The Belfast Medical Society – a forerunner of the Ulster Medical Society – was founded
in 1806. Following the Act of Union, in 1801, Ireland lost its own Parliament but
Dublin remained the administrative capital of the country. Indeed, at that time, many
regarded Dublin as the second city in the Empire. It was only natural that all the
seats of learning – University and College – had been established there. Dublin University
(Trinity College) had been granted a Royal Charter by Queen Elizabeth I in 1593. However,
a medical school was not established in the college until 1711.1 The College of Physicians
in Ireland was granted its Charter by King Charles II in 1667. In the reign of William
and Mary in 1692, it was granted another Charter which enabled it to grant licences
in Medicine and Midwifery.
The College of Surgeons was granted its Charter by King George III in 1784. It appointed
its first Professor of Midwifery in 1785. It was not until 1828 that the College established
a Diploma in Midwifery and one in Diseases of Women and Children. In 1745, a Charter
was granted to the Society of Apothecaries which enabled its officers to control the
manufacture and sales of medicines in Ireland. In 1837 a School of Medicine was established.
The paper has been divided into four main sections:
What was the State of Midwifery in 1806?
Developments from 1806 - 1921 when Northern Ireland was established.
Developments from 1921-1948 when the National Health Service started.
Developments from 1948 - 2006.
WHAT WAS THE STATE OF MIDWIFERY IN 1806?
In Wilson's Almanac of 1775 in Dublin there were 112 registered physicians and surgeons.2
Only 12 were licensed to practise midwifery. In 1770, lectures in Midwifery for medical
students and midwives had commenced in the Rotunda Hospital. There are no details
of the content of either the lectures or the numbers who attended.
Physicians were the only medical practitioners to have even a smattering of scientific
training. Surgeons and apothecaries received their training as apprentices. Regulations
as regards qualifications and the right to practise were rarely enforced.
The position of obstetricians (“men midwives”) was even poorer. Midwifery was looked
upon by physicians as totally beneath their high calling. In case of difficulty they
were sometimes called in consultation, but as they had never studied the subject,
their advice was of little use. The situation for midwives was even worse. In 1692
the College had been empowered to examine and license midwives. In the following 50
years only four had been granted a licence to practise. Indeed in 1753, the College
issued a statement in which they refused to license in medicine any person who practised
midwifery. Midwifery was learned the hard way – both for the patient and attendant.
A few doctors went abroad to study the subject.
Bartholomew Mosse (
fig 1
) studied the subject in Holland and France. His friend Fielding Ould studied in Paris.
Ould obtained a licence from the College of Physicians to practise midwifery. In 1769
he delivered the Countess of Mornington, near Dublin when she was returning from a
holiday in the family home in Belvoir Park, Belfast. The baby, a boy, later became
the Duke of Wellington, the victor of the Battle of Waterloo. After he had been knighted
for his services to the Countess he applied to Trinity College to be examined in Medicine.
The authorities of Trinity and the College of Physicians had an agreement not to award
a degree in Medicine to one who practised Midwifery! After acrimonious negotiations,
both Trinity and the College eventually awarded him a degree in Medicine.
Pregnancy was regarded as a normal event so no special attention had been given to
pregnant women during the antenatal period and in labour. When Mosse returned to Dublin
in 1742 he was horrified at the conditions in which poor pregnant women lived, were
delivered and reared their children. He wrote “Their lodgings are generally in cold
garrets open to every wind, or in damp cellars subject to floods from excessive rains;
themselves destitute of attendance, medicines and often proper food; by which hundreds
perish with their little infants and the community is at once deprived of mother and
child.”
He immediately decided to help. He collected money from friends and opened, in 1745,
the Dublin Lying–In Hospital in Great George's Street. It contained facilities for
twelve beds. This was the first lying-in hospital in Ireland and the second in the
British Isles – the forerunner of Queen Charlotte's had been opened in London in 1739.
In 1787 he had collected sufficient funds to open a larger hospital, still known today
as the Rotunda Hospital, a name taken from the Concert Hall built in the grounds of
the hospital and used as a source of income for the hospital.
In Belfast conditions for pregnant women were the same as in Dublin. In contrast to
the work of Mosse and his friends, doctors did not take part in the establishment
of the first lying-in hospital. The suggestion to provide one had been made by the
Revd John Clark, then a curate in St Anne's Church. A charity called “The Humane Female
Society for the Relief of Lying-In Women” was established at a meeting in the Linen
Hall in 1793. The original 180 members subscribed 10s 6d each per year. A house, 25
Donegall Street, (
fig 2
) was rented. It held six beds for patients. It opened in 1794. During 1803, sixty
three women were delivered. The resident staff was a midwife and a maid. If difficulties
arose the midwife had permission to call in a Dr Stephenson for advice.
