Crisman
Mark V.
3.1—Syncope and Weakness
Syncope is a clinical syndrome consisting of a generalized weakness, sudden collapse,
and a transient cessation of consciousness. Syncopal episodes are uncommon in horses,
and generally few or no premonitory warning or presyncopal (faintness) signs are evident
to the rider or handler. The subsequent loss of consciousness and collapse may be
potentially harmful or dangerous to the horse and the rider. Despite the infrequent
reports of true syncopal episodes in horses, the clinical signs are sufficiently dramatic
to cause great concern on the part of the owner. Syncope in horses has been virtually
unstudied. Consequently, most of the following information has been drawn from studies
of persons and other animal species.
Although presyncopal signs have been well described in human beings (i.e., dizziness,
yawning, confusion, and spots before the eyes), these signs are generally not evident
in horses. Horses may stumble initially and go down or collapse completely. The depth
and duration of unconsciousness may vary, but generally unconsciousness lasts for
a few minutes. Horses may be slightly unsteady or struggle during recovery. After
a syncopal attack, the horse will completely recover and appear normal.
Pathophysiology
Syncope results from a sudden reduction in cerebral blood flow and subsequent cerebral
ischemia. Cerebral blood flow is maintained primarily by arterial blood pressure and
cerebrovascular resistance. In response to falling or rising systemic blood pressure,
the cerebral blood flow autoregulatory mechanism automatically regulates cerebral
vessels to constrict or dilate. This control phenomenon maintains a constant cerebral
blood flow despite fluctuations in arterial blood pressure, whether or not these fluctuations
are physiologic or pathologic. If perfusion pressure in human beings falls below 60
mm Hg, the cerebral blood flow autoregulatory mechanism may fail. Mean resting arterial
pressure measured at the carotid artery in horses has been reported to be 97 ± 12
mm Hg at a heart rate of 42 ± 10 beats/min.
1
Systolic pressure in horses experiencing syncope has not been determined.
Disturbances in oxygen supply to the brain generally result from three primary causes:
anoxia, anemia, and ischemia. Although a variety of conditions or diseases may cause
these disturbances, all three potentially deprive the brain of its critical oxygen
supply.
2
Anoxia generally is described as insufficient oxygen reaching the blood so that arterial
oxygen content and tension are low. This insufficiency results from an inability of
oxygen to cross the alveolar membrane (e.g., pulmonary disease) or low oxygen tension
in the environment (e.g., high altitude). In situations of mild hypoxia, the cerebral
blood flow autoregulatory mechanism maintains oxygen delivery to the brain. When the
hypoxia is severe or the compensatory mechanism fails, cerebral hypoxia occurs and
syncope may result.
Anemia is defined functionally as a decreased oxygen-carrying capacity of the blood.
This may be characterized by several mechanisms, including a reduction in the amount
of hemoglobin available to bind and transport oxygen or changes in hemoglobin that
interfere with oxygen binding (e.g., methemoglobin). If the anemia is severe, the
oxygen concentration drops below the metabolic requirements of the brain despite increased
cerebral blood flow.
Finally, cerebral ischemia results when cerebral blood flow is insufficient to supply
cerebral tissue. Any disease that greatly reduces cardiac output, such as myocardial
infarction or an arrhythmia, ultimately may result in cerebral ischemia. If any of
these aforementioned conditions occurs and cerebral blood flow is interrupted or stops
with resultant cerebral underperfusion, consciousness is lost. If tissue oxygenation
is restored immediately, consciousness generally returns quickly without sequelae.
Areas of the brain that maintain or control consciousness have been the subject of
much debate and research. Generally, the level of activity of the brain (alertness)
is maintained through sensory input to the ascending reticular activating system in
the rostral brainstem, thalamus, and cerebral cortex. More specifically, the bulboreticular
facilitatory area within the reticular substance of the middle and lateral pons and
mesencephalon is considered to be the central driving component of the excitatory
area of the brain. Recent studies have identified the role of the midbrain reticular
formation and the thalamic intralaminar nuclei in maintaining consciousness and arousal
in animals and human beings.
3
Syncope may result if regional cerebral blood flow to this area is disrupted for any
reason.
In horses, syncope may be cardiogenic or extracardiac (neurocardiogenic) in origin.
The primary cause of syncope in horses is generally cardiovascular disease. Cardiogenic
syncope may result from (1) myocardial disease, (2) cardiac dysrhythmias (i.e., atrial
fibrillation and third-degree heart block), (3) congenital heart disease, (4) pulmonary
hypertension or stenosis, and (5) pericardial disease. Although many of these conditions
are uncommon in horses, atrial fibrillation has been associated with several reports
of syncope.
4
Cardiovascular disease, resulting in an inability to regulate heart rate or in stroke
volume, ultimately decreases cardiac output. Atrial fibrillation can lead to heart
rates greater than 240 beats/min with submaximal exercise. The lack of effective atrial
contraction prevents complete ventricular filling at the end of diastole, thus causing
a great reduction in effective cardiac output. Complete heart block may be persistent
or intermittent and also has been associated with syncopal episodes in horses. When
the block is complete and the pacemaker below the block fails to function, syncope
occurs. This situation has been reported in human beings and horses as Morgagni-Adams-Stokes
syndrome. This syndrome is the most frequent arrhythmic cause of syncope in human
beings.
5
Morgagni-Stokes-Adams attacks result from an advanced atrioventricular block and usually
involve a momentary sense of weakness followed by an abrupt loss of consciousness.
After cardiac standstill or prolonged periods of asystole, unconsciousness results
from cerebral ischemia. These “cardiac faints” have been reported to occur several
times a day in human beings. Additional, less common causes of cardiogenic syncope
usually involve the distal conduction system (His-Purkinje system) and may be persistent
or episodic. Heart block involving the atrioventricular node or proximal conduction
system may be congenital or drug induced (e.g., digitalis). Sick sinus syndrome, a
condition described in elderly human beings, involves impaired sinoatrial impulse
formation or conduction and has been associated with cerebral anoxia. With any of
these conditions, cardiac output does not increase sufficiently during skeletal muscle
exercise to meet peripheral oxygen demands. Blood preferentially flows to exercising
muscle, resulting in systemic arterial hypotension, which results in cerebral ischemia
leading to weakness or syncope.
Extracardiac causes of syncope indirectly may involve the cardiovascular system and
were referred to previously as vasovagal or vasodepressor syncope. The term neurocardiogenic
syncope more accurately describes this phenomenon. Neurocardiogenic syncope is the
most common type of syncope reported in human beings and often is precipitated by
stress or pain.
6
Although not specifically described in horses, a similar mechanism of collapse likely
may exist. The critical cardiovascular features include hypotension and paradoxical
sinus bradycardia, heart block, or sinus arrest after sympathetic excitation. Additionally,
cardiac asystole may occur as an extreme manifestation of neurocardiogenic syncope.
The mediating mechanisms of neurocardiogenic syncope are not well understood; however,
several theories have been proposed. Hypercontractile states may cause excessive stimulation
of the myocardial mechanoreceptors (C fibers) located in the left ventricle. The result
is an exaggerated parasympathetic afferent signal carried by the vagus and glossopharyngeal
nerves with a subsequent decrease in sympathetic tone. Inhibition of sympathetic vasoco
strictor activity results in vasodilation, which may be especially evident during
periods of vigorous activity and increased heart rates and blood pressure. The excess
vagal activity produces bradycardia and a decrease in cardiac output. This combination,
along with a decrease in peripheral vascular resistance, ultimately leads to syncope.
Regardless of the specific cause, syncope results from a sudden fall in cerebral blood
flow. The loss of consciousness is caused by a reduction of oxygenation to the parts
of the brain that maintain consciousness. In horses, syncope usually is caused by
a fall in systemic blood pressure resulting from a decrease in cardiac output.
Additional, less common causes of syncope in horses may include neurologic disease
from space-occupying lesions or increased intracranial pressure. Syncopal episodes
have been reported in foals with severe respiratory or congenital heart disease.
7
After minimal exercise or restraint in these foals, hypoxia and subsequently reduced
cerebral blood flow may result in syncope. Certain drugs, specifically phenothiazine
tranquilizers (acepromazine), have been reported to cause syncope in horses. These
tranquilizers produce antiadrenergic effects primarily through α1-blockade with resultant
vasodilation and hypotension. If phenothiazine tranquilizers are administered to severely
hypovolemic horses or to horses that have hemorrhaged, severe hypotension and syncope
may result.
Several disorders often are confused with syncope and should be differentiated carefully
by an accurate history and thorough physical examination. These disorders include
(1) epilepsy, (2) hypoglycemia, (3) narcolepsy and cataplexy, (4) cerebrovascular
disease, and (5) hyperkalemic periodic paralysis.
Epileptic seizures generally differ from syncope in that they have immediate onset
and involve loss of consciousness, tonic and clonic convulsive activity with opisthotonos,
and changes in visceral function (urination and defecation). Seizures commonly last
for several minutes and often are followed by a postictal phase in which the horse
may pace, appear blind, and not recognize its surroundings.
Metabolic disturbances such as hypoglycemia frequently are observed in neonatal foals
and may be associated with weakness or syncopal-like episodes. Typically, foals are
premature or are subject to perinatal stress with subsequent increased glucose use
following hypoxia or sepsis. Serum glucose determination is necessary to evaluate
hypoglycemia.
Narcolepsy, an abnormal sleep tendency, and cataplexy occasionally may be difficult
to distinguish from syncope as a cause of unconsciousness. Attacks of narcolepsy or
cataplexy may be preceded by signs of weakness (buckling at the knees) followed by
total collapse and areflexia. Rapid eye movements may occur with an absence of spinal
reflexes. No other neurologic abnormalities are observed between attacks, although
animals may appear sleepy between episodes. Provocative testing with physostigmine
(0.05 mg/kg) may induce narcoleptic attacks and might be helpful in differentiating
syncope from narcolepsy or cataplexy.
Cerebrovascular disease associated with head trauma and subarachnoid hemorrhage may
cause temporary unconsciousness in horses. Clinical signs resulting from brain trauma
generally are associated with focal cerebral dysfunction and therefore are readily
distinguishable from syncope.
Hyperkalemic periodic paralysis causes weakness and collapse without alterations in
consciousness. This autosomal dominant disorder has been reported in certain lines
of registered Quarter Horses, Paints, and Appaloosas. A reliable DNA-based test is
available to diagnose hyperkalemic periodic paralysis in horses.
Evaluation of Syncope
A thorough evaluation of syncope in the horse consists of the following:
1.
History: Emphasis should be placed on obtaining a detailed history. The onset and
the duration of the problem along with performance history should be determined.
2.
Physical examination: After a thorough physical examination and determination of vital
signs, a detailed cardiovascular and neurologic examination should be performed. In
addition to heart rate at rest and pulse characteristics, a thorough cardiac auscultation
should be performed in a quiet room to identify any murmurs or cardiac dysrhythmias.
An electrocardiogram and echocardiogram also provide valuable information. A neurologic
examination should evaluate reflexes and sensory and motor function carefully to identify
any central or peripheral neuropathies.
3.
Complete blood count and biochemical profile: To rule out other potential causes of
syncopelike episodes (e.g., hypoglycemia and sepsis), a complete blood count and biochemical
profile should be performed. Additionally, serum lactate dehydrogenase (isoenzymes
1 and 2) and creatine kinase (CK-2) concentration determinations may be helpful in
identifying cardiac dysfunction.
4.
Exercise/stress test: A thorough cardiac evaluation should be performed following
strenuous exercise, including auscultation and an electrocardiogram. If available,
a high-speed treadmill may be helpful in this phase of the evaluation. If any cardiac
abnormalities are detected on physical examination, exercise testing on a treadmill
will allow a more thorough evaluation of the cardiovascular system, although care
must be taken to ensure that such testing does not exacerbate the condition of the
horse.
Diagnosis of the cause of syncope in horses is not always easy, because the cause
should be considered a symptom complex rather than a primary disease. In addition
to the infrequent reports of syncope, the history is often vague and the neurologic
and cardiovascular examinations may not lead to a specific cause. Even in the absence
of apparently overt cardiovascular disease (e.g., atrial fibrillation), cardiac dysrhythmias
cannot be excluded as the possible cause of syncope.
Treatment of Syncope
Options for treating syncope in horses are limited. The frequency of the syncopal
attacks and the underlying cause (i.e., cardiogenic or neurocardiogenic) may determine
if a course of treatment should be undertaken. Generally, treatment of syncope should
be directed toward preventing or correcting the cause of the decreased cerebral perfusion.
An accurate pathophysiologic diagnosis is essential for treating cardiogenic syncope.
A few reports in the literature indicate successful treatment of syncope in horses
associated with atrial fibrillation.
4
A horse with a complete heart block returned to work after implantation of a transvenous
cardiac pacing system.
8
REFERENCES
1
Physick-Shepard
PW
Cardiovascular response to exercise and training in the horse
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
1
1985
383
3878196
2
Plum
F
Posner
JB
Multifocal, diffuse, and metabolic brain disease causing stupor or coma
Plum
F
Posner
JB
The diagnosis of stupor and coma
ed 3
1986
FA Davis
Philadelphia
3
Kinomura
S
Larsson
J
Gulyas
B
Activation by attention of the human reticular formation and thalamic intralaminar
nuclei
Science
271
1996
512
515
8560267
4
Deegen
E
Buntenkotter
S
Behavior of the heart rate of horses with auricular fibrillation during exercise and
after treatment
Equine Vet J
8
1976
26
29
1253777
5
O'Rourke
RA
Walsh
RA
Easton
JD
Faintness and syncope
Stein
JH
Internal medicine
ed 4
1994
Mosby
St. Louis
6
Sra
JS
Jazayeri
MR
Avitall
B
Comparison of cardiac pacing with drug therapy in the treatment of neurocardiogenic
(vasovagal) syncope with bradycardia or systole
N Engl J Med
328
1993
1085
1090
8455666
7
Vitamus
A
Bayly
WM
Pulmonary atresia with dextroposition of the aorta and ventricular septal defect in
three Arabian foals
Vet Pathol
19
1982
160
168
7072088
8
Reef
VB
Clark
ES
Oliver
JA
Implantation of a permanent transvenous pacing catheter in a horse with a complete
heart block and syncope
J Am Vet Med Assoc
189
1986
449
452
3759616
Kohn
Catherine W.
Hansen
Bernard
3.2—Polyuria and Polydipsia
The complaint of excessive urination and drinking may be encountered with some frequency
in equine practice. Before pursuing a lengthy diagnostic workup, verifying that 24-hour
urine production and voluntary water consumption exceed reference ranges is important.
Urine production in adult horses may range from 15 to 30 ml/kg/day, and values as
high as 48 ml/kg/day have been reported.1, 2, 3, 4 Daily urine volume is affected
by diet; more water is lost in the urine in horses fed pelleted diets and legume hays
than in horses fed grass hay. The latter excrete more water in feces.5, 6 Generally,
any component of the diet that increases renal solute load increases urine volume
(e.g., high salt content in the diet). Voluntary water intake also is affected by
the ambient temperature (Table 3.2-1
). When temperatures are high and evaporative water losses increase to cool the horse,
voluntary water intake also increases. Diet and climatic conditions therefore must
be considered when interpreting water consumption and urine production data. Water
requirements are proportional to metabolic body size rather than to body mass. Thus
larger horses, particularly draft breeds, require less water per kilogram than do
smaller horses, ponies, or miniature horses. In addition, fat is low in water content
compared with lean body tissue, and fat animals require proportionately less water
than do lean animals.
7
TABLE 3.2-1
Voluntary Water Consumption in Healthy Horses
WATER CONSUMPTION
AMBIENT TEMPERATURE
ml/kg/day
L/450 kg
5°–16°C (41°–61°F)
44–61
19.8–27.5
25°C (77°F)
70
31.5
Data from Tasker JB: Fluid and electrolyte studies in the horse. III. Intake and output
of water, sodium and potassium in normal horses, Cornell Vet 57:649–657, 1967; Rose
BD: Clinical physiology acid-base and electrolyte disorders, New York, 1989, McGraw-Hill
Information Services; and Groenedyk S, English PB, Abetz I: External balance of water
and electrolytes in the horse, Equine Vet J 20:189–193, 1988.
© 2004 McGraw-Hill Information Services
2004
Since January 2020 Elsevier has created a COVID-19 resource centre with free information
in English and Mandarin on the novel coronavirus COVID-19. The COVID-19 resource centre
is hosted on Elsevier Connect, the company's public news and information website.
Elsevier hereby grants permission to make all its COVID-19-related research that is
available on the COVID-19 resource centre - including this research content - immediately
available in PubMed Central and other publicly funded repositories, such as the WHO
COVID database with rights for unrestricted research re-use and analyses in any form
or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are
granted for free by Elsevier for as long as the COVID-19 resource centre remains active.
Some owners may misinterpret polyalkiuria (frequent urination usually of small volume)
as polyuria. Quantitative collection of urine for a 24-hour period may be required
to verify excessive urine production. Several simple collection apparatuses have been
described.8, 9
Maintenance of Water Balance in Health
Maintenance of water homeostasis depends on establishing a balance between intake
and excretion such that plasma osmolality remains constant (within approximately 2%
of normal).
10
The primary determinant of renal water excretion is antidiuretic hormone (ADH).
11
ADH is a polypeptide synthesized in three nuclei in the hypothalamus (suprachiasmatic,
paraventricular, and supraoptic nuclei)
12
and transported from the latter two nuclei in secretory granules down axons of the
supraopticohypophyseal tract into the posterior lobe of the pituitary where ADH is
stored. Some ADH enters the cerebrospinal fluid or portal capillaries of the median
eminence from the paraventricular nucleus.
11
In addition, neurons from the suprachiasmatic nucleus deposit ADH in other areas in
the central nervous system.
12
In human beings, lesions of the posterior pituitary or supraopticohypophyseal tract
below the median eminence usually do not lead to permanent central diabetes insipidus
because ADH still has access to systemic circulation in these cases.
11
The clinical importance of these anatomic relationships in horses is not known.
ADH increases renal water reabsorption and urine osmolality by augmenting water permeability
of luminal membranes of cortical and medullary collecting tubules. ADH augments urea,
and in some species NaCl, accumulation in the interstitium, therefore promoting medullary
hypertonicity. The primary stimuli for ADH release are plasma hyperosmolality and
depletion of the effective circulating blood volume. Osmoreceptors in the hypothalamus
detect changes in plasma osmolality of as little as 1%.
11
Although the threshold for ADH release in the horse is not known, 24-hour water deprivation
in healthy ponies resulted in approximately an 8 mOsm/kg increase in plasma osmolality
(about 3%), from 287 ±3 mOsm/kg to 295 ± 4 mOsm/kg, which was associated with an increase
in plasma ADH concentration from 1.53 ± 0.36 pg/ml to 4.32 ± 1.12 pg/ml.
13
In another study of ponies, water deprivation for 19 hours resulted in an increase
in plasma osmolality from 297 ± 1 mOsm/L to 306 ± 2 mOsm/L.
14
In human beings, plasma osmolalities of 280 to 290 mOsm/L stimulate ADH release. The
organs that sense changes in effective circulating blood volume include arterial and
left atrial baroreceptors. These stretch receptors function indirectly as volume sensors
by responding to the reductions in intraluminal pressure that typically accompany
loss of plasma volume. Reduced activation of these receptors by hypovolemia or heart
failure is a potent cause of ADH release, even in the absence of increased plasma
osmolality. ADH secretion also may be stimulated by stress (pain), nausea, hyp glycemia,
and certain drugs including morphine and lithium.
11
When the need for water in body fluids cannot be met by conservation via the renal/ADH
axis, thirst is stimulated. Thirst is regulated primarily by plasma tonicity; however,
in human beings the threshold for stimulation of thirst is approximately 2 to 5 mOsm/kg
greater than that for stimulation of ADH release.
11
Thirst is controlled by osmosensitive neurons in close proximity in the hypothalamus
to osmoreceptors that mediate ADH secretion.
12
Thirst is sensed peripherally by oropharyngeal mechanoreceptors as dryness of the
mouth. Thirst also may be stimulated by volume depletion through an incompletely understood
mechanism. Experimental ponies drank when their plasma osmolalities increased by 3%
after water deprivation, when plasma Na concentrations increased by approximately
5%, and after induction of a plasma volume deficit of 6%.
14
Mechanism of Urine Concentration
For the kidney to make concentrated urine, ADH must be produced, the renal collecting
tubules must respond to ADH, and the renal medullary interstitium must be hypertonic.
Generation of medullary hypertonicity is initiated in the thick ascending limb of
the loop of Henle by active transport of NaCl out of the lumen. Because the thick
ascending limb is impermeable to water, active resorption of NaCl results in hypotonicity
of the fluid entering the distal tubule in the renal cortex (Figure 3.2-1, A
). The distal tubules and cortical portions of the collecting ducts are permeable
to water (Figure 3.2-1, B), which is reabsorbed down its concentration gradient into
the interstitium. Reabsorbed water is transported rapidly out of the interstitium
by the extensive cortical capillary network, and interstitial hypertonicity is preserved.
Urea remains in the lumen of the distal tubule and cortical collecting duct and is
concentrated further. Luminal fluid flows into the medullary collecting duct, which
is permeable to water and urea when under the influence of ADH (Figure 3.2-1, C).
Water is reabsorbed down its progressively steeper concentration gradient as luminal
fluid moves through the medullary collecting ducts. Some urea also is reabsorbed into
the interstitium. Reabsorbed water is removed efficiently by the vasa recta in the
renal medulla. Because these blood vessels also are arranged in a hairpin loop, minimal
loss of medullary interstitial solute occurs with water removal. Some reabsorbed urea
enters the loop of Henle (Figure 3.2-1, D) and thus is recycled, helping to maintain
medullary hypertonicity. In the absence of ADH, the collecting ducts are relatively
impermeable to water and urea, resulting in water and urea loss in urine and reduction
of medullary solute. Prolonged diuresis of any cause may result in the loss of medullary
hypertonicity (medullary washout) with subsequent impairment of renal concentrating
ability. Water is reabsorbed down its concentration gradient from the thin descending
limb of the loop of Henle (Figure 3.2-1, E) as a consequence of medullary hypertonicity.
This segment of the nephron is impermeable to NaCl and urea, thus the osmolality of
luminal fluid in the most distal portion of the loop approaches that of the interstitium.
The thin ascending limb of the loop of Henle is permeable to NaCl, which diffuses
down its concentration gradient into the interstitium (Figure 3.2-1, F). As previously
mentioned, this segment is also permeable to urea, and some interstitial urea enters
the tubule lumen by diffusion down its concentration gradient. Luminal fluid entering
the thick ascending limb of the loop of Henle is thus hypotonic to the interstitium.
Figure 3.2-1
The countercurrent hypothesis identifies the roles of sodium chloride and urea transport
in the generation of concentrated urine.
From Hansen B: Polyuria and polydipsia. In Fenner WR: Quick reference to veterinary
medicine, ed 2, Philadelphia, 1991, JB Lippincott. Adapted from Jamison RL, Maffly
RH: The urinary concentration mechanism, N Engl J Med 295:1059-1067, 1976.)
© 2004 JB Lippincott
2004
Since January 2020 Elsevier has created a COVID-19 resource centre with free information
in English and Mandarin on the novel coronavirus COVID-19. The COVID-19 resource centre
is hosted on Elsevier Connect, the company's public news and information website.
Elsevier hereby grants permission to make all its COVID-19-related research that is
available on the COVID-19 resource centre - including this research content - immediately
available in PubMed Central and other publicly funded repositories, such as the WHO
COVID database with rights for unrestricted research re-use and analyses in any form
or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are
granted for free by Elsevier for as long as the COVID-19 resource centre remains active.
When luminal fluid reaches the thick ascending limb of the loop of Henle, approximately
80% of the glomerular filtrate has been reabsorbed. Therefore only 20% of the glomerular
filtrate is available for reabsorption via the action of ADH.15, 16
Primary Polydipsia
Excessive water intake may result in water diuresis. Primary polydipsia has been described
in horses residing in the southern United States during months when ambient temperature
and humidity are high. Apparent psychogenic polydipsia may result from boredom, especially
in stalled, young horses.
8
Psychogenic polydipsia also has been reported anecdotally in horses with chronic liver
disease and central nervous system signs that had been treated with intravenous fluids.
17
Primary disorders of thirst are poorly understood in horses.
Causes of Polyuria With Secondary Polydipsia
Increased urine flow may be induced by solute or water diuresis (Box 3.2-1
). Solute diuresis results in increased urine flow because of excessive renal excretion
of a nonreabsorbed solute such as glucose or sodium. During solute diuresis, the urine
osmolality is equal to or higher than the plasma osmolality. Primary renal insufficiency
or failure (33% or fewer intact nephrons) result in solute diuresis, because each
functional nephron must filter an increased amount of solute to maintain daily obligatory
solute excretion. Fractional clearances of solutes such as Na, K, and Cl therefore
appropriately increase. Solute diuresis caused by glucosuria occurs in hyperglycemic
horses when the maximal renal reabsorptive capacity for glucose is exceeded (180 to
200 mg/dl).
18
Solute diuresis caused by glucosuria has been reported in horses with pituitary adenoma
and in a hyperglycemic horse with bilateral granulosa cell tumors.19, 20 Primary diabetes
mellitus, a common cause of hyperglycemia and glucosuria in other species, is uncommon
in the horse, although type 2 diabetes mellitus was diagnosed in a 15-year-old Quarter
Horse mare.
21
Primary renal tubular glucosuria caused by a defect in proximal tubular glucose reabsorption
(as is seen in Basenji dogs with Fanconi-like syndrome)
15
has not been reported in horses. Psychogenic salt consumption also has been reported
to cause solute diuresis in a horse.
22
Postobstructive solute diuresis is not diagnosed commonly in horses because nephrolithiasis
and ureterolithiasis are uncommon; when they occur, the condition is often bilateral
and associated with chronic renal failure, and treatment is usually unsuccessful.23,
24
BOX 3.2-1
CAUSES OF POLYURIA AND POLYDIPSIA
Solute Diuresis
Primary renal insufficiency or failure
Glucosuria (adenoma of the pars intermedia of the pituitary)
Psychogenic salt consumption
Diabetes mellitus
Postobstructive diuresis
Water Diuresis
Insufficient antidiuretic hormone (central diabetes insipidus)
Adenoma of the pars intermedia of the pituitary
Head trauma
(Potassium depletion)*
Insufficient response of collecting ducts to antidiuretic hormone
Acquired nephrogenic diabetes insipidus
Hyperadrenocorticism (glucocorticoid excess with adenoma of the pars intermedia of
the pituitary)
Endotoxemia
(Drugs: gentamicin, lithium, methoxyflurane, amphotericin B, propoxyphene, etc.)
(Congenital nephrogenic diabetes insipidus)
Renal medullary solute washout
Chronic diuresis of any cause
Inappropriate renal tubular sodium handling
Apparent psychogenic polydipsia
(Chronic liver disease)
(Polycythemia)
(Pyometra)
(Hypercalcemia)
(Potassium depletion)
Iatrogenic
Intravenous fluid therapy
Excess dietary salt
Drugs:
Diuretics
Glucocorticoids
(Drugs causing acquired diabetes insipidus)
© 2004 JB Lippincott
2004
Since January 2020 Elsevier has created a COVID-19 resource centre with free information
in English and Mandarin on the novel coronavirus COVID-19. The COVID-19 resource centre
is hosted on Elsevier Connect, the company's public news and information website.
Elsevier hereby grants permission to make all its COVID-19-related research that is
available on the COVID-19 resource centre - including this research content - immediately
available in PubMed Central and other publicly funded repositories, such as the WHO
COVID database with rights for unrestricted research re-use and analyses in any form
or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are
granted for free by Elsevier for as long as the COVID-19 resource centre remains active.
Modified from Hansen B: Polyuria and polydipsia. In Fenner WR: Quick reference to
veterinary medicine, ed 2, Philadelphia, 1991, JB Lippincott.
Decreased water resorption in the collecting tubules or inappropriately large voluntary
water intake causes water diuresis. The osmolality of the urine during water diuresis
is less than that of plasma. Water diuresis may be caused by insufficient ADH secretion,
insensitivity of the receptors of the distal collecting duct and collecting tubules
to the action of ADH, renal medullary solute washout, or apparent psychogenic polydipsia.
Insufficient secretion of ADH (central diabetes insipidus) may be associated with
adenoma of the pars intermedia of horses but has never been documented
25
and with head trauma and potassium depletion in other species. A case of idiopathic
central diabetes insipidus was reported in a Welsh pony.
26
Insensitivity of collecting duct receptors to ADH may occur during endotoxemia and
hyperadrenocorticism (glucocorticoid excess associated with tumors of the pars intermedia).
In other species, potassium depletion, hypercalcemia, and the administration of certain
drugs (including gentamicin) have been reported to cause insensitivity of the collecting
duct receptors to ADH.
15
Congenital diabetes insipidus also has been reported in other species.
26
True nephrogenic diabetes insipidus implies isolated dysfunction of response to ADH
by collecting tubules that are not associated with other structural or metabolic lesions
of the kidney. The occurrence of nephrogenic diabetes insipidus in two sibling Thoroughbred
colts has suggested that the condition might be heritable in some horses.
27
Renal medullary washout (loss of medullary Na, Cl, and urea) leading to water diuresis
may result from chronic diuresis of any cause. Diuresis is associated with increased
tubular flow rates and inability to resorb sodium and urea adequately from the tubular
lumen. Enhanced medullary blood flow may deplete medullary solute further. Water diuresis
also has been reported in association with pyometra, hypoadrenocorticism (chronic
renal sodium loss), chronic liver disease (increased aldosterone concentration promotes
sodium retention, smaller daily load of urea for excretion caused by decreased conversion
of ammonia to urea), primary polycythemia, hypercalcemia, and potassium depletion
in other species.
15
Approach to the Horse With Polyuria and Polydipsia
Iatrogenic causes of polyuria and polydipsia (see Box 3.2-1) should be ruled out by
careful assessment of the history and by documentation of return to normal urine volume
and water intake after withdrawal of intravenous fluids, excess dietary salt, or drugs
implicated in causing polyuria and polydipsia (Figure 3.2-2
). Verification of 24-hour urine volume and water intake should be undertaken for
horses suspected of having polyuria and polydipsia that do not display obvious polyuria
(frequent large volume urination and wet stall) and polydipsia (water bucket always
empty and overt thirst). Hemogram, serum biochemistries, and urinalysis should be
assessed for all horses with polyuria and polydipsia. A hallmark finding in horses
with polyuria and polydipsia is a decreased urine specific gravity (USG). Identification
of other abnormalities on laboratory tests (e.g., increased blood urea nitrogen or
creatinine concentrations, hyperglycemia, and hypokalemia) necessitates ruling out
the presence of underlying diseases (such as renal insufficiency and adenoma of the
pars intermedia of the pituitary) using specialized laboratory tests.
Figure 3.2-2
Approach to the polyuric patient. PUPD, Polyuria and polydipsia; U/A, Urinalysis.
Modified from Hansen B: Polyuria and polydipsia. In Fenner WR: Quick reference to
veterinary medicine, ed 2, Philadelphia, 1991, JB Lippincott.
© 2004 JB Lippincott
2004
Since January 2020 Elsevier has created a COVID-19 resource centre with free information
in English and Mandarin on the novel coronavirus COVID-19. The COVID-19 resource centre
is hosted on Elsevier Connect, the company's public news and information website.
Elsevier hereby grants permission to make all its COVID-19-related research that is
available on the COVID-19 resource centre - including this research content - immediately
available in PubMed Central and other publicly funded repositories, such as the WHO
COVID database with rights for unrestricted research re-use and analyses in any form
or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are
granted for free by Elsevier for as long as the COVID-19 resource centre remains active.
The hydration status of horses then should be assessed carefully. Those horses that
are dehydrated should be rehydrated judiciously with intravenous fluids, taking care
not to overhydrate horses with renal insufficiency. After rehydration, when possible,
creatinine clearance should be determined by using a urine collection apparatus to
allow 24-hour volumetric urine collection. A creatinine clearance value below the
reference range (1.46 to 3.68 ml/min/kg)
28
suggests that renal insufficiency with decreased glomerular filtration rate and solute
diuresis are likely present. A creatinine clearance within the reference range indicates
that central diabetes insipidus (CDI), nephrogenic diabetes insipidus (NDI), or apparent
psychogenic polydypsia (APP) is present. To distinguish among these differential diagnoses,
an exogenous ADH challenge test should be performed (see the subsequent discussion).
