- Record: found
- Abstract: found
- Article: found
‘For fear of being condemned as old fashioned’: liberal democracy vs. popular democracy in sub‐saharan Africa
Abstract
This article is a theoretical companion to an essay on the ‘transition to democracy’, which we published in our previous issue, ROAPE72. Here John Saul contrasts two approaches to the understanding of democracy and democratisation, both of which see democratic transition as part of a larger political and economic process, which for one limits the possible scope and sustainability of democratisation, and for the other both threatens but also enhances its scope and strength. The latter approach, older and currently less fashionable, sees democracy and democratisation (and our analysis of them) as rooted in processes of imperialism, class struggle and state‐society relations. This ‘political economy’ of democratisation’ approach, characteristic of the work of Issa Shivji and of John Saul, is contrasted with a larger and more pessimistic body of work, which Saul labels as the ‘political science of democratisation’. Thus Diamond, Huntington, Przeworski, Di Palma and others, while stressing the necessity of democratic institutions and values, at the same time argue that only a highly attenuated version of these is feasible under current (African) conditions, and that ‘if reform is to be adopted without provoking a crisis’ (Diamond), then it must be reform consistent with the demands of capital and the neo‐liberalism of the IFIs: ‘thin’ democracy.
Content
Author and article information
Bibliography
Ake Claude. . 1995. . “‘The New World Order: A View from Africa’. ”. In Whose World Order? Uneven Globalization and the End of the Cold War . , Edited by: Holm Hans‐Henrik and Sorenson George. . Boulder : : Westview Press. .
Allen Chris, Baylies Carolyn and Szeftel Morris. . 1992. . ‘Surviving Democracy?’. . Review of African Political Economy . , Vol. 54:
Anderson Perry. . 1992. . A Zone of Engagement . , London : : Verso. .
Anyang and Nyongo Peter. . 1992. . ‘Democratization Processes in Africa’. . Review of African Political Economy . , Vol. 54:
Barber Benjamin. . 1984. . Strong Democracy: Participatory Politics for a New Age . , Berkeley/ Los Angeles : : University of California Press. .
1995. . Jihad vs. McWorld . , New York/Toronto : : Random House. .
Bayart Jean‐François. . 1986. . “‘Civil Society in Africa’. ”. In Political Domination in Africa: Reflections on the Limits of Power . , Edited by: Chabal Patrick. . Cambridge : : Cambridge University Press. .
Becker David G and Sklar Richard. . 1987. . “‘Why Postimperialism?’. ”. In Postimperialism: International Capitalism and Development in the Late Twentieth Century . , Edited by: Becker David G, Frieden Jeff, Schatz Sayre P and Sklar Richard L. . Boulder/London : : Lynne Rienner. .
Bienefeld Manfred. . 1995. . “‘Structural Adjustment and the Prospects for Democracy in Southern Africa’. ”. Edited by: Moore and Schmitz. .
Burdette Marcia. . 1992. . ‘Democracy vs. Economic Liberalization: The Zambian Dilemma’. . SAR . , Vol. 8((1)) July;
Callaghy Thomas M and Ravenhill John. . 1993. . Hemmed In: Responses to Africa's Economic Decline . , New York : : Columbia University Press. .
Diamond Larry. . 1993a. . “‘Three Paradoxes of Democracy,’. ”. In The Global Resurgence of Democracy . , Edited by: Diamond Larry and Plattner Marc F. . Baltimore : : Johns Hopkins. .
Slater Robert O, Schutz Barry M and Dorr Steven R. , eds. 1993b. . “‘The Globalization of Democracy’. ”. In Global Transformation and the Third World . , Boulder : : Lynne Rienner. .
Di Palma Giuseppe. . 1990. . To Craft Democracies: An Essay on Democratic Transitions . , Berkeley/ Los Angeles : : University of California Press. .
Fraser Nancy. . 1995. . ‘From Redistribution to Recognition? Dilemmas of Justice in a “Post‐Socialist” Age’. . New Left Review . , Vol. 212: July‐August;
George Susan and Sabelli Fabrizio. . 1994. . Faith and Credit: The World Bank's Secular Empire . , London : : Penguin Books. .
Gills Barry, Rocamora Joel and Wilson Richard. . 1993. . Low Intensity Democracy . , London : : Pluto Press. .
Green Philip. . 1989. . Retrieving Democracy: In Search of Civil Equality . , London : : Methuen. .
Hyden Goran. . 1992. . “‘Governance in the Study of Politics’. ”. In Governance and Politics in Africa . , Edited by: Hyden Goran and Bratton Michael. . Boulder : : Lynne Rienner. .
Kaballo Sidgi. . 1995. . ‘Human Rights and Democratization in Africa’. . Political Studies . , Vol. 43:
Leys Colin. . 1994. . ‘Confronting the African Tragedy’. . New Left Review . , Vol. 204: March‐April;
1996. . ‘The world, society and the individual’. . Southern Africa Report . , Vol. 11((3))
Loxley John and Seddon David. . 1994. . ‘Stranglehold on Africa’. . ROAPE . , Vol. 62:
Macpherson C B. . 1972. . “‘Politics: Post‐Liberal Democracy’. ”. In Ideology in Social Science . , Edited by: Blackburn Robin. . London : : Fontana. .
Miliband Ralph. . 1994. . Socialism for a Sceptical Age . , London : : Verso. .
Moore David B and Schmitz Gerald J. . 1995. . Debating Development Discourse: Institutional and Popular Perspectives . , London : : Macmillan. .
Nelson Joan. . 1993. . ‘The Politics of Economic Transformation: Is Third World Experience Relevant in Eastern Europe?’. . World Politics . , Vol. 45((3))
Nzouankeu Jacques‐Mariel. . 1991. . ‘The African attitude to democracy’. . International Social Science Journal . , Vol. 128:
Przeworski Adam. . 1991. . Democracy and the Market . , Cambridge : : Cambridge University Press. .
Robinson William L. . 1996. . Promoting Polyarchy: Globalization, US Intervention and Hegemony . , Cambridge : : Cambridge University Press. .
Saul John S. . 1994. . “‘Globalism, Socialism and Democracy in the South African Transition’. ”. In Socialist Register 1994: Between Globalism and Nationalism . , Edited by: Miliband Ralph and Panitch Leo. . London : : Merlin Press. .
1997. . ‘Liberal Democracy vs. Popular Democracy in Southern Africa’. . ROAPE . , Vol. 72:: 219––36. .
Schmitz Gerard. . 1995. . “‘Democratization and Demystification: Deconstructing “Governance” as Development Discourse’. ”. Edited by: Moore and Schmitz. .
Shivji Issa. . 1991b. . ‘The Democracy Debate in Africa: Tanzania’. . ROAPE . , Vol. 50:
1991a. . State and Constitutionalism: An African Debate on Democracy (especially his own chapter 2) and ‘Epilogue') . , Harare : : SAPES. .
Wood Ellen Meiksins. . 1990. . “‘The Uses and Abuses of ‘Civil Society’. ”. In The Socialist Register 1990: The Retreat of the Intellectuals . , Edited by: Miliband Ralph and Panitch Leo. . London : : Merlin Press. .