DEVELOPMENTS FROM 1806 – 1921
In 1806 all pregnant women were delivered at home except the few who were admitted
to the lying-in hospitals in Dublin and Belfast. The majority were delivered by ‘handy-women’
– ladies who had no training but had learned from older women or their own experiences
of pregnancy and labour.
The population of Belfast increased dramatically – due to the ravages of the famine
during the 1840's in the West and South of the country. In addition, there was rapid
industrialisation in the City with the development of a cotton manufacturing industry,
followed by the linen industry – both employing mainly female workers. At the same
time there was also a rapid development in shipbuilding, which, of course, employed
men.
In 1806 the population was 22,000. There were 19 doctors2 in the city. In 1831 the
population was 50,000 while in 1881 it had risen to 100,000. At the end of the century
it was 348,180.3 This rapid expansion led to gross overcrowding which in turn led
to a series of epidemics with a very high mortality.
The Rev W M O'Hanlon's letters in the Northern Whig drew attention to the deplorable
conditions of the poor who inhabited the back streets, courts and alleys of the rapidly
expanding and populous town. The letters were later published in a book.4 In that
year (1882) Dr Andrew Malcolm5 read a paper to the British Association which was holding
its meeting in Belfast. He gave proof of the connection between filth and fever. He
reported that in the epidemic during 1847, 70% of the homes deficient in sewerage
had fever while in those with such facilities only 19% had the problem. He calculated
that in 1852 the average age of death in Belfast was nine years because infant mortality
was absolutely excessive. It was in these homes that women were delivered.
Developments in the Speciality
The establishment of lying-in hospitals stimulated interest in and research into the
care of pregnant women and drew attention to the necessity of improvements in the
practice of Midwifery.
The first development was the result of work carried out by a doctor from Northern
Ireland in Paris, and later in Dublin. John Creevy Ferguson was born in Tandragee,
Co Armagh in 1802. His father, an apothecary, moved to Dublin to enable his family
to have a better life. The boy was educated in Dublin and enrolled in the Trinity
Medical School from which he graduated in 1823. In that year, he went to Edinburgh
with his friend William Stokes for one year and then went to Paris for another year.
In 1816, Laennec had invented the first stethoscope. Ferguson met him and his colleague
de Kergardac. The latter invited him to listen to the abdomen of a pregnant patient
in anticipation of hearing the fetus splash in the liquor. Instead he heard the fetal
heart. Thus, Ferguson was the first person from the British Isles to hear the fetal
heart. He returned to Dublin. He commenced practice as a physician but demonstrated
the use of the instrument to colleagues in the Rotunda Hospital. It was immediately
introduced into the routine work in the hospital. In 1833, Evory Kennedy, while Master
of the Rotunda, published his experiences of fetal auscultation. Many readers believed
that he had introduced the stethoscope into obstetric practice!
Fortunately, Ferguson6 had read a paper to members of the Association of Fellows and
Licentiates of King's and Queen's College of Physicians in Ireland in November 1829.
In the paper he described the use of the stethoscope in three women to confirm the
diagnosis of pregnancy. He was appointed in turn Professor of Medicine in Apothecaries
Hall 1832, Professor of Medicine in Trinity College in 1846 and finally moving to
Belfast in 1850, he became the first Professor of Medicine in the new faculty of Queen's
College. In 1862 he became the first President of the Ulster Medical Society which
had been formed by the amalgamation of the Belfast Medical and the Belfast Clinical
and Pathological Societies.
Professor JHM Pinkerton7 extensively researched the life and work of Professor Ferguson.
He found a photograph of Ferguson in the College of Physicians in Dublin. At the conclusion
of his lecture to the Society he presented a photograph of Ferguson to Dr Margaret
Haire, the then President, for display in the Society Rooms.
Intermittent fetal monitoring using the fetal stethoscope has now been used for many
years during antenatal examinations and regularly during the course of labour. Irregularities
in the heart rate were regarded as a sign of fetal distress. Recently its use in practice
has been replaced by ultra-sound studies.
The second development in the diagnosis of pregnancy also took place in Dublin. William
Featherstone Montgomery (
fig 3
) was born in Dublin in 1797 and died there in 1859. In 1829 he had been appointed
as the first Professor of Midwifery in the College of Physicians, Dublin. He was an
extremely able doctor and was twice elected President of the College. Despite this,
little was known about him by local obstetricians until 1958 when the American Medical
Historian Harold Spreet, included the life of Montgomery in his book “Obstetric and
Gynaecological Milestones”.8 This stimulated Professor J B Fleming9 to seek further
information about him. These findings were later published.