Horses with polyuria and polydipsia that are well hydrated and healthy based on physical
examination and results of hemogram and serum biochemistry determinations should be
subjected to a water deprivation test to assess renal ability to conserve water.2,
29, 30 Water deprivation testing is contraindicated in a dehydrated horse with a low
USG. Such horses have already undergone an endogenous water deprivation test (clinical
dehydration is present) and have responded with an inappropriately low USG. The following
guidelines for interpretation of water deprivation test results are based on practical
experience and the limited data available. A positive response to water deprivation
(USG >1.030) indicates that the horse has APP, whereas a negative response (USG <1.008)
after 24 hours of water deprivation or greater than 5% weight loss
31
is consistent with a diagnosis of CDI, true NDI, insensitivity of collecting duct
receptors to ADH, or apparent psychogenic polydipsia and medullary solute washout
(APP plus MSW). Horses with a negative response to water deprivation testing should
undergo an exogenous ADH challenge. Some horses may have an intermediate response
to water deprivation. An intermediate response is consistent with partial CDI or APP
plus MSW or renal insufficiency, and assessment of creatinine clearance is indicated.
Consult Chapter 18 for a more detailed discussion of water deprivation testing.
An evaluation of a response to the administration of exogenous ADH is indicated for
horses that do not concentrate their urine adequately during water deprivation testing,
for horses that require rehydration and subsequently demonstrate creatinine clearance
values within reference ranges, and for rehydrated horses for which creatinine clearance
determinations are impractical. Two regimens for exogenous ADH administration have
been reported: 40 to 80 IU ADH as Pitressin tannate in oil intramuscularly
32
or 0.25 IU/kg aqueous or repository ADH intramuscularly. A few reports of responses
of horses to exogenous ADH administration have been made, and the following recommendations
are based on clinical experience. A positive response to exogenous ADH (USG >1.020)
confirms the diagnosis of CDI.A negative response (USG <1.020) implies that NDI or
APP plus MSW is present.
31
MSW may result in a decreased USG despite the presence of adequate ADH. A partial
water deprivation test should result in an increase in USG in horses with APP plus
MSW but should have no effect on horses with true NDI or insensitivity of collecting
duct receptors to ADH. The horse is allowed to consume its normal diet and water ad
libitum. Voluntary water consumption is monitored closely for 3 to 4 days to establish
a baseline. Water available to the horse then is decreased by 5% to 10% of the baseline
voluntary intake. Water should be offered in aliquots several times a day to prevent
the horse from consuming most of the water in a short time. Water intake should never
be restricted below maintenance requirements (about 40 ml/kg/day). During water restriction,
the horse is allowed to eat its regular diet. The horse should be weighed daily if
possible and should be observed carefully for signs of dehydration (prolonged capillary
refill time, increasing heart rate, prolonged skin tenting, and hypernatremia). Moderate
water restriction in the face of continued intake of dietary solutes facilitates reestablishment
of the corticomedullary osmotic gradient.
15
Results of partial water deprivation tests in horses have been reported infrequently.
The diagnosis of true NDI or insensitivity of collecting duct receptors to ADH may
be confirmed by measuring plasma ADH concentrations before and after partial water
deprivation. ADH concentrations have been reported to increase from baseline values
of 1.53 ± 0.36 pg/ml to 4.32 ± 1.12 pg/ml after 24 hours of water deprivation in ponies.
13
Because CDI, NDI, and APP are uncommon in horses, the presenting complaint of polyuria
and polydipsia usually signifies other underlying disease. The most likely underlying
disease is renal insufficiency. Pituitary adenoma should be considered in horses with
compatible clinical signs (hirsutism, weight loss, and laminitis) and supporting laboratory
data (hyperglycemia and failure of suppression of cortisol production by dexamethasone).33,
34 Medullary washout may be a more common complication of primary diseases and their
therapy in horses than has been reported to date. Potential causes of diuresis compatible
with the case history and clinical signs should be investigated, and a partial water
deprivation test should be considered when horses exhibit polyuria and polydipsia.
REFERENCES
1
Tasker
JB
Fluid and electrolyte studies in the horses. III. Intake and output of water, sodium
and potassium in normal horses
Cornell Vet
57
1967
649
657
2
Rumbaugh
GE
Carlson
GP
Harrold
D
Urinary production in the healthy horse and in horses deprived of feed and water
Am J Vet Res
43
1982
735
737
7073100
3
Morris
DD
Divers
TJ
Whitlock
RH
Renal clearance and fractional excretion of electrolytes over a 24-hour period in
horses
Am J Vet Res
45
1984
2431
2435
6524740
4
Kohn
CW
Strasser
SL
24-hour renal clearance and excretion of endogenous substances in the mare
Am J Vet Res
47
1986
1332
1337
3729136
5
Cymbaluk
NF
Water balance of horses fed various diets
Equine Pract
11
1989
19
24
6
Rose
RJ
Electrolytes: clinical application
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
6
1990
281
294
7
Kohn
CW
DiBartola
SP
Composition and distribution of body fluids in dogs and cats
Fluid therapy in small animal practice
1992
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
8
Roussel
AJ
Carter
GK
Polyuria and polydipsia
Problems in equine medicine
1989
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
9
Harris
P
Collection of urine
Equine Vet J
20
1988
86
88
3286244
10
Humes
HD
Disorders of water metabolism
Fluids and Electrolytes
1986
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
11
Rose
BD
Clinical physiology of acid-base and electrolyte disorders
1989
McGraw-Hill Information Services
New York
12
Zerbe
RL
Robertson
GL
Osmotic and nonosmotic regulation of thirst and vasopressin secretion
Maxwell and Kleeman's clinical disorders of fluid and electrolyte metabolism
1994
McGraw-Hill
New York
13
Houpt
KA
Thornton
SN
Allen
WR
Vasopressin in dehydrated and rehydrated ponies
Physiol Behav
45
1989
659
661
2756059
14
Suffit
E
Houpt
KA
Sweeting
M
Physiological stimuli of thirst and drinking patterns in ponies
Equine Vet J
17
1985
12
16
3979367
15
Hansen
B
Polyuria and polydipsia
Quick reference to veterinary medicine
ed 2
1991
JB Lippincott
Philadelphia
16
Jamison
RL
Maffly
RH
The urinary concentrating mechanism
N Engl J Med
295
1976
1059
1067
972660
17
Carlson
GP
Discussion: practical clinical chemistry
Proceedings of the 23rd AAEP Convention
1977
American Association of Equine Practitioners
Golden, Colo
18
Stewart
J
Holman
HH
The “blood picture” of the horse
Vet Rec
52
1940
157
165
19
Corke
MJ
Diabetes mellitus: the tip of the iceberg
Equine Vet J
18
1986
87
88
3698960
20
McCoy
DJ
Diabetes mellitus associated with bilateral granulosa cell tumors in a mare
J Am Vet Med Assoc
188
1986
733
734
3700232
21
Ruoff
WW
Baker
DC
Morgan
SJ
Type II diabetes mellitus in a horse
Equine Vet J
18
1986
143
144
3778577
22
Buntain
BJ
Coffman
JR
Polyuria and polydypsia in a horse induced by psychogenic salt consumption
Equine Vet J
13
1981
266
268
7318809
23
Laverty
S
Pascoe
JR
Ling
GV
Urolithiasis in 68 horses
Vet Surg
21
1992
56
1580059
24
Ehnen
SJ
Divers
TJ
Gillette
D
Obstructive nephrolithiasis and ureterolithiasis associated with chronic renal failure
in horses: eight cases (1981-1987)
J Am Vet Med Assoc
197
1990
249
2200763
25
Baker
JR
Ritchie
HE
Diabetes mellitus in the horse: a case report and review of the literature
Equine Vet J
6
1974
7
11
4819829
26
Breukink
HJ
Van Wegen
P
Schotman
AJH
Idiopathic diabetes insipidus in a Welsh pony
Equine Vet J
15
1983
284
287
6884322
27
Schott
HC
Bayly
WM
Reed
SM
Nephrogenic diabetes insipidus in sibling colts
J Vet Intern Med
7
1993
68
72
8501698
28
Kohn
CW
Chew
DJ
Laboratory diagnosis and characterization of renal disease in horses
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
3
1987
585
615
3322528
29
Brobst
DF
Bayly
WM
Responses of horses to a water deprivation test
J Equine Vet Sci
2
1982
51
56
30
Genetzky
RM
Loparco
FV
Ledet
AE
Clinical pathologic alterations in horses during a water deprivation test
Am J Vet Res
48
1987
1007
1011
3605802
31
Ziemer
EL
Water deprivation test and vasopressin challenge
Equine medicine and surgery
1991
American Veterinary Publications
Goleta, Calif
32
Whitlock
RH
Polyuria
Robinson
NE
Current therapy in equine medicine
ed 3
1992
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
33
Madigan
JE
Dybdal
NO
Endocrine and metabolic diseases
Large animal internal medicine
1990
CV Mosby
St Louis
34
Groenedyk
S
English
PB
Abetz
I
External balance of water and electrolytes in the horse
Equine Vet J
20
1988
189
193
3402414
Hinchcliff
Kenneth W.
3.3—Edema
Edema is the excessive and abnormal accumulation of fluid in the interstitium. Interstitial
fluid accumulates because of imbalances in the rates with which fluid enters and exits
the interstitium. Factors that increase the rate of fluid flux from the capillary
or impair lymph drainage sufficiently to overwhelm normal compensatory mechanisms
result in accumulation of fluid and the development of edema.
Physiology
The volume of interstitial fluid and lymph fluid in the normal horse is 8% to 10%
of body mass,
1
or 36 to 45 L in a 450-kg horse. Interstitial fluid consists of water, protein, and
electrolytes. Compared with plasma, interstitial fluid has a slightly lower concentration
of cationic electrolytes, a slightly higher concentration of chloride, and a much
lower concentration of protein (1.2 versus 0.2 mOsm/L of water).
2
The amount and function of plasma proteins within the interstitial space are not inconsequential.
A constant circulation of plasma proteins occurs between the vascular and interstitial
spaces, with about half of the protein circulating every 24 hours in human beings.
More than half of the plasma protein content of the body is contained within the interstitial
space at any one time. Plasma proteins within the interstitial space are important
in the transport of water-insoluble substances from the vascular space and in resistance
to infection.
3
Interstitial fluid is contained within the interstitium, the intercellular connective
tissues that lie between the cellular elements of the vascular and cellular compartments
of the body. The extracellular tissue of the interstitium, except in the case of bone,
consists of a three-dimensional collagen fiber network embedded in a proteoglycan
gel matrix.
4
Interstitial water exists as free water and as water within the proteoglycan gel.
Normally, only a small proportion of interstitial fluid exists as free water, most
of the water being contained in the interstitial gel. However, in edematous states,
the proportion of fluid as free water within the interstitium increases.
2
The source of interstitial fluid is the intravascular space. The volume of interstitial
fluid is determined by the functional relationships of three major anatomic structures:
the capillary, the interstitial space, and the lymphatics.
5
Functionally, the volume of fluid that accumulates in the interstitium is determined
by the rate of ingress of fluid from the vascular space, the compliance of the interstitium,
and the rate at which fluid is evacuated from the interstitium. The net rate of ingress
of fluid from capillaries into the interstitium is determined by a number of factors
acting across the capillary membrane, the effects of which are related by Starling's
equation:
J
=
Kf
[
(
P
C
-
P
t
)
-
σ
(
π
P
-
π
t
)
]
in which J equals the volume flow across the capillary wall; Kf equals the filtration
coefficient of the capillary wall (volume flow per unit time per 100 g of tissue per
unit pressure); Pc equals capillary hydrostatic pressure; Pt equals interstitial fluid
hydrostatic pressure; σ equals the osmotic reflection coefficient; πp equals the colloid
osmotic (oncotic) pressure of the plasma; and πt equals the colloid osmotic (oncotic)
pressure of the interstitial fluid.
6
Although all these factors act in concert to determine the rate of net fluid efflux
from the capillary, considering them individually is conceptually easier.
FILTRATION (Kf) AND REFLECTION (σ) COEFFICIENTS
Together the filtration and reflection coefficients describe the properties of the
capillary membrane that determine the ease with which water, protein, and other plasma
constituents move from the vascular space to the interstitium. The filtration coefficient,
which is the product of the hydraulic permeability and surface area of the capillary,
is a measure of the ease with which water crosses the capillary membrane. The reflection
coefficient is an indicator of the degree to which the capillary membrane resists
the passage of a substance, such as protein. A reflection coefficient can be defined
for each substance; a reflection coefficient of 0 indicates that the molecule crosses
the membrane as readily as does water, whereas a value of 1 indicates that the membrane
is impermeable to the substance. The reflection coefficient for a substance may vary
with the anatomic site of the capillary7, 8: Capillaries in the liver are permeable
to albumin, whereas capillaries in muscle are much less permeable and cerebral capillaries
are among the least permeable to albumin.
The movement of fluid and protein across the vascular membrane is assumed to be passive,
with plasma water and protein exiting the vascular space through pores in the capillary
membrane. However, the rate with which various plasma constituents cross the capillary
membrane varies considerably depending on the constituent and the tissue. For example,
muscle capillary pores are permeable to water molecules (reflection coefficient of
0) but much less permeable to albumin (reflection coefficient of approximately 0.9).
2
Movement of solutes across the endothelium is not understood fully, being complex,
but is affected by the concentration of the solutes on either side of the membrane,
solute charge and interaction with other solutes, and capillary pore configuration.
9
Together the filtration and reflection coefficients partially determine the rate of
fluid flux across the capillary wall, and the composition of the fluid. For a given
hydrostatic and oncotic pressure difference, tissues with higher filtration coefficients
(whether because of a larger capillary surface area or more porous capillaries) will
have a greater fluid flux. Conversely, under the same circumstance, increases in the
reflection coefficient of the capillary wall reduce fluid flux. The differential permeability
of the capillary membrane to water and protein has important consequences in the maintenance
of the oncotic pressure difference between plasma and interstitial fluid.
HYDROSTATIC AND COLLOID OSMOTIC PRESSURES
Transcapillary fluid flow is results from an imbalance between the hydraulic forces
favoring movement of water from the capillary into the interstitium and the forces
favoring movement of water in the reverse direction. The forces contributing to fluid
movement out of the capillary are the intracapillary hydrostatic pressure and the
interstitial colloid osmotic pressure, whereas those forces favoring movement of fluid
from the interstitium to the capillary are the interstitial hydrostatic pressure (if
it is positive) and the plasma colloid osmotic pressure.
10
The principal force favoring fluid efflux from the capillary is the hydrostatic pressure
within the capillary. Capillary hydrostatic pressure varies among different tissues
and decreases along the length of the capillary. Hydrostatic pressure within a capillary
is determined by the arterial and venous pressures and by the precapillary and postcapillary
resistances.
11
Specifically, capillary pressure is determined by the ratio of the postcapillary resistance
(Ra) to the precapillary resistance (Rv), and the arterial (Pa) and venous (Pv) pressures:
P
C
=
(
R
V
/
R
a
)
P
a
+
P
V
1
+
(
R
V
/
R
a
)
Thus a small increase in venous pressure has a much greater effect on capillary pressure
than does an increase in arterial pressure. For this reason the hydrostatic pressure
is greater in capillaries below the heart (e.g., legs) than in those above the heart
(e.g., head).
The colloid osmotic pressure of the plasma is the principal force minimizing fluid
efflux from the capillary. The colloid osmotic pressure is generated because the plasma
and interstitial fluid are separated by a semipermeable membrane—the endothelium—and
vary slightly, but significantly, in composition. As noted previously, the interstitial
fluid has a lower protein concentration than does plasma but has an essentially identical
electrolyte concentration. The difference in protein concentration across the semipermeable
endothelium generates an osmotic force that tends to draw water from the interstitium
into the plasma.
In addition to the capillary hydrostatic pressure, the colloid osmotic pressure and
negative hydrostatic pressure of the interstitial fluid favor fluid movement out of
the capillary. Fluid flux across the capillary results from the summation of these
forces (Table 3.3-1
). These figures should be recognized as representing the forces at the midpoint of
an idealized capillary and that the forces are dynamic, changing between tissues and
even along the length of the capillary. In fact, a large net flux of fluid from the
capillary occurs at its arteriolar end, where capillary hydrostatic forces are greatest
and plasma oncotic forces are least, and a net flux of fluid into the capillary toward
its venous end, where capillary hydrostatic forces are least and plasma oncotic pressure
is greatest.
TABLE 3.3-1
Mean Forces (mm Hg) Influencing Fluid Movement Into or Out of the Capillary
HYDROSTATIC PRESSURES
Mean capillary pressure
17.0
Interstitial pressure
–5.3
Total hydrostatic pressure favoring filtration
22.3
COLLOID ONCOTIC PRESSURES
Plasma oncotic pressure
28.0
Interstitial oncotic pressure
6.0
Total oncotic pressure opposing filtration
22.0
TOTAL PRESSURE FAVORING FILTRATION
0.3
Data from Guyton AC: Textbook of medical physiology, ed 8, Philadelphia, 1986, WB
Saunders.
The small imbalance in filtration forces results in a net efflux of fluid from the
capillary into the interstitial tissue. This fluid does not accumulate in the interstitium;
it is removed by the lymphatics.
LYMPHATICS
The lymphatics drain the interstitium of fluid and substances, notably proteins, that
are not absorbed by the capillaries. The lymphatics represent the only means by which
interstitial protein is returned to the circulation. Interstitial fluid, and with
it protein, moves down a pressure gradient into lymphatic capillaries through clefts
between the lymphatic endothelial cells. Lymphatic endothelial cells are supported,
and the lymphatic capillaries maintained patent, by anchoring filaments that attach
the endothelial cells to surrounding connective tissue. Lymphatic fluid progresses
centripetally through progressively larger vessels before draining into the great
veins of the chest. Lymphatic valves prevent the retrograde flow of fluid from the
lymphatics. Lymph is propelled by factors extrinsic to the lymphatics, including muscle
activity, active and passive motion, posture, respiration, and blood vessel pulsation.
Exercise causes a significant increase in lymph flow, at least in part because of
the increase in tissue pressure that is associated with muscle contraction, although
passive motion also increases lymph flow. Standing results in significant diminution
or cessation of lymph flow from, and the prompt accumulation of interstitial fluid
in, the lower extremities of human beings. In addition to the extrinsic factors affecting
lymph flow, coordinated contractions of lymphatic vessels contribute substantially
to the centripetal flow of lymph.
12
Mechanisms of Edema Formation
Simply stated, accumulation of excessive fluid in the interstitial spaces—edema—results
from an imbalance of the rates of fluid filtration from the capillaries and drainage
by the lymphatics. Perturbations of one or more of the forces that affect filtration
across the capillary alter the rate at which fluid enters the interstitium. Increases
in capillary hydrostatic pressure, decreases in plasma oncotic pressure, and increases
in interstitial oncotic pressure all favor increased fluid filtration. Conversely,
increased interstitial hydrostatic pressure and decreased interstitial oncotic pressure
act to inhibit fluid filtration.
Box 3.3-1
lists the fundamental mechanisms of accumulation of excessive interstitial fluid.
Increases in capillary hydrostatic pressure, which occur with venous obstruction or
arteriolar dilation, such as that associated with inflammation, increase net fluid
efflux. The edema that occurs with congestive heart failure likely has an increase
in capillary hydrostatic pressure as one of its causes, although the mechanism is
complex.
13
Posture also affects capillary hydrostatic pressure; capillaries below the level of
the heart have higher hydrostatic pressures than do capillaries above the level of
the heart.
BOX 3.3-1
PATHOGENESIS OF EDEMA
Increased Capillary Hydrostatic Pressure
Venous obstruction
Thrombophlebitis
Compression (mass, tourniquet)
Venous congestion
Posture (dependent limbs)
Congestive heart failure
Arteriolar dilation
Inflammation
Increased body water
Decreased Plasma Oncotic Pressure
Panhypoproteinemia
Hypoalbuminemia
Increased Interstitial Oncotic Pressure
Increased capillary permeability
Decreased Lymph Flow
Lymphatic obstruction
A decrease in the oncotic gradient across the capillary endothelium, which occurs
with a decreased plasma oncotic pressure or an increased interstitial oncotic pressure,
results in an increase in efflux of fluid from the capillary. A decrease in plasma
oncotic pressure decreases the oncotic gradient that favors movement of fluid into
the capillary. Consequently, the capillary hydrostatic pressure, which favors filtration,
predominates and fluid accumulates in the interstitium. Plasma oncotic pressure decreases
when plasma protein concentration declines. Albumin is the plasma protein that exerts
the preponderance of the oncotic force
8
; therefore clinically, edema often is associated with hypoalbuminemia. An increase
in the permeability of the capillary membrane greatly increases fluid and protein
transport into the interstitium and decreases the ability of the membrane to maintain
a difference in oncotic pressure between the plasma and the interstitium.
5
Capillary permeability increases when the endothelium is damaged, such as by vasculitis
or inflammatory reactions.
Lymphatic obstruction prevents the removal of interstitial fluid and protein. Filtration
of fluid and passage of small amounts of protein into the interstitial space continues
in the presence of lymphatic obstruction. The interstitial fluid is reabsorbed by
the capillaries; however, the protein is not. Consequently, the protein content of
the interstitial fluid gradually increases, with a resultant increase in interstitial
oncotic pressure that favors filtration of fluid. The increased interstitial oncotic
pressure causes fluid to accumulate in the interstitium, thus exacerbating the edema.
2
Alterations in the magnitude of one or more of Starling's forces may be offset by
compensatory changes in lymph flow and other of Starling's forces. In concert, Starling's
forces and lymph flow act as “edema safety factors” to prevent the excess accumulation
of interstitial fluid and development of frank edema. For example, lymph flow increases
with the increased filtration associated with increased capillary hydrostatic pressure.
Thus a larger volume of fluid enters and is removed from the interstitial space. The
interstitial protein concentration decreases as increased fluid flow washes protein
out of the interstitial space. Reduced interstitial space protein concentration increases
the oncotic gradient, inhibiting fluid efflux from the capillary, and decreases the
rate of movement of fluid from the capillary to the interstitial space.
6
Diagnostic Approach to the Patient With Edema
Edema is not of itself a disease; rather it is a sign of a disease process. Therefore
the diagnostic approach to the patient with edema is based on an understanding of
the pathogenesis of edema and a knowledge of the diseases likely to be involved (Box
3.3-2
). The diagnostic approach to an animal with edema should not be any different than
for any other sign of disease. A clinical examination, including history and physical
examination, permit the development of a list of potential diagnoses and dictate the
appropriate subsequent steps in confirming the diagnosis. The reader is referred to
those sections of the text that deal with specific diseases for a description of the
appropriate diagnostic aids.
BOX 3.3-2
COMMON CAUSES OF PERIPHERAL OR VENTRAL EDEMA IN HORSES
Congestive Heart Failure
Valvular disease
Myocarditis
Monensin toxicosis
Vasculitis
Equine viral arteritis
Equine ehrlichiosis
Purpura hemorrhagica
Equine infectious anemia
Venous Obstruction and Congestion
Catheter-related thrombophlebitis
Disseminated intravascular coagulation
Tight bandages
Tumors
Immobility
Cellulitis
Staphylococcal
Clostridial
Counterirritant application
Lymphatic Obstruction
Ulcerative lymphangitis
Lymphadenitis (Streptococcus equi, Corynebacterium pseudotuberculosis)
Lymphosarcoma
Tumors
Hypoalbuminemia
Parasitism
Pleural and peritoneal effusions
Protein loss (gastrointestinal, renal, or wounds)
Inadequate production (starvation)
Hemodilution (subsequent to hemorrhage)
Shock
Hemorrhagic
Endotoxic
Pleuritis
Late-Term Pregnancy
Prepubic Tendon Rupture
Starvation
Inadequate intake
Malabsorption
When taking the history of a horse that has edema, one should focus on acquiring those
facts that have the greatest diagnostic use in differentiating among those diseases
that have edema as a sign. One should consider the following aspects:
•
Housing, season, and geographic region
•
Vaccine and parasiticide administration
•
Exposure to other horses and diseases present within the herd
•
The duration of the edema, its distribution, and the presence of any other clinical
signs
One should investigate the remainder of the history depending on the responses to
initial questions.
The physical examination should begin with a visual evaluation of the attitude and
physical condition of the horse. The temperature, pulse, and respiration should be
recorded. Although the physical examination should be complete, particular attention
should be paid to those body systems that the preliminary examination indicates may
be involved in the disease process. The physical examination reveals the distribution
and severity of edema. Edema that is localized to one extremity or is not bilaterally
symmetric is more likely to be caused by local factors (e.g., lymphangitis or venous
obstruction) than by systemic disease. Conversely, edema that involves several areas
of the body and has a symmetric distribution is likely to be associated with systemic
disease (e.g., the ventral edema of congestive heart failure).
Following the initial clinical examination, the clinician will have developed an ordered
list of potential diagnoses. Confirmation, or elimination, of these diagnoses depends
on subsequent diagnostic procedures, including the response to therapy. Sections of
this text deal with the specific disease processes for appropriate diagnostic procedures.
REFERENCES
1
Carlson
GP
Blood chemistry, body fluids, and hematology
Gillespie
JR
Robinson
NE
Equine exercise physiology
ed 2
1987
ICEEP Publications
Davis, Calif
2
Guyton
AC
The body fluid compartments: extracellular and intracellular fluids; interstitial
fluid and edema
Guyton
AC
Textbook of medical physiology
ed 8
1986
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
3
Renkin
EM
Some consequences of capillary permeability to macromolecules: Starling's hypothesis
revisited
Am J Physiol
250
1986
H706
H710
3706547
4
Comper
WD
Interstitium
Staub
NC
Taylor
AE
Edema
1984
Raven Press
New York
5
Demling
RH
Effect of plasma and interstitial protein content on tissue edema formation
Curr Stud Hematol Blood Transfus
53
1986
36
52
6
Taylor
AE
Capillary fluid filtration: Starling forces and lymph flow
Circ Res
49
1981
557
575
7020975
7
Taylor
AE
Granger
DN
Exchange of macromolecules across the microcirculation
Renkin
EM
Michel
CC
Handbook of physiology
1984
Oxford University Press
New York
8
Raj
JU
Anderson
J
Regional differences in interstitial fluid albumin concentration in edematous lamb
lungs
J Appl Physiol
72
1992
699
705
1559950
9
Berne
RM
Levy
MN
The microcirculation and lymphatics
Berne
RM
Levy
MN
Physiology
ed 2
1986
CV Mosby
St Louis
10
Michel
CC
Microvascular permeability, venous stasis and oedema
Inter Angiol
8
1984
9
13
11
Green
JF
Fundamental cardiovascular and pulmonary physiology
1987
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
12
Gnepp
DR
Lymphatics
Staub
NC
Taylor
AE
Edema
1984
Raven Press
New York
13
Weaver
LJ
Carrico
CJ
Congestive heart failure and edema
Staub
NC
Taylor
AE
Edema
1984
Raven Press
New York
Foreman
Jonathan H.
3.4—Changes in Body Weight
An unwelcome or unexpected change in the body weight of a horse is a commonly encountered
problem in equine practice. Although obesity may be a more common problem, weight
loss often represents a more serious situation, with potentially severe consequences.
Normal or acceptable body weight is also in the eye of the beholder, because a horse
with a given body weight might look overweight as an endurance horse, appropriate
as a Thoroughbred racehorse, or too thin as a show hunter.
Whether dealing with a problem of weight loss or weight gain, the veterinarian always
should investigate the feeding practices of the horse. Not uncommonly the owner reports
that the horse is receiving 3 lb of grain twice daily when the actual measuring device
(usually the everyday coffee can) differs in net grain weight once the volume of the
measuring device and grain density are taken into account. Observing firsthand the
feeding practices of the stable may be necessary to document that the horse actually
is getting the reported amount of grain 2 or 3 times daily. Hay should be examined
for type, quality (color, texture, leafiness, and steminess), mold, weeds, and potentially
toxic plants. The horse in question should be observed eating hay and grain to ensure
that it really does consume the amounts the owner or feeder reports.
The veterinarian also should observe nursing foals when they suckle. The udder should
be examined before and after nursing to ensure that the mare actually is producing
sufficient milk and that the foal actually is nursing the mare completely until her
udder is empty. The milk itself should be examined from both halves of the udder to
see that it appears grossly normal (no evidence of mastitis). The nostrils of the
foal should be examined after nursing to determine the presence of milk reflux caused
by dysphagia, esophageal obstruction, or gastric reflux associated with gastrointestinal
ulcers.
Decreased Body Weight
Losses in body weight are usually insidious and chronic but may be surprisingly rapid
in the face of acute overwhelming systemic infections (Box 3.4-1
). Causes have been classified variously as gastrointestinal, nutritional, infectious,
or hypoproteinemic.1, 2 Differential mechanisms include decreased feed intake, decreased
absorption of nutrients, decreased nutrient utilization, and increased loss of energy
or protein leading to a catabolic “sink.”1, 2, 3
BOX 3.4-1
MECHANISMS AND DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSES FOR DECREASED BODY WEIGHT
Decreased Dietary Intake
Inadequate diet
Lameness
Pecking order
Poor dentition
Dysphagia
Esophageal obstruction
Maldigestion and Malabsorption
Lactose intolerance
Gastrointestinal ulceration
Parasitism
Diarrhea
Inflammatory intestinal disease
Granulomatous enterocolitis
Eosinophilic enterocolitis
Lymphocytic/plasmacytic enterocolitis
Gastrointestinal neoplasia
Inappropriate Hepatic Utilization
Inadequate circulation and respiration
Heart failure
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Increased Rate of Protein and Energy Loss
Infection
Pneumonia
Pleuritis
Peritonitis
Equine infectious anemia
Protein-losing eneropathy
Diarrhea
Gastrointestinal ulceration
Parasitism
Inflammatory intestinal disease
Gastrointestinal neoplasia
Renal disease (glomerular)
Increased metabolic energy use
Chronic pain
Secondary hyperadrenocorticism
Decreased feed intake may be caused by management factors, poor dentition, dysphagia,
or esophageal obstruction. Management factors leading to weight loss may be multifactorial
and include inadequate amounts of feed, inadequate quality of feed, or inability of
the horse to eat the proper amounts of the feed given. A horse with severe lameness
(e.g., chronic laminitis) may not be able to ambulate to the feed source. A horse
low on the pecking order in a pasture hierarchy may be unable to eat because it cannot
approach the feed without the other horses bullying it and fending it away. The feed
must be palatable and digestible. Appropriate amounts and types of concentrates must
be fed considering the work schedule or pregnancy status of the horse. Proper investigation
of stable feeding practices is described earlier.
Poor dentition may cause the horse not to eat some or all of its grain or hay. Parrot-mouthed
horses or aged horses with receding incisor teeth (more than 25 years old) may have
difficulty in tearing off grass when grazing. A horse with one or more oral sores
from a poorly fitting bit or from sharp cheek teeth may exhibit partial or complete
inappetence because of pain associated with chewing. Sharp cheek teeth, wave mouth,
or step mouth may lead to poor digestion and incomplete absorption of nutrients because
of inadequate mastication of hay leading to poor fiber use during the hindgut (cecum)
fermentation process.
Dysphagia has many causes, including abnormal prehension, chewing, or swallowing.
4
Abnormal prehension can be caused by tongue lacerations; dental, mandibular, or maxillary
fractures; damage to nerves supplying the tongue or facial musculature (local trauma,
equine protozoal myelitis, or polyneuritis equi); or central neurologic disease (equine
protozoal myelitis). Basal ganglia lesions caused by poisoning by ingestion of yellow
star thistle or Russian knapweed prevent normal prehension in the pharynx.
5
Swallowing abnormalities may be caused by neurologic (equine protozoal myelitis, viral
encephalitis, or guttural pouch infection), muscular, or physical obstructions such
as strangles, abscesses, or guttural pouch distention.
4
Muscular causes include hyperkalemic periodic paralysis in Quarter Horse foals, vitamin
E or selenium deficiency in neonates, botulism in neonates and adults, and local trauma
subsequent to laryngeal surgery (laryngoplasty).
Esophageal obstruction usually presents acutely because an apparently dysphagic horse
regurgitates food from its nostrils while attempting to eat or drink. Chronic choke,
or anorexia related to painful swallowing caused by partial esophageal obstruction
may lead to weight loss without the owner realizing that the horse is not eating adequately.
Esophageal endoscopy is usually diagnostic, but positive contrast radiography may
be helpful and is sometimes necessary to establish an accurate diagnosis.
If the horse with weight loss has been observed fully to ingest adequate amounts of
good-quality hay and grain, then decreased feed absorption must be considered the
reason for weight loss. Maldigestion and malabsorption are not easily confirmed diagnoses,
but tests based on luminal absorption of simple sugars (xylose or glucose tolerance
tests) have been used to document malabsorption syndromes.3, 6, 7 These tests are
described in greater detail in Chapter 13.4. Malabsorption may be caused by parasitism,
diarrhea, and inflammatory or neoplastic intestinal disease.
