- Record: found
- Abstract: found
- Article: found
Liberal democracy vs. popular democracy in Southern Africa
Abstract
This article accompanies an essay reviewing recent literature on ‘transitions to democracy’, which we publish in our next issue. There Saul contrasts two approaches to the understanding of democratisation. Both see transition as part of a larger political and economic process; for one this limits the possible scope and sustainability of democratisation, while for the other it threatens but also enhances its scope and strength. The latter approach, older and currently less fashionable, sees democratisation (and its analysis) as rooted in processes of imperialism, class struggle and state‐society relations. This ‘political economy of democratisation’ approach, characteristic of the work of Shivji and Saul, contrasts with a larger, more pessimistic body of work, which Saul labels the ‘political science of democratisation’. While sometimes used in suggestive ways, it can narrow debate disastrously when detached from any self‐conscious mooring in the critical traditions of political economy. This literature stresses the necessity of democratic institutions and values, but argues that only highly attenuated versions are currently feasible: ‘if reform is to be adopted without provoking a crisis’, then it must be reform consistent with the demands of capital and the neo‐liberalism of the IFIs.
This companion article analyses two highly significant cases of transition in southern Africa; each seems to epitomise the ‘political science’ approach, yet to contain the longer term possibility of ‘popular democracy’. Thus in South Africa the left accepted the necessity of a carefully negotiated transition to obviate the risk of civil war. However, the ANC, to retain the ‘confidence’ of local and external capital and of foreign governments, has had to demobilise its (non‐electoral) popular support, and to abandon a social redistributive strategy in favour of a one dominated by neo‐liberal ‘market solutions’. What keeps a progressive agenda alive in these conditions are the pressures from trade unions, civics, women's organisations etc, where there are growing signs, at least at grassroots level, of resistance to the ANC's new project. In Mozambique, the transition has been less euphoric, more perhaps a matter of transition from authoritarian rule and from war than to a democratic regime. As in South Africa, the transition would seem to disempower popular forces ‐ but outside the electoral arena, there are instances of resistance and struggle within civil society, which may carry with them the longer‐term potential for the growth of popular democracy.
Content
Author and article information
Bibliography
Adler Glenn and Webster Eddie. . 1995. . ‘Challenging Transition Theory: The Labour Movement, Radical Reform, and the Transition to Democracy in South Africa’. . Politics and Society . , Vol. 23((1)) March;
African National Congress. . 1994. . The Reconstruction and Development Programme . , Johannesburg : : Umanyano Publications. .
Barber Benjamin. . 1984. . Strong Democracy: Participatory Politics for a New Age . , Berkeley and Los Angeles : : University of California Press. .
1995. . Jihad vs. McWorld . , New York and Toronto : : Random House. .
Bengelsdorf Carollee. . 1994. . The Problem of Democracy in Cuba: Between Vision and Reality . , New York and Oxford : : Oxford University Press. .
Bond Patrick. . 1994. . ‘The RDP ‐ a Site for Socialist Struggle’. . The African Communist . , Vol. 137((Second Quarter))
1995. . ‘Under the Microscope: The ANC in Power’. . Southern Africa Report (SAR) (Toronto) . , Vol. 10((3)) March;
Bowen Merle. . 1992. . ‘Beyond Reform: Adjustment and Political Power in Contemporary Mozambique’. . Journal of Modern African Studies . , Vol. 30((2))
Chossudovsky Michel. . 1997. . ‘Exporting Apartheid: Mozambique and Beyond’. . Southern Africa Report . , Vol. 12((2)) February;
Cronin Jeremy. . 1992. . “The boat, the tap and the Leipzig way’. . The African Communist . , Vol. 130((3rd. Quarter))
‘Sell‐Out, or the Culminating Moment? Trying to Make Sense of the Transition’. In: . paper presented to the History Workshop Conference on ‘Democracy: Popular Precedents, Practice, Culture’; . July. 1994 ; , Johannesburg . . University of the Witwatersrand. .