Before the development of biological and biochemical tests for the diagnosis of pregnancy
the doctors only means of assessment were the interpretation of the various body changes
which the pregnant state produced. A series of such signs were named after various
authors, for example, Hegar, Braxton Hicks, Jacquemier etc. Breast changes in pregnancy
were first adequately described in English by Montgomery in his book ‘An Exposition
of the Signs and Symptoms of Pregnancy’ published in 1837.
In the book, Montgomery10 produced seven coloured drawings of a patient's breasts
from the third until the ninth month. The patient permitted an artist to do this at
each visit. With each drawing, Montgomery wrote a long description of the changes
from previous months. The change in colour from a delicate pink to a deep red in the
areola was noted. He also pointed out that a regression in the colour change was due
to an intra-uterine death.
Montgomery did not have an attachment to any of the well known Lying-In Hospitals.
Although the fetal stethoscope was in common use in Dublin he did not refer to it
in his book. His method could not compete with it and soon fell into disrepute. He
had been honoured by noting the colour changes in the areola during pregnancy but
today is only remembered for the presence of Montgomery's Glands – sebaceous glands
– in that part of the breast.
His great grandson was the late HL Hardy Greer, for many years senior obstetrician
and gynaecologist in the Royal Hospitals, Clinical Lecturer in Queens and Council
Member of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologist in London. He was also
the first assessor of Maternal Deaths in Northern Ireland. The first specialist staffed
maternity hospital in Downpatrick was named Hardy Greer House in his honour.
Further Development in the Service
The hospital in Donegall Street soon became too small. In 1830 a larger hospital having
18 beds was opened in Clifton Street, (
fig 4
) built on land owned by the Belfast Charitable Society. In 1837 Dr Burden (later
Professor) replaced Dr Stephenson.
The next milestone was the passage of the Poor Law Act in 1838.11 One hundred and
thirty “Unions” were created in Ireland. Each was managed by a Board of Guardians.
In each Union a workhouse to accommodate paupers was built. These were built to a
definite plan to house 200 to 1,000 paupers. The Belfast Workhouse held 1,000 people
– men, women and children. Obviously a small number of pregnant destitute women were
delivered in these institutions.
At this time there were many dispensary doctors in the Province who were employed
by various bodies. In 1862 the Charities Act was passed. This led to the establishment
of 180 dispensary districts in the Province. All these were managed by the Boards
of Guardians. A dispensary doctor and midwife were appointed in each district. The
doctors duties were to care for the poor and destitute while the midwife was expected
to deliver the poor pregnant women.
In 1898 local councils – urban and rural were established. They were empowered to
offer ante-natal care to all pregnant women. These midwives did not undertake any
deliveries. In 1921 only 21 of the 64 councils now comprising Northern Ireland offered
this service. Many women had to pay ‘handy-women’ or a midwife to care for them in
labour.12
There was a gradual development in hospital deliveries. The Lying-In Hospital in Clifton
Street became too small. In November 1904 it transferred to a larger hospital with
28 beds in Townsend Street, now known as the Incorporated Belfast Maternity Hospital
(
fig 5
).13 In the Union Infirmary Ward 11 was reserved for pregnant women. In time this
became too small so a dedicated maternity hospital “Ivy Cottage” together with a nurses
home was built adjacent to the Infirmary. The unit contained 30 beds14 A small unit
– St Mary's Maternity Hospital opened in 1912 in Londsdale Terrace as part of the
Mater Infirmorum Hospital. It closed early in the First World War and the beds were
used for injured soldiers returning from France.15 In 1912 only 8% of deliveries took
place in hospital in the Belfast area.16
Caesarean Section was rarely performed. In 1816 Dr Todd performed the first operation
in the Rotunda Hospital on a Mrs McClarey from Loughbrickland, Co Down. The baby survived
but the mother died. In 1829 Dr McKibben performed the operation in the Belfast Lying-In
Hospital. The antero-posterior diameter of pelvic brim was only ½ inches. No anaesthesia
was used. The baby was still born and the mother died seventeen hours later. In 1849
Dr John Campbell, Medical Officer to the Lisburn Infirmary performed the operation
in the patient's home – described as a wretched cabin – near Dromara. Chloroform was
used. Simpson of Edinburgh had only reported its use in obstetrics in 1847.17
The use of the obstetric forceps is always associated with the Chamberlain family
in England. They always performed the delivery under a sheet so that no one could
see the procedure! Many Irish obstetricians had their own special forceps made. None
are in use except the Neville axis traction handle which fitted on to the Barnes forceps.