Gastrointestinal parasitism results in weight loss because of several mechanisms.
2
Parasites may compete directly for nutrients within the lumen of the bowel. Malabsorption
may result from a lack of mucosal integrity, a decrease in intestinal villi size and
number (and subsequent decrease in mucosal absorptive surface area), and a decrease
in digestive enzymes that originate in the mucosa. Competition of parasites for protein
sources may result in decreased availability of amino acids for production of digestive
enzymes or mucosal transport proteins. Increased mucosal permeability caused by leakiness
in mucosal intercellular bridges may result in mucosal edema and increased transudation
of intercellular fluid and its associated electrolytes, amino acids, and sugars into
the lumen of the intestine.
Chronic diarrhea results in partial or complete anorexia, which contributes directly
to weight loss. More rapid (decreased) gastrointestinal transit time results in increased
losses of incompletely digested dietary feedstuffs. Malabsorption may result from
decreased transit time and from villus blunting caused by specific pathogens, such
as in viral diarrhea (see Chapter 13.4). Bacterial pathogens may compete directly
for luminal nutrients. Mucosal invasion by viral and bacterial pathogens may cause
mild to severe degrees of mucosal sloughing (ulcers), which result in maldigestion,
malabsorption, and increased mucosal losses of intercellular fluid (e.g., in parasitism).
Given that the horse has adequate feed intake and absorption, inappropriate hepatic
use of amino acids and sugars must be considered as a differential diagnosis for weight
loss. Chronic liver disease may result in weight loss because of inappetance, maldigestion
(caused by inadequate bile acid production), and inadequate or improper processing
of amino acids into normal plasma proteins in the liver. These abnormalities may result
in lowered concentrations of serum albumin, liver-dependent clotting factors (factors
II, VII, IX, and X), and total plasma or serum protein. Lowered circulating proteins
(especially albumin) may result in decreased plasma colloid osmotic pressure and thus
may manifest as peripheral dependent edema in the distal limbs, pectoral region, and
ventral midline. This peripheral edema may mask further weight loss by making the
torso of the horse appear to be heavier than it actually is. Decreases in clotting
factors may result in bleeding diatheses. Hyperlipemia, hyperlipidemia, fatty liver
syndrome, and ketosis may be seen in poorly fed ponies and in miniature horses with
acute anorexia or overwhelming energy demands, such as pregnancy or lactation.
8
Increased loss of protein or energy is a common cause of decreased body weight in
horses. Luminal losses of fluid, electrolytes, and nutrients were described earlier
for intestinal parasitism and diarrhea. Acute inflammatory protein losses may occur
into major body cavities in overwhelming infections such as pleuritis or peritonitis.
Chronic abscessing pneumonia, pleuritis, and peritonitis often result in increased,
rather than acutely decreased, serum total protein because of increased γ-globulin
production in response to chronic antigenic stimulation from the chronic infection.
These chronic infections also usually have weight loss as an additional clinical sign
because of the continuing catabolic processes associated with the infection itself.
Equine infectious anemia is a type of persistent systemic infection that in its symptomatic
form may result in chronic weight loss and varying levels of anemia.
9
Asymptomatic equine infectious anemia carriers may have no weight loss or other obvious
clinical signs but can infect pasture mates via vector transmission.
Protein-losing enteropathy is not a definitive diagnosis but rather is a group of
diseases, each of which results in luminal losses of fluid, electrolytes, plasma proteins,
and nutrients. Mechanisms of protein and fluid loss were described earlier for intestinal
parasitism and diarrhea. Gastrointestinal ulcers have been reported to result in lowered
serum total protein and weight loss.
10
One of the early indications of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drug toxicity is detection
of a lowered serum total protein. Horses with such a condition also may manifest varying
degrees of inappetence and colic, especially associated with the immediate postprandial
period. Intestinal neoplasms (usually lymphosarcoma) often manifest as a protein-losing
enteropathy with weight loss.
11
Acute or chronic renal diseases, especially involving glomerulonephritis, can result
in urinary protein loss and subsequent body weight loss.
12
Horses with this condition may have polyuria and polydipsia as associated clinical
signs. Owners or handlers often report polyuria as increased wetness in stall bedding.
The veterinarian should question owners thoroughly regarding the water intake of the
horse. The veterinarian may need to observe stable watering habits, often including
actually measuring the volume of the water buckets to establish definitively the presence
of polydipsia. Turning off automatic waterers in the stall or pasture and offering
the horse measured volumes of water from additional buckets may be necessary to establish
a diagnosis of polydipsia. Urine puddles in stalls or collected urine samples may
foam excessively because of increased protein concentrations. Increased urinary protein
concentrations can be diagnosed quickly on the farm with the proper interpretation
of urine dipstick protein indicators.
Neoplasms or abscesses within the thorax or abdomen serve as catabolic energy and
protein sinks, resulting in chronic weight loss.11, 12, 13 Chronic pain, such as that
associated with severe, unresponsive laminitis, results in increased catabolism and
weight loss, probably because of chronically elevated systemic catecholamine levels.
Increased circulating epinephrine and norepinephrine levels result in a whole-body
catabolic state with increased breakdown of stored energy sources and ultimately result
in chronic weight loss. Similar weight loss caused by systemic catabolism can result
from chronically elevated serum cortisol associated with pituitary adenoma and secondary
hyperadrenocorticism.
Heart murmurs and resultant heart failure can cause weight loss because of inefficiency
of circulation of nutrients and oxygen to peripheral tissues. Chronic obstructive
pulmonary disease or heaves may result in weight loss because of an increase in the
work of breathing and poor oxygenation of peripheral tissues. Although ventral abdominal
musculature may hypertrophy and result in a heave line, weight loss is manifested
by increased depth between the ribs and decreased muscular thickness and definition
along the dorsal midline. Suckling foals with severe pneumonia may manifest weight
loss if they become inappetent because of decreased suckling related to their severe
dyspnea.
An appropriately taken history should document the type, amount, and quality of feed
and hay being provided daily. Documentation of deworming products used and intervals
of administration is critical. The history also may document the presence of anorexia,
depression, polyuria, polydipsia, diarrhea, or other important historical signs that
may point more quickly toward a specific cause of the weight loss.
The physical examination should reveal the presence of weight loss, a cardiac murmur,
pneumonia or pleuropneumonia (increased lung sounds), chronic obstructive pulmonary
disease (increased abnormal expiratory lung sounds), dental abnormalities, peripheral
edema, urine staining on the hindlimbs, diarrhea, icterus, nasal discharge (dysphagia,
pneumonia), fever, or hirsutism (secondary hyperadrenocorticism). The rectal examination
may document the presence of intraabdominal masses (abscesses or neoplasms), enlarged
left kidney, thickened intestinal or rectal wall, colonic displacement, gritty peritoneal
surfaces (peritonitis), gritty feces (sand impaction), or diarrhea.
Fecal flotation may serve as an adequate screening tool to determine whether any evidence
of parasitism exists. In the event of a positive fecal flotation, Baermann sedimentation
may be necessary to determine quantitatively the severity of the patent parasitic
load in the horse with weight loss. Fecal occult blood may be positive with gastrointestinal
ulceration or neoplasms, but parasites or a recent rectal examination also may result
in positive results.
Routine hematologic testing (complete blood count and fibrinogen) should assist in
diagnosing infectious conditions such as pleuritis or peritonitis. Decreased serum
or plasma total protein and albumin concentrations are evidence of hypoproteinemia
and make the following conditions more likely: severe malnutrition, protein-losing
enteropathy (diarrhea, parasitism, ulceration, intestinal neoplasms, or inflammatory
intestinal disease), glomerular disease, acute pleuritis or peritonitis, or chronic
liver disease. Increased total protein concentrations, especially γ-globulins, make
chronic closed-cavity infections such as abscesses, peritonitis, or pleuritis more
likely. Increased β-globulin fractions suggest the presence of parasitism.
Routine serum biochemistries should aid in diagnosing renal (renal azotemia, electrolyte
abnormalities) and liver disease (increased γ-glutamyltransferase, aspartate aminotransferase,
serum alkaline phosphatase, and lactate dehydrogenase). Urinalysis should reveal increased
protein levels on dipstick or quantitative analysis in the event of glomerular protein
losses. Metabolic alkalosis may be evident in the aftermath of salivary bicarbonate
losses caused by dysphagia or esophageal obstruction.
Endoscopy may aid in diagnosing causes of dysphagia or esophageal obstruction. Lengthy
endoscopes are necessary for examination of large adult horses for suspected gastrointestinal
ulcers, but shorter endoscopes may suffice for foals or shorter-necked adults (e.g.,
Arabians and ponies).
Peritoneal fluid analysis documents the presence of a transudate (equivocal infection)
or exudate (probable infection).14, 15 Aerobic and anaerobic peritoneal fluid cultures
should be performed if intraabdominal infection is suspected. Exfoliative cytologic
examination rarely may document the presence of neoplastic cells from intraabdominal
neoplasms.11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16
Nonroutine tests should be performed only as indicated and should include oral absorption
tests (see Chapter 13.4) and biopsies of the liver, kidney, or intestinal wall. Abdominal
or thoracic ultrasonography should help to rule out abnormalities of the liver or
kidneys and may document the presence of abnormal fluid (peritonitis or pleuritis)
or masses (abscesses or neoplasms). Cardiac ultrasound should be definitive in the
event of a murmur and suspected heart failure. Radiography also may be helpful to
document the presence of thoracic masses or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease,
but increased pleural fluid obscures visualization of other intrathoracic structures.
Increased Body Weight
Overfeeding may be the most common cause of obesity in horses and also may be the
easiest to correct. The veterinarian should investigate the feeding practices of the
stable and feed and hay sources thoroughly. Novice horse owners, single horse owners,
and pony owners commonly overfeed their animals.
Ponies seem to be particularly susceptible to obesity, perhaps because their size
renders them more easily overfed. However, at least one author has proposed that this
tendency toward obesity in ponies receiving modern confinement diets may be because
of their having evolved in the inhospitable ice age climates of northern Europe.
17
In that era, the lack of readily available grazing feedstuffs might have placed greater
selection pressure on survival of ponies with more efficient dentition and better
nutrient and fluid absorption from the gastrointestinal tract. The author argues that
those ponies that had greater feed conversion efficiency would have been stronger,
had longer lives, and been more available for breeding. Current illustrations of this
theory may lie in the Welsh and Connemara pony breeds that still thrive and flourish
in the wild in the inhospitable north Atlantic climates of the western coasts of Wales
and Ireland, respectively.
Pregnancy in mares is a normal physiologic event that leads to increased body weight.
Surprisingly, many new owners of mares may not know that their new purchase is pregnant.
For an earlier negative pregnancy diagnosis to have been in error is not uncommon.
Any mare that is gaining weight in an unexpected manner should be examined rectally,
and by ultrasonography if necessary, for a possible pregnancy.
Hypothyroidism has been reported to be associated with weight gain and failure to
become pregnant in broodmares.
18
Evidence for hypothyroid-associated weight gain and infertility was lacking in surgically
created hypothyroid pony
19
and Quarter Horse
20
subjects. An abundance of field experience exists, however, from which to infer a
relationship between obesity, hypothyroidism, and infertility in mares.
17
Documentation of hypothyroidism must be by performance of a thyroid-stimulating hormone
or thyroid-releasing hormone stimulation test,21, 22 because resting thyroid levels
vary diurnally
23
and do not truly reflect thyroid function. One must also remember that only 5 days
of normal phenylbutazone therapy results in abnormally low resting serum thyroid levels
because of direct competition of phenylbutazone with thyroid hormone for serum protein-binding
sites.
21
The diagnosis and treatment of hypothyroidism is described in greater detail elsewhere
in this text.
Differential diagnoses for increased body weight include overfeeding, pregnancy, hypothyroidism,
and other conditions that result in abdominal distention, such as bloat, ascites,
uroperitoneum, fetal hydrops, and rupture of the prepubic tendon or abdominal wall
musculature. The latter conditions are described in greater detail in Chapter 16.
Feeding practices should be investigated and observed firsthand if necessary. A positive
pregnancy status should be an easy historical and rectal diagnosis. Most hematologic
and biochemical tests are normal in the pregnant or simply overweight horse. Thyroid
status should be assessed appropriately, not by simple resting thyroid hormone concentrations,
but by thyroid-stimulating hormone or thyroid-releasing hormone stimulation tests
that have been described previously and that are presented elsewhere in this text.21,
22
Education of the client is important regarding feeding practices, especially if the
overweight horse is determined simply to have been overfed by a novice owner. Dangerous
consequences, including colic and laminitis, should be explained to the client.
REFERENCES
1
Ettinger
SJ
Body weight
Ettinger
SJ
Textbook of veterinary internal medicine
ed 2
1983
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
2
Maas
J
Alterations in body weight or size
Smith
BP
Large animal internal medicine
1990
CV Mosby
St. Louis
3
Brown
CM
Chronic weight loss
Brown
CM
Problems in equine medicine
1989
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
4
Brown
CM
Dysphagia
Robinson
NE
Current therapy in equine medicine
ed 3
1992
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
5
Oehme
FW
Plant toxicities
Robinson
NE
Current therapy in equine medicine
ed 2
1987
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
6
Roberts
MC
Malabsorption syndromes in the horse
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
7
1985
S637
7
Jacobs
KA
Bolton
JR
Effect of diet on the oral D-xylose absorption test in the horse
Am J Vet Res
43
1982
1856
7149392
8
Moore
BR
Abood
AS
Hinchcliff
KW
Hyperlipemia in 9 miniature horses and miniature donkeys
J Vet Intern Med
8
1994
376
7837116
9
Clabough
DL
Equine infectious anemia: the clinical signs, transmission, and diagnostic procedures
Vet Med
85
1990
1007
10
Snow
DH
Douglas
TA
Thompson
H
Phenylbutazone toxicosis in Equidae: a biochemical and pathophysiologic study
Am J Vet Res
42
1981
1754
7325437
11
Traub
JL
Bayly
WM
Reed
SM
Intra-abdominal neoplasia as a cause of chronic weight loss in the horse
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
5
1983
S526
12
Divers
TJ
Equine renal system
Smith
BP
Large animal internal medicine
1990
CV Mosby
St Louis
13
Rumbaugh
GE
Smith
BP
Carlson
GP
Internal abdominal abscesses in the horse: a study of 25 cases
J Am Vet Med Assoc
172
1978
304
621178
14
Nelson
AW
Analysis of equine peritoneal fluid
Vet Clin North Am Large Anim Pract
1
1979
267
399709
15
Duncan
JR
Prasse
KW
Cytology
Duncan
JR
Prasse
KW
Veterinary laboratory medicine
ed 2
1986
Iowa State University Press
Ames
16
Foreman
JH
Weidner
JP
Parry
BA
Pleural effusion secondary to thoracic metastatic mammary adenocarcinoma in a mare
J Am Vet Med Assoc
197
1990
1193
2254151
17
Schafer
M
An eye for a horse
1980
JA Allen
London
18
Nachreiner
RF
Hyland
JH
Reproductive endocrine function testing in mares
McKinnon
AO
Voss
JL
Equine reproduction
1993
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
19
Lowe
JE
Kallfelz
FA
Thyroidectomy and the T4 test to assess thyroid dysfunction in the horse and pony
Proc Am Assoc Equine Pract
16
1970
135
20
Vischer
CM
Hypothyroidism and exercise intolerance in the horse, master's thesis
1996
University of Illinois
Urbana-Champaign
21
Morris
DD
Garcia
M
Thyroid-stimulating hormone response test in healthy horses, and effect of phenylbutazone
on equine thyroid hormones
Am J Vet Res
44
1983
503
6682298
22
Foreman
JH
Hematological and endocrine assessment of the performance horse
Robinson
NE
Current therapy in equine medicine
ed 3
1992
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
23
Duckett
WM
Manning
JP
Weston
PG
Thyroid hormone periodicity in healthy adult geldings
Equine Vet J
21
1989
125
Foreman
Jonathan H.
3.5—Abdominal Distention
Increases in body weight because of overeating or pregnancy must be distinguished
from increases in body girth caused by bloat, ascites, uroperitoneum, fetal hydrops,
or ruptured prepubic tendon. In each of these conditions, body weight actually may
increase because of fetal growth or fluid accumulation. More important, however, a
perceptible change in the shape of the abdomen of the horse occurs.
Bloat usually is associated with colic signs in horses and is caused by gaseous intestinal
distention resulting from ileus or simple obstruction of the large, or rarely small,
intestine. Ileus caused by diarrhea, peritonitis, colic surgery, or parasympatholytic
agents (e.g., atropine) can result in sufficient accumulation of intraluminal gas
to be manifested as tympany, bloat, and mild to severe abdominal pain.
1
If optic topical atropine application is overly aggressive, secondary ileus and bloat
may result. Rapid and severe gas production may follow grain overload; cecal and colonic
fermentation of readily available carbohydrate sources results in rapid-onset colonic
tympany and abdominal distention.
2
Exhaustion in endurance horses also is associated with intestinal shutdown and subsequent
abdominal distention.
3
In any of these bloat conditions, abdominal auscultation in the flank area reveals
decreased or absent intestinal motility sounds (borborygmi) and perhaps increased
gaseous distention sounds (pinging). Decreased borborygmi in the right flank are specific
for cecal ileus.
Simple colonic obstruction also results in tympany and bloat. Strangulating obstruction
results in greater pain than usually is manifested in simple obstruction and bloat.
Colonic displacements are more common in older postpartum mares.
4
These horses often initially show mild colic signs and progressively develop more
dramatic pain and abdominal distention. Miniature horses with simple obstructions
caused by fecoliths often have bloat as the initial clinical sign.
5
Such cases have the additional complication that rectal examination may be impossible
for differentiation of the source of the bloat. Even in full-sized horses, rectal
examination may reveal that the abdomen is so filled with distended colon that the
examiner can push an arm into the rectum no farther than wrist-deep. Colonic or cecal
bloat can be relieved by trocarization through the flank, but relief is merely palliative
and is usually temporary because the cause of the obstruction still has not been resolved.
Ascites does not occur commonly in horses and usually is caused by peritonitis or
abdominal neoplasms. Peritonitis is caused by septicemia, laparotomy, intestinal leakage,
internal abscess, or a penetrating external wound resulting in inflammation and usually
infection of the peritoneal lining of the abdomen. Such inflammation results in increased
fluid production by the squamous abdominal epithelium. Initially, this increased abdominal
fluid may be characterized as a transudate (low cell count and low total protein).
If inflammation with infection persists, the character of the fluid may change to
that of an exudate (increased cell count >5000 nucleated cells/μl, increased neutrophil
count, increased degenerate neutrophils, microscopically visible bacteria, and increased
total protein).6, 7 These increases in abdominal fluid volume can be substantive and
can result in abdominal distention that eventually becomes clinically apparent. Fluid
ballottement in the equine abdomen is not an easily performed diagnostic technique
but may be easier in foals, ponies, or miniature horses than in full-sized horses.
Ascites also may result from abdominal neoplasms. Tumors reported to cause ascites
and weight loss in horses include lymphosarcoma, squamous cell carcinoma, mammary
adenocarcinoma, and mesothelioma.8, 9 Although rare, mesothelioma may cause the most
fluid production, because it is a tumor of the fluid-producing cells of the peritoneal
lining. Mesothelioma may result in the production of large volumes of fluid (several
liters) in a short time (24 hours) after a similarly large volume is drained from
the same horse via abdominal catheterization or trocarization.
Ascites also may result from any condition that produces lowered serum total protein
and albumin. With lowered intravascular colloid osmotic pressure, fluid diffuses or
moves from the vasculature and results in dependent peripheral edema. Fluid also may
accumulate within the major body cavities (i.e., the thorax and the abdomen).
7
The mechanisms for such low-protein conditions include poor protein intake, malabsorption,
poor hepatic utilization, and increased rate of protein loss such as in glomerular
renal disease, peritonitis/pleuritis, or gastrointestinal transudation (diarrhea or
ulceration). Causes of peripheral edema are described elsewhere in this text.
Increased preload because of right ventricular heart failure also can result in a
transudate fluid accumulation within the abdomen.
7
A horse with right ventricular heart failure usually has tricuspid insufficiency and
manifests other signs of right ventricular heart failure, such as a murmur, exercise
intolerance, jugular pulse, and edema of the ventral abdomen, pectoral muscles, and
distal limbs. Severe mitral insufficiency also can result in right ventricular heart
failure, but only after the development of left ventricular heart failure and its
associated pulmonary edema, which is manifested by exercise intolerance, coughing,
epistaxis, and increased respiratory effort.
Uroperitoneum results from leakage of urine from some part of the urinary tract into
the abdomen and most commonly is associated with a ruptured bladder in neonatal foals
(usually male). Uroperitoneum also may result from a necrotic bladder caused by neonatal
sepsis and urachal abscesses. Such foals often have pendulous, bloated abdomens that
ballotte more easily than do the abdomens of adult horses with accumulation of fluid.
Abdominal fluid actually may smell like urine, and peritoneal fluid creatinine concentrations
will be high—often more than twice those of peripheral blood.10, 11, 12 Because most
classically described neonatal urinary bladder tears are dorsal near the trigone,
the foal still may be able to produce a stream of urine despite having a leaking bladder.
A ruptured urinary bladder abscess should be suspected in a foal with sepsis that
initially responds to therapy for sepsis and then, several days later, has acute-onset
depression, anorexia, ileus, and abdominal distention. Adults horses rarely have uroperitoneum;
however, uroperitoneum has been associated with ruptured urinary bladders during stressful
parturition in mares that manifest mild postpartum abdominal pain and abdominal distention.12,
13
Fetal hydrops results from an accumulation of excessive amounts of fluid within the
amnion (hydrops amnion) or chorioallantois (hydrops allantois).
14
Hydrops results in a bilaterally pendulous abdomen in a late-term pregnant mare. A
rapid accumulation of fluid over 10 to 14 days may makes walking or perhaps even breathing
difficult for the mare. A diagnosis may be made after taking history and performing
a rectal examination, although palpating the fetus is usually difficult because the
excess fluid causes the uterus to descend out of reach of the examiner. If necessary,
a percutaneous ultrasonographic examination may be used to confirm the diagnosis by
documenting the presence of increased intrauterine fluid within the fetal membranes.
A ruptured prepubic tendon results in a unilateral lowering of the abdominal margin
and apparent distention of the abdomen only on the affected side. The condition is
associated routinely with later-term pregnancy in mares and is thought to occur simply
because of the increased weight of the pregnant uterus pressing downward on the abdominal
wall. Rupture of the rectus, transverse, or oblique abdominal muscles also can result
in ventral dropping or herniation of the abdomen late in gestation.
14
Ruptures may be more common in older or more sedentary mares, probably because of
decreased abdominal wall strength and tone. Other than a focal abdominal wall hernia,
a unilateral prepubic tendon rupture results in the only form of prominent unilateral
abdominal distention in horses. Mares with ruptured prepubic tendons may have elicitable
pain in the local abdominal wall and may demonstrate a reluctance to walk. They may
need assistance during parturition, because they may have difficulty performing an
effective abdominal press to aid in fetal expulsion.
Pregnancy, diarrhea, colic signs, colic surgery, and the use of parasympatholytic
agents should be evident from the history. The rate of onset of abdominal distention
may help to distinguish more acute conditions (e.g., gastrointestinal bloat from grain
overload) from more chronic conditions (e.g., ascites caused by heart or liver failure).
Signalment and history may assist in indicating specific conditions. A depressed,
48- to 72-hour-old male foal with fluid abdominal distention may be a likely candidate
to have a ruptured urinary bladder and uroperitoneum. Miniature horses with bloat
and colic signs frequently have simple obstructions owing to fecoliths or enteroliths.
A complete physical examination reveals the presence of a murmur that may be associated
with heart failure and ascites. Other signs of heart failure also may be evident on
physical examination. An actual defect in the integrity of the abdominal wall may
be palpable on external examination of the abdomen in a mare with a ruptured prepubic
tendon or ruptured abdominal wall musculature.
14
The veterinarian should attempt ballottement to discern the presence of increased
free abdominal fluid in suspected ascites or uroperitoneum. Fever may indicate the
presence of an infectious peritonitis or umbilical abscess.
A rectal examination is a critical part of examining a horse with bloat or colic but
may be difficult to accomplish if colonic distention is dramatic or if the patient
is small (i.e., a foal, pony, or miniature horse). A rectal examination further may
document advanced pregnancy, resulting in mild bilateral abdominal distention (normal
pregnancy), abnormal or severe bilateral distention (hydrops or bilateral ruptured
prepubic tendon), or unilateral distention (unilateral ruptured prepubic tendon or
focal abdominal wall hernia). A rectal examination also may reveal abnormalities of
the urinary tract (enlarged kidney or ureter, abscess, or neoplasm), which may result
in uroperitoneum in adults.
An ultrasonographic examination may be helpful and is sometimes necessary to examine
the distended abdomen and fetus in a pregnant mare. Such an examination must be performed
percutaneously in late gestation. Ultrasonography can determine the location of increased
abdominal fluid (intrauterine or extrauterine) and the health status of the fetus.
Percutaneous placement of base-apex electrocardiographic leads across the abdomen
of the mare may help to document that the fetus is still viable if an ultrasound examination
does not produce definitive evidence (heart movement or gross fetal movement).
15
Cardiac ultrasonography may help to document the presence of a cardiac valvular defect
that can be the cause of ascites in a horse with heart failure. Abdominal radiography
may assist in the diagnosis of abdominal distention caused by intestinal obstruction
in a foal or miniature horse. Percutaneous ultrasound examination also may assist
in documenting the source of abdominal distention (e.g., intussusception) in smaller
horses or foals16, 17 and in characterizing umbilical and urachal abnormalities.
17
Complete blood counts and plasma fibrinogen concentrations assist in diagnosing inflammatory
conditions such as infectious peritonitis. Urachal or urinary bladder abscesses also
may be associated with inflammatory leukograms. Blood or peritoneal fluid cultures
may assist in documenting the offending bacterial agent(s). Foals or adults with uroperitoneum
have elevated serum urea nitrogen, creatinine, and potassium and decreased serum sodium,
chloride, and bicarbonate concentrations.10, 11
Abdominocentesis should be attempted to distinguish the cause of ascites. Care must
be taken, however, in obtaining peritoneal fluid from late-term pregnant mares to
avoid penetrating directly into the distended uterus. Analysis of peritoneal fluid
reveals abdominal fluid to be a transudate (equivocal infection) or exudate (probable
infection).6, 7 Fluid should be cultured aerobically and anaerobically when infectious
peritonitis is suspected. Exfoliative cytologic examination rarely may document the
presence of neoplastic cells.8, 9 Peritoneal fluid creatinine concentration approaches
or often exceeds (more than twice) that of serum if uroperitoneum is present.10, 11
Serum and peritoneal urea nitrogen concentrations are less reliable for such a diagnosis
because the peritoneal membrane does not differentially sequester urea nitrogen (but
does creatinine) within the abdominal cavity.
REFERENCES
1
Ducharme
NG
Fubini
SL
Gastrointestinal complications associated with the use of atropine in horses
J Am Vet Med Assoc
182
1983
229
6826443
2
Huskamp
B
Diseases of the stomach and intestine
Dietz
O
Wiesner
F
Diseases of the horse
1984
Karger
New York
3
Swanson
TD
The veterinarian's responsibilities at trail rides
Robinson
NE
Current therapy in equine medicine
ed 3
1992
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
4
Sullins
KE
Diseases of the large colon
White
NA
The equine acute abdomen
1990
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
5
Ragle
CA
Snyder
JR
Meagher
DM
Surgical treatment of colic in American miniature horses: 15 cases (1980-1987)
J Am Vet Med Assoc
201
1992
329
1500336
6
Nelson
AW
Analysis of equine peritoneal fluid
Vet Clin North Am Large Anim Pract
1
1979
267
399709
7
Duncan
JR
Prasse
KW
Cytology
Duncan
JR
Prasse
KW
Veterinary laboratory medicine
ed 2
1986
Iowa State University Press
Ames
8
Traub
JL
Bayly
WM
Reed
SM
Intra-abdominal neoplasia as a cause of chronic weight loss in the horse
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
5
1983
S526
9
Foreman
JH
Weidner
JP
Parry
BA
Pleural effusion secondary to thoracic metastatic mammary adenocarcinoma in a mare
J Am Vet Med Assoc
197
1990
1193
2254151
10
Behr
MJ
Hackett
RP
Bentinck-Smith
J
Metabolic abnormalities associated with rupture of the urinary bladder in neonatal
foals
J Am Vet Med Assoc
178
1981
263
7228782
11
Richardson
DW
Kohn
CW
Uroperitoneum in the foal
J Am Vet Med Assoc
182
1983
267
6681809
12
Divers
TJ
Equine renal system
Smith
BP
Large animal internal medicine
1990
CV Mosby
St Louis
13
Nyrop
KA
DeBowes
RM
Cox
JH
Rupture of the urinary bladder in two post-partum mares
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
6
1984
S510
14
Lofstedt
RM
Miscellaneous diseases of pregnancy and parturition
McKinnon
AO
Voss
JL
Equine reproduction
1993
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
15
Colles
CM
Parkes
RD
May
CJ
Foetal electrocardiography in the mare
Equine Vet J
10
1978
32
631104
16
Bernard
WV
Reef
VB
Reimer
JM
Ultrasonographic diagnosis of small intestinal intussusception in three foals
J Am Vet Med Assoc
194
1989
395
2645258
17
Reef
VB
Ultrasonographic evaluation and diagnosis of foal diseases
Robinson
NE
Current therapy in equine medicine
ed 3
1992
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
Beard
Laurie A.
3.6—Dysphagia
Normal Eating
Normal eating is complex and requires normal anatomic structures and neurologic function.
The process of eating can be divided into prehension (uptake of food into the oral
cavity) and deglutition (transport of food from the oral cavity to the stomach). Prehension
requires the lips to grasp and the incisors to tear the food.
1
Motor innervation to the tongue, lips, and muscles of mastication is provided by the
hypoglossal, facial, and trigeminal nerves. Sensory input is important for successful
prehension and requires intact olfactory, optic, and trigeminal nerves, providing
smell, sight, and sensation of the rostral oral mucosa and lips. Normal prehension
depends on the central nervous system to coordinate movements of the tongue and lips.
Deglutition involves mastication, swallowing, and transport of food through the esophagus
to the stomach. Mastication or chewing of food initiates mechanical digestion and
insalivation. Mastication is specifically a function of the molars to grind feed and
the tongue and buccal muscles to position the food. The facial nerve provides motor
and sensory fibers to the tongue and pharynx. The glossopharyngeal nerve provides
sensory fibers to the caudal third of the tongue. The trigeminal nerve is sensory
to the teeth and provides the important parasympathetic fibers to the parotid salivary
gland. Function of this gland is critical to help liquefy food and provides a small
amount of digestive enzymes.
Swallowing is complex and is performed in a series of steps. Initially, food must
be moved to the base of the tongue and formed into a bolus. This action requires coordinated
movements of the tongue and pharynx. Second, the bolus is forced caudally. As this
action takes place, the oropharynx relaxes and the soft palate elevates to seal the
palatopharyngeal arch and nasopharynx.
1
Next, the bolus enters the oropharynx and the hyoid apparatus swings rostrodorsally,
which draws the larynx and the common pharynx forward.1, 2 The epiglottis is tipped
caudally and prevents the bolus from entering the larynx. Finally, the bolus is moved
into the common pharynx with pharyngeal muscle contractions and enters the open cranial
esophageal sphincter. The sphincter closes to prevent esophagopharyngeal reflux and
aerophagia. Herbivores are unique, because breathing continues uninterrupted during
swallowing, unlike other animals.
1
The glossopharyngeal, vagus, and spinal accessory nerves provide sensory and motor
fibers to the pharynx, larynx, and soft palate.
The esophageal phase of eating involves the transport of the food bolus to the stomach,
with primary peristaltic waves, which are generated by continuous contraction of the
pharyngeal peristalsis. The bolus is transported to the caudal esophageal sphincter,
which relaxes to allow the bolus to enter the stomach and then contracts to prevent
gastroesophageal reflux. If reflux does occur, esophageal clearance is achieved by
secondary peristaltic waves. Antiperistalsis is normal in ruminants during eructation
and regurgitation but is not normal in horses.
1
Dysphagia
Dysphagia is defined as difficulty in swallowing but often is used to describe problems
with eating.
