Background
Biliary stones are a common disease in western countries, and its management has changed
dramatically over the past decade. Due to the increase of the middle-aged people,
a larger number of elderly patients are affected by this disease. Laparoscopic cholecystectomy
(LC) represents the gold standard for the treatment of gallbladder stones, and in
cholecystectomized patients, the treatment of CBD stones remains the exclusive work
of the endoscopist. But if the patient still has the gallbladder with stones, the
ideal management of CBD stones remains controversial. There are two treatment options:
the two time (LC and pre or postoperative ERCP), and the one time procedures (trans
cystic approach and CBD exploration and laparoendoscopic procedure called “rendezvous”:RV).
The aim of the work is to analyse our results of the mininvasive treatment of the
cholecysto-choledocolithiasis in elderly patients.
Materials and methods
In the period between September 2008 and November 2010, all patients affected by CBD
stones and admitted to the Department of Emergency Surgery of Cannizzaro Hospital
in Catania, were analyzed, and from this group patients aged >65 years were considered
for the present study. Age, sex, main clinical data, history, diagnosis, type of treatment,
postoperative complications, length of hospital stay and mortality were recorded.
Patients affected by cholecysto-choledocolithiasis were submitted to the LC and RV
technique. If the patients couldn’t be submitted to this procedure because of high
anaesthetic risks, ERCP was performed. However ERCP was always performed in cholecistectomized
patients with jaundice, biliary pancreatitis, cholangitis and imaging showing CBD
stones.
Results
In the period of the study we observed 68 patients with CBD stones, 37 were older
than 65 years: 15 (40.5%) males and 22 (59.5%) female, with a mean age of 76.45 years
(range 65 -93). Twelve (32.4%) patients were treated by LC and intraoperative clearance
of the CBD by the RV. ERCP was performed in 22 (59.5%) patients: 8(21.6%) previous
cholecistectomized and 14(63.6%) who still had their gallbladder, but with high anaesthetic
risk. In one patient the RV technique failed and laparoscopic choledocotomy was performed
and a T-tube left in situ, but after 3 week trans-Kher cholangiography showed residual
stones, so the patient was submitted to ERCP. In other two cases only LC was performed
because the papilla of Vater was difficult to approach. The length of hospital stay
was on average 7 days. Postoperative complications occurred in 7(20%) patients: one
patient developed post-ERCP pancreatitis, two patients post-ERCP increasing of sieric
amylase and lipase, three patients with early stones recurrence, one patient developed
post- ERCP cholecystitis. Only one death was recorded.
Conclusions
For the treatment of the cholecysto-choledoco lithiasis, the RV technique is the best
option, even in the elderly, because the morbidity and the risk of iatrogenic damage
seem lower than ERCP. However in an older high risk patient the ERCP remains a good
therapeutical option, achieving an acceptable risk of postoperative complications.