The handle was necessary during a high cavity operative delivery. The operation has
been abandoned and in such situations delivery is now effected by Caesarean Section.
The axis traction handle is still in use in a low cavity forceps delivery. Neville,
an Assistant Master in the Coombe, introduced his handle in 1886.18
Feeding of the infant using cows milk was attempted in the 18th Century. Frequently,
the milk supplier had diluted the milk, which again was diluted by the attendant,
so the calorie count was low on many occasions! Attempts were made to make artificial
teats from linen, leather or sponge – all fertile fields for bacteria! The milk was
not pasteurised and frequently it contained the bovine tuberculous organism.
Breast feeding has always been a problem but at this time before the introduction
of the modern artificial milk feeds, the inability of a mother to breast feed regularly
led to the death of the baby. In each annual report from the lying-in hospital an
appeal was made to other mothers to act as a wet nurse for such infants.
Development of Medical Education
In 1835 a medical school was established in the Royal Belfast Academical Institution
(INST).20 Professors were appointed to various faculties. Dr Little was appointed
as Professor of Midwifery. The school closed in 1849 and students transferred to newly
opened Queen's College. Dr Burden13 was appointed to the Chair in 1840 and moved to
the Queen's College in 1849. Burden had a junior attachment to the Lying-In Hospital.
He was succeeded by RF Dill in 1867. He retired from the Chair in 1893. Prior to his
appointment, Dill had resigned from the staff of the hospital so he taught his students
practical midwifery in the patients homes and gave his lectures in his own home. He
was succeeded in 1893 by Professor JW Byers. Prof CG Lowry succeeded him in 1920.
There was a marked antipathy to training of medical students in midwifery. Three students
attended the lying-in hospital in 1854. In the following year members of the Charitable
Society did not approve and demanded rent from the hospital committee. The hospital
had been built on land owned by the Society in Clifton Street. The Bishop of Down
and others withdrew their annual subscription and in turn the Management charged both
Professor Burden and the students fees for the use of the facilities!
In 1852 an ordinance of the University had shown a standard of training which was
higher than that demanded by the General Medical Council today. The General Medical
Council was established in 1858. In 1886 the Council made it compulsory for students
to be proficient in midwifery. The present rules were adopted in 1906. All Universities
in Ireland award the degree of Bachelor of the Art of Obstetrics (BAO). The degree
is not registered by the General Medical Council.
The Training of Midwives
Professor Burden attempted to train midwives in the hospital. He invited a Mrs Hamill
to the hospital – to attend on the same terms as a medical student. In addition he
arranged to give her extra tuition on a one to one basis.
The Obstetrical Society was founded in London in 1870.14 This body conducted examinations
and issued certificates of proficiency in Midwifery until 1905 when it was replaced
by the Central Midwives Board. Pupil midwives had to travel to London to take this
examination. In April 1901, in Ireland, a Code of Training was laid down. The course
of training, which until then was only 3 months, was now increased to six months in
recognised hospitals. An Ulster Board of Examiners was established. The examination
consisted of both a written paper and an oral examination.
The Midwives Act (Ireland) was not passed until 1918. It controlled the training and
registration of midwives. It also forbade unregistered midwives to practice and outlawed
the use of ‘handy-women’.
DEVELOPMENTS FROM 1921 – 1948
In 1921 Northern Ireland was established as part of the UK. In 1924 Sir Dawson Bates
established an enquiry to examine the provision of the health service. In 1928 the
Minister thanked the Committee but stated that there was no money to carry out any
of its recommendations.12 At that time the Province had the highest maternal mortality
and second highest infant mortality in the United Kingdom. Several of the Union Infirmaries
were converted to district hospitals, and the Minister was loathe to agree to these
changes as hospitals were a charge on the Exchequer, while Infirmaries were supported
by the Poor Law Rates! These hospitals were usually staffed by local general practitioners.
Pregnant women with complications could be admitted to these hospitals as fee-paying
patients.
The first hospital antenatal clinic was established in 1921 by HL Hardy Greer19 in
the Incorporated Maternity Hospital in Townsend Street. This was a very important
step as often as that time this was the first occasion at which the women had a complete
medical examination – being before the school medical service and the pre-employment
medical examination. At this examination medical problems were diagnosed and treated,
some problems in pregnancy could be prevented and complications like transverse lie
or breech presentation corrected.