2
Problems with eating may include problems with prehension, mastication, swallowing,
and esophageal transport. In this section, the term dysphagia is used in the broader
sense to describe problems with eating. Dysphagia can result from a number of disorders
affecting any part of the upper gastrointestinal system (oral cavity, pharynx, and
esophagus). Clinical signs of dysphagia vary depending on the cause and the location
of the problem but may include ptyalism (excessive salivation), gagging, dropping
food, nasal discharge, and coughing. Dysphagia can result from morphologic or functional
disorders. The causes of these diseases may be acquired or congenital. Morphologic
causes of dysphagia include abnormal anatomy, obstruction of the upper gastrointestinal
tract, inflammation, and pain. Examples of anatomic abnormalities include a cleft
palate and subepiglottic cysts.3, 4 Obstruction of the upper gastrointestinal tract
most commonly includes feed impactions of the esophagus but also can include pharyngeal
obstructions secondary to retropharyngeal lymph node masses or severe guttural pouch
tympany.5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 Inflammatory conditions resulting in pain and dysphagia
include periodontal diseases, foreign bodies, pharyngitis, epiglottitis, and mandibular
or maxillary fractures.3, 6
Functional disorders resulting in dysphagia include neurologic, neuromuscular, and
muscular diseases. Functional disorders frequently result in problems with swallowing
but less commonly involve mastication and prehension and rarely occur with esophageal
transport. Neurologic diseases resulting in dysphagia may be peripheral or central.
Peripheral neurologic problems frequently result from abnormalities of the guttural
pouch but also can include toxic peripheral neuropathies, such as lead toxicity. Problems
of the guttural pouch include infection (tympany, empyema, or mycosis), iatrogenic
problems (infusion of caustic substances), and trauma (rupture of the longus capitis
muscle from the basisphenoid bone and hemorrhage into the guttural pouch).2, 11, 12
Central neurologic diseases may result in problems in prehension, mastication, or
swallowing. Specific examples include equine protozoal myelitis, viral encephalitis
(rabies and eastern and western encephalitis), toxic neuropathies (leukoencephalomalacia
and nigropallidal encephalomalacia), and cerebral trauma.1, 2, 7, 13, 14, 15 Neuromuscular
problems resulting in dysphagia generally present as a systemic disease and include
diseases such as botulism and organophosphate toxicity.1, 2, 16, 17 Muscular diseases
resulting in dysphagia are rare but include nutritional muscular dystrophy (white
muscle disease) in foals.
18
BASIC APPROACH TO DYSPHAGIA
The initial evaluation of dysphagia focuses on determining whether morphologic or
functional abnormalities exist. To answer these questions best, a thorough history,
physical examination (including observation of the horse eating), and additional tests
(e.g., endoscopic examination and radiographs) are required. A history of an acute
onset of dysphagia is often consistent with trauma, whereas a slow progressive onset
of clinical signs is more consistent with a neurologic problem such as guttural pouch
mycosis, equine protozoal myelitis, or toxicities. The clinician should assess exposure
of the horse to toxic substances or plants (lead or yellow star thistle). A history
of treatment before the onset of dysphagia suggests trauma or injury to the pharynx.
Use of a balling gun or flushing of guttural pouches may result in iatrogenic injury
to the pharynx, esophagus, and guttural pouches. The clinician should determine concurrent
problems in other horses (e.g., strangles or other bacterial infections of the submandibular
lymph nodes).
In performing the physical examination, the clinician should pay close attention to
the head and neck. Because rabies is a potential cause of dysphagia, protective measures
while performing a careful and thorough physical examination are necessary. Ideally,
all clinicians working on horses should have an adequate rabies antibody titer. An
examination of the oral cavity is best accomplished with a mouth speculum, good light,
and if necessary, the administration of sedation. The teeth should be examined carefully
for retained deciduous caps, sharp points or hooks, wave mouth or step mouth, dental
fractures, or patent infundibula.
3
Foreign bodies may become wedged between the molars or under the tongue. The tongue
should be examined for lacerations, foreign bodies, and evidence of neoplasia. The
throat latch area and neck should be examined for heat or swelling, which might be
caused by a ruptured esophagus. The lungs should be auscultated carefully to determine
if the horse shows evidence of aspiration pneumonia resulting from dysphagia.
A valuable activity is to watch the horse eat. The distinction between dysphagia and
anorexia is important. Dysphagic horses usually are hungry and will attempt to eat.
Problems with prehension generally suggest a primary neurologic problem. Watching
the horse try to graze and eat hay or grain may be necessary. Ingestion of yellow
star thistle or Russian knapweed results in basal ganglia lesions (nigropallidal encephalomalacia).
Horses with these lesions are unable to prehend food (with lack of coordination of
the lips and tongue), but they can swallow.
14
Their ability to drink water should be evaluated carefully, because some horses continue
to drink despite having difficulty in swallowing. Horses that expel food while chewing
may have problems with mastication. Coughing and nasal discharge indicate aspiration
of food into the trachea. Problems with swallowing or regurgitation may cause aspiration.
Esophageal obstruction results in regurgitation of food through the nares. Regurgitation
often is observed during feeding but may occur shortly after or even hours after feeding.
Ptyalism, without dysphagia, may result from ingestion of legume plants (especially
second-cutting red clover) contaminated with Rhizoctonia leguminicola. This fungus
produces a mycotoxin called slaframine, which has parasympathomimetic properties.
19
The excess salivation disappears once the animal stops feeding on the plant.
MORPHOLOGIC ABNORMALITIES
Morphologic abnormalities that cause dysphagia are easier to diagnose than are functional
disorders. Morphologic problems of the oral cavity generally result in problems of
prehension or mastication. An oral examination (as outlined earlier) is particularly
useful. The passing of a nasogastric tube, endoscopic examination, and radiographs
(if necessary) are other diagnostic tests that may help to identify the anatomic localization
and cause of dysphagia. Complete obstruction of the esophagus can be excluded if a
nasogastric tube is passed successfully into the stomach. Feed impactions of the esophagus
are common in horses. Esophageal impactions of feed may occur because of poor mastication
or esophageal strictures or diverticulum.5, 6, 7 The most common sites for obstructions
occur in the cranial esophagus, at the thoracic inlet, and at the base of the heart.
7
Other esophageal abnormalities include rupture, fistula, cyst, megaesophagus, and
neoplasms.5, 20 An endoscopic examination allows visualization of the nasal passageways,
nasopharynx, guttural pouches, pharynx, larynx, and esophagus. Inflammation of the
pharynx, larynx, or esophagus is assessed best by endoscopic examination. Partial
obstructions of the pharynx often result in dyspnea, especially during exercise, and
sometimes can cause dysphagia. Retropharyngeal masses, guttural pouch tympany, and
rarely neoplasms may result in pharyngeal obstruction and collapse.2, 9, 10 Depending
on the length of the endoscope available, the clinician can evaluate all or part of
the esophagus for inflammation or obstruction.
Radiographs can provide additional information in horses with morphologic causes of
dysphagia; however, they are not required in all situations. Radiographs of the skull
can help demonstrate the presence of periodontal disease, fractures of the mandible
or maxilla, lesions of the temporomandibular joint, or radioopaque foreign bodies.
3
Radiographs of the larynx or pharynx are indicated in cases of pharyngeal obstruction
and are especially useful to evaluate retropharyngeal masses, neoplasms, or trauma.8,
9, 10 Radiographs of esophageal perforations reveal subcutaneous air, which shows
up as extraluminal radiolucencies.
6
Contrast studies of the esophagus, with the use of barium sulfate, may help differentiate
cases of esophageal strictures, dilation, or diverticulum.
5
Radiographs of the thorax are indicated in horses with nasal discharge and abnormal
thoracic auscultation because of the concerns of aspiration pneumonia.
FUNCTIONAL ABNORMALITIES
Functional disorders that cause dysphagia are more difficult to diagnose and should
be pursued after morphologic causes are not identified. The clinician also should
consider a functional abnormality if the initial physical examination provides strong
evidence of a neurologic, neuromuscular, or muscular problem. The initial step to
evaluate functional causes of dysphagia is to perform a neurologic examination. The
neurologic examination helps establish a neuroanatomic localization by (1) assessing
brain, brainstem, and spinal cord functions; (2) determining if the problem is focal,
multifocal, or diffuse; and (3) determining if the problem is a peripheral or central
problem.
Cerebral disease usually manifests as seizures, head pressing, wandering, depression,
and changes in mentation. Brainstem function can be assessed by cranial nerve examination.
Evaluation of an abnormal response of the cranial nerves should establish the location
of the problem within the brainstem. For example, the optic nerve can be assessed
by the menace response (requiring the facial nerve) and by the pupillary light reflex
(requiring the oculomotor nerve). Abnormalities of the oculomotor, trochlear, and
abducens nerves manifest as strabismus or lack of a pupillary light reflex. Facial
nerve paralysis (ear, eyelid, and muzzle droop) and vestibular disease (circling,
nystagmus, and head tilt) often occur together because of the close proximity of these
nerves as they exit the brainstem.
21
Endoscopic examination is a valuable tool to determine if pharyngeal or laryngeal
paralysis is present. These problems may be caused by peripheral or central diseases.
The dorsolateral wall of the medial compartment of the guttural pouch contains a plexus
of nerves, including the glossopharyngeal nerve; branches of the vagus, spinal accessory,
and hypoglossal nerves; and the cranial cervical ganglion. Mycotic plaques, empyema,
and trauma (hematoma) of the guttural pouch can result in pharyngeal paralysis, dorsal
displacement of the soft palate, laryngeal hemiplegia, and occasionally Horner's syndrome.1,
2, 11, 12, 21 The clinician should obtain skull radiographs in many horses with dysphagia,
and they are especially helpful when traumatic injuries are suspected. Rupture of
the longus capitis muscle results in ventral deviation of the dorsal pharynx and narrowing
of the nasopharynx. Bony fragments may be evident ventral to the basisphenoid bones
in these horses.
12
Otitis media and pathologic fracture of the petrous temporal bone frequently result
in vestibular disease and facial nerve paralysis and occasionally in glossopharyngeal
and vagus nerve involvement. An endoscopic examination of the guttural pouches is
helpful with this problem, because the distal stylohyoid bone is thickened and irregular.
Ventrodorsal, lateral, and rostrolateral oblique radiographs also may reveal osseous
changes of the stylohyoid bone, tympanic bulla, or petrous temporal bone.
21
The clinical examination should include an evaluation of gait. Signs of ataxia, generalized
weakness, and hypermetria along with cranial nerve signs may be observable with brainstem
involvement. The clinician should evaluate the horse at the walk, trot, down an incline,
over a step, and backing and turning in tight circles. The clinician may wish to place
the feet of the horse in abnormal positions and determine if the horse can reposition
the leg correctly in a reasonable time. Generalized weakness (without ataxia) may
manifest with a decrease in tail, eyelid, and tongue tone and muscle fasciculations.
Weakness generally suggests a neuromuscular (botulism, organophosphate poisoning)
or muscular problem.16, 17, 18 Equine lower motor neuron disease results in generalized
weakness and weight loss; however, horses are not dysphagic and do not exhibit cranial
nerve abnormalities.
22
Ataxia or hypermetria along with dysphagia suggests a diffuse or multifocal disease
that affects the spinal cord and brainstem. Examples of such diseases include equine
protozoal myelitis, rabies, equine herpes myeloencephalopathy, polyneuritis equi,
and a migrating parasite.12, 23, 24 Further diagnostic tests are indicated in these
cases, such as an evaluation of spinal fluid for cytologic abnormalities and chemistry
and Western blot analysis for antibodies to Sarcocystis neurona.
25
Grass sickness, a disease found in Great Britain and in other northern European countries,
results in ileus and colic. Grass sickness can result in dysphagia, with problems
in swallowing or esophageal transport.
26
Grass sickness is regarded as a fatal disease, resulting in ileus of the gastrointestinal
tract, dysphagia, and weight loss, which most likely is caused by an unidentified
neurotoxin. Grass sickness can be defined as a dysautonomia characterized by pathologic
lesions in autonomic ganglia, enteric plexi, and specific nuclei in the central nervous
system.
27
Additional information about the specific causes of dysphagia are covered elsewhere
in this text.
REFERENCES
1
Watrous
BJ
Dysphagia and regurgitation
Anderson
NY
Veterinary gastroenterology
ed 2
1992
Lea & Febiger
Malvern, Penn
2
Brown
CM
Dysphagia
Robinson
NE
Current therapy in equine medicine
ed 3
1992
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
3
Baum
KH
Modransky
PD
Halpern
NE
Dysphagia in horses: the differential diagnosis, part I
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
10
1988
1301
1307
4
Stick
JA
Boles
C
Subepiglottic cyst in three foals
J Am Vet Med Assoc
177
1980
62
7429941
5
Stick
JA
Esophageal disease
Robinson
NE
Current therapy in equine medicine
ed 2
1987
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
6
Merrit
AM
Dysphagia in horses
Anderson
NY
Veterinary gastroenterology
ed 2
1992
Lea & Febiger
Malvern, Penn
7
Baum
GH
Halpern
NE
Banish
LD
Dysphagia in horses: the differential diagnosis, part II
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
10
1988
1405
1408
8
McCue
PM
Freeman
DE
Donawick
WJ
Guttural pouch tympany: 15 cases (1977-1986)
J Am Vet Med Assoc
12
1989
1761
1763
9
Sweeny
CR
Benson
CE
Whitlock
RH
Streptococcus equi infection in horses, part I
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
9
1987
689
693
10
Todhunter
RJ
Brown
CM
Stickle
R
Retropharyngeal infections in five horses
J Vet Med Assoc
187
1985
600
604
11
Greet
TRC
Outcome of treatment in 35 cases of guttural pouch mycosis
Equine Vet J
19
1987
483
487
3500040
12
Sweeny
CR
Freeman
DE
Sweeny
RW
Hemorrhage into the guttural pouch (auditory tube diverticulum) associated with rupture
of the longus capitis muscle in three horses
J Am Vet Med Assoc
202
1993
1129
1131
8473229
13
MacKay
RJ
Davis
SW
Dubey
JP
Equine protozoal myeloencephalitis
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
14
1992
1359
1367
14
Oehme
FW
Plant toxicities
Robinson
NE
Current therapy in equine medicine
ed 2
1987
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
15
Uhlinger
C
Clinical and epidemiologic features of an epizootic of equine leukoencephalomalacia
J Am Vet Med Assoc
198
1991
126
128
1995569
16
Swerczek
TW
Toxicoinfectious botulism in foals and adult horses
J Am Vet Med Assoc
176
1980
217
220
6988376
17
Oehme
FW
Insecticides
Robinson
NE
Current therapy in equine medicine
ed 2
1987
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
18
Moore
RM
Kohn
CW
Nutritional muscular dystrophy in foals
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
13
1991
476
490
19
Bowman
KF
Salivary gland disease
Robinson
ED
Current therapy in equine medicine
ed 2
1987
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
20
Green
S
Green
EM
Arson
E
Squamous cell carcinoma: an unusual cause of choke in the horse
Mod Vet Pract
67
1986
870
875
21
Power
HT
Watrous
BJ
de Lahunta
A
Facial and vestibulocochlear nerve disease in six horses
Am J Vet Med Assoc
183
1983
1076
1080
22
Divers
TJ
Mohammed
HO
Cummings
JR
Equine lower motor neuron disease: findings in 28 horses and proposal of a pathophysiological
mechanism
Equine Vet J
26
1994
409
415
7988544
23
Kohn
CW
Fenner
WR
Equine herpes myeloencephalopathy
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
3
1987
405
419
3040197
24
Yvorchuk-St
Jean: Neuritis of the cauda equina
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
3
1987
421
426
3040198
25
Granstrom
DE
Dubey
JP
Davis
SW
Equine protozoal myeloencephalitis: antigen analysis of cultured Sarcocystis neurona
merozoites
J Vet Diagn Invest
5
1993
88
90
8466988
26
Doxey
DL
Milne
EM
Gilmour
JS
Clinical and biochemical features of grass sickness (equine dysautonomia)
Equine Vet J
23
1991
360
364
1959527
27
Griffiths
IR
Kydriakides
E
Smith
S
Immunocytochemical and lectin histochemical study of neuronal lesions in autonomic
ganglia of horses with grass sickness
Equine Vet J
25
1993
446
452
8223378
Rush
Bonnie R.
3.7—Respiratory Distress
Respiratory distress is defined as labored breathing and is characterized by an inappropriate
degree of effort to breathe based on rate, rhythm, and subjective evaluation of respiratory
effort.
1
Dyspnea is the sensation of arduous, uncomfortable, or difficult breathing that occurs
when the demand for ventilation exceeds the patient's ability to respond.
2
Dyspnea describes a symptom rather than a clinical sign, and although the term often
is used, dyspnea is not technically applicable in veterinary medicine. The clinical
signs of respiratory distress vary with the severity and origin of impaired gas exchange.
Clinical signs commonly observed in horses with respiratory distress include flared
nostrils, exercise intolerance, inactivity, exaggerated abdominal effort, abnormal
respiratory noise (stridor), anxious expression, extended head and neck, cyanosis,
and synchronous pumping of the anus with the respiratory cycle.
1
Horses with chronic respiratory distress may develop a heave line resulting from hypertrophy
of the cutaneous trunci and abdominal muscles, which assist during forced expiration.
3
Respiratory distress usually results from inefficient exchange of oxygen and carbon
dioxide caused by primary pulmonary disease, airway obstruction, or impairment of
the muscles and supporting structures necessary for ventilation. In some cases, ventilation
increases in the absence of impaired gas exchange in response to pain, metabolic acidosis,
or high environmental temperature. Familiarity with the mechanics of breathing and
control of ventilation in healthy and diseased lungs facilitates the diagnosis and
treatment of respiratory distress.3, 4
Control of Ventilation
The partial pressure of oxygen (Pao2) and carbon dioxide (Paco2) in arterial blood
are maintained within a narrow range through rigid control of gas exchange.
2
The center controller of respiration in the medulla alters the rate and depth of respiration
via efferent signals to the muscles of respiration in response to afferent signals
from chemoreceptors in the peripheral vasculature and central nervous system and mechanoreceptors
in the upper and lower respiratory tract, diaphragm, and thoracic wall. The central
controller therefore adjusts alveolar ventilation to the metabolic rate of the individual.
4
SENSORS
The chemoreceptors identify changes in metabolism and oxygen requirements and provide
feedback to the central controller, thus allowing for modification of ventilation.
Central chemoreceptors respond predominantly to hypercapnia, whereas peripheral chemoreceptors
respond to hypoxia and hypercapnia. Central chemoreceptors, located in the ventral
medulla, monitor alterations in the pH of intracerebral interstitial fluid and cerebrospinal
fluid. The blood-brain barrier is impermeable to bicarbonate and hydrogen ions but
is freely permeable to carbon dioxide. Therefore acidification of the intracerebral
interstitial fluid and stimulation of the central chemoreceptors occur predominantly
in response to hypercapnia. The severity of acidosis in the intracerebral interstitial
fluid caused by hypercapnia is amplified by two features of the central nervous system:
(1) hypercapnia produces cerebral vasodilation, increasing the delivery of CO2 to
the central nervous system, and (2) cerebrospinal fluid has poor buffering capacity
because of low total protein concentrations.
2
Peripheral chemoreceptors are located in the arterial circulation and respond to acidemia,
hypercapnia, and hypoxemia. The carotid bodies are situated at the bifurcation of
the common carotid artery, and the aortic bodies are located near the aortic arch.
These receptors relay information to the central controller regarding arterial gas
tensions via the glossopharyngeal and vagus nerves. Their responsiveness to alterations
in Paco2 is less consequential than the central chemoreceptors; however, the peripheral
chemoreceptors are solely responsible for the hypoxic ventilatory drive. The peripheral
chemoreceptors demonstrate a nonlinear response to low arterial oxygen tension. They
are insensitive to alterations in Pao2 above 100 mm Hg, exhibit moderate response
to arterial O2 tensions between 50 and 100 mm Hg, and demonstrate a dramatic increase
in responsiveness when the partial pressure of oxygen falls below 50 mm Hg in the
arterial circulation.
2
The respiratory pattern elicited by hypoxia differs from that stimulated by hypercapnia.5,
6 Hypoxia evokes an increase in respiratory frequency, whereas hypercapnia triggers
an elevation in tidal volume. In addition, hypoxia stimulates recruitment of the inspiratory
muscles, whereas hypercapnia potentiates the activity of inspiratory and expiratory
muscles.
The sensitivity of peripheral chemoreceptors should be considered in the treatment
of patients with complex acid-base and blood-gas abnormalities. A patient suffering
from impaired gas exchange caused by pulmonary disease and metabolic acidosis resulting
from shock manifests respiratory distress in response to hypoxemia, hypercapnia, and
acidosis. Oxygen supplementation likely will improve the patient's arterial oxygen
tension. Such treatment, however, may abolish the hypoxic ventilatory drive and consequently
slow the ventilatory rate. This decreased ventilation could exacerbate respiratory
acidosis and may result in decompensation of the patient.
4
To avoid life-threatening acidemia, treatment of metabolic acidosis in addition to
oxygen supplementation is indicated.
Receptors located in the upper and lower respiratory tract respond to mechanical and
chemical stimuli and relay afferent information to the central controller of respiration
via the vagus nerve.1, 2 Vagal blockade abolishes tachypnea in horses with pulmonary
disease; therefore these receptors are likely to play an important role in development
of respiratory distress associated with primary pulmonary disease.7, 8, 9 Pulmonary
stretch receptors, also called slow-adapting stretch receptors, are located within
smooth muscle fibers in the walls of the trachea and bronchi.1, 2, 4 These receptors
are stimulated by pulmonary inflation and inhibit further inflation of the lung (Hering-Breuer
reflex). Conversely, at end expiration these receptors stimulate inspiratory activity.
These receptors are considered to be partially responsible for controlling the depth
and rate of respiration.
Irritant receptors (rapid-adjusting stretch receptors) are believed to be located
between epithelial cells of the conducting airways.
2
They are not likely to function in regulation of breathing in a normal resting horse.
4
Stimulation of these receptors by noxious stimuli triggers bronchoconstriction, cough,
tachypnea, mucus production, and release of inflammatory mediators.1, 2 Irritant receptors
can be triggered by exogenous stimuli (smoke, irritant gases, dust) or by endogenously
produced inflammatory mediators including histamine and prostaglandins. Production
of histamine, prostaglandins, and other inflammatory mediators increases in horses
with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).10, 11, 12 Stimulation of irritant
receptors by these inflammatory mediators may be responsible in part for bronchoconstriction,
mucus production, and tachypnea observed in horses with allergic airway disease. In
addition to their role as chemoreceptors, irritant receptors also function as mechanoreceptors.
1
An abrupt change in end-expiratory lung volume, such as occurs with pneumothorax or
pleural effusion, produces a tachypneic breathing pattern attributed to stimulation
of irritant receptors. Juxtacapillary receptors are believed to be located within
the wall of the alveolus. Stimulation by increased interstitial fluid volume triggers
the sensation of difficult breathing.
2
Nonmyelinated C fibers are located in the pulmonary parenchyma, conducting airways,
and blood vessels. These receptors respond to pulmonary edema, congestion, and inflammatory
mediators, and stimulation activates a tachypneic breathing pattern. In addition,
C fiber receptors may stimulate the release of pulmonary neuropeptides, which produce
bronchoconstriction, vasodilation, protein extravasation, and cytokine production.
1
Increased negative pressure (upper airway obstruction) within the airway stimulates
mechanoreceptors of the larynx and produces prolongation of inspiratory time and activation
of upper airway dilator muscles.
13
CENTRAL CONTROL OF RESPIRATION
The central controller consists of a group of motor neurons in the pons and medulla
that receive input from the peripheral and central receptors and initiate phasic activity
of diaphragmatic, intercostal, and abdominal respiratory muscles.
2
The medullary respiratory center, which is located in the reticular formation, controls
the rhythmic pattern of respiration. The dorsal respiratory group coordinates inspiratory
activity by assimilating afferent information from the glossopharyngeal and vagus
nerves and transmits efferent signals to the muscles of inspiration and neurons in
the ventral respiratory group. The ventral respiratory group consists of inspiratory
and expiratory motor neurons. This nucleus is relatively inactive at rest and has
a more dominant role during exercise. The apneustic center, located in the pons, provides
stimulatory input to inspiratory motor neurons. Damage to the apneustic center, from
trauma or neonatal maladjustment syndrome, results in prolonged inspiratory gasps
interrupted by transient expiratory efforts.
4
The pneumotaxic center, also located in the pons, inhibits the inspiratory centers
and regulates the volume and rate of respiration. The pneumotaxic center is not required
to maintain a normal respiratory rhythm; instead, this center functions to fine tune
the respiratory rhythm,
2
receiving afferent input from the vagus nerve regarding Pao2, Paco2, and pulmonary
inflation.
EFFECTORS OF RESPIRATION
The muscles required for ventilation include the diaphragm, the external and internal
intercostal muscles, and the abdominal muscles. The single most important muscle required
for the inspiratory phase of the respiratory cycle is the diaphragm. Contraction of
the diaphragm forces the abdominal contents back, increasing the length of the thoracic
cavity, and pulls the ribs abaxially, increasing the width of the abdominal cavity.
In addition, the external intercostal muscles participate in inspiration by pulling
the ribs abaxially to increase the width of the thoracic cavity. The net effect is
an increase in the size of the thoracic cavity, producing subatmospheric intrathoracic
pressure, to drive inspiration and pulmonary inflation. Expiration at rest is a passive
process in most species and relies on elastic recoil of the lung to create positive
intrathoracic pressure.
14
In horses, the first portion of expiration relies on elastic recoil of the lung to
the point of relaxation volume, whereby the tendency for pulmonary collapse equals
the tendency for expansion by the thoracic wall. However, horses further decrease
lung volume by active compression of the chest wall, through contraction of the internal
intercostal muscles and muscles of the abdominal wall.
15
Conversely, the first part of inhalation is passive until the relaxation volume is
reached, at which point the diaphragm and external intercostal muscles complete the
inspiratory phase. Mechanical (abdominal distention, trauma to the thoracic wall)
and neuromuscular (botulism, phrenic nerve damage, nutritional muscular dystrophy)
dysfunction of the diaphragm and intercostal muscles prevent expansion of the thoracic
wall and produce hypoventilation, hypoxemia, and respiratory distress.
4
Horses with torsion of the large colon develop significant abdominal distention and
respiratory distress. Respiratory failure caused by impaired diaphragmatic function
plays an important role in the pathophysiology and mortality associated with this
intestinal accident.
The diameter of the conducting airways is an important determinant of the degree of
pulmonary resistance and work of breathing and is controlled by the autonomic nervous
system. Vagal-mediated parasympathetic stimulation causes airway narrowing and is
one mechanism of bronchoconstriction associated with allergic airway disease. Administration
of atropine results in rapid relief of bronchoconstriction in some horses with COPD,
demonstrating the important role of parasympathetic bronchoconstriction in the pathogenesis
of this disease.16, 17 β2-Receptor stimulation produces smooth muscle relaxation and
bronchodilation. β2-Adrenergic receptors are abundant throughout the lung; however,
sympathetic innervation is sparse and β-receptors within the lung must rely on circulating
catecholamines for stimulation.
4
Airways must be constricted for β2-receptor stimulation or atropine blockade to produce
increased airway caliber.18, 19 β-Adrenergic receptors are less abundant than β2-receptors
and play no important role in the regulation of airway diameter. However, α-receptors
appear to be upregulated in horses with COPD and contribute to bronchoconstriction
associated with this disease.
20
Nonadrenergic-noncholinergic (NANC) innervation also contributes to large airway diameter.
Smooth muscles of the trachea and bronchi relax in response to activation of the inhibitory
NANC system. In COPD-affected horses with clinical signs of airway obstruction, inhibitory
NANC function is absent.
21
Failure of the inhibitory NANC system may result from the inflammatory response during
acute COPD or may be an inherent autonomic dysfunction of the conducting airways of
COPD-affected horses.
Hypoxemia
Respiratory distress most often originates from inadequate pulmonary gas exchange
to meet the metabolic demands of the individual, resulting in hypoxia and hypercapnia.
Hypoxia results from one or more of five basic pathophysiologic mechanisms: hypoventilation,
ventilation-perfusion mismatch, right to left shunting of blood, diffusion impairment,
and reduced inspired oxygen concentration. The degree of hypercapnia and response
to oxygen supplementation varies depending on the mechanism of impaired gas exchange.
Determination of these two parameters is useful in identifying the pathophysiologic
process predominantly responsible for the development of hypoxia.
22
HYPOVENTILATION
The hallmark of hypoventilation is hypercapnia.
22
The elevation in Paco2 is inversely proportional to the reduction in alveolar ventilation;
halving alveolar ventilation doubles Paco2.
2
The reduction in arterial oxygen tension is almost directly proportional to the increase
in CO2. For instance, if Paco2 increases from 40 to 80 mm Hg, then the Pao2 decreases
from 100 to 60 mm Hg. Therefore hypoxemia resulting from hypoventilation is rarely
life-threatening. In addition, oxygen supplementation easily abolishes hypoxemia caused
by pure hypoventilation. Acidosis caused by hypercapnia is the most clinically significant
feature of hypoventilation and may threaten the life of the patient.
22
Metabolic alkalosis or central nervous system depression (head trauma, encephalitis,
narcotic drugs) can produce hypoventilation; however, horses with these disorders
may not demonstrate clinical signs of respiratory distress. The following disorders
can cause alveolar hypoventilation, and affected patients usually demonstrate clinical
signs of respiratory distress: mechanical (abdominal distention, trauma to the thoracic
wall) and neuromuscular (botulism, phrenic nerve damage, nutritional muscular dystrophy)
dysfunction of the diaphragm and intercostal muscles, restrictive pulmonary disease
(silicosis, pulmonary fibrosis, pneumothorax, pleural effusion), and upper airway
obstruction.
4
VENTILATION-PERFUSION MISMATCH
Ventilation-perfusion (V-Q) mismatch is the most common cause of hypoxemia and is
characterized by unequal distribution of alveolar ventilation and blood flow.
4
Pulmonary regions that are overperfused in relation to ventilation (low V-Q ratio)
contribute disproportionate amounts of blood with low arterial oxygen content to the
systemic circulation.2, 22 Respiratory diseases characterized by low V-Q ratios include
COPD, pulmonary atelectasis, and consolidation.
4
If ventilation exceeds perfusion (high V-Q ratio), the ventilated pulmonary units
are inefficient for CO2 elimination and O2 uptake. Ventilation of poorly or nonperfused
units is wasted ventilation, termed alveolar dead space.
2, 22 Conditions associated with high V-Q ratios include pulmonary thromboembolism
and shock (low pulmonary artery pressure). Patients with V-Q mismatch often have a
normal arterial Pco2. The ventilatory drive to maintain normal Paco2 is powerful.
Because the CO2 dissociation curve is basically a straight line (direct relationship),
increased ventilation efficiently decreases Paco2 at high and low V-Q ratios. Because
the nearly flat shape of the O2 dissociation curve, increasing ventilation is inefficient
for proportionally increasing the arterial Po2. Only pulmonary units with moderate
to low V-Q ratios benefit from increased ventilation. Therefore the increased ventilatory
effort to maintain normal Paco2 is wasted and unnecessarily increases the work of
breathing. Oxygen supplementation increases Paco2 in patients with a V-Q mismatch.
However, elevation in arterial O2 is delayed compared with hypoventilation and in
some cases may be incomplete.
22
Compensatory mechanisms are present to minimize unequal distribution of ventilation
and perfusion in diseased lungs to prevent the development of hypoxemia until pulmonary
pathologic condition is severe.
23
Reflex pulmonary arterial constriction (hypoxic vasoconstriction) prevents perfusion
of unventilated alveolar units and attempts to redirect blood flow to alveoli that
are ventilated adequately. Airway hypocapnia causes bronchoconstriction of airways
that conduct to unperfused alveolar units, redirecting air flow to better perfused
alveoli.
SHUNT
Shunt is defined as blood that is not exposed to ventilated areas of the lung and
is added to the arteries of the systemic circulation.
22
Shunting can occur as an extreme form of V-Q mismatch or with direct addition of unoxygenated
blood to the arterial system. Physiologic shunting is defined as perfusion of nonventilated
or collapsed regions of the lung and occurs with pulmonary consolidation, atelectasis,
and edema. Congenital heart disease, such as tetralogy of Fallot and some cardiac
septal defects, is an example of a direct right-to-left shunt wherein unoxygenated
blood from the right side of the heart is added to oxygenated blood from the left
side of the heart. In these conditions, hypoxemia cannot be abolished by increasing
the oxygen content of inspired air. The shunted blood is never exposed to the higher
concentration of inspired oxygen in the alveolus, and the addition of a small amount
of shunted blood with its low O2 content greatly reduces the Po2 of arterial blood.
Compared with breathing room air, the decrement in Po2 is much greater at Po2 levels
associated with the inhalation of O2-enriched air because the O2 dissociation curve
is so flat at high Po2 levels. Only hypoxemia caused by right-to-left shunting behaves
in this manner when the patient is permitted to inspire high percentages of oxygen
(70% to 100%). Shunts do not usually cause hypercapnia.
