The female sex hormones, estrogens (E) and progesterone (P) are major determinants
of postnatal mammary gland development and are thought to promote breast carcinogenesis.
How do they impact on the human breast? The most widely used models to study E and
P signaling are hormone receptor positive breast cancer cell lines. However, it is
unclear to what extent they provide insights into the breast tissue molecular pathophysiology.
The study (Tamara T., Sflomos G et al., Science Translational Medicine, 2013, Vol.
5, Issue 182, p. 182) presents and validates a novel ex vivo culture model based on
tissue microstructures from fresh human reduction mammoplasty specimens. For the first
time, physiological hormone action can be studied in a human model and new opportunities
to unravel hormone action open up. The work revealed Progesterone/RANKL axis as a
major driver of cell proliferation in the adult human breast with potential clinical
implications for breast cancer patients. Current knowledge about the mechanisms by
which female reproductive hormones control mammary gland development and breast carcinogenesis
stem mainly from animal studies. In particular, the mouse model, in which genetic
tools can be combined with powerful tissue recombination techniques, has been instrumental
in revealing that epithelial estrogen receptor (ERα) signaling controls pubertal gland
development whereas progesterone receptor (PR) signaling is the major proliferative
stimulus in the adult mouse mammary gland. Across species, 30-50% of the breast epithelial
cells express the ERα and PR. The mouse model revealed that at the cellular level,
hormone action relies largely on paracrine signaling. In particular, receptor activator
of nuclear factor kappaB ligand (RANKL) is a central mediator of PR-induced cell proliferation.
RANKL, a transmembrane type II protein is a member of the tumor necrosis factor superfamily
and signals through its receptor RANK (Figure 1). Upon RANKL binding, RANK receptor
elicits activation of a signaling cascade important for mammary gland development
and tumorigenesis.
Figure 1
Model of the PR/RANKL signaling axis in the human breast
Activation of PR signaling by natural progesterone or progestins leads to increase
in RANKL protein levels in PR positive luminal breast epithelial cells (central cell
in light blue) mainly through stabilization of mRNA. RANKL protein binds to RANK receptor
(depicted on the adjacent green cell to the right) and activates this pathway leading
to cell proliferation. SPRMs and drugs that target RANKL pathway such as denosumab
may hence inhibit breast cell proliferation. (PR: Progesterone Receptor, SPRM: Selective
Progesterone Receptor Modulators, CD10: Cluster of Differentiation 10, EpCam: Epithelial
Cell adhesion molecule, RANK: Receptor activator of nuclear factor kappaB, RANKL:
Receptor activator of nuclear factor kappaB ligand).
Epidemiological studies have linked menstrual cycles to breast cancer risk and it
is conceivable that the associated peaks of serum progesterone levels could lead to
RANKL induction and subsequent cell proliferation. Such a scenario has clinical implications
because drugs that target PR/RANKL have been developed to treat reproductive disorders
and bone diseases, respectively. If the same pathway is involved in human breast carcinogenesis,
these drugs may be used for breast cancer prevention in high-risk patients who are
premenopausal to interfere with tumor promoting effects of menstrual cycles.
When primary human breast epithelial cells (HBECs) are grown on tissue culture plastic
they lose hormone receptor expression and cannot be used to study hormone action.
Hormone receptor positive breast cancer cell lines such as MCF-7 and T47D express
high levels of hormone receptors in vitro and are widely used models. However, estrogen
and progesterone targets identified in these cell lines differ largely from those
identified in the mouse mammary gland in vivo. Whether these discrepancies are due
to differences between mice and humans, relate to differences between in vitro and
in vivo assays and/or result from changes that occurred during oncogenic transformation
is unclear.
In light of the importance of paracrine signaling in the mouse mammary gland we argued
that it is important to maintain intercellular interactions. We minimally treated
fresh human breast reduction mammoplasty samples to obtain tissue microstructures.
In this ex vivo approach, breast cells retain hormone receptor expression and remain
hormone responsive. Interestingly, estrogens failed to elicit cell proliferation in
a consistent fashion whereas progesterone signaling induced proliferation in most
samples. Activation of progesterone receptor signaling did not affect RANKL expression
in MCF-7 and T47D cell lines but induced it in the tissue microstructures. RANKL induction
by progesterone receptor signaling is mediated mainly by molecular mechanisms controlling
RANKL's mRNA maturation and stability, leading to elevated amount of this protein
in the cell (Figure 1).
An important question that arises from these observations is whether the PR/RANKL
axis that operates in the normal breast epithelium is also active in primary breast
cancers? If RANKL continues to drive cell proliferation in breast carcinomas, cancer
patients might benefit from drugs that inhibit RANKL. Denosumab is a humanized antibody
that blocks RANKL signaling. It has been FDA approved for the treatment of bone disorders
and is generally well tolerated. As such it could quickly be tested and given to breast
cancer patients. While a role, at least during early stages of carcinogenesis is well
established in the mouse model, such a role of RANKL in human breast cancer is less
clear. This may in part be attributable to the lack of good antibodies to study protein
expression in tumor samples.
Anti-estrogens are mainstay of breast cancer treatment both for advanced-stage disease
and for the adjuvant settings. The new findings of this study suggest that it is worth
reconsidering drugs that target progesterone receptor signaling. New generation selective
progesterone receptor modulators (SPRMs) have been developed for gynecological disorders
and have fewer side effects compared to previous generations. If the paracrine axis
persists in patients bearing PR+ breast cancers then these patients may benefit from
these drugs.
Large studies of women on hormone replacement therapy have revealed puzzling results.
The intake of combined estrogen and progestin preparations increased breast cancer
risk whereas therapy with estrogen and natural progesterone did not. The ex vivo system
can be useful to address whether progesterone and progestins differ in their ability
to induce RANKL and/or other targets and promote cell proliferation not only from
microstructures derived from reduction mammoplasties but also from tumor samples.
Over decades, the approval of oral contraceptives has substantially improved birth
control and prevented unwanted pregnancies. However, many studies argue that contraceptive
pills, most of which include progestins, can increase breast cancer incidence for
reasons that are not yet fully understood. Additional bench work using the human microstructure
model will help us to identify the molecular underpinnings of these differences and
to determine individual risk factors related to new formulations of contraceptives
and to a woman's age or reproductive status. This new experimental model holds promise
to help us gain newinsights into hormone action in the human breast that is ever so
important to tumor development in this organ.