In 1933 the lying-in hospital moved to its present site and became the Royal Maternity
Hospital. (
fig 6
) A ward was reserved for septic patients. It was opened officially in 1934.20 In
1935 the Belfast Board of Guardians officially opened the Jubilee Maternity Hospital.14
(
fig 7
) Ivy Cottage (
fig 8
) was retained as an isolation unit for patients with puerperal sepsis. The Management
of the Mater Infirmorum Hospital opened a 24 bed hospital in 1942. These three specialist
hospitals were staffed by ten consultants. There were no specialist units outside
Belfast.
In 1926, Dr Bailie, Medical Officer of Health for Belfast wrote to the local branch
of the British Medical Association reporting that 27 patients in the district had
been notified to have developed puerperal sepsis in the previous three years 1923
– 1925. Thirteen had died. They all lived in poor circumstances and the husbands had
been unemployed. Among the survivors he reported that eleven had comfortable homes.
(A Eakins, personal communication 2005).
A very limited ante-natal care service was commenced in Jubilee in 1938.14 Only patients
who attended a Dispensary Doctor could be seen at the clinic or admitted. These women
were poor or destitute and been given a ‘line’ by an officer of the Guardians. Likewise
only dispensary doctors – they being employees of the Board of Guardians – could have
patients admitted to Jubilee. While the Royal Maternity had “booked” and emergency
admissions, the vast majority of patients were admitted with complications which had
developed in their own homes.
In 1936 the first enquiry into maternal mortality was held in the Province. The rate
was 7.3 per 1000 live births. In 1941 members of the Belfast Corporation Health Committee
invited Dr Carnwath22 to investigate health problems in the City. One of his recommendations
was the establishment of the Obstetrical Emergency Service (Flying Squad) based in
the Royal and Jubilee Maternity Hospitals.
At this time the majority of pregnant women were delivered at home. In 1947 52% of
patients in Belfast were now delivered in hospital.16 There were no maternity hospital
provision outside the city. The condition of many houses was still very bad. They
have been described by Nic Suibhne,23 Ballard24 and a Ligoniel midwife.25 Many ‘handy-women’
were still in practice despite the fact that their actions had been made illegal in
1917 (Donaldson).26 They did not charge fees but usually received a small financial
gift from the patient.
Analgesia was rarely available. Intermittent chloroform was often given in the later
stages of labour if a doctor had been engaged to perform the delivery. “Twilight sleep”
induced by morphine and scopolamine was used by specialists in private practice.
Obstetricians now began to look at their practice and analyse their results. Mr McClure27
published the results of a series of twin deliveries in the Incorporated Hospital
in Townsend Street and the Royal Maternity Hospital between 1926 – 1937. The maternal
mortality was 25.5 per thousand live births and the corrected infant mortality was
66 per thousand. In another paper, also published in 1937,28 he reported on the maternal
mortality in both the hospitals from 1926 – 1937. The overall maternal mortality was
12.9 per 1000 live births but 51.5 per 1000 live births in the group of emergency
admissions.
Breech delivery was always associated with a high infant mortality. Macafee and McClure29
discussed all such deliveries in the Royal Maternity Hospital between 1932 – 1936.
There were 349 such deliveries. The uncorrected fetal mortality was 33.8%. The corrected
figures for primigravidae was 10% and for multiparous women was 3.42%. In the article
they described what became known as the “Belfast Manoeuvre” to the extended posterior
arm. Breech delivery is seldom performed today. In the majority of such patients the
delivery is by elective Caesarean Section. With the availability of ultra sound the
diagnosis is seldom missed.
Rupture of the uterus is a serious complication which few obstetricians would have
to deal with today. Mr JA Price read a paper30 to members of the Ulster Obstetrical
and Gynaecological Society in which he described the management of and results of
treatment in Jubilee Maternity Hospital between 1937 - 1954. There were 30 such patients.
In only four was there a previous uterine scan. The other causes were an abnormal
lie or disproportion. The mortality was 30%. He pointed out that the last 10 patients
admitted between 1948 – 1954 survived after the beginning of the National Health Service.
He attributed this to both the ready availability of blood transfusion and expert
anaesthesia.
Of great importance was the introduction of the Conservative Treatment of Placenta
Previa.31 This method was based entirely on the clinical observation of CHG Macafee
(1937 – 1945) (
fig 9
) in the Royal Maternity Hospital. Although the placenta can now be located by ultrasound
Macafee's management is still standard practice throughout the world. Delivery may
be effected earlier than recommended in some hospitals with excellent neonatal services.