23
Chemoreceptors detect excess arterial CO2, and ventilation increases to reduce the
content of CO2 in unshunted blood until arterial Pco2 reaches the normal range. In
some cases of shunt, the arterial Pco2 is below normal because of hyperventilation
stimulated by the hypoxemic ventilatory drive.
DIFFUSION IMPAIRMENT
Gas exchange between the alveolus and the capillary occurs by passive diffusion, which
is driven by the property of molecules to move randomly from an area of high concentration
to one of low concentration.
23
Factors that determine the rate of gas exchange include the concentration gradient
between the alveolus and capillary blood, solubility of the gas, surface area available
for diffusion, and the width of the air-blood barrier. Diseases characterized by pure
diffusion impairment are rare in veterinary medicine.
4
Diffusion impairment can occur with pulmonary fibrosis, interstitial pneumonia, silicosis,
or edema caused by increased width of the barrier or decreased surface area available
for gas exchange. The clinician should recognize that the major component of hypoxemia
for these conditions is a V-Q mismatch; however, diffusion impairment can contribute
to the severity of hypoxemia. Supplemental oxygen therapy is effective in treating
hypoxemia caused by diffusion impairment because it creates a more favorable concentration
gradient and increases the driving pressure of oxygen to move from the alveolus into
the blood. Transport of CO2 is less affected by diseases of diffusion impairment because
of its greater solubility compared with O2.
23
REDUCTION OF INSPIRED OXYGEN
Hypoxemia resulting from decreased inspired oxygen content is uncommon and occurs
only under special circumstances. High altitude and iatrogenic ventilation with a
low oxygen concentration are the most common circumstances in which hypoxemia is attributed
to reduction of inspired oxygen content.
22
Most pulmonary diseases in horses incorporate more than one of these pathophysiologic
mechanisms for the development of hypoxemia. Horses with pleuropneumonia, for example,
may develop hypoxemia caused by hypoventilation (extrapulmonary restriction by pleural
effusion), V-Q mismatch (accumulation of exudate and edema within alveoli and conducting
airways), and diffusion impairment (exudate and edema within the interstitial spaces).
Obstructive Disease
The location (intrathoracic or extrathoracic) and nature (fixed or dynamic) of airway
obstruction determines whether impedance to air flow occurs during inspiration, expiration,
or both.
3
The phase of the respiration cycle affected by air flow obstruction are prolonged
and may be associated with a respiratory noise (stridor or wheeze).24, 25
The horse is an obligate nasal breather and can only breathe efficiently through the
nares.
4
Therefore upper airway obstruction within the nasal passages cannot be bypassed by
mouth breathing. In addition, approximately 80% of the total airway resistance to
air flow is located in the upper airway.
25
A 50% decrease in the radius of an airway increases its resistance by sixteenfold
(Poiseuille's law).
14
Therefore small changes in the upper airway diameter dramatically affect the overall
resistance to air flow and work of breathing for the horse. Extrathoracic airway pressures
are subatmospheric during inspiration; therefore poorly supported structures in the
upper airway narrow or collapse during inspiration (dynamic collapse). The most common
cause of non–fixed upper airway obstruction in horses is laryngeal hemiplegia, which
produces inspiratory stridor during exercise. Intraluminal masses and arytenoid chondritis
cause fixed upper airway obstruction and produce inspiratory and expiratory respiratory
distress.
3
Twenty percent of the total airway resistance is attributable to the small airways.
25
Although the radius of individual bronchioles is small, many of them exist and the
sum or collective radius is large, with the result that their overall contribution
to pulmonary resistance is low.
23
Because the resistance of the bronchioles is low, advanced disease must be present
for routine measurements of airway resistance to detect an abnormality, and obstruction
of these airways must be extensive before a horse would suffer from respiratory distress.
During pulmonary inflation, intrathoracic pressures are subatmospheric. Small airways
are pulled open by negative intrathoracic pressure and stretched parenchymal attachments
at high lung volumes. Thus resistance to air flow in small airways is low during the
inspiratory phase of respiration.
24
During exhalation, intrathoracic pressure is positive and the diameter of small airways
is decreased, and bronchioles may even close at low lung volumes. Therefore resistance
to air flow in small airways is greatest during the expiratory phase. In horses with
COPD, the airway diameter is reduced by inflammatory exudate, edema, and bronchoconstriction.16,
17 As lung volume decreases during expiration, the narrowed bronchioles are compressed
shut (dynamic airway collapse) and trap air distal to the site of closure.
4
This is an example of severe flow limitation, which may lead ultimately to the development
of emphysema. Flow limitation forces horses with COPD to breathe at higher lung volumes
and maintain a higher functional residual capacity to reduce or avoid dynamic airway
collapse. Affected horses attempt to reduce the end-expiratory lung volume by recruiting
abdominal muscles to increase the intrathoracic pressures during expiration. However,
the greater the end-expiratory pressure, the greater is the likelihood of small airway
compression and collapse. Hypertrophy of the cutaneous trunci and expiratory abdominal
muscles, especially the external abdominal oblique, produces the characteristic heave
line associated with COPD.
4
Because dynamic airway narrowing and collapse occurs during exhalation, wheezes are
loudest at end expiration in horses with COPD.16, 17
Restrictive Disease
Restrictive disease is less common than is obstructive pulmonary disease in horses.
4
By definition, restrictive disease inhibits pulmonary expansion and leads to inspiratory
respiratory distress.
26
The vital capacity and compliance (pulmonary or chest wall) decrease, expiratory flow
rates and elastic recoil increase, and airway resistance is normal. The characteristic
respiratory pattern in horses with restrictive pulmonary disease is rapid, shallow
respiration at low lung volumes.
4
This strategy takes advantage of high pulmonary compliance at low lung volumes and
decreases the work of breathing. This respiratory pattern has the disadvantage of
increased ventilation of anatomic dead space.
26
Restrictive diseases may be classified as intrapulmonary (pulmonary fibrosis, silicosis,
27
and interstitial pneumonia28, 29) and extrapulmonary (pleural effusion, pneumothorax,
mediastinal mass, botulism, and nutritional muscular dystrophy).
4
Hypoxemia observed in horses with intrapulmonary restrictive disease is attributed
to V-Q mismatch and diffusion impairment. Stimulation of juxtacapillary receptors
may contribute to respiratory distress observed in these patients.
26
The pathophysiologic mechanism for hypoxemia in horses with extrapulmonary restriction
is hypoventilation.
4
In cases of pleural effusion and pneumothorax, respiratory distress is likely to be
exacerbated by thoracic pain.
Nonpulmonary Respiratory Distress
Respiratory distress does not always originate from dysfunction of the pulmonary system
and its supporting structures. Nonpulmonary respiratory distress can occur because
of inadequate oxygen-carrying capacity of the blood, compensation for metabolic acidosis,
pain, and hyperthermia.
Impaired oxygen-carrying capacity of the blood may occur because of anemia (blood
loss, hemolytic, or aplastic) or dysfunction of red blood cells (methemoglobinemia,
carbon monoxide toxicity). In these cases, the arterial Po2 tension is normal; however,
the oxygen content of the blood is reduced greatly.
2
Tachypnea and respiratory distress occur in response to impaired oxygen delivery and
tissue hypoxia.
3
The respiratory system can compensate for metabolic acidosis by increasing ventilation
to lower Paco2 and attenuate acidemia.
2
The ventilatory drive increases in response to stimulation by peripheral chemoreceptors
by circulating hydrogen ions. Hypocarbic compensation for mild to moderate metabolic
acidosis is effective in returning blood pH to normal until renal compensatory mechanisms
can be established.
2
Pain and anxiety are physiologic causes of tachypnea and hyperpnea. Horses with musculoskeletal
pain are unlikely to demonstrate significant respiratory distress; however, rhabdomyolysis
and laminitis are painful musculoskeletal conditions that may produce tachypnea.
3
Marked respiratory distress is observed frequently in horses with abdominal pain;
however, the respiratory distress is not caused solely by pain and is exacerbated
by abdominal distention, shock, acidosis, and endotoxemia.
Hyperthermia caused by fever, high environmental temperature, exercise, and heat stress
can produce respiratory distress in horses. Tachypnea and elevation in body temperature
are the most prominent clinical signs in horses with anhydrosis.
30
Hyperpnea is an effective mechanism for heat dissipation in human beings, dogs, and
ruminants.
3
Unfortunately, increased ventilation is an inefficient mechanism for heat dissipation
in horses and appears to be wasted effort.3, 4
Clinical Evaluation of Respiratory Distress
A thorough physical examination is essential to determine the origin of respiratory
distress, identify concurrent disease, and direct further diagnostic testing. Prolonged
inspiration is consistent with restrictive or extrathoracic, nonfixed, obstructive
disease, whereas horses with intrathoracic airway obstruction exhibit expiratory difficulty.3,
24 Respiratory distress associated with inspiration and expiration may indicate an
extrathoracic fixed obstruction. Stridor is an abnormal respiratory noise that usually
is generated by obstruction of the upper airway and is audible most often during inspiration.
3
Horses with nonpulmonary respiratory distress demonstrate increased rate and depth
of respiration, without producing abnormal respiratory noise.
Thoracic auscultation identifies abnormal respiratory sounds (crackles and wheezes)
or regions of decreased breath sounds caused by pleural effusion, pneumothorax, or
pulmonary consolidation. Percussion of the thoracic wall generates a resonant and
hollow sound when performed over regions of normal lung. Pleural effusion and pulmonary
consolidation sound dull and flat during thoracic percussion, whereas pneumothorax
produces a hyperresonant sound.
31
Normal air flow occurs in laminar flow; therefore normal horses at rest do not generate
easily audible sounds.
4
Respiratory sounds are generated from vibration in tissue and sudden changes in pressure
of gas moving within the airway lumen. Airway narrowing and exudate generate audible
sounds by creating disturbances in laminar flow, turbulence, and sudden changes in
pressure of moving gas.
14
Crackles are intermittent or explosive sounds, generated by bubbling of air through
secretions or by equilibration of airway pressures after sudden opening of collapsed
small airways. The generation of crackles requires an air-fluid interface, and these
abnormal lung sounds occur in horses with pneumonia, interstitial fibrosis, COPD,
pulmonary edema, and atelectasis.
4
Wheezes are continuous, musical sounds that originate from oscillation of small airway
walls before complete closing (expiratory wheeze) or opening (inspiratory wheeze).
14
Expiratory wheezes are the hallmark of obstructive pulmonary disease.
24
Arterial blood gas determination provides a quantitative evaluation of pulmonary function,
alveolar ventilation, and acid-base status and may identify the origin of respiratory
distress (hypercapnia, hypoxemia, or acidemia).
22
The clinician may determine the pathophysiologic mechanism of hypoxemia by examining
the Paco2 level and by investigating the response of Pao2 to supplemental oxygen therapy.
In addition, serial blood gas monitoring can determine response to bronchodilator,
parasympathomimetic, or antiinflammatory therapy.
Additional diagnostic tests that may be indicated in horses with respiratory distress
include thoracic radiography, thoracic ultrasonography, endoscopic examination of
the upper airway, and atropine challenge. The findings during thoracic auscultation
and percussion are valuable in determining indication for ultrasonography versus radiography.
Pulmonary consolidation, abscessation, fibrosis, interstitial pneumonia, peribronchial
infiltration, and mediastinal mass are differentiated and diagnosed readily via thoracic
radiography. Thoracic ultrasonography is superior to radiography in detecting and
characterizing pleural fluid and peripheral pulmonary abscessation and consolidation
in horses. Air reflects the ultrasound beam; therefore ultrasonography does not image
deep pulmonary lesions if the overlying lung is aerated.
32
An endoscopic examination of the upper airway is indicated in horses with inspiratory
stridor and suspected upper airway obstruction.
33
Horses with extreme respiratory distress may resent endoscopic examination, and forced
examination may precipitate a respiratory crisis. Atropine administration in horses
with COPD may provide rapid relief of respiratory distress, if the major component
of airway obstruction is reversible bronchoconstriction. Horses that respond to an
atropine challenge likely will respond favorably to bronchodilator therapy. Incomplete
response to atropine in horses with COPD indicates that exudate or fibrosis is contributing
to airway obstruction, and limited response to bronchodilator therapy is anticipated.16,
17
REFERENCES
1
Ainsworth
DM
Davidow
E
Respiratory distress in large animals. Proceeding of the twelth annual forum American
College of Internal Medicine
1994
The College
San Franciseo
589
591
2
West
JB
Control of ventilation
West
JB
Respiratory physiology: the essentials
1990
Williams & Wilkins
Baltimore
3
Wilson
WD
Lofstedt
J
Alterations in respiratory function
Smith
BP
Large animal internal medicine
1990
CV Mosby
St Louis
4
Derksen
FJ
Applied respiratory physiology
Beech
J
Equine respiratory disorders
1991
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
5
Ainsworth
DM
Ducharme
NG
Hackett
RP
Regulation of equine respiratory muscles during acute hypoxia and hypercapnia
Am Rev Respir Dis
147
1993
A700
6
Muir
WW
Moore
CA
Hamlin
RL
Ventilatory alterations in normal horses in response to changes in inspired oxygen
and carbon dioxide
Am J Vet Res
36
1975
155
161
1111380
7
Derksen
FJ
Robinson
NE
Slocombe
RF
Ovalbumin induced allergic lung disease in the pony: role of vagal mechanisms
J Appl Physiol
53
1982
719
724
7129995
8
Derksen
F
Robinson
N
Slocombe
R
3-Methylindole-induced pulmonary toxicosis in ponies
Am J Vet Res
43
1982
603
607
7073081
9
Derksen
FJ
Robinson
NE
Stick
JA
Technique for reversible vagal blockade in the standing conscious pony
Am J Vet Res
42
1981
523
531
7271019
10
McGorum
BC
Quantification of histamine in plasma and pulmonary fluids from horses with chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease, before and after “natural (hay and straw) challenges,”
Vet Immunol Immunopathol
36
1993
223
237
8506613
11
Watson
E
Sweeney
C
Steensma
K
Arachidonate metabolites in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid from horses with and without
COPD
Equine Vet J
24
1992
379
381
1396512
12
Grunig
G
Hermann
M
Winder
C
Procoagulant activity in respiratory tract secretions from horses with chronic pulmonary
disease
Am J Vet Res
49
1988
705
709
3395015
13
Sant'Ambrogio
G
Mathew
OP
Fisher
JT
Laryngeal receptors responding to transmural pressure, airflow, and local muscle activity
J Appl Physiol
65
1983
317
330
14
West
JB
Mechanics of breathing
West
JB
Respiratory physiology: the essentials
1990
Williams & Wilkins
Baltimore
15
Koterba
AM
Kosch
PC
Beech
J
The breathing strategy of the adult horse (Equus caballus) at rest
J Appl Physiol
64
1988
337
343
3356653
16
Derksen
FJ
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Beech
J
Equine respiratory disorders
1991
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
17
Beech
J
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Smith
BP
Large animal internal medicine
1990
CV Mosby
St Louis
18
Derksen
FJ
Scott
JS
Slocombe
RF
Effect of clenbuterol on histamine-induced airway obstruction in ponies
Am J Vet Res
48
1987
423
429
3565899
19
Scott
J
Broadstone
R
Derksen
F
Beta adrenergic blockade in ponies with recurrent obstructive pulmonary disease
J Appl Physiol
64
1988
2324
2328
2841272
20
Scott
JS
Garon
HE
Broadstone
RV
Alpha 1 adrenergic induced airway obstruction in ponies with recurrent pulmonary disease
J Appl Physiol
65
1988
686
791
21
Robinson
NE
Derksen
FJ
Olszewski
MA
The pathogenesis of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease of horses
Br Vet J
152
1996
283
306
8762605
22
West
JB
Gas exchange
West
JB
Pulmonary pathophysiology: the essentials
1990
Williams & Wilkins
Philadelphia
23
West
JB
Ventilation-perfusion relationships
West
JB
Respiratory physiology: the essentials
1990
Williams & Wilkins
PhiladelphiJa
24
West
JB
Obstructive diseases
West
JB
Pulmonary pathophysiology: the essentials
1990
Williams & Wilkins
Baltimore
25
Macklem
PT
Mead
J
Resistance of central and peripheral airways measured by retrograde catheter
J Appl Physiol
22
1967
395
402
4960137
26
West
JB
Restrictive diseases
West
JB
Pulmonary pathophysiology: the essentials
1990
Williams & Wilkins
Baltimore
27
Berry
CR
O'Brien
TR
Madigan
JE
Thoracic radiographic features of silicosis in 19 horses
J Vet Intern Med
5
1991
248
256
1941758
28
Buergelt
CD
Hines
SA
Cantor
G
A retrospective study of proliferative interstitial lung disease of horses in Florida
Vet Pathol
23
1986
750
756
3811140
29
Lakritz
J
Wilson
WD
Berry
CR
Bronchointerstitial pneumonia and respiratory distress in young horses: clinical,
clinicopathologic, radiographic, and pathological findings in 23 cases (1984-1989)
J Vet Intern Med
7
1993
277
288
8263846
30
Mayhew
IG
Ferguson
HO
Clinical, clinicopathologic, and epidemiologic features of anhidrosis in central Florida
thoroughbred horses
J Vet Intern Med
1
1987
136
141
3506097
31
Beech
J
Examination of the respiratory tract
Beech
J
Equine respiratory disorders
1991
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
27
40
32
Reimer
JM
Diagnostic ultrasonography of the equine thorax
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
12
1990
1321
1327
33
Robertson
JT
Pharynx and larynx
Beech
J
Equine respiratory disorders
1991
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
Kohn
Catherine W.
3.8—Cough
Cough, a sudden explosive expulsion of air through the glottis, is a common sign of
respiratory disease and a reflex pulmonary defense mechanism. Coughing facilitates
the removal of noxious substances and excessive secretions from the airways by creating
maximum expiratory airflow. A high-velocity airflow generates the shear forces required
to separate mucus from the airway walls, enabling expulsion of exudate and debris
from the airway.
1
An understanding of the cough reflex provides insight into the pathophysiology of
diseases characterized by cough.
The cough reflex has been studied infrequently in horses. Descriptions of the cough
cycle and the neural basis of cough presented in this section are based on data from
other species. The author infers that similar events occur in horses. Because differences
exist among species regarding the cough reflex,
2
studies on horses will be required to define the physiologic events of the cough reflex
in this species.
Cough Cycle
The cough cycle has four phases: inspiration, compression, expression, and relaxation.
1
Deep inspiration, which immediately precedes cough, increases lung volume. As lung
volume increases, the ability to generate maximum expiratory airflow increases because
of the greater force of contraction achieved by the muscles of respiration when their
precontraction length increases and because of the greater elastic recoil pressure
of the lung at high lung value.
3
Thus precough expansion of lung volume maximizes the velocity of expiratory airflow.
Achievement of maximum expiratory airflow rates requires a relatively gentle expiratory
effort, and airflow maxima are therefore independent of effort.
2
After deep inspiration, the glottis closes. While the glottis remains closed, compression
of the chest cavity occurs by contraction of the thoracic and abdominal musculature
during an active expiratory effort. Compression of the chest results in an increase
in pleural pressure from 50 to 100 mm Hg.
2
This increase in pleural pressure is transmitted to pressure in the intrathoracic
airways and trachea. Intraalveolar pressures actually exceed intrapleural pressures
by an amount equal to the elastic recoil pressure of the lung.
4
Expression occurs when the glottis opens abruptly, thus producing a gradient in airway
pressure (atmospheric at the pharynx and high in the alveoli), and air is expired
forcefully. The occurrence of dynamic airway compression in larger airways maximizes
the velocity of airflow toward the mouth (Figure 3.8-1
). The intraairway pressures vary in the respiratory system according to the instantaneous
transpulmonary pressure.
3
At the equal pressure point, the airway pressure equals the pleural pressure. Toward
the mouth from the equal pressure point (downstream), the pleural pressure is greater
than intrathoracic airway pressure, and the intrathoracic airways therefore are compressed
dynamically. Partial collapse of the airways downstream of the equal pressure point
maximizes airflow velocities in these airways by decreasing their diameter. At high
lung volumes, the equal pressure point likely is in the larger airways and therefore
only the intrathoracic trachea may be subject to dynamic compression and maximal airflow
velocity.
4
Maximum airflow velocity produces high shearing forces that dislodge mucus and debris
from airway walls, thus facilitating expectoration. Cough is therefore most effective
as a defense mechanism for clearing the larger airways in healthy animals. Removal
of noxious substances from the smaller peripheral airways depends on the presence
of mucus in the airways, and irritants that stimulate cough also may stimulate mucus
production.
5
Figure 3.8-1
Dynamic airway compression during cough or maximum expiratory airflow. Lungs are represented
at total lung capacity. When chronic obstructive pulmonary disease is present, the
equal pressure point moves toward the alveoli. This peripheral migration of the equal
pressure point results in dynamic compression in more peripheral airways during cough
than would be found in a healthy individual.
(Redrawn from Robinson NE: Pathophysiology of coughing. In Proceedings of the thirty-second
convention of the American Association of Equine Practitioners, Nashville, 1986, pp
291-297.)
© 2004
2004
Since January 2020 Elsevier has created a COVID-19 resource centre with free information
in English and Mandarin on the novel coronavirus COVID-19. The COVID-19 resource centre
is hosted on Elsevier Connect, the company's public news and information website.
Elsevier hereby grants permission to make all its COVID-19-related research that is
available on the COVID-19 resource centre - including this research content - immediately
available in PubMed Central and other publicly funded repositories, such as the WHO
COVID database with rights for unrestricted research re-use and analyses in any form
or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are
granted for free by Elsevier for as long as the COVID-19 resource centre remains active.
In diseases characterized by increased resistance in small peripheral airways caused
by partial obstruction (e.g., chronic obstructive pulmonary disease [COPD]), maximal
expiratory flow rates are reduced. When small airways are obstructed partially, the
equal pressure point moves toward the periphery of the lung during coughing because
pressures in airways downstream of the partial obstruction are lower than are pressures
in those airways in healthy lungs (see Figure 3.8-1). This shift in the equal pressure
point subjects more peripheral airways to dynamic compression. Coughing is likely
to be less effective as a clearance mechanism when obstructive diseases of the small
airways are present. Bronchodilator therapy may increase the effectiveness of cough
in such patients by increasing expiratory airflow rates.
4
The sound of cough is generated by vibration of laryngeal and pharyngeal structures
caused by the rapid expulsion of air immediately after opening of the glottis,
3
by narrowing and deformation of airways, and by vibration of surrounding lung tissue.
Variations in the sound of cough most likely relate to the quantity and quality of
mucus in the airway.
6
At the end of cough, relaxation occurs. Intrapleural pressure falls, and the muscles
of expiration relax. Transient bronchodilation occurs.
1
Neural Basis of the Cough Reflex
The afferent input for the cough reflex is carried predominantly in the vagus nerves,
and the cough reflex depends uniquely on vagal afferents in the species studied.5,
7, 8 Sensory myelinated nerves in the larynx respond to mechanical and chemical irritation
and mediate cough and changes in airway diameter.
7
Debate continues about the identity of receptors that initiate cough in the lower
airways; however, all the receptors described is this section likely contribute to
the cough response.
8
Rapidly adapting receptors are located in the airway mucosa in the region of the carina
and are stimulated primarily by mechanical deformation produced, for example, by inhaled
particles, mucus, or cellular debris accumulating near the carina. Chemical irritants
(e.g., ammonia fumes, ozone, and inflammatory mediators) evoke cough by stimulation
of receptors located in the peripheral airways. Pulmonary C fibers may mediate a chemically
evoked cough, although this issue still is debated. Chemical mediators known to stimulate
pulmonary C fibers and cough when inhaled as aerosols by human beings include bronchodilator
prostaglandins, bradykinin, and capsaicin.
8
Forced expiration during coughing may be facilitated by the modulating effects of
information from these receptors on central respiratory neurons.
Bronchoconstriction is a constant component of cough,3, 6 and stimuli of cough also
may cause bronchoconstriction; however, cough and bronchoconstriction are separate
airway reflexes. Inhalation of dust and irritant gases causes reflex bronchoconstriction
in the species studied. Reflex bronchoconstriction has a slow onset and is long lasting
compared with the cough reflex.
9
Bronchoconstriction may increase the efficiency of cough by decreasing airway diameter
and therefore increasing airflow velocity. In some cases, bronchodilating drugs may
suppress the cough reflex by desensitizing airway receptors that elicit cough.
6
Sensory nerves mediating bronchoconstriction and cough are distributed unevenly along
the airways.
7
Laryngeal receptors and sensory nerves in the extrapulmonary airways may be more sensitive
to mechanical stimuli, whereas intrapulmonary receptors may respond preferentially
to chemical mediators and irritants.
Little is known about the brainstem neuronal pathways of the cough reflex. In the
cat, the cough center is reported to be in the medulla at the level of the obex, alongside
the solitary nucleus of the vagus and close to the expiratory neurons of the respiratory
center. On the motor side of the cough reflex, the vagal, phrenic, intercostal, and
lumbar nerves and motor portions of the trigeminal, facial, hypoglossal, and accessory
nerves are distributed to the striated and smooth muscles of respiration, the vocal
fold abductors and adductors, and glands of the respiratory tract.
3
Stimuli of Cough
Cough may be stimulated by airway smooth muscle contraction (bronchoconstriction),
excessive mucus production, presence of inhaled particles in the airways, release
of inflammatory mediators (infectious diseases), exposure to cold or hot air, intramural
or extramural pressure or tension on the airways (tumor, granuloma, abscess, or decreased
pulmonary compliance caused by restrictive disease such as interstitial fibrosis or
pleuritis), sloughing of airway epithelial cells, and enhanced epithelial permeability
(pulmonary edema).
5
Epithelial sloughing and enhanced epithelial permeability theoretically increase the
accessibility of cough receptors to the mechanical or chemical agents that stimulate
them. Loss of the integrity of the epithelial lining of the respiratory tract is a
common feature in many respiratory diseases associated with cough (infectious diseases);
however, a cause-and-effect relationship between alterations in respiratory epithelium
and cough has not been established.
5
Diseases of the respiratory tract may alter the sensitivity of the cough reflex.
5
For example, viral diseases may increase the responsiveness of cough receptors to
stimuli.
Deleterious Consequences of Cough
Although cough is an important defense mechanism of the respiratory system that promotes
expectoration of inhaled noxious substances and voluminous airway secretions, cough
may lose its original defensive function and may contribute to the morbidity and discomfort
associated with bronchopulmonary disease.
8
This is especially true when the effort to cough is intense and when multiple coughs
occur sequentially. Chronic coughing is exhausting and, especially in foals, may decrease
food intake. Paroxysmal or persistent cough may impair respiration. Coughing may have
profound effects on the cardiovascular system. During the deep inspiratory phase of
cough, the rise in intraabdominal pressure because of contraction of the diaphragm
and the fall in intrathoracic pressure combine to aspirate blood from the vena cava
to fill the right atrium and ventricle abruptly.
3
Because the pleural pressure decreases, the pulmonary artery pressure also decreases.
During the expiratory phase of cough, an initial increase in systemic arterial blood
pressure and a simultaneous and commensurate increase in cerebral venous and cerebrospinal
fluid pressures occur. However, venous return to the heart soon decreases and within
a few heartbeats, filling of the heart and stroke volume decrease.2, 3 Hypotension
ensues. Falling arterial blood pressure in the face of high cerebral venous pressures
reduces the effective perfusion pressure of the brain. Cerebral hypoperfusion and
anoxia may occur. Cough-induced syncope has been reported in human beings
2
and in dogs.
10
In chronic cough, bronchial muscular hypertrophy may develop. Bronchial mucosal edema
or emphysema may accompany chronic cough. During cough inspiration, inflammatory debris
may be aspirated into previously uncontaminated areas of the lung. Cough in dogs has
been associated with pneumothorax (from rupture of preexisting pulmonary bullae) and
lung lobe torsion.
11
Rib and vertebral fractures have been reported in human beings with powerful coughs
but have not been reported in horses.2, 3
Clinical Approach to the Coughing Horse
Cough is a common sign of respiratory disease in horses (Figure 3.8-2
). Cough is an indication of mechanical or irritant stimulation of cough receptors
for which the potential causes are diverse. Many clinical approaches exist for anatomic
localization of the origin of the cough stimulus in respiratory disease and for discovery
of the cause. All methods have in common a systematic and thorough evaluation of the
history and physical examination of the patient. To aid the clinician in formulating
a rational approach to diagnosis, diseases associated with cough may be grouped according
to those characterized by fever (current or historical) and those characterized by
lack of an elevated body temperature. The clinician should keep in mind that exceptions
to generalizations always occur concerning disease processes, and the following discussion
therefore serves only as a guide to develop a logical approach to differenting diseases
characterized by cough.
Figure 3.8-2
Approach to cough. EHV1, 4, Equine herpesvirus 1 or 4.
COUGH WITH FEVER
Horses with cough and fever should have a thorough physical examination (see Chapter
7 for a complete description of a physical examination for horses with respiratory
disease). A minimum laboratory database for the coughing horse with fever should include
the results of a hemogram and a fibrinogen determination. The clinician carefully
should auscultate the thorax of the horse in a quiet room with the horse breathing
quietly. If the horse is not dyspneic or hypoxemic, the clinician also should undertake
auscultation during forced breathing. A plastic bag loosely held over the nostrils
of the horse forces the horse to increase tidal volume and respiratory rate. This
maneuver causes many horses with exudate in the airways to cough, and deep breathing
may be frankly painful for some horses with pleuropneumonia. Auscultation during forced
breathing is not necessary in horses with obviously abnormal lung sounds during quiet
breathing and is not advisable in horses with pneumonia (especially aspiration pneumonia)
or in horses with foreign material in the trachea. Crackles and wheezes heard repeatedly
during the inspiratory and early expiratory phases of breathing suggest that pulmonary
parenchymal disease is present. Accentuated normal bronchovesicular sounds sometimes
are present in horses with pulmonary consolidation, because of referral of sounds
from the aerated lung. Absence of lung sounds in dependent portions of the thorax
indicates that pulmonary consolidation, atelectasis, or fluid in the pleural cavity
may be present. Thoracic percussion and sonographic evaluation are particularly helpful
in documenting the presence of fluid in the pleural cavity. Ultrasonography also may
show pleural irregularities and superficial parenchymal abscessation, atelectasis,
or consolidation. Thoracic radiographs are especially helpful in demonstrating deeper
parenchymal disease. Many equine practitioners do not have access to thoracic radiography
but can perform thoracic ultrasonography.
Abnormal lung sounds, percussion irregularities, and sonographic evidence of fluid
or consolidation are indications for performing transtracheal aspiration (TTA) and
bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL). When both procedures are to be performed on the same
patient, the clinician should perform TTA first to obtain a sample for culture before
the airway is contaminated by the BAL tube. Many practitioners prefer to obtain TTA
samples transendoscopically to avoid percutaneous aspiration. Despite the development
of guarded culture swabs for transendoscopic use, this technique does not always prevent
contamination of lower airway fluid samples. One study demonstrated that Pseudomonas
spp. and anaerobic bacteria in cultures of tracheal fluid obtained transendoscopically
should be viewed as potential contaminants.
12
Cytologic evaluation of the TTA/BAL, indicating an increase in polymorphonuclear leukocytes
(PMNs), is consistent with parenchymal disease. Some PMNs may be degenerate. Although
some clinicians feel that PMNs may be seen in the tracheal aspirates of normal horses,
few PMNs are found in bronchoalveolar lavage fluids from healthy horses (4.4 ± 3.3
cells to 8.9 ± 1.2 cells/μl).
13
How well the results of cytologic evaluation of BAL fluids represent the environment
of the lower airways is a matter of some debate. Bronchoalveolar lavage fluids are
harvested from a focal area of the lung. If parenchymal disease is not generalized,
bronchoalveolar lavage may miss the diseased region. Results of BAL fluid analysis
are normal in some horses with pneumonia and pleuropneumonia. Transtracheal wash fluid
consists of secretions from both lungs, and TTA cytologic examination was abnormal
in all horses with pneumonia and pleuropneumonia in one study.
14
The prevalence of PMNs in TTA fluid from horses without lower respiratory tract disease
has not been determined.
