
            Bookmark
            • Record: found
            • Abstract: found
            • Article: not found

            Comparison of blood vessel sealing among new electrosurgical and ultrasonic devices.

            Bipolar electrosurgical devices and ultrasonic devices are routinely used in open and advanced laparoscopic surgery for hemostasis. New electrosurgical and ultrasonic instruments demonstrate improved quality and efficiency in blood vessel sealing. The 5-mm laparoscopic Gyrus PKS Cutting Forceps (PK), Gyrus Plasma Trissector (GP), Harmonic Scalpel (HS), EnSeal Tissue Sealing and Hemostasis System (RX), LigaSure V with LigaSure Vessel Sealing Generator (LS), LigaSure V with Force Triad Generator (FT), and Ligamax 5 Endoscopic Multiple Clip Applier (LM) were tested to compare burst pressure, sealing time, and failure rate. Each device was used to seal 13 small (2-3 mm diameter), 13 medium (4-5 mm diameter), and 13 large (6-7 mm diameter) arteries from euthanized pigs. A p value <0.05 was considered statistically significant. Mean burst pressures were not statistically different for 2-3 mm or 6-7 mm vessels. For 4-5 mm vessels, LS had the highest mean burst pressure recorded. Mean seal times were shorter for every vessel size when FT was compared with LS (p < 0.05). The shortest sealing times for 2-3 mm vessels were recorded for GP. The shortest sealing times for medium and large vessels were observed with FT. The highest percentage failure rate for each vessel size occurred with GP. For 4-5 mm diameter vessels, the failure rate was 48% for GP, 41% for PK, and 22% for HS. For 6-7 mm diameter vessels, the failure rate was 92% for GP, 41% for PK, and 8% for HS. LM and FT had no recorded failures. Among the new 5-mm laparoscopic electrosurgical and ultrasonic instruments available for testing, RX, LS, and FT produced the highest mean burst pressures. FT had the shortest mean seal times for medium and large vessels. Minimal or no seal failures occurred with HS, RX, LS, LM, and FT.
              Bookmark
              • Record: found
              • Abstract: found
              • Article: not found

              Real-time thermography during energized vessel sealing and dissection.

              Energized dissection systems facilitate laparoscopic dissection and hemostasis and reduce instrument traffic. However, they can introduce undesirable thermal collateral/proximity damage to adjacent structures mainly by heat conduction, although other mechanisms may be involved. The latest generation devices have the potential to reduce the incidence of such problems through use of active feedback control over the power output. This effectively regulates the delivery of energy to the target tissue with minimal thermal collateral damage. In addition, innovative heat-sink engineering of the device head ensures that the surface of the instrument tip remains cool (<45 degrees C). In this study, we evaluated the performance of this technology (LigaSure) by using dynamic infrared thermography. The thermal imaging measurements were then correlated with histopathologic studies. The overall value of in situ thermography as an adjunct to energized surgical dissection systems was also assessed. Eight anesthetized pigs underwent open surgery to mobilize eight target vessels/organs in a randomized fashion. The LigaSure vessel sealing system with Instant Response Technology was used with three different interchangeable heads. In situ dynamic thermography was undertaken with a thermal imaging camera operating in the mid-infrared (3-5 microm) waveband and with each fully digitized 12-bit thermographic frame acquired at a rate of 60 Hz. Following sacrifice at the end of the dissection, tissue from the dissected regions was harvested for histology by an independent pathologist who was blinded to the thermographic data. Seals made with both the LS1000 5-mm laparoscopic head (predominantly to the small bowel and colon) and the LS1100 10-mm (Atlas) device (on the liver and short gastric tissues) were outwardly satisfactory. The average thermal spread [see text] with the LS1000 was = [see text] 4.4 mm, and the exposed surface of the instrument tip developed a temperature of approximately 100 degrees C. This instrument thus has the potential, albeit small, for heat-related proximity iatrogenic injury. The more technologically advanced LS1100 10-mm laparoscopic instrument exhibited a superior performance, with [see text] = 1.8 mm, and with a maximal temperature on the exposed surface of the jaws well within tolerable limits (approximately 35 degrees C) for use during surgery (laparoscopic or open). This was confirmed by histological studies that demonstrated negligible evidence of thermal damage. In situ thermal imaging represents a powerful modality for the monitoring of energized dissection/coagulation during surgery. The LigaSure system used with the LS1100 head constitutes a very safe option for energized dissection and hemostasis of vessels with a diameter of up to approximately 7 mm.
                Bookmark

                Author and article information

                Journal
                J Endourol
                J. Endourol
                end
                Journal of Endourology
                Mary Ann Liebert, Inc. (140 Huguenot Street, 3rd FloorNew Rochelle, NY 10801USA )
                0892-7790
                1557-900X
                01 April 2018
                01 April 2018
                01 April 2018
                : 32
                : 4
                : 329-337
                Affiliations
                [ 1 ]Department of Urology, University of California , Irvine, Orange, California.
                [ 2 ]Department of Urology, University of California , Irvine, Orange, California.
                [ 3 ]Department of Pathology, Duke University , Durham, North Carolina.
                [ 4 ]Department of Pathology, University of California , Irvine, Orange, California.
                Author notes
                Address correspondence to: Jaime Landman, MD, Department of Urology, University of California, Irvine 333 City Boulevard West, Suite 2100, Orange, CA 92868, E-mail: landmanj@ 123456uci.edu
                Article
                10.1089/end.2017.0596
                10.1089/end.2017.0596
                5909080
                29463122
                ae4f0ed4-c14c-4e3b-a46c-135cb0cb070a
                © Zhamshid Okhunov, et al., 2018; Published by Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.

                This Open Access article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons License ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

                History
                Page count
                Figures: 4, Tables: 5, References: 17, Pages: 9
                Categories
                Experimental Endourology

                vessel sealing technologies,laparoscopic hemostasis,surgical energy devices,ligasure,harmonic scalpel,enseal,caiman

                Comments

                Comment on this article