128
views
0
recommends
+1 Recommend
1 collections
    0
    shares

      From January 2024, all of our readers will be able to access every part of ROAPE as well as its archive without a paywall. This will make ROAPE accessible to a much wider readership, especially in Africa. We need subscriptions and donations to make this revolutionary intiative work. 

      Subscribe and Donate now!

       

      scite_
       
      • Record: found
      • Abstract: found
      • Article: found
      Is Open Access

      Forced resettlement and the political economy of South Africa

      Published
      research-article
      Review of African Political Economy
      Review of African Political Economy
      Bookmark

            Abstract

            Apart perhaps from the direct confrontations that take place between capital and labour, the most significant social process in recent South African history has been the continued and massive population removals. The South African government has at times insisted that such removals were fundamentally voluntary in character. Since the often bitterly resisted removals of the 1950s from both urban and rural areas, however, force has at least potentially been at issue and often directly applied. Consequently it seems appropriate to refer to a policy of forcedresettlement.

            In their recent important analysis of South African conditions, John Saul and Stephen Gelb described the population removal programme as the ‘ugliest of all aspects of apartheid’. This justifiable assertion follows on sporadic, often journalistic, coverage of removal that goes back to Cosmas Desmond's remarkable book, The Discarded People.Desmond's account was largely narrative and concerned with the unpleasantnesses of removal itself and its immediate consequences. Saul and Gelb, by contrast, only devote a short if valuable amount of space to discussing forced resettlement. Between these two poles there is a need for a generalised and analytical assessment which places the programme in a political and historical context and this is the aim of the following discussion.

            Content

            Author and article information

            Journal
            crea20
            CREA
            Review of African Political Economy
            Review of African Political Economy
            0305-6244
            1740-1720
            July 1984
            : 11
            : 29
            : 49-63
            Article
            8703567 Review of African Political Economy, Vol. 11, No. 29, July 1984, pp. 49-63
            10.1080/03056248408703567
            edcea236-c852-45c2-b8ad-d117c2b3cc11

            All content is freely available without charge to users or their institutions. Users are allowed to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of the articles in this journal without asking prior permission of the publisher or the author. Articles published in the journal are distributed under a http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

            History
            Page count
            Figures: 0, Tables: 0, References: 24, Pages: 15
            Categories
            Original Articles

            Sociology,Economic development,Political science,Labor & Demographic economics,Political economics,Africa

            Bibliographic note

            1. Mare Gerry. . 1980. . African Population Relocation in South Africa . , SAIRR. .

            2. Yawitch Joanne. . 1981. . Betterment; the Myth of Homeland Agriculture . , SAIRR. .

            3. Baldwin Alan. . 1976. . ‘Mass Removals and Separate Development’. . Journal of Southern African Studies . , Vol. I:

            4. Desmond Cosmas. . 1971. . The Discarded People . , Harmondsworth : : Penguin Books. .

            5. 1981. . Popple . , Hodder & Stoughton. .

            6. Western John. . 1981. . Outcast Cape Town . , Minneapolis : : University of Minnesota Press. .

            7. West Martin. . 1982. . ‘From Pass Courts to Deportation’. . African Affairs . , Vol. LXXXI:

            8. Silk Andrew. . 1981. . A Shanty Town in South Africa; the Story of Modderdam . , Johannesburg : : Ravan Press. .

            9. Maasdorp Gavin and Humphreys A.S.B.. 1975. . From Shantytown to Township; an Economic Study of African Poverty and Rehousing in a South African City . , Cape Town : : Juta. .

            10. Perlman J.M.. 1983. . “‘The State and the African Working Class in the Pretoria‐Odi Area: Population Relocation, State Management and Class Restructuring’. ”. (SARS/DSG Dissertation Series 1). Johannesburg :

            11. Saul John and Gelb Stephen. . 1981. . The Crisis in South Africa; Class Defence, Class Revolution . , New York : : Monthly Review Press. .

            12. Lacey Marion. . 1981. . Working for Boroko . , Johannesburg : : Ravan Press. .

            13. Davies Robert. . 1979. . ‘Capital Restructuring and the Modification of the Radial Division of Labour’. . Journal of Southern African Studies . , Vol. V:

            14. Wilson Frances. . 1980. . “‘Current Labour Issues in South Africa’. ”. In The Apartheid Regime . , Edited by: Price Robert and Rosberg Carl. . Institute of International Studies, University of California. .

            15. Hindson D.C.. 1983. . “‘Pass Offices and Labour Bureaux: An Analysis of the Development of a National System of Pass Controls in South Africa 1923–80. ”. University of Sussex. .

            16. Hindson D. and Lacey M.. 1983. . “‘Influx control and labour allocation. Policy and practice since the Riekert Commission’. ”. In South African Review . , Edited by: Jaffee G.. Vol. Vol.1. , Johannesburg : : Ravan. .

            17. Innes Duncan and O'Meara Dan. . 1976. . ‘Class Formation and Ideology: the Transkei Region’. . Review of African Political Economy . , Vol. 7:

            18. Streek Barry and Wicksteed Richard. . 1981. . Render unto Kaiser; a Transkei Dossier . , Johannesburg : : Ravan Press. .

            19. Manona C.W.. 1980. . “‘Ethnic Relations in the Ciskei’. ”. In Ciskei . Edited by: Charton Nancy. . Croom Helm :

            20. Green Philippa and Hirsch Alan. . 1982. . ‘The Ciskei — the Political Economy of Control’. . South African Labour Bulletin . , Vol. VII:

            21. Southall Roger. . 1983. . South Africa's Transkei . , New York : : Monthly Review Press. .

            22. Perlman Janice. . 1982. . “‘Favela Removal: The Eradication of a Lifestyle’. ”. In Involuntary Migration and Resettlement . , Edited by: Hansen Art and Oliver‐Smith Anthony. . Boulder , Colo. : : Westview Press. .

            23. Bello Walden, Kinley David and Elinson Elaine. . 1982. . Development Debacle: the World Bank in the Philippines . , San Francisco : : Institute for Food and Development Policy. .

            24. Scudder Thayer. . 1982. . No place to Go: Effects of Compulsory Relocation on Navajos . , Philadelphia : : Institute for the Study of Human issues. .

            Comments

            Comment on this article