The Training of Medical Students and Doctors 1921 – 1948
It was not until the appointment of Professor CG Lowry that teaching, as we know it
today, was revised. The format of the course was continued by Professor Macafee. Formal
lectures were given on four days each week for 30 weeks in the University in the penultimate
year of Training. In the final year, three lectures and one case discussion were given
for 30 weeks by the Consultant staff of the Royal Maternity Hospital. In the final
year there were two months of compulsory residence in a recognised teaching hospital
and the delivery of twelve patients under supervision. Until the late 1940's many
of the students undertook their practical training in the Rotunda Hospital, Dublin.
Student deliveries in that unit were based in the huge district service which the
hospital controlled and as future general practitioners would practise in such circumstances
many felt that this experience was superior to that offered locally.
There was no formal training for doctors. A few would have gained some experience
while acting as “house-men” in the specialist hospitals. Several specialists obtained
the Fellowship of the Royal College of Surgeons in Edinburgh which had an examination
in Midwifery and Gynaecology.
In 1929 the College (later Royal) of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists was founded
in London. Professor Lowry was a founder member. Several consultants were granted
honorary membership. Examination for its Diploma or Membership commenced in 1932.
The Belfast Hospitals were not recognised for training until 1947.
The Training of Midwives 1921 – 1948
In the Province, Midwives trained in the Belfast Incorporated Maternity Hospital (later
in 1934 to become the Royal Maternity Hospital), the Belfast City Hospital (known
as the Union Infirmary until 1942) and in the Union Infirmary in Lurgan, and Malone
Place Hospital, Belfast. The course of training was increased from 4 months to 6 months
in 1926. The course was again lengthened to one year in 1937.
DEVELOPMENTS FROM 1948 – 2006
Service Provision
The Health Services Act (NI) 1946 swept away all piecemeal health care. Free health
care was offered to all from 5 July 1948. County Health Committees became responsible
for domiciliary midwifery, the fees of family doctors who cared for pregnant women,
the provision of a free home help service in difficult pregnancies and a maternity
grant to all patients. The Hospitals Authority was made responsible for all maternity
hospitals – specialist and general practitioners. Specialist hospitals were established
throughout the Province – the last being in 1963. General practitioner hospitals both
“stand-alone” and adjacent to specialist units also were established – the last being
in 1973.
The facilities offered to the domiciliary patients was enormous including the building
of many new homes in the post war era. But the increasing number of women in employment
meant there was a sharp decrease in help from family and neighbours, at and after
delivery, so home confinement reduced dramatically. In turn the newer developments
in the speciality, e.g. monitoring and scanning increased the demand for confinement
in specialist units at the expense of both domiciliary deliveries and general practitioner
units. General practitioner hospitals gradually closed – Sanderson32 and Rutherford33
have described their work as general practitioner obstetricians.
It was the policy of Government to maintain a large domiciliary service. Women who
had their baby at home received a monetary grant which was not given to those delivered
in hospital. However, there was a constant demand for hospital beds. This was achieved
by the earlier discharge of women and their babies to their homes. In 1948 after delivery
in hospital, women remained in bed for 12 days, were then allowed up to toilet etc.
for two days before discharge. In many hospitals today some women are discharged within
12 hours of delivery! It had been hoped that many would breast feed their babies as
there was constant midwife availability. Unfortunately this did not happen.
The tremendous developments in medical knowledge in the speciality and other specialists
who offered services to obstetricians revolutionised maternity care. Many general
practitioners only undertook ante-natal care so the general practitioners maternity
hospitals closed – the last in 1990 as did the domiciliary service.
With an improved ante-natal service, attention to the fetus in utero and the baby
after birth developed. Perinatal Surveys were carried out in England and Wales in
1958 and 1970. The term perinatal mortality which includes stillbirths and first week
neonatal deaths was first used in England in 1953 and is regarded as a guide to the
standard of care offered to mother and baby. A survey was undertaken here of neonatal
deaths in 1976. One of their recommendations was the establishment of a committee
to investigate infant mortality and handicap in the Province. This committee chaired
by Dr Baird recommended that maternity hospitals should be large enough not only to
have sufficient obstetricians but also dedicated obstetric anaesthetists and neonatologists.
This report was accepted and many of the smaller specialist maternity hospitals have
closed. They include Tyrone County (1992), Waveney (1994), Larne (1994), South Tyrone
(1999), Ards (1997), Ballymoney (2001), Downpatrick (2003). The closure of Jubilee
and transfer of services to Royal Maternity was made not because of this report but
the lack of cardiac neo-natal services. The transfer took place in 2000. Several specialist
hospitals which do not fulfil the recommendation of the “Baird Report” remain open.