The presence of degenerate PMNs and extracellular or intracellular bacteria in TTA/BAL
fluid is consistent with the diagnosis of a septic process. The clinician should evaluate
a Gram stain to guide the initial choice of antimicrobial agents while awaiting results
of culture and sensitivity determinations. Growth of aerobic or anaerobic bacteria
in a culture of TTA fluid confirms the presence of bacterial pneumonia if clinical
and radiographic findings are also consistent with this disease process. Contamination
of cultures of airway secretions obtained via TTA occasionally may occur. Lack of
growth of bacterial pathogens from TTA fluid suggests that viral, interstitial, or
fungal pneumonia might be present. These possibilities should be investigated by evaluating
paired serum samples taken 10 to 14 days apart for influenza virus, equine herpesvirus
1 (EHV1), EHV4, rhinovirus, and equine viral arteritis. Serologic testing for histoplasmosis,
blastomycosis, coccidioidomycosis (southwestern United States especially), and possibly
mycobacteria should be evaluated. Fungal cultures of tracheal fluid should be evaluated
when other more common causes of pneumonia have been ruled out and if the clinical
signs of the patient are consistent with this diagnosis. Negative results on serologic
tests and fungal cultures in patients with a significant interstitial pattern on thoracic
radiographs should prompt consideration of the diagnosis of interstitial pneumonia,
a condition for which the inciting cause has not been established and for which the
prognosis is grave.
Percussion, radiographic, or ultrasonic evidence of increased intrapleural fluid is
an indication for thoracocentesis. Many horses with bacterial pleuropneumonia have
elevated pleural fluid PMN concentrations, and PMNs may be degenerate. Intracellular
or extracellular bacteria may be seen on cytologic evaluation. Occasionally, frankly
neoplastic cells may be identified in thoracic fluid (usually squamous cells or lymphocytes).
Many cytologists are uncomfortable diagnosing thoracic neoplasia based solely on an
evaluation of pleural fluid. Thoracic fluid should be cultured aerobically and anaerobically.
A positive culture identifies the cause of bacterial pleuritis; however, often pleural
fluid cultures may be negative. Cultures of TTA fluid are more likely to be positive
in horses with pleuropneumonia, and TTA cultures should be performed routinely for
these patients. Primary viral pleuritis, although rare in the author's experience,
has been reported in horses, and paired serologic examinations for influenza virus
and EHV1/EHV4 may be helpful when cultures are negative. One case of pleuritis caused
by Mycoplasma felis has been reported.
15
Culture of pleural fluid and paired serologic examinations for this organism should
be performed in patients for which other tests have not proved diagnostic.
Intrathoracic neoplasms may cause cough with or without accompanying fever. Confirmation
of a thoracic tumor may require an ultrasound-guided biopsy or an exploratory thoracotomy
and a biopsy. Secondary bacterial pleuritis may complicate thoracic neoplasms, and
aerobic and anaerobic cultures of thoracic fluid from patients suspected of having
thoracic neoplasms should be performed.
Some febrile coughing horses have no abnormalities on auscultation, percussion, thoracic
radiography, or ultrasound. In such patients, occult pulmonary disease may be present
and TTA/BAL and culture of TTA fluid are indicated. Alternatively, such horses may
have upper airway disease (sinusitis, sinus tumor, guttural pouch empyema), and an
endoscopic evaluation is also indicated.
COUGH WITHOUT FEVER
When auscultation of the thorax demonstrates primarily expiratory crackles and wheezes,
thoracic percussion often reveals a caudoventral expansion of the lung borders. These
findings suggest that COPD may be present. Thoracic radiographs usually show increased
interstitial densities; radiographs are useful to rule out occult underlying pulmonary
disease (such as a well walled-off abscess) but are not required for diagnosis in
most cases. TTA and BAL are indicated. Horses with COPD usually have an increase in
well-preserved PMNs, and sometimes eosinophils, in TTA and BAL fluids. Growth of pathogens
in aerobic or anaerobic culture of TTA fluid identifies secondary bacterial infection.
No growth in cultures of TTA fluid is also consistent with the diagnosis of COPD.
Occasionally, TTA/BAL fluids may contain parasite larvae or many eosinophils. If horses
historically have been housed with donkeys or mules, one should suspect Dictyocaulus
arnfieldi infestation. Coughing horses younger than 18 months of age with eosinophilic
TTA fluid may be experiencing an aberrant migration of Parascaris equorum larvae.
The clinician should attempt to identify the larvae, although this may be difficult.
A direct cytologic evaluation of unfixed, unstained, or iodine-stained mucus may be
helpful to identify larvae of D. arnfieldi. The clinician should perform a Baermann
flotation on feces from the patient and potential reservoir hosts, but the test may
not demonstrate ascarid larvae, because pulmonary migration may occur early in the
prepatent period.
16
The diagnosis of pulmonary ascarid migration is based on ruling out other causes of
pneumonia.
When TTA/BAL fluids have no abnormal cells, cultures still should be assessed. For
afebrile coughing horses with thoracic auscultation findings of inspiratory crackles
and wheezes and cardiac murmur or arrhythmia, one should take thoracic radiographs.
The presence of diffuse pulmonary infiltrates in a bronchoalveolar pattern suggests
that pulmonary edema may be present. A complete ultrasonic evaluation of the heart
is indicated.
Some coughing, afebrile horses have no abnormalities on auscultation or percussion,
and endoscopy of the upper airway and trachea is indicated. Some horses have endoscopic
evidence of exudate in the trachea and likely have low-grade COPD. The clinician should
take thoracic radiographs of these horses if possible and perform TTA/BAL testing
followed by culture of TTA fluid. A transtracheal aspirate should not be obtained
immediately after tracheoscopy because bacteria on the endoscope may contaminate airway
cultures.
In other patients, cough may be a symptom of upper airway obstructive disease (dorsal
displacement of the soft palate, rostral displacement of the palatopharyngeal arch,
arytenoepiglottic fold entrapment, subepiglottic cyst, arytenoid chondritis/chondrosis,
laryngeal hemiplegia, or tracheal stenosis, collapse, or partial obstruction) or maxillary
or frontal sinusitis with discharge into the nasal passages via the nasomaxillary
opening or laryngeal/pharyngeal paresis. The latter may be a symptom of guttural pouch
mycosis, empyema, or systemic disease (e.g., botulism or equine protozoal myelitis).
Cough also may be a symptom of a tracheal foreign body (e.g., a twig or TTA catheter)
in the airway. One should suspect horses with cough but no abnormalities on endoscopic
examination of having low-grade COPD.
Cough after exercise or feeding also should prompt an endoscopic evaluation. Evidence
of hemorrhage in the trachea after exercise indicates that exercise-induced pulmonary
hemorrhage is likely. This diagnosis can be confirmed by finding hemosiderin-laden
macrophages in BAL or TTA fluid. Thoracic radiographs may show interstitial densities
and pleural thickening in the caudodorsal lung field. Postprandial cough may be associated
with soft palate paresis, dorsal displacement of the soft palate, cleft palate (neonates
and foals), or dysphagia of any cause.
A detailed description of diagnostic and therapeutic strategies for diseases of the
respiratory system can be found in Chapter 7.
REFERENCES
1
Fuller
RE
Cough
Crystal
RG
West
JB
The lung: scientific foundation
1991
Raven Press
New York
2
Leith
DE
Cough
Brain
JD
Proctor
DF
Reid
LM
Respiratory defense mechanisms, part II
vol 5
1977
Marcel Dekker
New York
In Lenfant C, editor: Lung biology in health and disease
3
Korpas
J
Tomori
Z
Cough and other respiratory reflexes
Prog Respir Res
12
1979
15
148
4
Robinson NE: Pathophysiology of coughing. Proceedings of the thirty-second convention
of the American Association of Equine Practitioners, Nashville, 1986. pp 291-297.
5
Karlsson
JA
Sant'Ambrogio
G
Widdicombe
J
Afferent neuronal pathways in cough and reflex bronchoconstriction
J Appl Physiol
65
1988
1007
1023
3053580
6
Korpas
J
Widdicombe
JG
Aspects of the cough reflex
Respir Med
85
suppl A
1991
3
5
7
Karlsson
J-A
Hansson
L
Wollmer
P
Regional sensitivity of the respiratory tract to stimuli causing cough and reflex
bronchoconstriction
Respir Med
85
suppl A
1991
47
50
8
Coleridge
HM
Coleridge
JCG
Pulmonary reflexes: neural mechanisms of pulmonary defense
Annu Rev Physiol
56
1994
69
91
8010756
9
Widdicombe
JG
Respiratory reflexes and defense
Brain
JD
Proctor
DF
Reid
LM
Respiratory defense mechanisms, part II
vol 5
1997
Marcel Dekker
New York
In Lenfant C, editor: Lung biology in health and disease
10
Ware
WA
Disorders of the cardiovascular system
Nelson
RW
Couto
CG
Essentials of small animal internal medicine
1992
Mosby-Year Book
St Louis
11
Sherding
R
Personal communication
June 1995
Ohio State University
12
Sweeney
CR
Sweeney
RW
Benson
CE
Comparison of bacteria isolated from specimens obtained by use of endoscopic guarded
tracheal swabbing and percutaneous tracheal aspiration in horses
J Am Vet Med Assoc
195
1989
1225
1229
2584119
13
Moore
BR
Dradowka
S
Robertson
JT
Cytologic evaluation of bronchoalveolar lavage fluid obtained from standardbred racehorses
with inflammatory airway disease
Am J Vet Res
56
1995
562
567
7661448
14
Rossier
Y
Sweeney
CR
Ziemer
EL
Bronchoalveolar lavage fluid cytologic findings in horses with pneumonia or pleuropneumonia
J Am Vet Med Assoc
198
1991
1001
1004
2032901
15
Ogilvie
TH
Rosendal
S
Blackwell
TE
Mycoplasma felis as a cause of pleuritis in horses
J Am Vet Med Assoc
192
1983
1374
1376
16
Beech
J
Parascaris equorum infection and Dictyocaulus arnfeldi infection
Colahan
PT
Mayhew
IG
Merritt
AM
Equine medicine and surgery
1991
American Veterinary Publications
Goleta, Calif
Hines
Melissa T.
3.9—Changes in Body Temperature
Assessment of body temperature is an essential part of every physical examination.
As with all mammalian species, horses normally maintain their core body temperature
within a narrow range despite extremes in environmental conditions. The core temperature
may vary by approximately 1° C (2° F) between individuals. In adult horses, the average
normal body temperature is 38.0° C (100.5° F), whereas in neonatal foals the temperature
tends to be slightly higher, ranging from 37.8° to 38.9° C (100.0° to 102.0° F). A
diurnal variation of up to 1° C (2° F) may occur, with the low point typically in
the morning and the peak in the late afternoon.
Control of Body Temperature
The set-point is the crucial temperature that the body attempts to maintain, primarily
via neuronal control operating through temperature centers in the hypothalamus.1,
2 Peripheral and central thermoreceptors sense changes in ambient and core body temperatures
and activate feedback mechanisms that bring the temperature back to the set-point.
Specifically, the anterior hypothalamic-preoptic area contains large numbers of heat-sensitive
neurons and lower numbers of cold-sensitive neurons that function as temperature detectors.
Peripheral receptors, which are generally most sensitive to low temperatures, are
located in the skin and in some deep tissues, such as the spinal cord, abdominal viscera,
and around certain great veins. The anterior hypothalamic-preoptic area and the peripheral
receptors transmit signals into the posterior hypothalamic area, subsequently activating
autonomic and behavioral effector responses to regulate body temperature.
When the body temperature is too high, heat loss increases and heat production diminishes.
Increasing blood flow to the skin is an effective mechanism for heat transfer from
the body core to the surface. In response to changes in core body temperature and
environmental temperature, the sympathetic nervous system regulates the degree of
vasoconstriction and thus the amount of blood flow. Heat is lost from body surfaces
to the surroundings by several physical mechanisms, including radiation, conduction,
and convection. Evaporation is also an important mechanism of heat loss in horses.
3
The rate of sweating controls to some extent the amount of evaporative heat loss.
However, even when the animal is not sweating, water evaporates insensibly from the
skin and lungs, causing continual heat loss. In horses, evaporative heat loss, primarily
though increased sweating but also through increased respiration, becomes more important
as the ambient temperature rises and during exercise.3, 4 In addition to increased
heat loss when the body temperature rises, the horse also decreases temperature further
by inhibiting means of heat production, such as shivering, and by behavioral responses,
such as seeking shade, wind currents, and wading into water.
Mechanisms that increase body temperature come into play when the body temperature
is too low.
2
Heat is conserved by stimulation of the posterior hypothalamic sympathetic centers
leading to cutaneous vasoconstriction and piloerection. Heat production also increases
and may occur through increased muscle activity ranging from inapparent contractions
to generalized shivering. Shivering may increase heat production by 4 to 5 times baseline.
The primary motor center for shivering is in the posterior hypothalamus, which normally
is stimulated by cold signals from the peripheral receptors and to some extent the
anterior hypothalamic-preoptic area. Signals from heat sensitive neurons in the anterior-hypothalamic-preoptic
area inhibit the center. Digestion of food also contributes to total body heat. Sympathetic
stimulation may increase the rate of cellular metabolism, increasing heat production
by chemical thermogenesis. Cooling also increases the production of thyrotropin-releasing
hormone, ultimately increasing thyroid hormones and cellular metabolism, and further
contributing to chemical thermogenesis. In addition to these physiologic adaptations,
behavioral responses to conserve heat also occur, such as adopting a huddled stance,
aggregating in groups, and seeking shelter.
Conditions of Increased Body Temperature
Elevation of the body temperature above normal is one of the most common clinical
problems encountered, and although classically associated with infection, a variety
of disorders may cause increased body temperature. One should distinguish between
conditions of hyperthermia, in which the temperature set-point is unaltered, and true
fever, in which the set-point actually increases.
HYPERTHERMIA
The body temperature may become elevated without an increase in the set-point when
a loss of equilibrium occurs in the heat balance equation. Increased heat production
or absorption of heat beyond the ability of the body to dissipate heat may occur.
In some conditions, impaired heat loss also may occur. Hyperthermic conditions include
problems such as exercise-related hyperthermia, heat stroke, malignant hyperthermia,
anhidrosis, central nervous system disorders, and reactions to certain toxins or drugs.
In general, these conditions do not respond to treatment with antipyretic drugs.
EXERCISE-RELATED HYPERTHERMIA
During sustained or high-intensity exercise, increased heat production is associated
with muscular activity.3, 4 The heat produced may exceed the ability of the body to
lose heat, resulting in an increased core body temperature. Typically, the temperature
returns to normal with rest as heat loss mechanisms remain activated. Elevated temperature
also may occur with the intense muscle activity associated with generalized seizures.
HEAT STROKE
Heat stroke occurs when the body temperature rises above a critical temperature, leading
to multisystemic problems. In horses, signs of heat stroke may develop when the body
temperature is above 41.5° C (107° F), which most often occurs in association with
exercise in environmentally stressful conditions. Although horses can acclimatize
to various weather conditions to some extent, the efficiency of evaporative heat loss
may be compromised significantly in hot, humid weather.4, 5 Susceptibility to heat
stroke may increase if sweating leads to dehydration and electrolyte imbalances. Once
the body temperature reaches the critical point, the homeostatic mechanisms of thermoregulation
fail, resulting in peripheral vasoconstriction, decreased cardiac output, and decreased
blood pressure. Affected horses are lethargic, with weak flaccid muscles. Prostration,
circulatory shock, disseminated intravascular coagulation, multiple organ failure,
and death may occur.
ANDHIDROSIS
Especially in hot, humid climates, horses may develop anhidrosis, which is characterized
by a partial or total loss of the ability to sweat.
6
Because of the resulting impaired heat loss, hyperthermia may develop. Clinical signs
of poor performance, increased respiratory rate, and poor hair coat also are observable.
MALIGNANT HYPERTHERMIA
Malignant hyperthermia encompasses a group of inherited skeletal muscle disorders
in which calcium metabolism is altered.
7
Although the condition is most common in human beings and pigs, it has been reported
in several species, including horses.8, 9 The disorder is characterized by a hypermetabolic
state of muscle that generally is induced by halogenated inhalation anesthetics, depolarizing
skeletal muscle relaxants, and occasionally local anesthetics or stress. Clinical
signs include a rapid increase in core body temperature, skeletal muscle rigidity,
and tachycardia. Affected animals may develop significant acidosis and muscle necrosis
and in some cases may die. In pigs, malignant hyperthermia has been linked to a single
point mutation in the gene for the skeletal muscle ryanodine receptor, but a genetic
basis has not yet been established in horses.
7
CENTRAL NERVOUS SYSTEM DISORDERS
Any condition affecting those areas of the hypothalamus involved in thermoregulation
may alter the body temperature, with hyperthermia being more common than hypothermia.1,
2 Thus central hyperthermia occurs in association with a variety of conditions, including
hemorrhage, neoplasms or abscesses, infectious/inflammatory changes, and degenerative
disorders. Central hyperthermia usually is characterized by a lack of any diurnal
variation, absence of sweating, resistance to antipyretic drugs, and excessive response
to external cooling.
CERTAIN TOXINS OR DRUGS
Occasionally, hyperthermia has been associated with toxins or drugs. Exposure to compounds
that act to uncouple oxidative phosphorylation, such as the wood preservative pentachlorophenol,
potentially could cause a significant rise in body temperature.
10
Foals treated with the antibiotic erythromycin are at risk of developing hyperthermia.
11
Such predisposition has been attributed to a reaction to the erythromycin itself or
to an alteration of the thermoregulatoy system of the foal by mechanisms not yet described.
Environmental conditions may exacerbate the development of hyperthermia, with foals
exposed to high ambient temperatures and direct sunlight being at greatest risk.
Pathogenesis of True Fever
In true fever the set-point for the desired core body temperature increases and then
is maintained by the same mechanisms that maintain the normal body temperature. Although
primarily associated with infectious diseases, fever is also a prominent component
of many inflammatory, immunologic, and neoplastic conditions. Although the pathogenesis
of the febrile response is complex, essentially all of these conditions initiate fever
by stimulating the release of endogenous pyrogens (Figure 3.9-1
).
Figure 3.9-1
Schematic representation of the pathogenesis of fever. cAMP, Cyclic adenosine monophosphate;
IFN, interferon; IL, interleukin; TNF, tumor necrosis factor.
Endogenous pyrogens are substances with the biologic property of fever induction.12,
13 Initially endogenous pyrogen was assumed to be a single molecule produced by leukocytes,
thus the name leukocytic or granulocytic pyrogen. Now, multiple cytokines are known
to act as pyrogens, and a variety of cell types produce them, with monocytes and macrophages
predominating. Currently, the following cytokines are thought to be intrinsically
pyrogenic in that they produce a rapid-onset fever via direct action on the hypothalamus
without requiring formation of another cytokine: interleukin-1α (IL-1α) and IL-1β,
tumor necrosis factors (TNF) α and β, interferon-α, and IL-6. IL-1α and IL-1β and
TNF-α appear to be among the most potent pyrogens. Many endogenous pyrogens use the
cell-signaling apparatus gp130. Cytokines that act through this receptor include IL-6,
IL-11, oncostatin M, ciliary neurotrophic factor, cardiotropin-1, and leukemic inhibitory
factor. From a clinical standpoint, several pyrogenic cytokines are produced during
most febrile diseases and contribute to the febrile response.
The precise mechanism of action of pyrogenic cytokines in the central nervous system
is still unclear. Endogenous pyrogens probably act on the circumventricular organs
or organum vasculosum laminae terminalis (OVLT), a rich vascular network associated
with neurons of the preoptic anterior hypothalamus.13, 14, 15 Ablation of the OVLT
prevents fever after a peripheral injection of endogenous pyrogens but has no effect
when endogenous pyrogens are injected directly into the brain tissue.
14
In the region of the OVLT the blood-brain barrier is minimal, and endothelial cells
lining this region may allow direct movement of endogenous pyrogens into the brain
or they may release arachidonic acid metabolites in response to endogenous pyrogens,
which then move into the brain. The production of arachidonic acid metabolites, particularly
prostaglandin E2 via the cyclooxygenase 2 (COX-2) pathway is clearly important in
the pathogenesis of fever, because COX inhibitors, and specifically COX-2 inhibitors,
effectively reduce the febrile response but have no effect on the normal body temperature.
The prostaglandins do not act directly but initiate neuronal signaling by producing
a cascade of changes in cyclic nucleotides, calcium, and monoamines leading to a higher
set-point in the hypothalamic thermoregulatory center.
Physiologic mechanisms exist to control the febrile response and prevent extremes
that are incompatible with life. Multiple feedback mechanisms limit the activity of
the pyrogenic cytokines and many endogenous cryogens or antipyretics have been identified.16,
17 For example, IL-10, which can be induced by pyrogenic cytokines, inhibits further
production of IL-1 and TNF. Arginine vasopressin and α-melanocyte-stimulating hormone
act within the brain to decrease fever.16, 17, 18, 19 When administered to human beings,
α-melanocyte-stimulating hormone is a much more potent antipyretic than acetaminophen.
Nitric oxide also has been shown to have an antipyretic role, mediated by cyclic guanosine
monophosphate, in the anterior hypothalamic-preoptic region.
20
The cytokines that act as endogenous pyrogens have a variety of biologic effects.
Therefore the onset of fever is accompanied by several hematologic, immunologic, and
metabolic changes referred to as the acute phase response. In particular, IL-6 and
IL-11 induce the synthesis of acute phase proteins by hepatocytes, including fibrinogen,
C-reactive protein, haptoglobin, and others. Similarly, hypoferremia, hypozincemia,
and hypercupremia are cytokine mediated, as is the activation of lymphocytes, which
in turn produce additional cytokines.
Pyrogenic cytokines, particularly IL-1 and TNF-α cause membrane perturbation with
an increase in phospholipases and the production of arachidonic acid.12, 13 The subsequent
production of mediators depends on the metabolic pathways for arachidonic acid in
the target tissue. Prostaglandins induced by endogenous pyrogens stimulate the muscle
catabolism associated with fever and induce collagenase synthesis from synovial cells,
contributing to the muscle and joint pain often seen with fever. Local tissue responses
to IL-1β and TNF-α may stimulate afferent neural impulses that lead to behavioral
responses associated with fever, such as lethargy and anorexia. As expected, treatment
with COX inhibitors can diminish many of the signs of fever.
Effects of Fever
Fever is a normal physiologic response with beneficial and adverse effects to the
animal. With the exception of some viral infections, the elevation in temperature
is generally not high enough to affect pathogens directly. However, studies on bacterial
infections in several species have demonstrated an increase in survival with fever,
which is thought to be caused primarily by enhanced host defenses.21, 22, 23 In addition,
the concentration of iron, which is required by many bacteria for multiplication,
decreases during the acute phase response.24, 25, 26 If the temperature becomes extremely
high, many of the beneficial effects are reversed.2, 27, 28 In rabbits the severity
of bacterial infection increases when the body temperature in more than 3° C (5° F)
above normal. The increased catabolism, variable anorexia, and increased metabolic
rate can lead to muscle wasting and weakness when fever is prolonged. Although seizures
induced by fever are uncommon in horses, they can be seen in neonates when the temperature
is above 42° C (108° F).
29
In debilitated animals, prolonged fever has been associated with cardiovascular failure.
Approach to Fever
Increased body temperature is a common clinical sign with diverse causes (Figure 3.9-2
). Fortunately, in many cases the cause may be readily apparent based on the signalment,
history, and physical examination. Conditions of increased temperature such as exercise-related
hyperthermia and malignant hyperthermia are often apparent from the history. Infectious
diseases remain the most common cause of fever, and often localizing clinical signs
such as nasal discharge or diarrhea aid in the diagnosis. In other cases, an increased
temperature may be one component of another obvious condition, such as neoplasm, immune-mediated
disease, or a drug reaction.
Figure 3.9-2
Approach to changes in body temperature.
Fever of Unknown Origin
Fever of unknown origin exists when fever is prolonged with no other specific signs.
In many cases, the cause is a common disease with an unusual presentation. The specific
criteria used to define fever of unknown origin in the horse in a review of 63 cases
included the following: (1) illness of at least 3 weeks' duration associated with
nonspecific signs, (2) body temperature of at least 38.6° C (101.5° F) on several
occasions, and (3) no clear diagnosis after an initial complete blood count and serum
biochemical profile.
30
The most common cause was found to be infection, which was responsible for 43% of
the cases. Other causes included neoplasms in 22% of cases, immune-mediated diseases
in 6.5%, and miscellaneous diseases including toxic hepatopathy, parasitism, and others
in 19%. In 9.5% of cases, no diagnosis was made. Therefore diagnosis of fever of unknown
origin requires a systematic approach with emphasis on the evaluation of infectious
disease.
The clinician can have the body temperature taken twice daily over a period of time
to document fever and identify any pattern. Although some inconsistencies in the precise
terminology used to define patterns of fever exist, intermittent fevers generally
are characterized by recurring paroxysms of elevated temperature followed by periods
of normal temperature, such as those fevers that demonstrate diurnal variation. Intermittent
fevers most often are associated with infectious causes, particularly viral infections,
although they may be seen with a variety of other conditions. In most cases of intermittent
fever the temperature tends to peak in the late afternoon or evening, though this
is not always the case. Remittent fevers are those in which diurnal variation is exaggerated
without a return to normal body temperature or those with a cyclic pattern in which
the temperature elevation lasts for several days, such as may be seen with equine
infectious anemia virus. Biphasic fevers, in which an initial rise in body temperature
precedes a period of normal temperature and then a second rise, are characteristic
of certain diseases such as equine monocytic ehrlichiosis (Potomac horse fever). Sustained
fevers are those in which the elevation of temperature is consistent.
A complete history is important when one is investigating fever of unknown origin.
Any exposure to Streptococcus equi ssp. equi (strangles) may be significant because
of the association of this organism with internal abscessation. Travel history may
be relevant, especially regarding diseases with a geographic influence such as babesiosis
and coccidioidomycosis.
The clinician always should perform a careful physical examination, including rectal
palpation. Repeating the physical examination may yield new information. The clinician
also should perform a complete neurologic examination, because disorders of the central
nervous system may cause aberrations in temperature through pyrogenic cytokines or
in some cases through direct effects on thermoregulatory centers.
Ancillary diagnostic tests usually are required to diagnose fever of unknown origin.
A minimum database, including complete blood count, fibrinogen, biochemical profile
with bile acids, and urinalysis should be performed. Hemoparasites occasionally may
be seen on the blood smear, but the apparent absence of organisms does not rule out
a parasitemia that is below readily detectable limits. Abnormalities consistent with
chronic infection or inflammation, including anemia, hyperfibrinogenemia, and hyperglobulinemia
are common but nonspecific findings. If an elevation of serum protein occurs, further
assessment by serum protein electrophoresis and specific immunoglobulin quantitation
may be indicated. A monoclonal gammopathy is characteristic of plasma cell myeloma
and other tumors of the reticuloendothelial system, both of which may initiate fever
directly and increase susceptibility to bacterial infection. In general, immunodeficiencies
may be associated with chronic infections. If the serum protein is low, one should
investigate the causes of hypoproteinemia, including decreased production because
of significant hepatic disease, increased gastrointestinal or renal loss, or loss
into a third space. The presence of hypercalcemia can be helpful in establishing a
diagnosis, because in horses, hypercalcemia most often is linked with renal disease
or neoplasms.
Infections of the respiratory tract and abdomen frequently are associated with fever
of unknown origin in the horse, and therefore one should evalute these systems thoroughly.
Careful auscultation of the thorax using a rebreathing bag should be performed at
rest and, if possible, after exercise. Endoscopy, including examination of the guttural
pouches can be useful. Diagnostic imaging of the thorax, including radiographs and
ultrasound, often is indicated. The clinician also should include thoracocentesis
in evaluation of the thorax, for abnormalities occasionally are apparent even without
increases in the volume of pleural fluid. Pleuroscopy, which allows direct visual
examination of the pleural space and which may facilitate biopsy of any masses, can
be helpful in establishing a diagnosis, especially when neoplasia is suspected.
Peritonitis and abdominal abscessation are common causes of fever of unknown origin,
and one should include abdominocentesis in the diagnostic plan. The peritoneal fluid
should be evaluated for protein, cellularity, and cell morphology, and culture should
be performed. One should remember that although many neoplastic conditions involve
the abdomen, neoplastic cells are not always observed in the peritoneal fluid. In
cases of gastric squamous cell carcinoma, gastroscopy is helpful in establishing the
diagnosis. Radiographs of the abdomen may be useful, especially in neonates, and ultrasound
of the abdomen may help to identify fluid for collection or abnormalities that indicate
further evaluation, such as abdominal masses or pathologic liver conditions.
Gastrointestinal parasitism is a common clinical problem in the horse, although it
is associated only occasionally with fever. However, one should examine feces for
parasite ova in horses with fever of unknown origin. In cases of suspected gastrointestinal
protein loss, diarrhea, or melena, one should consider diagnostic procedures such
as fecal culture, polymerase chain reaction for Salmonella, rectal mucosal biopsy,
or absorption tests.
Bacterial endocarditis can cause a fever of unknown origin, although the condition
is not as common in horses as in some other species. In the study by Mair, Taylor,
and Pinsent, the authors identified endocarditis in 3 of 63 cases of fever of unknown
origin.
30
In each case a murmur they did not identify initially became apparent several weeks
after the onset of illness. Therefore a thorough cardiac evaluation, including echocardiography,
is indicated.
Blood cultures are generally most useful in neonates but can yield valuable information
in adult horses with fever as well. Ideally, one should collect three to five samples
at least 45 minutes apart when the horse is not in a regimen of antibiotic therapy.
Sampling just before and during a temperature rise is most likely to yield a positive
culture.
The clinician should consider equine infectious anemia as a differential diagnosis
for horses with fever of unknown origin and should perform a serologic examination.
Recently, a serologic test for detection of antibodies to the M protein of Streptococcus
equi ssp equi was developed as an aid in the diagnosis of internal abscessation.
31
Serologic tests for equine babesiosis, brucellosis, and coccidioidomycosis are also
available.
Immune-mediated disorders such as autoimmune hemolytic anemia, immune-mediated thrombocytopenia,
systemic lupus erythematosis, vasculitides, and rheumatoid arthritis have been implicated
as causes of fever of unknown origin, but more commonly in human beings and small
animals than in horses. However, appropriate diagnostic tests, such as the Coombs'
test, skin biopsy, and antinuclear antibody testing may be useful in some cases.
Exploratory laparoscopy or laparotomy is indicated when abdominal involvement is evident
or the animal is becoming progressively debilitated. Occasionally, bone marrow aspiration
may be useful, particularly in those cases with persistent abnormalities in circulating
cell populations. In cases in which a specific diagnosis has not been made, therapeutic
trials with antimicrobials may help, and in cases of suspected immune-mediated disease,
corticosteroids may help.
Hypothermia
Hypothermia occurs when the core body temperature drops below accepted normal values.
In clinical cases, hypothermia can be characterized as accidental or pathologic (see
Figure 3.9-2). In accidental hypothermia a spontaneous decrease in the core body temperature
occurs independent of actual disruption to the thermoregulatory system. These cases
often can be identified from the history. Mild accidental hypothermia sometimes occurs
with surgical procedures. Most often, accidental hypothermia is associated with exposure
to cold or cold, damp environments, which can lead to severe hypothermia and death.
Neonates are particularly susceptible to hypothermia, although central thermoregulation
through the hypothalamus is normal.32, 33 Sick foals often decrease their activity
and nutritional intake and have alterations in circulation. They also have a large
ratio of surface area to body weight, enhancing heat loss. Geriatric and otherwise
debilitated animals are also at increased risk of hypothermia.
One should consider pathologic causes of hypothermia when no clear reason for accidental
hypothermia is evident. Pathologic hypothermia occurs in association with disorders
that decrease metabolic activity or directly affect the thermoregulatory center and
occurs with endocrine disorders, sepsis, and intracranial disease. In horses, hypothyroidism
is probably an uncommon clinical problem; however, impaired thermoregulation has been
seen in foals with congenital hypothyroidism.
34
Lesions of the thyroid gland also have been associated with hypothermia in donkeys.
35
Hypothermia has been observed with septicemia and shock, especially in neonates, in
which 24% of septic foals were found to have a decreased body temperature.
36
The ability to generate heat through shivering is impaired or lost when the body temperature
becomes too low. The animal experiences a decrease in the metabolic rate of most tissues.
Heart rate, cardiac output, glomerular filtration, and blood pressure may decrease.
