113
views
0
recommends
+1 Recommend
1 collections
    0
    shares

      If you have found this article useful and you think it is important that researchers across the world have access, please consider donating, to ensure that this valuable collection remains Open Access.

      Prometheus is published by Pluto Journals, an Open Access publisher. This means that everyone has free and unlimited access to the full-text of all articles from our international collection of social science journalsFurthermore Pluto Journals authors don’t pay article processing charges (APCs).

      scite_
       
      • Record: found
      • Abstract: found
      • Article: found
      Is Open Access

      Federalism in the Regulation of Chemical Pollutants in Australia

      Published
      research-article
      Bookmark

            Abstract

            In response to the growth of the environment movement and increasing citizen concern for the environment, the Commonwealth and the Australian states moved to set up government departments of environment, or Environment Protection Agencies, in the early 1970s. At first the issues which engaged the public were 'green' ones, involving land and marine degradation, biodiversity (a term not then in use), and activities such as logging, mining and the generation of hydro-electric power. These were soon joined on the public agenda, however, by concerns over 'brown' issues such as chemical pollution and the management of hazardous chemicals and chemical wastes, but these were less well understood by the general public than the more visible 'green' issues. At this time, also, Australian governments took significant steps to achieve nationally consistent regulation through the work of ministerial councils, notably the Australian Environment Council (AEC) and subsequently the Australian and New Zealand Environment and Conservation Council (ANZECC). A further wave of environmentalism in the late 1980s and early 1990s, coupled with further development of the federalism model for environmental regulation that flowed from high-level inter-government meetings that were formalised as the Council of Australian Governments (COAG), gave rise to the formation of the National Environment Protection Council (NEPC). This body, while not giving more power to the Commonwealth, achieves national harmonisation of regulations through slightly more coercive processes than are available to the older-style ministerial councils. These continue to exist, however, operating in parallel with NEPC. For chemicals coming into use, there are national schemes under which the Commonwealth, states and territories regulated industrial, agricultural and veterinary chemicals, therapeutic substances, and food additives. Most 'brown' issues, however, remain with the successor to ANZECC, the Environment Protection and Heritage Council, as part of which NEPC continues to develop national approaches. In both periods of rapid change, there was a coincidence of environmentalism and federalism, but international developments were also important--in the first phase the United Nations' first 'environment' meeting, held in 1972 in Stockholm, and in the second the developments flowing from the so-called 'Earth Summit' held in Rio de Janeiro in 1992. Although public environmentalism continues to be mainly concerned with 'green' issues, the 'brown' issues remain a focus for governments and some non-government organisations.

            Content

            Author and article information

            Journal
            cpro20
            CPRO
            Prometheus
            Critical Studies in Innovation
            Pluto Journals
            0810-9028
            1470-1030
            June 2003
            : 21
            : 2
            : 247-264
            Article
            10032493 Prometheus, Vol. 21, No. 2, June 2003, pp. 247-264
            10.1080/08109020308128
            1b8da1f6-1251-4383-b075-a1f2e5dec10d
            Copyright Taylor & Francis Group, LLC

            All content is freely available without charge to users or their institutions. Users are allowed to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of the articles in this journal without asking prior permission of the publisher or the author. Articles published in the journal are distributed under a http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

            History
            Page count
            Figures: 0, Tables: 0, References: 63, Pages: 18
            Categories
            Original Articles

            Computer science,Arts,Social & Behavioral Sciences,Law,History,Economics
            Waste Chemicals,Pollution,National-international Influences,Commonwealth-state Cooperation,Regulation,Policy

            References

            1. Matthews B.. 1999. . Federation . , Melbourne : : Text Publishing. .

            2. Crisp L. F.. 1983. . Australian National Government, . , 5th edition. , p. 83––4. . Melbourne : : Longman Cheshire. .

            3. Powell J. M.. 1977. . Mirrors of the New World. Images and Image-makers in the Settlement Process . , p. 119––43. . Dawson : : Archon Books. .

            4. 2001. . State of the Environment, Australia 2001 . , Collingwood : : CSIRO Publishing. .

            5. 1996. . State of the Environment, Australia 1996 . , Collingwood : : CSIRO Publishing. .

            6. 1987. . State of the Environment in Australia 1986 . , Canberra : : (Department of Arts, Heritage and Environment), Australian Government Publishing Service. .

            7. Walker K. J.. , ed. 1992. . Australian Environmental Policy. Ten Case Studies . , Kensington , NSW : : New South Wales University Press Ltd. .

            8. Walker K.J.. 1999. . Australian Environmental Policy 2. Studies in Decline, Devolution . , Edited by: Crowley K.. Kensington , NSW : : University of New South Wales Press Ltd. .