Diamond L. . 1993. . “‘Three Paradoxes of Democracy’. ”. In The Global Resurgence of Democracy . , Edited by: Diamond and Plattner Marc F. . Baltimore : : Johns Hopkins. .
Fraser Nancy. . 1995. . ‘From Redistribution to Recognition? Dilemmas of Justice in a “Post‐Socialist” Age’. . New Left Review . , Vol. 212: July‐August;
Friedman Steven. . 1993a. . ‘South Africa's Reluctant Transition’. . journal of Democracy . , Vol. 4((2)) April;
1993b. . The long journey: South Africa's quest for a negotiated settlement . , Braamfontein : : Raven Press. .
Friedman Steven and Atkinson Doreen. , eds. 1994. . The small miracle: South Africa's negotiated settlement . , Braamfontein : : Ravan Press. .
Giliomee Herman. . 1995. . ‘Democratization in South Africa’. . Political Science Quarterly . , Vol. 110((1))
Gondangwana Enoch and Jordan Pallo. . 1993. . contributions (at pages 86 and 92 respectively) to the debate entitled ‘Social democracy or democratic socialism’ featured in. . South African Labour Bulletin . , Vol. 17((6)) November‐December;
Green Philip. . 1989. . Retrieving Democracy: In Search of Civil Equality . , London : : Methuen. .
Hanlon Joseph. . 1995a. . ‘Acceptable ‐ but was it fair?’. . African Agenda . , Vol. 1((4))
1995b. . ‘A democratic one‐party state’. . African Agenda . , Vol. 1((4))
Hirson Baruch. . 1995. . ‘The Election of a Government’ and ‘South Africa: The State of a Nation’. . Searchlight South Africa . , Vol. 12: June;
Hume Cameron. . 1994. . Ending Mozambique's War: The Role of Mediation and Good Offices . , Washington : : United States Institute for Peace. .
Jacobson Ruth. . November. 1994 . “‘Dancing Towards a Better Future? Gender and the 1994 Mozambican Elections’. ”. November. , Norwegian Agency for Development Cooperation. .
Johnstone Frederick. . 1992. . ‘Quebeckers, Mohawks and Zulus: Liberal Federalism and Free Trade’. . Telos . , Vol. 93: Fall;
1994. . ‘New World Disorder: Fear, Freud and Federalism’. . Telos . , Vol. 100: Summer;
Landsberg Chris. . 1994. . “‘Directing from the stalls? The international community and the South African negotiation forum’. ”. Edited by: Friedman and Atkinson. .
Leys Colin. . 1994. . ‘Confronting the African Tragedy’. . New Left Review . , Vol. 204: March‐April;
Leys Colin and Saul John S. . 1994. . Namibia's Liberation Struggle: The Two‐Edged Sword . , London : : James Currey. .
Loxley John and Seddon David. . 1994. . ‘Stranglehold on Africa’. . Review of African Political Economy . , Vol. 62:
Macpherson C B. . 1972. . “‘Politics: Post‐Liberal Democracy’. ”. In Ideology in Social Science . , Edited by: Blackburn Robin. . London : : Fontana. .
Marshall Judith. . 1992. . War, debt and structural adjustment in Mozambique . , Ottawa : : North‐South Institute. .
Matleff Judith. . 1995. . ‘South African Blacks Ask Why They Should Vote’. . Christian Science Monitor . , February 17;
Mazula Brazao. , ed. 1995. . “‘Mozambique: Eleiçøes, Democracia e Desenvolvimento’. ”. Maputo : : Inter‐Africa Group. .
Miliband Ralph. . 1994. . Socialism for a Sceptical Age . , London : : Verso. .
Minter William. . 1994. . Apartheid's Contrast An Inquiry into the Roots of War in Angola and Mozambique . , London : : Zed Books. .