On 28 September the Minister of Health announced that £300,000,000 was to be spent
on a new Children's and new Maternity Hospital to replace present hospitals on the
Royal site. He allocated £2.62 million to Management to plan the new hospitals. Work
is expected to start in May 2008 and be completed in 2017.35
During the 1970's the introduced of the ‘Syntocinon” drip and the use of Prostaglandin
made induction of labour a much safer procedure than the old fashioned Oil, Bath and
Enema. Obstetricians gradually changed their motto from that of “Masterly Inactivity”
to that of “Active Intervention”. This led to an increase in the rate of delivery
by Caesarean Section. In 195340 the rate in Northern Ireland was 2.8% whereas in 2004
it had risen to 27.48%. (Margaret Boyle personal communication).
Development of the Speciality and those Allied to it
Electronic fetal monitoring had been introduced in the USA by Hon in 1950. It was
first used in Belfast in 1970 by Professor CR Whitfield36 who had trained in that
unit. Ultrasound scanning of the pregnancy had been developed in Glasgow by Donald
in 1958.37 The first commercial machine was brought into the Province in 1973 by Professor
JHM Pinkerton. Rhesus incompatibility38 was a major problem in the Province. At one
time 15% of all admissions into Royal Maternity had this problem. Clarke and his colleagues
in Liverpool developed a prophylaxis programme. This was introduced into clinical
use in the Province in 1968.
The development of a group of doctors who dedicated their work to obstetric anaesthesia
led to the increased safety of operative obstetrics. Hospitals could now offer a 24
hour epidural analgesic service. A society of like minded doctors to advance this
sub-specialty was founded in 1976. Dr M Lewis was the local founder member.
Family Planning
For generations this was achieved by abstinence or coitus interruptus – both unsatisfactory
methods. Male barrier methods using various products have been used from pre-historic
times but it was not until the 1930's when latex was developed that the condom became
a satisfactory method. Female barrier methods were not introduced until the late 19th
century.
The first attempt to establish a clinic in the Province was made by Marie Stopes in
1934.39 This closed in 1947 due to a lack of demand! A small clinic started in Royal
Maternity Hospital in 1940 and a second in Malone Place Hospital in 1951. A revolution
took place when the contraceptive pill was introduced into clinical practice in 1963.
These drugs became freely available on the National Health Service. A major advance
in the provision of this service was achieved when all forms of family planning became
part of the National Health Service in 1974.40
Blood transfusion41 has saved many lives. The service was established here by Sir
Thomas Houston and Professor JH Biggart in 1943. Dr Ruth Huth became the first full
time Director in 1946. Not only was blood readily available but every pregnant women
had blood grouping and other tests carried out by the services. The anti-D serum used
in Rhesus negative was obtained by removing blood from patients with the complication.
As the numbers decreased the officers of the service injected D antigen into Rhesus
negative male volunteers in order to maintain supplies of the serum.
Investigation into the problems of babies with congenital abnormalities was started
when Dr (later Professor) N Nevin was appointed to the Department of Epidemiology
and Medical Statistics in Queen's University in 1969. He held clinics in both Royal
Maternity and Jubilee Hospitals. Amniocentesis was performed where necessary.
Neonatology
The greatest advance in the entire obstetrical and allied services was that of Neonatology.
Following the various reports Neonatal intensive care units were established in 3
hospitals, Altnagelvin, Craigavon and then Ballymena/Antrim complex – now Antrim only.
A highly sophisticated Regional intensive care unit was developed in the Royal Maternity
Hospital.
Obstetric consultants were encouraged to send women in premature labour to these hospitals.
A ‘neonatal flying squad’ was recommended to transport the premature babies if delivered
in a hospital without adequate facilities.
The presence at all “difficult” or premature births of a doctor trained in neonatology
improved the survival of many babies. The use of oxygen administered intermittently
by a face mask was replaced by passing of an endotracheal tube. Whiskey on a midwife's
finger was replaced by modern drugs! Heated resuscitation cots were provided in all
labour wards.
Respiratory distress syndrome was first described as a specific pathological entity
in 1953 when it was known as ‘hyaline membrane disease’. The Lecthin Sphingomyelin
Area Ratio (LSAR) test performed on liquor obtained by amniocentesis was a test which
could predict respiratory problems. Whitfield et al
42 developed this test from one introduced by Gluck. For many years Belfast was the
most advanced centre for this study in Great Britain. It was known that the use of
surfactant would prevent the complication. Using artificial surfactant produced in
Sweden, Halliday43 and his colleagues reported dramatic results. Numerous multi-centre
clinical trials have been performed. Professor Halliday44 was the co-ordinator for
the European trials.