            9. Papadakis E.. 1993. . Politics and the Environment. The Australian Experience . , St Leonards , NSW : : Alien & Unwin. .

            10. Galligan B. and Fletcher C.. New Federalism, Intergovernmental Relations and Environmental Policy . , Commonwealth of Australia Coastal Zone Inquiry. .

            11. Painter M.. 1998. . Collaborative Federalism. Economic Reform in Australia in the 1990s . , Cambridge : : Cambridge University Press. .

            12. Hutton D. and Connors L.. 1999. . A History of the Australian Environment Movement . , Melbourne : : Cambridge University Press. .

            13. Papadakis E.. 1996. . Environmental Politics and Institutional Change . , Cambridge : : Cambridge University Press. .

            14. Unglik A.. 1996. . Between a Rock and a Hard Place. The Story of the Development of the EPA . , Melbourne : : Environment Protection Authority. .

            15. Horsman D.. 1995. . 'Environmental reform-the regulatory scene nationwide'. In: . paper read at UR Conference held at Sydney; . March. 1995 ; .

            16. Dingle T. and Rasmussen C.. 1991. . Vital Connections. Melbourne and its Board of Works 1891-1991 . , Ringwood : : McPhee Gribble/Penguin. .

            17. Goodman R. and Low N.. 1995. . 'The management and disposal of hazardous waste in Victoria'. . Urban Policy and Research . , Vol. 13((1)): 48––56. .

            18. O'Brien B. J.. 1994. . Environmental Strategies: 'East-West' Tensions Within Australia . , Perth : : Eco Ethics, Brian J. O'Brien & Associates Ply Ltd. .

            19. O'Brien B.. 1995. . 'East/West tensions: the missing link in Australian environmental strategies'. . ATSE Foots (Australian Academy of Technological Sciences and Engineering) . , Vol. 85: January/ February;: 4––12. .

            20. Fisher D. E.. 1980. . Environmental Law in Australia. An Introduction . , p. 19––30. . St Lucia : : University of Queensland Press. .

            21. Clark S., Crommelin M. and Saunders C.. , eds. 1991. . The Constitution and the Environment . , Parkville : : Centre for Comparative Constitutional Studies, University of Melbourne. .

            22. Barrie D. P.. 1992. . Environmental Protection in Federal States. Interjurisdictional Cooperation in Canada and Australia . , (Federalism Research Centre Discussion Paper No. 18). Canberra : : Australian National University. .

            23. Mathews R. L.. , ed. 1985. . Federalism and the Environment . , Canberra : : Centre for Research on Federal Financial Relations, Australian National University. .

            24. Tighe P. J.. “'Hydroindustrialisation and conservation policy in Tasmania'. ”. Edited by: Walker. . p. 124––55. .

            25. Lowe D.. 1984. . The Price of Power. The Politics Behind the Tasmanian Dams Case . , South Melbourne : : Macmillan. .

            26. Beder S.. 1993. . The Nature of Sustainable Development . , p. 94––6. . Newham , NSW : : Scribe Publications. .

            27. Opie H. O.. 1976. . 'Commonwealth power to regulate industrial pollution'. . Melbourne University Law Review . , Vol. 10:: 577––613. .

            28. Powell J. M.. 1976. . Environmental Management in Australia, 1788-1914 . , Melbourne : : Oxford University Press. .

            29. Reid G. S. and Forrest M.. 1989. . Australia's Commonwealth Parliament 1901-1988. Ten Perspectives . , p. 368––81. . p. 393––97. . Melbourne : : Melbourne University Press. .

            30. 1970. . Report of the Senate Select Committee on Air Pollution . , (Commonwealth Parliamentary Paper No. 91 of 1970). Canberra : : Commonwealth Government Printing Office. .

            31. Water Pollution in Australia. . 1970. . Report from the Senate Select Committee on Water Pollution . , Canberra : : Commonwealth Government Printing Office. .

            32. 1977. . Review of the Report of the Senate Select Committee on Air Pollution . , Canberra : : The Acting Commonwealth Government Printer. .

            33. Department of Territories, Air Pollution Ordnance. . 1986. . Annual Report 1984-85 . , Canberra : : Australian Government Publishing Service. .

            34. Glascott J.. 1972. . 'In a Labor environment…'. . The Australian . , 4 May;: 6

            35. 1986. . Register of Commonwealth-State Co-operative Arrangements, . , 4th revised edition. , Hobart : : Advisory Council for Intergovernmental Relations. .

            36. Painter M.. 1995. . The Council of Australian Governments and Intergovernmental Cooperation-Competitive or Collaborative Federalism . , (Federalism Research Centre Discussion Paper No. 28). p. 9p. 13 Canberra : : Australian National University. .