1995. . ‘Winner takes all’. . Mozambique Peace Process Bulletin . , Vol. 14: February;
O'Laughlin Bridget. . 1992. . ‘Interpretations Matter: Debating the War in Mozambique’. . SAR . , Vol. 7((3)) January;
Ottaway Marina. . 1991. . ‘Liberation Movements and Transition to Democracy’. . Journal of Modern African Studies . , Vol. 29((1))
Plank David. . 1993. . ‘Aid, Debt, and the End of Sovereignty: Mozambique and its Donors’. . Journal of Modern African Studies . , Vol. 31((3))
Reynolds Andrew. , ed. 1994. . Election ‘94 South Africa: The Campaign, Results and Future Prospects . , London : : James Currey. .
Roesch Otto. . 1992. . ‘Mozambique Unravels? The Retreat to Tradition’. . SAR7 . , Vol. 5: May;
John S Saul ( 1993a ), ‘The Frelimo State: From Revolution to Recolonization’ in Saul , 1993b
1993b. . Recolonization and Resistance in Southern Africa in the 1990s . , Trenton : : African World Press. .
Ali Taisier and Mathews Robert. , eds. 1997. . “‘Inside from the Outside: The roots and resolution of Mozambique's un/civil war’. ”. In Civil Wars in Africa . , Kingston and Montreal : : McGill‐Queen's University Press. .
Saunders Richard. . 1995a. . ‘Not by votes alone,’. . African Agenda . , Vol. 1((4))
1995b. . ‘A Hollow Shell: Democracy in Zimbabwe’. . SAR . , Vol. 10((4)) May;
Issa Shivji (ed.) ( 1991a ) State and Constitutionalism: An African Debate on Democracy , especially his own chapters ‘State and Constititonalism: A New Democratic Perspective’ (ch. 2) and ‘Contradictory Class Perspectives in the Debate on Democracy’ (editor's Epilogue) , Harare : SAPES
1991b. . ‘The Democracy Debate in Africa: Tanzania’. . ROAPE . , Vol. 50: March;
Sisk Timothy D. . 1995. . Democratization in South Africa: The Elusive Social Contract . , Princeton : : Princeton University Press. .
Slovo Joe. . 1992. . ‘Negotiations: What room for compromise?‘. . The African Communist . , Vol. 130:
Sparks Alaister. . 1995. . Tomorrow is Another Country: The Inside Story of South Africa's Road to Change . , New York : : Hill and Wang. .
Southall Roger. . 1994. . ‘The South African Elections of 1994: The Remaking of the Dominant‐Party State’. . Journal of Modern African Studies . , Vol. 32((4))
1994. . ‘Mozambique: The Peace Election’. . Southern Africa Report . , Vol. 10((2)) December;
1995. . ‘SA: Concern grows at apathy over voter registration’. . Southscan . , Vol. 10((15)) April, 14;
March 21. 1997a . “‘Unions on confrontation course over labour laws, democracy’. ”. Vol. Vol. 12. , March 21. ,
( 1997b ), ‘Battles ahead as SACP leaders launch broadside at ANC , 12 , 13 ( April 4 ).
Szeftel Morris. . 1994. . ‘‘Negotiated Elections” in South Africa: 1994’. . ROAPE . , Vol. 61:
Vines Alex. . 1994. . “‘No democracy without money: the road to peace in Mozambique (1982–1992)’. ”. London : : Catholic Institute for Intenrnational Relations. .
von Holdt Karl. . 1993. . ‘COSATU Special Congress: The uncertain new era’. . South African Labour Bulletin . , Vol. 17((5)) September‐October;
Wilson Ken. . 1995. . ‘More on Mozambique Now: Not the Whole Story’. . SAR . , Vol. 10((4)) May;
Wood Ellen Meiksins. . 1990. . “‘The Uses and Abuses of ‘Civil Society’. ”. In The Socialist Register 1990: The Retreat of the Intellectuals . , Edited by: Miliband Ralph and Panitch Leo. . London : : Merlin Press. .