236
views
0
recommends
+1 Recommend
1 collections
    0
    shares

      CVIA now indexed by SCOPUS from February 2024. CVIA received its first Journal Impact Factor (0.5) in the 2023 Journal Citation Reports Release. 

      Interested in becoming a CVIA published author?

      • Platinum Open Access with no APCs. 
      • Fast peer review/Fast publication online after article acceptance.

      Submissions should be made electronically at: https://mc04.manuscriptcentral.com/cvia-journal.

      Please refer to the Author Guidelines at https://cvia-journal.org/instructions-to-authors/ before submission.

       

      scite_
       
      • Record: found
      • Abstract: found
      • Article: found
      Is Open Access

      Guidelines

      article-commentary
      , MD, MACC 1 ,
      Cardiovascular Innovations and Applications
      Compuscript
      Bookmark

            Main article text

            Definition of Guidelines

            I would like to start out this editorial by reviewing for the reader my view of what guidelines are. I like the definition put forth by the Institute of Medicine (IOM). They define guidelines as “systematically developed statements to assist practitioner and patient decisions about appropriate healthcare for a specific clinical circumstance”. I think the operative words in this statement is to “assist the practitioner and patient”. Therefore guidelines are there to aid with clinical decision making and as far as I know are not mandatory or enforced.

            Guidelines change

            Guidelines are not static and are rather fluid. For example, guidelines written 10 years ago may not necessarily apply to the same condition in 2017. If there are changes, the guidelines should be upgraded based on new and confirmed clinical information.

            Guideline Similarity and Differences

            Often there are differences in guidelines generated from the European Society of Cardiology, Canadian Cardiovascular Society and the ACC/AHA. Admittedly, the differences are small but there are differences despite the fact that guidelines are generated by a group of individuals who generally have the same amount of clinical information and level of expertise in all three societies. Are these differences related to the EGO’s of the societies?

            Do Guidelines apply to all patients?

            Guidelines may not necessarily apply to all patients given the same cardiovascular condition. Thus judgement is still necessary since decision making in an individual patient is not one based on 1,000 or 10,000 patients as it is in clinical trials but on an “N” of one.

            Guideline Writing Committees

            What follows are recommendations from most guideline writing committees related to the class of recommendation (COR) and the level of evidence (LOE) for the recommendation.

            Class of Recommendations (COR) [1]

            Class 1 COR

            A class one recommendation is a strong recommendation in favor of the procedure or diagnostic study and benefits are far greater than the risks.

            Class 2A COR

            Class 2A recommendations indicate that the benefit is greater than the risk and the procedure and/or diagnostic study is reasonable and useful.

            Class 2B COR

            Class 2B recommendation indicates that the benefit is slightly greater than the risk and the procedure may or might be reasonable and may or might be considered but the usefulness/effectiveness etc. is not well established.

            Class 3 COR

            Class 3 recommendation is moderate if the benefits equal the risk. Although the procedure is not recommended or indicated and probably should not be performed. When the risk is greater than the benefit, procedures are considered potentially harmful, and may be associated with excess mortality and morbidity. It is strongly recommended that the procedure should not be performed.

            What Guidelines are Acceptable?

            It seems to me that all guidelines except guideline with the COR of 3 are acceptable recommendations. Some more than others.

            Level of Evidence (LOE)

            Level A

            Level A indicates that the evidence is high quality from more than one randomized controlled trial or a meta-analysis of high quality randomized controlled trials or the combination of a high quality randomized controlled trial and high quality registries data.

            Level B

            Level B (randomized), this level of evidence comes from moderate quality evidence from one or more randomized controlled trials or meta-analyses of a moderate quality randomized controlled trial.

            Level B (non-randomized), this level of evidence comes from moderate quality evidence from one or more well-designed well-executed non-randomized studies observational studies or registry studies.

            Level C

            Level C can also be divided into two groups one with limited data and the other related to expert opinion:

            • Expert opinion LOE C Limited Data, derived from randomized or non-randomized observational registry studies with limitations of design or execution, Meta-analyses of such studies, and physiologic or mechanistic studies in human subjects.

            • Expert Opinion LOE C is a consensus based on clinical experience. The latter recommendation does not imply that the recommendation is weak since many important clinical questions addressed in guidelines do not lend themselves to clinical trials but there may be a clear consensus that a particular test or therapy is useful or effective.

            Relationship of LOE to Patient’s Desires

            None of the class of recommendations (COR) or level of evidence (LOE) makes any statement about patient’s wishes to have or not to have the recommended procedure.

            It seems to me that all except class of recommendations 3 are acceptable; patient preference may influence decision making by the practitioner.

            Remember; guidelines recommendations are based on results of population research with a large “N”. When a physician is faced with a single patient the “N” is one [2]. Thus the guidelines can be used to help make judgements. Judgement is still a major requirement when taking care of one patient at a time.

            References

            1. PageRL, JoglarJA, CaldwellMA, CalkinsH, ContiJB, DealBJ, et al. 2015 ACC/AHA/HRS guideline for the management of adult patients with supraventricular tachycardia. J Am Coll Cardiol 2016;67(13):e27–115.

            2. ContiCR. Cardiovascular Guidelines, Board Review Questions and Cardiovascular trainees. Cardiovasc Innov App, Doi 10.15212/CVIA.2016.0050.

            Author and article information

            Journal
            CVIA
            Cardiovascular Innovations and Applications
            CVIA
            Compuscript (Ireland )
            2009-8782
            2009-8618
            February 2019
            February 2019
            : 3
            : 4
            : 441-442
            Affiliations
            [1] 1University of Florida Medical School, Gainesville, FL, USA
            Author notes
            Correspondence: C. Richard Conti, MD, MACC, University of Florida Medical School, Gainesville, FL, USA, E-mail: conticr@ 123456medicine.ufl.edu
            Article
            cvia20170020
            10.15212/CVIA.2017.0020
            bbd2c515-cc09-4b1c-8c0d-c43dcdb75261
            Copyright © 2019 Cardiovascular Innovations and Applications

            This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 Unported License (CC BY-NC 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. See https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.

            History
            Categories
            Commentaries

            General medicine,Medicine,Geriatric medicine,Transplantation,Cardiovascular Medicine,Anesthesiology & Pain management

            Comments

            Comment on this article