            37. 1972. . Summary Report of Australian Delegation to the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment . , Canberra : : Australian Government Publishing Service. .

            38. Glascott J.. 1972. . 'Now that the environment is here …'. . The Australian . , 2 May;: 6

            39. Hodges J.. 1980. . seminar papers of the 13th annual conference of the Queensland Regional Group of the Royal Institute of Public Administration, entitled Relations Between Levels of Government; . . 1980 ; . pp.p. 13––6. .

            40. Makeham P. M. and Cook G. E.. 1978. . “'Management of air quality'. ”. In Managing the Environment . , Edited by: Crawford P. J.. p. 25––40. . Canberra : : Australian Government Printing Service. .

            41. 1986. . Guide to Environmental Legislation and Administrative Arrangements in Australia, . , second edition. , (Australian Environment Council Report No. 18). Canberra : : Australian Government Publishing Service. .

            42. Graham Deacons and James for the Australian and New Zealand Environment and Conservation Council. . 1997. . Guide to Environmental Legislation in Australia and New Zealand: A Summary and Brief Description of Environment Protection and Related Legislation of the Federal, State and Territory Governments of Australia and New Zealand, . , 5th edition. , (ANZECC Report No. 31). Canberra : : ANZECC. .

            43. Australian Environment Council and Council of Nature Conservation Ministers. . 1982. . Australian Achievements in Environment Protection and Nature Conservation . , Canberra : : Australian Government Printing Service. .

            44. House of Representatives Standing Committee on Environment and Conservation. . March. 1982 . Hazardous Chemical Wastes-Storage, Transport and Disposai First Report of the Inquiry into Hazardous Chemicals . , March. , Canberra : : Australian Government Publishing Service. .

            45. December. 1982 . Second Report of the Inquiry into Hazardous Chemicals . , December. , Canberra : : Australian Government Publishing Service. .

            46. House of Representatives Standing Committee on Environment and Conservation. . October. 1982 . Australia's Participation in International Environmental Organisations . , October. , Canberra : : Australian Government Publishing Service. .

            47. Third Meeting of the OECD Environment Committee at Ministerial LeveL Report by the Australian Delegation; . Canberra : : Australian Government Publishing Service. .

            48. Kelly P.. 1994. . The End of Certainty. Power, Politics and Business in Australia, . , revised edition. , p. 524––43. . St Leonards , NSW : : Alien & Unwin. .

            49. Pakulski J. and Crook S.. 1998. . Ebbing of the Green Tide? Envimnmentaiism, Public Opinion and the Media in Australia . , Hobart : : School of Sociology and Social Work, University of Tasmania. .

            50. Hodge A.. 2001. . 'Green concern down, action up'. . The Australian . , 23 November;: 4

            51. Hawke R. J. L.. 1989. . Our Country Our Future . , Canberra : : Australian Government Publishing Service. .

            52. 1989. . 'Government plan for the environment'. . Australian Foreign Affairs and Trade . , Vol. 60((7)): 333––8. .

            53. 1999. . Commonwealth Environment Powers . , (Report of the Senate Environment, Communications, Information Technology and the Arts References Committee). p. 73––85. . Canberra : : Senate Printing Unit. .

            54. Crommelin M.. 1987. . Commontuealth Involvement in Environment Policy: Past, Present and Future, Intergovernmental Relations in Victoria Program . , Parkville : : University of Melbourne. .

            55. Anton D. K., Kohout J. and Pain N.. 1993. . 'Nationalizing environmental protection in Australia: the international dimensions'. . Environmental Lam . , Vol. 23:: 763––84. .

            56. 1998. . OECD Environmental Performance Review of Australia . , Paris : : Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. .

            57. Robinson N. A., Hassan P. and Burhenne-Guilmin F.. 1992-93. . The Rio Declaration on Environment and Development and Agenda 21 . , Vol. six volumes. , New York : : Oceana Publications. .

            58. 1990. . 'ALP pledges funds boost for pollution'. . The Australian . , 19 March;: 4

            59. 1990. . 'The Green Guide. What the parties are offering and what the conservationists want'. . The Australian . , 20 March;: 8

            60. 1990. . The Australian . , 22 May;: 4

            61. 1990. . presentation at the 'Building Bridges' seminar; . May 21– 1990 ; , Sydney . .

            62. Sawer G.. 1994. . “'Conservation and the law'. ”. In Conservation, . , revised edition. , Edited by: Coster A. B. and Frith H. J.. p. 268––83. . Blackburn , Victoria : : Penguin Books. .

            63. Fowler R. J.. 1991. . Proposal for a Federal Environment Protection Agency . , Fitzroy , Victoria : : Australian Conservation Foundation. .

            Comments

            Comment on this article