REFERENCES
1
Dinarello
CA
Thermoregulation and the pathogenesis of fever
Infect Dis Clin North Am
10
1996
433
450
8803628
2
Guyton
AC
Hall
JE
Body temperature, temperature regulation, and fever
Textbook of medical physiology
ed 10
2000
WB Saunders
Philadelphia
3
Guthrie
AJ
Lund
RJ
Thermoregulation: base mechanisms and hyperthermia
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
14
1998
45
59
9561687
4
Marlin
DJ
Schroter
RC
White
SL
Recovery from transport and acclimatisation of competition horses in a hot humid environment
Equine Vet J
33
2001
371
379
11469770
5
Geor
RJ
McCutcheon
LJ
Ecker
GL
Heat storage in horses during submaximal exercise before and after humid heat acclimation
J Appl Physiol
89
2000
2283
2293
11090580
6
Mayhew
IG
Ferguson
HO
Clinical, clinicopathological, and epidemiological features of anhidrosis in central
Florida thoroughbred horses
J Vet Intern Med
1
1987
136
141
3506097
7
Fujii
J
Otsu
K
Zorzato
F
Identification of a mutation in porcine ryanodine receptor associated with malignant
hyperthermia
Science
253
1991
448
451
1862346
8
Manley
SV
Kelly
AB
Hodgson
D
Malignant hyperthermia-like reactions in three anesthetized horses
J Am Vet Med Assoc
183
1983
85
89
6874529
9
Smyth
GB
Spinal cord decompression and stabilization of a comminuted axis fracture complicated
by intraoperative malignant hyperthermia like reaction in a filly
Aust Equine Vet
10
1992
133
136
10
Exon
JH
A review of chlorinated phenols
Vet Hum Toxicol
26
1984
508
520
6393562
11
Stratton-Phelps
M
Wilson
WD
Gardner
IA
Risk of adverse effects in pneumonic foals treated with erythromycin versus other
antibiotics: 143 cases (1986-1996)
J Am Vet Med Assoc
217
2000
68
73
10909450
12
Dinarello
CA
Cytokines as endogenous pyrogens
J Infect Dis
179
suppl 2
1999
S294
S304
10081499
13
Luheshi
GN
Cytokines and fever: mechanisms and sites of action
Ann N Y Acad Sci
856
1998
83
89
9917868
14
Blatteis
CM
Bealer
SL
Hunter
WS
Suppression of fever after lesions of the anteroventral third ventricle in guinea
pigs
Brain Res Bull
11
1983
519
526
6365250
15
Still
JT
Evidence for the involvement of the organum vasculosum laminae terminalis in the febrile
response of rabbits and rats
J Physiol
368
1985
501
511
4078749
16
Kozak
W
Kluger
MJ
Tesfaigzi
J
Molecular mechanisms of fever and endogenous antipyresis
Ann N Y Acad Sci
917
2000
121
134
11268336
17
Tatro
JB
Endogenous antipyretics
Clin Infect Dis
5
suppl
2000
S190
S201
18
Catania
A
Lipton
JM
Peptide modulation of fever and inflammation within the brain
Ann N Y Acad Sci
856
1998
62
68
9917865
19
Lipton
JM
Catania
A
Anti-inflammatory actions of the neuroimmunomodulator alpha-MSH
Immunol Today
18
1997
140
145
9078687
20
Steiner
AA
Antunes-Rodrigues
J
McCann
SM
Antipyretic role of the NP-cGMP pathway in the anteroventral preoptic region of the
rat brain
Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol
282
2002
R584
R593
11792670
21
Weinstein
MP
Iannini
PB
Stratton
CW
Spontaneous bacterial peritonitis: a review of 28 cases with emphasis on improved
survival and factors influencing prognosis
Am J Med
64
1978
592
598
645725
22
Banet
M
Fever and survival in the rat: the effect of enhancing fever
Pflugers Arch
381
1979
35
38
384358
23
Jiang
Q
Cross
AS
Singh
IS
Febrile core temperature is essential for optimal host defense in bacterial peritonitis
Infect Immun
68
2000
1265
1270
10678936
24
Grieger
TA
Kluger
MJ
Fever and survival: the role of serum iron
J Physiol
279
1978
187
196
678329
25
Kluger
MJ
Rothenburg
BA
Fever and reduced iron: their interaction as a host defense response to bacterial
infection
Science
203
1979
374
376
760197
26
Ballantyne
GH
Rapid drop in serum iron concentrations as a host defense mechanism: a review of experimental
and clinical evidence
Am Surg
50
1984
405
411
6465688
27
Mackowiak
PA
Plaisacne
KI
Benefits and risks of antipyretic therapy
Ann N Y Acad Sci
856
1998
214
223
9917880
28
Plaisacne
KI
Mackowiak
PA
Antipyretic therapy: physiologic rationale, diagnostic implications and clinical consequences
Arch Intern Med
160
2000
449
456
10695685
29
Green
SL
Mayhew
IG
Neurologic disorders
Koterba
AM
Drummond
WH
Kosch
PC
Equine clinical neonatology
1990
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
30
Mair
TS
Taylor
FG
Pinsent
PJ
Fever of unknown origin in the horse: a review of 63 cases
Equine Vet J
21
1989
260
265
2767027
31
Sheoran
AS
Sponseller
BT
Holmes
N
Serum and mucosal antibody isotype responses to M-like protein (SeM) of Streptococcus
equi in convalescent and vaccinated horses
Vet Immunol Immunopathol
59
1997
239
252
9477475
32
Webb
AI
Normalization of body temperature
Koterba
AM
Drummond
WH
Kosch
PC
Equine clinical neonatology
1990
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
33
Brock
KA
Thermoregulation
Koterba
AM
Drummond
WH
Kosch
PC
Equine clinical neonatology
1990
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
34
Irvine
CH
Hypothyroidism in the foal
Equine Vet J
16
1984
302
306
6383812
35
Stephen
JO
Baptiste
KE
Townsend
HG
Clinical and pathologic findings in donkeys with hypothermia: 10 cases (1988-1998)
J Am Vet Med Assoc
216
2000
725
729
10707690
36
Brewer
BD
Neonatal infection
Koterba
AM
Drummond
WH
Kosch
PC
Equine clinical neonatology
1990
Lea & Febiger
Philadelphia
Hines
Melissa T.
3.10—Diarrhea
Diarrhea, defined as an increase in the frequency, fluidity, or volume of bowel movements,
is a commonly encountered clinical problem in the horse. Diarrhea may occur as a primary
disease of the gastrointestinal tract or as a secondary response to another disease
process, such as sepsis, endotoxemia, or hepatic disease.
The function of the equine gastrointestinal tract is complex and involves maintenance
of normal fluid balance and digestion and absorption.1, 2, 3 As a result of dietary
intake and endogenous secretions, normally a large volume of fluid enters the gastrointestinal
tract, most of which is reabsorbed. In the adult horse absorption occurs predominantly
in the large bowel, where a volume of water approximately equal to the total extracellular
fluid volume of the animal, or about 100 L, is recovered during the course of the
day. Because the large colon is the primary site of water resorption, most significant
diarrheal disease in the adult horse involves the colon. In young foals, however,
small intestinal disorders such as rotaviral infection also may result in diarrhea.
4
A second critical function of the large bowel is that of microbial digestion of carbohydrates
and, to some extent, protein or nonprotein nitrogen.1, 2, 3 Microbial fermentation
of carbohydrates in the cecum and colon results primarily in the production of volatile
fatty acids, which are absorbed readily, providing up to 75% of the energy requirement
of the horse. Therefore maintaining a stable environment for the microbial population
is important. In general, efficient function of the large bowel requires mechanisms
that limit the rate of digesta passage, provide optimal conditions for microbial digestion,
and allow for efficient transport of solutes and water.
The characteristics of normal equine feces vary somewhat with diet. Generally, equine
feces are tan, brown, or greenish, and although approximately 75% water, they are
well formed. An adult horse on a diet of grass hay and approximately 3 lb of oats
per day produces about 20 to 28 g of feces per kilogram of body mass per day or about
11 to 13 kg of feces per day.
5
In cases of diarrhea, the amount of feces may increase up to tenfold, with horses
producing more than 200 g/kg/day, or more than 90 L of diarrhea. As a result, diarrhea
can cause significant losses of electrolytes and water and significant systemic acid-base
imbalances. However, despite large water losses, horses with chronic diarrhea seldom
develop severe dehydration or electrolyte abnormalities because they compensate for
increased fecal losses.
Mechanisms of Diarrhea
Inflammation within the bowel plays a central role in the pathogenesis of diarrhea.
Several basic mechanisms of diarrhea have been described, and in most diarrheal diseases,
more than one mechanism is involved. These mechanisms include the following:
1.
Malabsorption: Malabsorption results from a decrease in the functional absorptive
surface area of the gastrointestinal tract. Villus atrophy in the small intestine,
seen with rotaviral enteritis and infiltrative bowel disease, can result in malabsorption
because of the loss of functional epithelium and maldigestion caused by decreased
production of digestive enzymes. A number of insults to the colon result in inflammation
and disruption of absorptive cells and tight junctions, leading to decreased absorptive
capacity and decreased ability to retain absorbed fluid, that is, increased loss.
Several inflammatory mediators, such as histamines and prostaglandins, contribute
to the colonic inflammation. These mediators are produced primarily by inflammatory
cells in the lamina propria and inhibit absorption through a variety of mechanisms.6,
7, 8, 9, 10
2.
Increased secretion: The increased secretion of solutes and water by the inflamed
colon can contribute significantly to the development of diarrhea. Although the precise
mechanisms of secretion in the equine colon are not understood fully, active secretion
and passive fluid loss occur.6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 Control of active secretion is
complex, involving two primary pathways: first, the activation of adenyl cyclase,
resulting in an increase of intracellular cyclic adenosine monophosphate concentrations,
and second, the activation of calcium channels, leading to increased intracellular
calcium concentrations.11, 12 Cyclic adenosine monophosphate and calcium stimulate
specific secretory activities, primarily through chloride channels. In some cases
of diarrhea, bacterial enterotoxins such as those produced by certain strains of Escherichia
coli and Salmonella stimulate adenyl cyclase activity, thus increasing active secretion.
This is true hypersecretory diarrhea. Also, a number of inflammatory mediators produced
by the inflamed colon, particularly prostaglandin E, increase intracellular concentrations
of cyclic adenosine monophosphate and to some extent calcium, thereby increasing active
secretion by mucosal cells.11, 12, 13 Inflammation also enhances passive fluid loss
through a number of factors, such as changes in hydrostatic pressure in the colonic
capillaries, mucosal damage, and loss of tight junctions. In cases of severe mucosal
injury, the loss of protein can decrease vascular oncotic pressure and further potentiate
fluid exchange across the endothelium.
3.
Decreased transit time (abnormal motility): Progressive motility must be present for
diarrhea to occur. Primary motility disorders causing diarrhea are not well recognized,
although diarrhea associated with stress or excitement may represent this phenomenon.
Inflammation is known to influence gastrointestinal motility, in addition to altering
absorption and secretion. However, the precise significance of the altered motility
in the pathogenesis of diarrhea is not clear. Sufficient retention time and thorough
mixing are required for digestion and absorption of nutrients and fluid to occur,
and decreased intestinal transit time has been recognized in association with many
gastrointestinal diseases, including infectious diarrhea. Absorption of endotoxin
and the release of inflammatory mediators, including prostaglandins, disrupts normal
motility patterns.
14
In some cases of acute colitis, a period of ileus may occur without diarrhea. With
diarrheal diseases, the elimination of gut contents is part of the normal host defense
mechanism, and thus decreasing motility is not indicated in most cases.
4.
Osmotic overload: Any increase in osmotically active particles within the intestinal
lumen can result in diarrhea. The increase can be associated with the administration
or ingestion of osmotically active substances such as magnesium sulfate. The increase
also may be associated with overloading of the intestine with carbohydrates or occasionally
lipids beyond the amount that can be digested and absorbed. Therefore sudden dietary
changes that result in significant shifts in gut flora and changes in fermentation
or gastrointestinal diseases that result in malabsorption or maldigestion also may
result in an osmotic diarrhea. In foals the loss of villus epithelial cells in the
small intestine associated with disorders such as rotavirus infection and clostridiosis
may lead not only to malabsorption but also to maldigestion caused by the decreased
production of lactase.4, 15 The resulting lactose intolerance allows excess lactose
to enter the large intestine, increasing the osmotic load.
5.
Increased hydraulic pressure from the blood to the lumen: This mechanism of diarrhea
is more common in chronic conditions, such as congestive heart failure or inflammatory
bowel disease. The condition may result from decreased oncotic pressure associated
with hypoproteinemia, increased capillary hydrostatic pressure (as in heart failure),
or decreased lymphatic drainage associated with inflammation of lymphatics and lymph
nodes.
Understanding the mechanisms of diarrhea can be helpful in directing therapy. However,
one must remember that most disorders that cause diarrhea, whether infectious or noninfectious,
do so through inflammatory mechanisms resulting in multiple functional alterations.
Diagnostic Approach to the Patient With Diarrhea
Diarrhea is a common, and sometimes fatal, clinical problem of adult horses and foals.
A number of specific causes for acute and chronic diarrhea have been identified (TABLE
3.10-1, TABLE 3.10-2, TABLE 3.10-3
). A comprehensive evaluation may help in establishing a diagnosis and developing
a treatment plan (Box 3.10-1
). However, even in severe cases a definitive diagnosis often is not made, making
the problem particularly frustrating.16, 17
TABLE 3.10-1
Differential Diagnoses for Acute Diarrhea in Adult Horses
CAUSES
MAJOR DIAGNOSTIC TEST(S)
COMMON
Salmonellosis
Fecal culture or polymerase chain reaction (PCR), culture of rectal mucosal biopsy
Potomac horse fever (equine monocytic ehrlichiosis)
PCR (feces, peripheral blood), paired serologic tests
Clostridiosis (Clostridium difficile, C.perfringens)
Fecal culture, toxin analysis
Antibiotic-associated diarrhea
History
Nonsteroidal antiinflammatory toxicity (primarily right dorsal colitis)
History and supportive clinicopathologic findings, ultrasonography, exploratory surgery
with biopsy
Undiagnosed
Other conditions ruled out
LESS COMMON
Cantharidin toxicity
Parasitism (strongylosis, cyathostomiasis, other)
Aeromonas, Campylobacter
Sand
Carbohydrate overload
Arsenic toxicity, other toxicities
Thromboembolic disease
Anaphylaxis
TABLE 3.10-2
Differential Diagnoses for Chronic Diarrhea in Adult Horses
CAUSE OF DIARRHEA
MAJOR DIAGNOSTIC TEST(S)
Chronic salmonellosis
Fecal culture or polymerase chain reaction, culture of rectal mucosal biopsy
Sand
Fecal sedimentation
Parasitism (strongylosis, cyathostomiasis)
Fecal egg count, empirical deworming
Nonsteroidal antiinflammatory toxicity (primarily right dorsal colitis)
History and supportive clinicopathologic findings, ultrasonography, exploratory surgery
with biopsy
Inflammatory or infiltrative disorders
Histopathologic exam, absorption tests (supportive but nonspecific)
Inflammatory bowel disease (granulomatous, lymphocytic-plasmacytic, or eosinophilic
enterocolitis)
Mucosal lymphosarcoma
Amyloidosis
Dietary: abnormal fermentation
History
Neoplasms: lymphosarcoma, squamous cell carcinoma
Histopathologic exam
Peritonitis, abdominal abscessation
Peritoneal fluid analysis, ultrasound, exploratory surgery
Nongastrointestinal causes (chronic liver disease, congestive heart failure, renal
disease)
Physical exam, clinicopathologic findings
TABLE 3.10-3
Differential Diagnoses for Diarrhea in Foals
CAUSE OF DIARRHEA
MAJOR DIAGNOSTIC TEST(S)
Salmonellosis
Fecal culture or polymerase chain reaction (PCR)
Clostridiosis (Clostridium difficile, C.perfringens)
Fecal culture, toxin analysis
Endotoxemia, gram-negative septicemia
Blood culture, physical exam, complete blood count, sepsis score
Antibiotic-associated diarrhea
History
Foal heat diarrhea
History, physical exam
Viral: rotavirus; rarely coronavirus or adenovirus
Electron microscopy, enzyme immunoassay
Protozoan: cryptosporidiosis
Fecal analysis
Secondary lactose intolerance
Oral lactose tolerance test, response to therapy
Rhodococcus equi
Culture, PCR
Lawsonia intracellulare
Fecal PCR, serologic testing
Gastric ulcer disease syndrome
Gastric endoscopy
Strongyloides westeri
Fecal egg count
Sand
Fecal sedimentation
BOX 3.10-1
OUTLINE OF DIAGNOSTIC APPROACH TO DIARRHEA
I.
Signalment, history, and physical examination
II.
Clinical pathology
1.
Minimum database: complete blood count, fibrinogen, and serum chemistry profile
a.
Assess hydration, acid-base status, electrolyte abnormalities, and protein status.
b.
Assess renal and hepatic function.
c.
Assess endotoxemia.
2.
Serum protein electrophoresis and immunoglobulin quantitation
3.
Serologic testing: Ehrlichia risticii and Lawsonia intracellulare
4.
Peritoneal fluid analysis
III.
Evaluation of feces
1.
Gross appearance: severity, hemorrhage, odor, and presence of sand
2.
Direct smear: evaluation of protozoan populations and presence of leukocytes and epithelial
cells
3.
Parasite evaluation: including evaluation for Cryptosporidium parvum, especially in
foals
4.
Evaluation of bacterial pathogens
a.
Gram stain and spore stain
b.
Aerobic and anaerobic culture (culture of multiple samples or rectal mucosal biopsy
for Salmonella)
c.
Clostridial toxin analysis
d.
Polymerase chain reaction: Salmonella, E. risticii, and L. intracellulare
5.
Foals: evaluation of viral pathogens, primarily rotavirus (electron microscopy and
enzyme immunoassay)
IV.
Diagnostic imaging: radiography and ultrasonography
V.
Endoscopic examination: stomach, rectum, and descending colon
VI.
Absorption tests (glucose or xylose absorption): primarily for chronic protein-losing
enteropathy
VII.
Histopathologic examination
VIII.
Toxin evaluation: cantharidin in urine or gastrointestinal contents, arsenic in liver,
or other
IX.
Response to therapy
HISTORY AND PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
One should consider the signalment and history carefully when evaluating a patient
with diarrhea. Age is particularly important because several disorders, such as foal
heat diarrhea and rotavirus, are age related. The genetic background also may be significant,
because diarrhea has been associated with certain heritable immunodeficiencies, and
granulomatous bowel disease has been identified in three sibling horses.18, 19, 20
Establishing whether the diarrhea is acute or chronic is important. Other historical
questions of particular relevance include dietary changes, deworming program, involvement
of single versus multiple animals, exposure to sand, and the use of medications, especially
antibiotics and nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs.21, 22, 23 Other concurrent diseases,
stress, possible exposure to toxins, weight loss, water consumption, and salt availability
also may be significant. The information obtained helps to prioritize differential
diagnoses and direct further testing.
The clinician should perform a complete physical examination. The body condition of
the horse and the presence of any edema should be noted. The presence of fever, dehydration,
or signs of endotoxemia may help in assessing the severity of the disease and differentiating
the cause, because some causes of diarrhea are not associated typically with systemic
signs of illness. Careful evaluation of the abdomen should be performed. Visible abdominal
distention is often an indication of large intestinal distention, which may occur
in association with acute colitis. However, distention also may be visible with extreme
dilation of multiple loops of small intestine. Careful auscultation of the abdomen
can be useful in assessing motility. Generally, progressive borborygmi heard about
every 3 to 4 minutes on both sides of the abdomen suggests normal motility of the
cecum and colon. Auscultation behind the xiphoid process may help to identify the
presence of sand or gravel if one hears particles grinding together during contractions
of the colon.
24
Particularly in foals, transabdominal palpation and ballottement may be useful to
identify increased abdominal fluid or large masses near the body wall. Transrectal
palpation can be helpful in assessing the size of intestinal segments, consistency
of contents, and wall thickness as well as in identifying masses, enlarged lymph nodes,
or mesenteric arteritis.
CLINICAL PATHOLOGY
Routine analysis of blood work rarely identifies a specific cause of diarrhea but
can be important in directing appropriate supportive care and may help to establish
whether diarrhea is caused by another condition, such as hepatic or renal disease.
Some important parameters to evaluate include the presence of leukopenia, particularly
neutropenia with a left shift and toxic changes in the white blood cells. These abnormalities
suggest endotoxemia, which also may be associated with thrombocytopenia and coagulopathies.
One also should evaluate the concentration of protein, as well as the albumin/globulin
ratio. Significant hypoproteinemia, especially hypoalbuminemia caused primarily by
protein loss, may occur with acute and chronic diarrhea. Hyperglobulinemia may indicate
a chronic inflammatory condition. Disturbances in acid-base balance, especially metabolic
acidosis, and electrolyte abnormalities frequently occur in cases of acute diarrhea
but are uncommon in chronic diarrhea. Because of the dehydration frequently seen with
acute diarrhea, prerenal azotemia is common and is important to recognize because
some therapies, especially nonsteroidal antiinflammatory medications, may worsen the
condition. In a study of 122 horses with acute diarrhea, horses with azotemia and
clinicopathologic findings consistent with hemoconcentration and hypoproteinemia were
less likely to survive.
17
The diagnostic and prognostic value of serum protein electrophoresis has been evaluated
in horses with chronic diarrhea.
25
Significantly higher levels of β1-globulin were found in horses with larval cyathostomiais
than in other horses, and such values in conjunction with a decreased albumin were
helpful in diagnosing intestinal parasitism. However, a normal β1-globulin concentration
was not a reliable indicator of the absence of the disease. Significantly lower albumin
concentrations and significantly higher α2-globulin concentrations were found in horses
that did not survive, suggesting that these parameters are nonspecific indicators
of the severity of inflammatory changes within the intestinal wall. Parasitic infections,
particularly strongylosis, also may be associated with elevated serum concentrations
of immunoglobulin G(T).
26
Infrequently, immunodeficiencies are associated with diarrhea.18, 19 Therefore in
some cases, further evaluation of immune status may be indicated and may include specific
immunoglobulin quantitation, evaluation of specific lymphocyte subsets, or functional
assays. One should consider genetic testing for severe combined immunodeficiency in
sick foals of Arabian breeding.
Analysis of peritoneal fluid may be useful in some cases of diarrhea. Abnormalities
in the peritoneal fluid may reflect the severity of inflammation and in some cases
may help to establish a specific diagnosis. Increases in protein and sometimes nucleated
cell count may be seen in association with ulcerative colitis.
23
In cases of bacterial peritonitis, one may find organisms on cytologic examination
or culture. Occasionally, one may identify neoplastic cells in the peritoneal fluid,
although their absence does not rule out the presence of neoplasia.
EVALUATION OF FECES
Evaluation of the feces may yield important information in cases of diarrhea. Even
the gross appearance of the feces can be helpful. For example, profuse, watery diarrhea
is not generally consistent with a diagnosis of right dorsal colitis. Frank blood
in the feces suggests bleeding into the distal colon from mucosal damage. Hemorrhagic,
foul-smelling feces often are seen in association with clostridial diarrhea. One also
can assess the feces for the presence of occult blood, which indicates bleeding from
any source. Although excess sand in the feces is readily apparent in some cases, other
cases require mixing the feces in a rectal sleeve with water and allowing the sand
to settle.
Microscopic examination of the feces for evidence of parasitism and evaluation of
viable protozoal populations also may be useful. A direct smear of fresh feces allows
for observation of the motility of ciliates and can be used as a screen for the presence
of ova and oocysts, although more sensitive techniques, including fecal flotation
and sedimentation, are recommended for evaluation of parasitism. Ideally, a quantitative
method that allows for estimation of the number of eggs per gram of feces, such as
McMaster's or Stolley's, is recommended. However, one must remember that fecal examination
for parasites sometimes can be misleading, giving false-negative results. Cryptosporidium
parvum infection can be difficult to diagnose, but oocysts can be detected in the
feces by acid-fast staining or by immunofluorescence assay.
27
Fecal samples also can be examined microscopically for leukocytes and epithelial cells.
In general the cellularity increases with the severity of diarrhea. Fecal leukocytes
and epithelial cells are increased in salmonellosis, but are not specific for this
disorder.
28
More than 10 leukocytes per high-power field may indicate salmonellosis.
Evaluation of the feces for infectious agents is essential in the diagnostic evaluation
of horses with diarrhea. Salmonella and Clostridium species are among the most common
causes of bacterial diarrhea in horses. Other less common bacterial agents include
Campylobacter spp., Aeromonas spp., and particularly in weanling age foals,
Lawsonia intracellulare.
29, 30 Although primarily a respiratory pathogen, Rhodococcus equi also can cause
diarrhea, particularly in foals 2 to 4 months of age.
31
Escherichia coli is an uncommon cause of diarrhea in foals, unlike in calves and piglets.
However, enterotoxigenic strains, characterized by the presence of virulence factors,
have been identified in foals. Gram stain and spore stain of fecal smears can help
to identify and quantitate the bacterial populations present, particularly clostridial
species. However, although large numbers of gram-positive rods or spores have been
identified in foals with clostridial enterocolitis, the results of direct staining
may be misleading.32, 33 In one study, Clostridium perfringens was cultured from 59%
of samples in which no gram-positive rods were visible. Some clostridial strains also
are likely part of the normal microflora.
34
Large numbers of yeast in the feces should alert the clinician to the possibility
of candidiasis, especially in compromised neonatal foals.
Fecal culture is used commonly to establish a diagnosis in cases of bacterial diarrhea.
When culturing feces, especially if an outside laboratory is used, one must consider
proper sample handling, particularly for anaerobic clostridia.
35
Salmonella spp. are one of the most significant bacterial pathogens in equine feces.
36
Although the number of Salmonella spp. organisms isolated from the feces of horses
with clinical salmonellosis is generally greater than from horses with asymptomatic
infections, the volume of feces in horses with profuse diarrhea may decrease recovery.
Culture of multiple fecal samples, typically five, is recommended to increase the
sensitivity. Culture of a rectal mucosal biopsy or rectal scraping is an alternative
to fecal cultures and may increase sensitivity, because Salmonella spp. are intracellular
organisms. Identifying clostridial species requires anaerobic culture. However, evaluating
the presence of toxin in cases of suspected clostridial diarrhea also is critical,
because Clostridium spp., particularly C. perfringens type A, may be present in normal
equine feces.
34
Depending on the clostridial species and the laboratory, toxin can be assessed by
detecting preformed toxin in the feces, toxin being produced by the isolate in culture,
or the toxin gene in the isolate.32, 33, 34, 35
An increasing number of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assays are available for detecting
causative agents of equine diarrhea. In comparing a PCR with microbial culture for
detection of salmonellae in equine feces and environmental samples, the PCR method
was found to be more sensitive and more rapid and required submission of fewer samples.37,
38 Currently, PCR is also available for detection of Ehrlichia risticii, the causative
agent of Potomac horse fever, in feces and peripheral blood.39, 40 Fecal PCR analysis
also has been shown to be useful in documenting equine proliferative enteropathy caused
by Lawsonia intracellulare.
30
Serologic methods, evaluating the presence of antibodies, are additional diagnostic
tests used for diagnosis of Ehrlichia and Lawsonia.
30, 40
Rotaviral infection is associated with diarrhea in foals and is most common in foals
from 1 to 4 weeks of age.4, 41 One generally makes a diagnosis by detecting the virus
by electron microscopy or the viral antigen by enzyme immunoassay (Rotazyme, Abbot
Laboratories, North Chicago, Illinois), which is generally more sensitive than direct
electron microscopy.
42
Coronavirus appears to have a low prevalence in foals but has been isolated from a
horse with diarrhea.
43
Less commonly used tests include evaluation of fecal osmolality and electrolyte concentrations
(sodium and potassium). If the concentration of sodium plus potassium is much less
than the osmolality, the result indicates the presence of osmotically active nonelectrolytes,
confirming an osmotic diarrhea.
DIAGNOSTIC IMAGING
Diagnostic imaging, although particularly useful in foals, also can be valuable in
adult horses. In foals, radiographs can detect gas distention in the lumen of the
gastrointestinal tract, and the gas pattern may help to differentiate ileus from mechanical
obstruction. Occasionally, gas may be seen within the bowel wall in severe cases of
clostridial necrotizing enterocolitis. In adult horses, abdominal radiography is limited
somewhat by having the proper facilities and equipment to perform the procedure safely.
However, radiographs can be effective in identifying radiodense material, such as
enteroliths and sand. Ultrasonography can be used in horses of all ages to evaluate
the amount and character of the peritoneal fluid, masses, intestinal distention, and
wall thickness. In cases of right dorsal colitis, the diagnosis has been supported
by ultrasonographic evidence of thickening of the right dorsal colon. Altough isotope-labeled
white blood cell scintigraphic scans also may help identify colonic ulcerations, the
availability and sensitivity of the procedure are limited.
OTHER DIAGNOSTICS
Endoscopic examination of the stomach and proximal duodenum may reveal the presence
of neoplasms or ulceration. Diarrhea and inappetance are common clinical signs in
symptomatic foals with ulceration of the squamous gastric mucosa. Endoscopy also can
be used for inspection of the mucosa of the rectum and descending colon, allowing
for evaluation of mural masses or mucosal inflammation.
Absorption tests are used primarily in cases of chronic diarrhea or weight loss to
evaluate the small intestinal absorptive capacity. Oral glucose and oral xylose absorption
tests have been used.44, 45 Although the plasma concentration of glucose may reflect
glucose metabolism as well as absorption from the gastrointestinal tract, the assay
has been shown to be reliable in the diagnosis of significant malabsorptive conditions.
Xylose is influenced less by the metabolic status of the horse, but the compound is
more expensive than glucose, and the assay is not available in many laboratories.
Results of both assays are nonspecific, but abnormal results support malabsorption
and may indicate the necessity of biopsy.
Diagnosing neoplasms and chronic inflammatory or infiltrative disorders often requires
histopathologic examination. A rectal mucosal biopsy is easy to collect and also can
be cultured, but the area that can be reached for biopsy is limited. Laparoscopy allows
for visualization of the abdomen and certain biopsies. One can obtain full thickness
intestinal biopsy during exploratory celiotomy.
Diarrhea is a component of the clinical syndrome associated with several toxins. Cantharidin
(blister beetle toxin) can be detected in urine or gastrointestinal contents.46, 47
One can measure lead in the blood and liver, selenium in the blood and liver, or arsenic
in the liver if they are suspected.47, 48 One should consider oleander toxicity in
horses with diarrhea, arrhythmias, and renal disease, especially if exposure is possible.
47
Oleandrin is detectable in urine and gastrointestinal contents.
EVALUATION OF RESPONSE TO THERAPY
Evaluating the response to empirical therapy may be helpful in some cases of chronic,
undiagnosed diarrhea. Dietary changes may decrease diarrhea in some cases, and often
a diet of grass hay alone is recommended. In cases in which right dorsal colitis is
suspected but cannot be confirmed, using pelleted feed may be beneficial. Addition
of psyllium mucilloid and corn oil to the diet also may be beneficial in right dorsal
colitis. Psyllium mucilloid also has been used in cases in which sand was suspected
as contributing to the diarrhea. Any medications that the horse has been receiving,
especially nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs or antibiotics, should be discontinued
in case they are contributing to the diarrhea.
Transfaunation can be used in an attempt to restore normal flora. Fresh colonic or
cecal contents are considered the best source of organisms, but feces can be used.
A number of commercial probiotics are available, but their efficacy has not yet been
established.
A course of corticosteroids can be tried in cases of chronic diarrhea in which infectious
causes have been ruled out. Treatment with a larvicidal anthelmintic may be beneficial
in some cases, and sometimes is used with corticosteroids. Some horses with chronic
diarrhea have responded to iodochlorhydroxyquin (10 g/450 kg/day for 2 weeks). This
drug sometimes has been used concurrently with trimethoprim-sulfa. Occasionally, transfusion
with plasma seems to suppress diarrhea in young horses.