Much research has been undertaken in the Royal Maternity Hospital into the nutritional
problems of premature babies. Special high calorie ‘milks’ for premature babies have
been manufactured following this work. Halliday44 was able to report on 40% survival
of babies weight less than 1000 grams.
The Training of General Practitioner Obstetricians
At the beginning of the National Health Service all doctors who practised midwifery
were placed on the obstetric list. From January 1967 it became compulsory to have
completed 6 months as a houseman in a recognised hospital before admission to the
list was granted. Thereafter the doctor had to attend a certain number of deliveries
and attend refresher courses to remain on the list. As the number of births decreased
these regulations had to be frequently altered. In Northern Ireland doctors did not
get a fee for shared antenatal care with the hospital staff unless they were on the
Obstetric List.
The Training of Specialist Obstetricians
The training of the Specialist Obstetrician is controlled by the Royal College of
Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. Like general practitioners the course of training
has been changed. There are now 4 sub-specialities within the overall training. The
minimum requirement for a consultant appointment is to hold the membership examination
of the College or equivalent.
For many years the College acted only as an Examination Body. Study days commenced
in 1962 and now study days and weeks are held on a regular basis.
In the early 1950's when the specialist service was established there was only one
consultant in each speciality in a hospital. Efforts were made to develop a further
education programme. Through the work of Mr Bill Laird, of the Waveney Hospital, the
Ulster Obstetrical and Gynaecological Society was formed in 1952. Members met four
times each year for “study days”. The programme consisted of demonstration of operative
technique, case discussions and lectures. At these, there was always a “guest lecturer”
from outside the Province.
The Training of Medical Students
In 1945 Professor Lowry had retired and was succeeded by Professor CHG Macafee. He
retired in 1963 and was succeeded by Professor JHM Pinkerton. During his term of office
Dr JGMcD Harley was awarded an Honorary Clinical Chair in 1973. Professor WJ Thompson
was appointed to a second Chair in 1980 and succeeded Professor Pinkerton in 1985.
Professor Neil McClure is the present holder of the Chair following Professor Thompson
in 2000.
The training in midwifery remained unchanged until the entire course of medical undergraduate
training was shortened and changed. The course was reduced to a hospital attachment
for 8 weeks. Compulsory residence was abolished in 1985.
The midwifery and gynaecological course now consists of only a 6 week attachment to
one of seven recognised teaching hospitals in the Province. During this time all students
attend 3 days of lectures – a total of 14 lectures. During the attachment, time is
spent between the labour ward, clinics which include maternity/gynaecological and
genitourinary diseases and observing gynaecological operations. The student of today
performs only three deliveries.
At the end of the attachment the students sit an examination – Objective Structured
Clinical Examination (OSCE). This replaces the Final Medical Examination. Since the
late 1980's, the majority of medical students are female. Women doctors now occupy
most of the trainee posts in obstetrics and gynaecology and now there are many women
consultants in the speciality in the Province.
Midwife Training
Important developments in midwife training were governed by the establishment of the
following: the Joint Nurses and Midwives Council for Northern Ireland in 1922; the
Northern Ireland Council for Nurses and Midwives in 1971 and the National Board for
Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting for Northern Ireland in 1979.
In 1980 the period of training was increased to eighteen months. In 1971 a Central
School of Midwifery was established by amalgamation of the existing schools in Jubilee
and Royal Maternity Hospitals. Later this was expanded to include Altnagelvin and
the Ulster Hospitals.
The training of midwives became the responsibility of Queen's University in 1997.
The course consists of both theoretical lectures given in the University and practical
work in the main maternity hospitals in the Province. The duration of the course is
either 18 months or three years depending on previous experience of the candidate.
The faculty is under the direction of Professor Jean Orr. Forty eight students are
admitted each year.
CONCLUSION
The story of the development of Midwifery is one of overall continuous progress in
abolishing almost completely the maternal mortality rate and markedly reducing the
perinatal mortality rate. These remarkable results could not have been achieved without
marked alterations to the care of the pregnant woman and her baby. In 1806 only a
few poor women were delivered in hospitals. Now almost all deliveries take place in
specialist hospitals with full neonatal, laboratory, anaesthetic and family planning
services. Interested general practitioners now only offer ‘shared care’ with the hospital
staff.
The development of better housing and the improvement in general health have contributed
to these results. The continual compulsory refresher courses for specialists and midwives
plays an important part in this progress.
The “Obstetric Physician” of old has been replaced by the modern “Surgical Obstetrician”.
Has active intervention gone too far Future obstetricians will have to decide!
Sections of the article have been taken from the unpublished thesis by the author
“The Development of Maternity Services in Northern Ireland 1948 – 1992” which is available
in Queen's University Science Library.