REFERENCES
1
Argenzio
RA
Lowe
JE
Pickard
DW
Digesta passage and water exchange in the equine large intestine
Am J Physiol
226
1974
1035
1042
4207578
2
Argenzio
RA
Stevens
CE
Cyclic changes in ionic composition of digesta in the equine intestinal tract
Am J Physiol
228
1975
1224
1230
1130521
3
Argenzio
RA
Functions of the large intestine and their interrelationship with disease
Cornell Vet
65
1975
303
327
237739
4
Conner
ME
Darlington
RW
Rotavirus infection in foals
Am J Vet Res
41
1980
1699
1703
6261616
5
Holland
JL
Kronfeld
DS
Sklan
D
Calculation of fecal kinetics in horses fed hay or hay and concentrate
J Anim Sci
76
1998
1934
1944
6
O'Louglin
EV
Scott
RB
Gall
DG
Pathophysiology of infectious diarrhea: changes in intestinal structure and function
J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr
12
1991
5
20
2061778
7
Rachmilewitz
D
Prostaglandins and diarrhea
Dig Dis Sci
25
1980
897
899
7449585
8
Hardcastle
J
Hardcastle
PT
Involvement of prostaglandin in histamine-induced fluid and electrolyte secretion
by rat colon
J Pharm Pharmacol
40
1988
106
110
2897440
9
Wang
YZ
Cooke
Su
HC
Histamine augments colonic secretion in guinea pig distal colon
Am J Physiol
258
1990
G432
G439
1969234
10
Clarke
LL
Argenzio
RA
NaCl transport across equine proximal colon and the effect of endogenous prostaglandins
Am J Physiol
259
1990
G62
G69
2372066
11
Halm
DR
Rechkemmer
GR
Schoumache
RA
Apical membrane chloride channels in a colonic cell line activated by secretory agonists
Am J Physiol
254
1988
C505
C511
2451430
12
Cliff
WH
Frizzell
RA
Separate Cl− conductances activated by cAMP and Ca2+ in Cl(−)-secreting epithelial
cells
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A
87
1990
4956
4960
2164213
13
Ling
BN
Kokko
KE
Eaton
DC
Prostaglandin E2 activates clusters of apical Cl− channels in prinicipal cells via
a cyclic adenosine monophosphate-dependent pathway
J Clin Invest
93
1994
829
837
8113415
14
King
JN
Gerring
EL
The action of low dose endotoxin on equine bowel motility
Equine Vet J
23
1991
11
19
2015801
15
Weese
JS
Parsons
DA
Staempfli
HR
Association of Clostridium difficile with enterocolitis and lactose intolerance in
a foal
J Am Vet Med Assoc
214
1999
229
232
9926015
16
Stewart
MC
Hodgson
JL
Kim
H
Acute febrile diarrhoea in horses: 86 cases (1986-1991)
Aust Vet J
72
1995
41
44
7779031
17
Cohen
ND
Woods
AM
Characteristics and risk factors for failure of horses with acute diarrhea to survive:
122 cases (1990-1996)
J Am Vet Med Assoc
214
1999
382
390
10023402
18
Mair
TS
Taylor
FG
Harbour
DA
Pearson
GR
Concurrent cryptosporidium and coronavirus infections in an Arabian foal with combined
immunodeficiency syndrome
Vet Rec
126
1990
127
130
2156372
19
Richards
AF
Kelly
DF
Knottenbelt
DC
Anaemia, diarrhoea and opportunistic infections in Fell ponies
Equine Vet J
32
2000
386
391
11037259
20
Sweeney
RW
Sweeney
CR
Saik
J
Chronic granulomatous bowel disease in three sibling horses
J Am Vet Med Assoc
188
1986
1192
1194
3721973
21
Wilson
DA
MacFadden
KE
Green
EM
Case control and historical cohort study of diarrhea associated with administration
of trimethoprim-potentiated sulphonamides to horses and ponies
J Vet Intern Med
10
1996
258
264
8819052
22
Stratton-Phelps
M
Wilson
WD
Gardner
IA
Risk of adverse effects in pneumonic foals treated with erythromycin versus other
antibiotics: 143 cases (1986-1996)
J Am Vet Med Assoc
217
2000
68
73
10909450
23
Karcher
LF
Dill
SG
Anderson
WI
Right dorsal colitis
J Vet Intern Med
4
1990
247
253
2262926
24
Ragle
CA
Meagher
DM
Schrader
JL
Abdominal auscultation in the detection of experimentally induced gastrointestinal
sand accumulation
J Vet Intern Med
3
1989
12
14
2538618
25
Mair
TS
Cripps
PJ
Ricketts
SW
Diagnostic and prognostic value of serum protein electrophoresis in horses with chronic
diarrhoea
Equine Vet J
25
1993
324
326
7689051
26
Patton
S
Mock
RE
Drudge
JH
Increase of immunoglobulin T concentrations in ponies as a response to experimental
infection with the nematode Strongyles vulgaris
Am J Vet Res
39
1978
19
22
75703
27
Cole
DJ
Cohen
ND
Snowden
K
Prevalence of and risk factors for fecal shedding of Cryptosporidium parvum oocysts
in horses
J Am Vet Med Assoc
213
1998
1296
1302
9810386
28
Morris
DD
Whitlock
RH
Palmer
JE
Fecal leukocytes and epithelial cells in horses with diarrhea
Cornell Vet
73
1983
265
274
6884036
29
Hathcock
TL
Schumacher
J
Wright
JC
The prevalence of Aeromonas species in feces of horses with diarrhea
J Vet Intern Med
13
1999
357
360
10449228
30
Lavoie
JP
Drolet
R
Parsons
D
Equine proliferative enteropathy: a cause of weight loss, colic, diarrhoea and hypoproteinemia
in foals on three breeding farms in Canada
Equine Vet J
32
2000
418
425
11037264
31
Cimprich
RE
Rooney
JR
Corynebacterium equi enteritis in foals
Vet Pathol
14
1977
95
102
857401
32
East
LM
Savage
CJ
Traub-Dargatz
JL
Enterocolitis associated with Clostridium perfringens infection in neonatal foals:
54 cases (1988-1997)
J Am Vet Med Assoc
212
1998
1751
1756
9621884
33
Magdesian
KG
Hirsh
DC
Jang
SS
Characterization of Clostridium difficile isolates from foals with diarrhea: 28 cases
(1993-1997)
J Am Vet Med Assoc
220
2002
67
73
12680451
34
Tillotson
K
Traub-Dargatz
JL
Dickinson
CE
Population-based study of fecal shedding of Clostridium perfringens in broodmares
and foals
J Am Vet Med Assoc
220
2002
342
348
11829266
35
Weese
JS
Staemplfi
HR
Prescott
JF
Test selections and interpretation in the diagnosis of Clostridium difficile-associated
colitis
Proc 45th Annual AAEP Convention
45
1999
50
52
36
Smith
BP
Salmonella infection in horses
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
3
1981
S4
S17
37
Cohen
ND
Neibergs
HL
Wallis
DE
Genus-specific detection of salmonellae in equine feces by use of the polymerase chain
reaction
Am J Vet Res
55
1994
1049
1054
7978642
38
Cohen
ND
Martin
LJ
Simpson
RB
Comparison of polymerase chain reaction and microbiological culture for detection
of salmonellae in equine feces and environmental samples
Am J Vet Res
57
1996
780
786
8725799
39
Barlough
JE
Rikihisa
Y
Madigan
JE
Nested polymerase chain reaction for detection of Ehrlichia risticii genomic DNA in
infected horses
Vet Parasitol
68
1997
367
373
9106958
40
Mott
F
Rikihisa
T
Zhang
Y
Comparison of PCR and culture to the indirect fluorescent-antibody test for diagnosis
of Potomac horse fever
J Clin Microbiol
35
1997
2215
2219
9276390
41
Browning
GF
Chalmers
RM
Snodgrass
DR
The prevalence of enteric pathogens in diarrhoeic thoroughbred foals in Britain and
Ireland
Equine Vet J
23
1991
397
398
1778153
42
Ellis
GR
Daniels
E
Comparison of direct electron microscopy and enzyme immunoassay for the detection
of rotaviruses in calves, lambs, piglets and foals
Aust Vet J
65
1988
133
135
3041953
43
Guy
JS
Breslin
JJ
Breuhaus
B
Characterization of a coronavirus isolated from a diarrheic foal
J Clin Microbiol
38
2000
4523
4526
11101590
44
Mair
TS
Hillyer
MH
Taylor
FGR
Small intestinal malabsorption in the horse: an assessment of the specificity of the
oral glucose tolerance test
Equine Vet J
23
1991
344
346
1959524
45
Roberts
MC
Norman
P
A re-evaluation of the d(+)-xylose absorption test in the horse
Equine Vet J
11
1979
239
243
540633
46
Schmitz
DG
Cantharidin toxicosis in horses
J Vet Intern Med
3
1989
208
215
2685272
47
Galey
FD
Disorders caused by toxicants
Smith
BP
Large animal internal medicine
ed 3
2002
Mosby
St Louis
48
Pace
LW
Turnquist
SE
Casteel
SW
Acute arsenic toxicosis in five horses
Vet Pathol
34
1997
160
164
9066085
Hines
Melissa T.
3.11—Clinical Assessment of Poor Performance
Any decrease in performance may be critical to the equine athlete. Numerous factors
influence performance, including genetics, training, desire, and overall health. Peak
athletic performance requires optimal function of all body systems, particularly those
involved in locomotion and oxygen transport.
Approach to Poor Performance
Determining the cause of poor performance in those horses without overt clinical disease
often is challenging.1, 2, 3, 4 In a study by Martin, Reef, Parente et al. of 348
cases of poor performance, a definitive diagnosis was established in 73.5% of cases
after in-depth examination, which included the use of a high-speed treadmill.
3
Subtle abnormalities may be sufficient to impair performance, and in some cases, problems
may be evident only during exercise, contributing to the difficulty of making a diagnosis.
Additionally, multiple problems may occur concurrently. In a study by Morris and Seeherman
of 275 racehorses with a history of poor racing performance, 84% were found to have
more than one abnormality.
2
Therefore determining the actual clinical significance of any given problem may be
difficult.
Equine athletes presented for poor performance should undergo a comprehensive evaluation,
the basic components of which include a history, detailed physical examination, and
laboratory screening. The clinician should emphasize examination of the respiratory,
musculoskeletal, and cardiovascular systems, because these systems most often are
linked to performance problems. In many cases, standardized exercise testing, generally
on a high-speed treadmill, is critical in identifying the problem. Endoscopic examination
of the upper airways during exercise has proved particularly useful.
History
Obtaining a complete history is a fundamental part of evaluating poor performance.
The clinician should establish the use of the horse, the time in training, and the
specifics of the training program. Determining whether the horse has never performed
as expected or has experienced a decline in the level of performance is crucial. If
the horse has never performed as expected, one should consider a lack of ability,
congenital abnormalities, or training problems. A change in performance, either sudden
or insidious, often is associated with an acquired problem. The clinician should characterize
specifically the decline in performance, including the intensity of exercise at which
signs are observed and whether performance is abnormal from the onset of exercise
or declines during an exercise bout. In those cases in which performance drops off
during exercise, the clinician should determine whether the decline is acute or gradual
and whether any other signs such as stridor are associated with it.
Other elements of the history with particular relevance to athletic performance include
any previous respiratory disease, respiratory noise, or respiratory distress associated
with exercise. Any change in gait also may be significant. Establishing the feeding
practices, changes in appetite or body condition, the type of tack used, and whether
sweating is appropriate is important. The clinician should determine the response
to any medications that have been used, such as phenylbutazone or furosemide. The
information obtained in the history may help direct the investigation.
General Physical Examination and Laboratory Screening
The clinician should perform a complete physical examination in all cases. Hematologic
testing and a biochemical profile are indicated, although in most horses presented
for poor performance without obvious clinical abnormalities, routine evaluation of
a single sample is within normal limits. Because exercise can induce some changes
in laboratory parameters, such as an increase in the packed cell volume and neutrophil
count, considering the time of sample collection relative to exercise is important.5,
6, 7 Potentially significant findings include changes consistent with chronic inflammation,
such as anemia, hyperglobulinemia, and possibly hyperfibrinogenemia. Subclinical infections
may have only slight alterations in the leukocyte count and differential. Viral infections,
especially in the early stages, may be associated with a leukopenia and neutropenia.
A decrease in the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio has been associated with overtraining,
although this is not a reliable correlation.
7
Horses at rest normally maintain a significant proportion of red blood cells and hemoglobin
in the splenic reserve.5, 6, 8 Thus although total body hemoglobin increases in response
to training and may correlate with performance, such cannot be determined from a resting
sample. Special techniques must be used to document total red cell mass or hemoglobin.8,
9 Anemia can decrease the oxygen-carrying capacity during exercise, resulting in suboptimal
performance.
Signs of organ dysfunction in horses presented for poor performance are not common
findings. Muscle enzymes may be elevated, although many cases of myopathy are subclinical
and require evaluation of muscle enzymes after exercise.
10
Much attention has been paid to the importance of electrolytes and exercise; however,
abnormalities seldom are found. In general, circulating electrolyte concentrations
are regulated tightly and may not reflect closely the total body electrolyte status.
11
However, a concentration of potassium consistently below 3 mEq/L may suggest a potassium
deficit. Chronic electrolyte deficiencies may be detected by performing renal fractional
excretion of electrolytes.
Evaluation of the Respiratory System
The clinician should give careful attention to examining the respiratory tract, because
abnormalities of this system frequently influence performance. The examination should
include evaluation of air flow from the nares and percussion of the sinuses, as well
as assessment of any cough or nasal discharge. Careful palpation of the larynx may
reveal an increase in prominence of the muscular process of the left arytenoid cartilage
resulting from a loss of mass of the left dorsal cricoarytenoid muscle associated
with idiopathic hemiplegia. The clinician can use the laryngeal adductor response
test, or slap test, to evaluate adduction of the arytenoid cartilages by slapping
the withers during expiration and evaluating movement of the contralateral arytenoid
by endoscopy or palpation. The clinician should perform a thorough auscultation of
the trachea and lungs. Having the horse rebreathe from a plastic bag placed over the
nostrils increases the respiratory rate and tidal volume, accentuating sounds. In
addition to auscultation, one should note the character and pattern of respiration,
including the presence of any abdominal component, and the recovery time. Percussion
of the thorax may be useful in establishing the lung border and any dull or hyperresonant
areas, as well as in detecting pleural pain.
Dynamic obstruction of the airway is among the most common causes of poor performance
in the equine athlete.2, 3, 12, 13, 14 In the study by Morris and Seeherman of 275
racehorses evaluated for poor performance, 40% were found to have dynamic obstruction.
2
Similarly, in the study by Martin, Reef, Parente et al. of 348 racehorses and show
horses with poor performance, 148 (42.6%) had dynamic obstruction of the airways.
3
Of these 148 affected horses, 39 were found to have multiple airway abnormalities.
An additional 22 horses had dynamic airway obstruction concurrently with a cardiac
arrhythmia. In both studies of poor performance the most common conditions causing
airway obstruction were dorsal displacement of the soft palate and idiopathic left
laryngeal hemiplegia with arytenoid collapse. Other conditions diagnosed included
dynamic pharyngeal collapse, epiglottic entrapment, subepiglottic cyst, rostral displacement
of the palatopharyngeal arch, and redundant alar folds. An important note is that
many of the horses with airway obstruction did not have a history of abnormal respiratory
noise and did not have abnormalities at rest. Also, not all abnormalities observed
at rest caused obstruction. Therefore these studies emphasize the importance of treadmill
videoendoscopy as a component of the evaluation of poor performance. In most cases,
the clinician should perform a treadmill videoendoscopy regardless of the history
and physical examination findings.
Endoscopy also can be useful in identifying respiratory problems other than dynamic
airway collapse. For example, one can identify narrowing of the ventral nasal meatus
associated with sinusitis, nasal masses, and pharyngitis. If the endoscope is sufficiently
long, tracheal injury and secretions in the lower respiratory tract can be visualized.
Sampling of airway secretions by bronchoalveolar lavage may aid in the diagnosis of
low-grade respiratory infections, small airway inflammatory disease, or exercise-induced
pulmonary hemorrhage. In some cases, evidence of inflammation and retropharyngeal
lymphadenopathy on endoscopic examination of the guttural pouches has been associated
with dorsal displacement of the soft palate, which may result from neuropathy of the
pharyngeal branch of the vagus nerve.
15
Radiographs and ultrasound may be indicated on evaluation of the respiratory system
of horses with poor performance, especially in those horses with evidence of lower
respiratory tract disease. Radiographs also can be useful in assessing upper respiratory
disorders, allowing for the evaluation of soft tissue masses or fluid accumulations.
In addition, sometimes one can identify abnormalities of the pharyngeal and laryngeal
structures such as thickening of the soft palate or hypoplasia of the epiglottis.
Evaluation of the Cardiovascular System
Any decrease in cardiac output potentially can limit performance, making thorough
evaluation of the cardiovascular system essential. On basic physical examination,
the clinician should evalutate the mucous membrane color, capillary refill time, and
arterial and venous peripheral pulses, although finding abnormalities in these parameters
in horses presented for decreased performance is uncommon. One should perform careful
auscultation of the heart on both sides of the thorax to evaluate the cardiac rhythm
and murmurs. Many horses have murmurs that are of little clinical significance.2,
16 In the study by Martin, Reef, Parente et al., 102 of the 348 horses were found
to have murmurs, the most common being mitral regurgitation.
3
In all cases the murmur was determined to be clinically unimportant.
The clinician can use electrocardiography to evaluate the cardiac rhythm further,
and ideally should perform the procedure before, during, and after exercise using
radiotelemetry. Cardiac arrhythmias were the only abnormality found in 33 of the 348
horses evaluated by Martin, Reef, Parente et al. and were found in conjunction with
dynamic airway obstruction in 22 horses.
3
However, in the study by Morris and Seeherman, arrhythmias were noted in just 2 of
275 horses.
2
The most frequent arrhythmias observed include atrial and ventricular premature depolarizations.
Ventricular tachycardia and paroxysmal atrial fibrillation also have been noted. Changes
in the T wave, once thought to be related to poor performance, and second-degree atrioventricular
block have been found to have no effect on exercise capacity.
17
Echocardiography before and after exercise helps to evaluate cardiac function. Martin,
Reef, Parente et al. found decreased fractional shortening indicating left ventricular
dysfunction after exercise in 19 horses, only 8 of which had echocardiographic changes
at rest.
3
Six of the 19 horses had clinically significant arrhythmias. Myocardial disease may
contribute to left ventricular dysfunction and arrhythmias. Elevations in myocardial
fractions of creatine kinase, lactate dehydrogenase, and troponin support myocardial
disease but are not present in all cases.
Evaluation of the Musculoskeletal System
A surprising number of horses presented for poor performance are found to be lame,
even when lameness is not part of the presenting complaint.1, 2, 4 Therefore the clinician
should perform a complete lameness examination in all cases. In some horses presented
for poor performance, the gait asymmetry may be subtle and only discernable at high
speed, making diagnosis by traditional methods difficult. In these cases, gait analysis
on the treadmill and advanced diagnostic techniques such as nuclear scintigraphy,
thermography, and computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging may be useful.
One also should perform a neurologic examination to identify any deficits that could
contribute to poor performance.
Myopathy can lead to decreased performance. In many cases the condition is subclinical
and requires an exercise challenge test to make the diagnosis.3, 10 One should measure
creatine kinase before exercise and ideally 4 to 6 hours after an exercise bout consisting
of 15 to 30 minutes at the trot. In normal horses, this light exercise rarely causes
more than a threefold increase in creatine kinase. An increase of fivefold or more
indicates exertional rhabdomyolysis. A muscle biopsy can help to define the myopathy.
In the study by Martin, Reef, Parente et al., 10 of 348 horses developed clinical
exertional rhabdomyolysis after exercise, and an additional 53 demonstrated subclinical
myopathy as demonstrated by increased creatine kinase levels after exercise.
3
Exercise Testing
Exercise testing provides a mechanism for evaluating a range of body systems under
standard exercise conditions. In particular, measurements of cardiorespiratory and
metabolic function taken during an exercise test provide information about the capacity
and efficiency of key body systems involved in energy production. From a clinical
standpoint, exercise testing is generally most useful in assessing the effect on performance
of abnormalities found on a physical examination. Testing also may help to establish
the reason for reduced athletic capacity in horses that have no abnormalities on basic
examinations. Exercise testing can be done in the field, which mimics the condition
in which the horse actually performs. However, most testing is currently done on a
treadmill, which provides more standard conditions and an opportunity to perform a
greater range of measurements. The specific protocol used for exercise testing may
vary somewhat.1, 18, 19 Occasionally a high-speed test is performed in which the horse
is accelerated rapidly to maximum speed and run to fatigue. However, the most common
type of test is an incremental test in which the speed increases every 1 to 2 minutes
until the horse reaches fatigue, allowing for the generation of data during submaximal
and maximal exercise. In most cases the test is performed with the treadmill at a
slope of 10%. This slope is not so steep as to be completely unrepresentative of normal
exercise, and yet it ensures that maximum intensity exercise can be performed without
reaching speeds that may be too fast for horse safety. Some parameters that can be
assessed in an exercise test include heart rate, blood lactate level, arterial blood
gases, total red cell volume, stride length, and oxygen uptake. As previously discussed,
treadmill videoendoscopy is often valuable.
HEART RATE DURING EXERCISE
Evaluation of the heart rate during exercise provides an indirect index of cardiovascular
capacity and function. Several heart rate monitors are available.
20
Radiotelemetry also can be used to evaluate the heart rate and rhythm, particularly
at the end of exercise. Because the stroke volume does not change greatly with increasing
exercise speed, the heart rate provides a guide to changes in cardiac output. In general,
a linear increase in heart rate occurs with increasing exercise speed up to the point
at which the maximal heart rate is reached.21, 22, 23 The maximal heart rate (HRmax)
is identified when no further increase in heart rate occurs despite an increase in
exercise speed. The HRmax does not change with training state, although the speed
at which it is reached increases with increasing fitness.
One reference point for comparison of cardiovascular capacity is the treadmill speed
at a heart rate of 200 bpm (V200). At a heart rate of 200 bpm, most horses are close
to the point of onset of blood lactate accumulation. The V200 can be calculated by
linear regression analysis or plotted using measurements taken at three to four submaximal
exercise speeds, without the horse reaching maximal exercise. One should take care
when using the V200 to assess exercise capacity, because at a heart rate of 200, horses
may be exercising at different proportions of their HRmax and therefore their maximal
oxygen uptake (VO2max). In general, however, horses with the highest cardiovascular
and metabolic capacities have the highest V200 values; that is, the better horses
reach a heart rate of 200 at higher speeds than those with a lower exercise capacity.
The V200 increases with training and can be useful for monitoring changes in fitness.
The better quality Thoroughbreds have a V200 of 8 to 9 m/sec in an exercise test with
the treadmill set at a 10% slope. Values less than 7 m/sec are abnormal and if found
in a fit horse indicate decreased cardiac capacity.
Another measurement of cardiovascular capacity is the treadmill speed at which the
horse reaches HRmax, known as VHRmax. This value correlates with VO2max and exercise
capacity but requires the horse to exercise up to maximal speeds so that a plateau
in heart rate can be identified.
Heart rate measurements are helpful in determining the actual significance of cardiac
abnormalities such as murmurs and arrhythmias. In horses with functional cardiac disease
the reduced stroke volume necessitates higher heart rates to maintain adequate cardiac
output. Also, studies in Standardbred racehorses have suggested that horses with musculoskeletal
problems have an increased V200 and that monitoring the V200 may help to identify
subclinical lameness.
BLOOD OR PLASMA LACTATE MEASUREMENT
Exercising muscles produce lactate to some extent during all intensities of exercise,
but production increases exponentially with the intensity of exercise.23, 24, 25 As
exercise becomes more intense, the aerobic energy contribution becomes insufficient
to meet total energy requirements, and increased anaerobic metabolism results in increased
lactate production. Lactate diffuses from muscle to blood, and therefore blood or
plasma concentrations of lactate reflect muscle lactate. Some evidence suggests that
whole blood concentrations most accurately measure lactate accumulation, because red
blood cells actively take up lactate.25, 26, 27, 28
The rate of increase of lactate in the blood may be used as an indirect indicator
of cardiovascular and metabolic capacity. Horses with the highest aerobic capacities
because of a high maximal cardiac output tend to have lower lactate values at submaximal
exercise intensities than those with lower aerobic capacities. Lactate values can
be used to compare horses or to evaluate training in the same horse. The treadmill
speed at which a plasma lactate of 4 mmol/L (VLA4) is reached is one measure of lactate
production, and a high value reflects good aerobic capacity. The VLA4 has been used
to monitor changes in fitness. In fit Thoroughbred horses 3 years of age and over,
values for VLA4 range from 8.0 to 9.5 m/sec. Horses that are not fit or have respiratory
disease have lower values. Another useful reference is the blood or plasma lactate
at conclusion of the 10 m/sec exercise step of the incremental test, and highly fit,
athletic horses usually have values less than 5 mmol/L. High-quality sprint horses,
which perform largely under anaerobic conditions and have a high anaerobic capacity,
may have high peak lactate values.
OXYGEN UPTAKE
The measurement of oxygen uptake (VO2) is critical to assessing athletic performance.21,
22 The VO2max has been used as a key indicator of exercise capacity in human athletes
since the 1950s. As the VO2 increases linearly with increasing treadmill speed, VO2max
can be identified when VO2 reaches a plateau despite an increase in speed. The Thoroughbred
horse has VO2max values that are higher than those of many other mammalian species
when expressed on a mass-specific basis. The major factor responsible for the high
VO2max in athletic horses is their high oxygen-carrying capacity, which arises from
a high maximum stroke volume and to some extent a large arteriovenous oxygen content
difference. The VO2max is a good index of changes in fitness and a measurement of
exercise capacity in performance horses.
MAXIMUM OXYGEN PULSE
The oxygen pulse is defined as the VO2/heart rate and is expressed as ml/kg/beat.
This value provides an indication of the maximum stroke volume, and in high-quality
horses, values range from 0.66 to 0.76 ml/kg/beat. Those horses with cardiac problems
resulting in low cardiac outputs and individuals with low VO2max values usually have
values in the range of 0.5 to 0.56 ml/kg/beat. The maximum oxygen pulse also has been
shown to correlate with treadmill total run time.
ARTERIAL BLOOD GAS ANALYSIS DURING EXERCISE
Arterial blood gas analysis during exercise may be indicated, especially in horses
in which respiratory disorders are the suspected cause of poor performance. For an
accurate blood gas analysis, one should take into account the temperature of the blood
because it may reach 42° C during maximal exercise. At exercise intensities above
65% VO2max, athletic horses become hypoxemic, although the extent varies between individuals.29,
30, 31, 32 Horses with low VO2max values do not necessarily have a significant decrease
in arterial oxygen tension.
HEMATOCRIT AND TOTAL RED CELL VOLUME DURING EXERCISE
The total volume of red cells is a major determinant of oxygen-carrying capacity,
and therefore measurement of red cell volume can give some index of exercise capacity.
A postexercise packed cell volume test is not a reliable indicator of total red cell
volume primarily because of plasma volume variations, but it does provide a rough
estimate of total circulating red cells.
One can make an accurate determination of red cell volume by techniques that use dye
dilution following mobilization of the splenic erythrocyte pool to measure the plasma
volume. Although total red cell volume increases with training, some evidence indicates
that Standardbred racehorses with overtraining syndrome may develop an abnormal red
cell hypervolemia that contributes to poor performance.
9
PEAK RUNNING SPEED AND TOTAL RUN TIME
The peak treadmill running speed and the total run time may indicate exercise capacity.
In some studies of human athletes, the peak treadmill running speed during an exercise
test was shown to be a predictor of performance. Athletic Thoroughbred racehorses
can complete 60 seconds at 13 m/sec during an incremental exercise test at a 10% slope.
STRIDE LENGTH
Athletic horses are thought to have better stride characteristics.4, 33 Some studies
have shown a correlation between maximum stride length and the treadmill run time.
An accelerometric device has been used to provide quantitative information about locomotory
variables that may be useful in evaluating performance.
33
REFERENCES
1
Rose RJ: Poor performance: a clinical and physiological perspective. Proceedings of
the nineteenth American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine Forum, Denver, Colo,
2001. pp 224-225.
2
Morris
EA
Seeherman
HJ
Clinical evaluation of poor performance in the racehorse: the results of 275 evaluations
Equine Vet J
23
1991
169
174
1884697
3
Martin
BB
Reef
VB
Parente
EJ
Causes of poor performance of horses during training, racing or showing: 348 cases
(1992-1996)
J Am Vet Med Assoc
216
2000
554
558
10687012
4
Seeherman
HJ
Morris
E
O'Callaghan
MW
The use of sports medicine techniques in evaluating the problem equine athlete
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
7
1991
259
269
1933564
5
Rose
RJ
Allen
JR
Hodgson
DR
Response to submaximal treadmill exercise and training in the horse: changes in haematology,
arterial blood gas and acid base measurements, plasma biochemical values and heart
rate
Vet Rec
113
1983
612
618
6665971
6
Rose
RJ
Allen
JR
Hematologic responses to exercise and training
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
1
1985
461
476
3877551
7
Tyler-McGowan
CM
Golland
LS
Evans
DL
Haematological and biochemical responses to training and overtraining
Equine Exerc Physiol Suppl
30
1999
621
635
8
McKeever
KH
Hinchcliff
KW
Reed
SM
Role of decreased plasma volume in hematocrit alterations during incremental treadmill
exercise in horses
Am J Physiol
265
1993
R404
R408
8368395
9
Persson
SGB
Osterberg
I
Racing performance in red blood cell hypervolaemic Standardbred trotters
Equine Vet J Suppl
30
1999
617
620
10
Valberg
SJ
MacLeay
JM
Mickelson
JR
Exertional rhabdomyolysis and polysaccharide storage myopathy in horses
Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet
19
1997
1077
1085
11
Rose
RJ
Electrolytes: clinical applications
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
6
1990
281
294
12
Dart
AJ
Dowling
BA
Hodgson
DR
Evaluation of high-speed treadmill videoscopy for diagnosis of upper respiratory tract
dysfunction in horses
Aust Vet J
79
2001
109
112
11256279
13
Christley
RM
Hodgson
DR
Evans
DL
Cardiorespiratory responses to exercise in horses with different grades of idiopathic
laryngeal hemiplegia
Equine Vet J
29
1997
6
10
9031857
14
King
CM
Evans
DL
Rose
RJ
Cardiorespiratory and metabolic responses to exercise in horses with various abnormalities
of the upper respiratory tract
Equine Vet J
71
1994
200
202
15
Holcombe
SJ
Derksen
FJ
Stick
JA
Pathophysiology of dorsal displacement of the soft palate in horses
Equine Vet J Suppl
30
1999
45
48
16
Kriz
NG
Hodgson
DR
Rose
RJ
Prevalence and clinical importance of heart murmurs in racehorses
J Am Vet Med Assoc
216
2000
1441
1445
10800517
17
King
CM
Evans
DL
Rose
RJ
Significance for exercise capacity of some electrocardiographic findings in racehorses
Aust Vet J
71
1994
200
202
7945097
18
Seeherman
HJ
Morris
EA
Methodology and repeatability of a standardized treadmill exercise test for clinical
evaluation of fitness in horses
Equine Vet J Suppl
9
1990
20
25
19
Seeherman
HJ
Treadmill exercise testing: treadmill installation and training protocols used for
clinical evaluations of equine athletes
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
7
1991
259
269
1933564
20
Evans
DL
Rose
RJ
Method of investigation of the accuracy of four digitally-display heart rate meters
suitable for use in the exercising horse
Equine Vet J
18
1986
129
132
3698951
21
Evans
DL
Rose
RJ
Cardiovascular and respiratory responses in thoroughbred horses during treadmill exercise
J Exp Biol
134
1988
397
408
3356965
22
Evans
DL
Rose
RJ
Determination and repeatability of maximum oxygen uptake and other cardiorespiratory
measurements in the exercising horse
Equine Vet J
20
1988
94
98
3371328
23
Rose
RJ
Hendrickson
DK
Knight
PK
Clinical exercise testing in the normal thoroughbred racehorse
Aust Vet J
67
1990
345
348
2288536
24
Evans
DL
Harris
RC
Snow
DH
Correlation of racing performance with blood lactate and heart rate after exercise
in thoroughbred horses
Equine Vet J
25
1993
441
445
8223377
25
Rasanen
Lampinen
KF
Poso
AR
Responses of blood and plasma lactate and plasma purine concentrations to maximal
exercise and their relation to performance in standardbred trotters
Am J Vet Res
56
1995
1651
1656
8599528
26
Vaihkonen
LK
Hyyppa
Poso
AR
Factors affecting accumulation of lactate in red blood cells
Equine Vet J Suppl
30
1999
443
447
27
Rainger
JE
Evans
DL
Hodgson
DR
Distribution of lactate in plasma and erythrocytes during and after exercise in horses
Br Vet J
151
1995
299
310
7640958
28
Poso
AR
Lampinen
KJ
Rasanen
LA
Distribution of lactate between red blood cells and plasma after exercise
Equine Vet J Suppl
18
1995
231
234
29
Bayly
WM
Shultz
DA
Hodgson
DR
Ventilatory responses of the horse to exercise: effect of gas collection systems
J Appl Physiol
63
1987
1210
1217
3115951
30
Christley
RM
Evans
DL
Hodgson
DR
Blood gas changes during incremental and sprint exercise
Equine Vet J Suppl
30
1999
24
26
31
Bayly
WM
Hodgson
DR
Schulz
DA
Exercise-induced hypercapnia in the horse
J Appl Physiol
67
1989
958
1966
32
Christley
RM
Hodgson
DR
Evans
DL
Effects of training on the development of exercise-induced arterial hypoxemia in horses
Am J Vet Res
58
1997
653
657
9185975
33
Barrey
E
Evans
SE
Evans
DL
Locomotion evaluation for racing in thoroughbreds
Equine Vet J Suppl
33
2001
99
103