The Case
We report the case of a 51-year-old man affected by End Stage Renal Disease due to
diabetic nephropathy, who received a kidney transplantation from a deceased donor.
After induction with basiliximab and high dose intravenous methylprednisolone boluses,
the patient was on maintenance immunosuppression with methylprednisolone, tacrolimus
and everolimus. Everolimus was chosen in order to minimize calcineurin inhibitor levels
in a patient with a long history of post-surgical diabetes mellitus. Major comorbidities
and other medications are reported in the Supplementary Materials.
Two months after transplantation, the patient started suffering from dyspnoea and
haemoptysis, in the absence of other associated symptoms. He was conscious, hemodynamically
stable and apyretic, and rhinopharyingeal swab for Sars-CoV-2 was negative. During
this period, everolimus and tacrolimus trough levels always remained within the optimal
ranges (3–8 ng/ml and 2–4 ng/ml, respectively). Chest auscultation revealed diffuse
inspiratory crackles and expiratory wheezing in both lungs. Chest X-ray showed bilateral
alveolar micronodules with interstitial thickening. Subsequently the patient underwent
high resolution CT scan (HRCT) that showed bilateral multiple “ground-glass” areas
and infiltrates consistent with alveolar haemorrhage (Fig. 1: day 1 (a), day 17 (b),
day 20 (c) and at 2-month follow up (d)).
Fig. 1
HRCT scan on day 1 (a), day 17 (b), day 20 (c) and at a 2-month follow up (d).
Empiric antibiotic therapy with piperacillin/tazobactam was started though with no
response. Five days later, blood tests showed severe anaemia (Hb 7.2 g/dL), renal
function impairment (eGFR 21 ml/min vs 35 ml/min), with normal white blood cell and
platelet counts and C-reactive protein levels.
Everolimus was discontinued and the patient was admitted to the Nephrology Unit: arterial
blood gas analysis showed severe respiratory insufficiency requiring high-flux oxygen
therapy. A red blood cell transfusion was performed. Further blood tests documented
negative ANA, ANCA and AntiGBM antibodies. Blood and sputum cultures were negative,
as were Quantiferon TB and polymerase chain reaction for CMV, EBV and BKV DNA.
Fibrobroncoscopy was performed and broncho-alveolar lavage (BAL) showed progressively
more bloody samples, typical of diffuse alveolar haemorrhage, which tested negative
for bacterial, viral and fungal cultures; cytological evaluation detected several
hemosiderin-laden macrophages (>20%) (Fig. 2).
Fig. 2
Bloody samples from broncho-alveolar lavage fluid
During hospitalization his clinical picture progressively improved with normalization
of gas exchanges. Follow-up HRCT revealed global regression of the pathologic findings,
albeit without complete resolution. Considering the rapid response to everolimus discontinuation,
once other infectious and immunological differential diagnoses were excluded, a diagnosis
of everolimus-related non-infectious pneumonitis was made.
Therapy with high-dose intravenous steroids was considered, but not prescribed due
to the rapid improvement of the clinical picture. The patient was discharged under
immunosuppression with methylprednisolone and tacrolimus.
However, the patient was re-admitted ten days later due to a relapse of dyspnoea,
haemoptysis and asthenia. New blood tests showed a relapse of severe anaemia and HRCT
revealed worsening of the “ground-glass”-like areas and alveolar haemorrhage.
Pulses of intravenous steroids the clinical picture progressively improved up to complete
resolution of symptoms, that led to hospital discharge.
Rapid tapering of steroids to the maintenance dose (predsnisone 5 mg daily) was carried
out and currently, after 12 months of follow-up, no relapse has occurred.
Clinical course is summarised in Fig. 3.
Fig. 3
Timeline of clinical course and drug administration
Lesson for the clinical nephrologist
Adverse events observed in patients undergoing systemic treatment with mammalian target
of rapamycin (mTOR) inhibitors include pulmonary dysfunction (non-infectious pneumonitis),
epithelial-cutaneous events (stomatitis, rash), metabolic dysfunction (elevated blood
levels of glucose and lipids), and immune suppression (infections).
MTOR inhibitors are commonly used for cancer treatment and as immunosuppressants to
prevent rejection of solid organ transplants. Everolimus, sirolimus and temsirolimus
belong to this class of drugs and are generally well tolerated (1).
The most common side effects related to everolimus include stomatitis, cutaneous rash,
metabolic dysfunction, infections, oedema, proteinuria and difficult wound healing
(2), while pulmonary toxicity is a rare complication that occurs in up to 16% of patients
receiving this mTORi as chemotherapy and in 4.3% of transplant recipients receiving everolimus
as an immunosuppressant (1, 3).
The cause of this potentially serious adverse event is not yet fully understood. Rapamycin
and its derivatives can induce autophagy in cells by inhibiting mTORC1, thus causing
phosphorylation of pro-autophagic kinases and determining autophagosome formation
and possible exposure of antigens on alveolar endothelial cells,which may explain
a lymphocyte-mediated toxicity (4). On the other hand, the clinical response to corticosteroids
and discontinuation of everolimus, together with T-cell lymphocytosis often reported
in bronchoalveolar lavage, suggests a hypersensitivity mechanism (1). According to
another hypothesis, the high affinity of sirolimus for plasma proteins may render
it immunogenic as a hapten, thus triggering a T-cell reaction against the antigen
complex (5). Direct toxicity may be suggested by the greater rates of pneumonitis
occurring in patients receiving high doses of mTORi and by the fact that discontinuation
of therapy is necessary to allow early remission of the symptoms (6, 7). Furthermore,
pulmonary toxicity does not seem to be related to longer drug exposure and/or higher
blood levels, since many reports of pneumonia are described in patients whose everolimus
levels are within therapeutic range (4, 6).
Once the diagnosis is made, clinical management largely depends on the severity of
the symptoms. Light to moderate cases usually benefit from drug dose reduction or
discontinuation and oral corticosteroid therapy (7), while the literature regarding
a therapeutic shift from everolimus to another mTORi is controversial (7, 8). Patients
with severe to potentially deadly clinical pictures showed good response to everolimus
discontinuation and high-dose intravenous corticosteroid therapy, which should be
administered while the evaluation is on-going if there is a solid clinical suspicion
of non-infectious pneumonitis (1, 7).
We report the case of a transplant recipient who developed severe respiratory insufficiency
due to alveolar haemorrhage, confirmed by fibrobronchoscopy, under everolimus treatment.
Bacteriological, mycobacteriological and viral tests allowed excluding the most common
infectious aetiologies; auto-immune study was also negative. The clinical picture
was not modified by broad spectrum antibiotic therapy, and indeed, it was responsive
to everolimus discontinuation. After observing an initial rapid clinical resolution
of symptoms and radiological signs of improvement, a relapse of the clinical picture
occurred almost 20 days after the discontinuation of everolimus, which resolved only
after intravenous pulse steroids. Relapse of symptoms after everolimus discontinuation
might lead us to speculate that the first diagnosis was wrong, however, after this
episode no other relapses were observed during 12 months of follow-up with standard
low-dose steroid maintenance therapy.
Non-infectious pneumonia related to everolimus is a rare and potentially harmful complication
that must always be considered in the differential diagnosis in patients receiving
mTOR inhibitors and complaining of non-specific respiratory symptoms, with or without
systemic conditions like fever or asthenia. Accurate management of this class-related
side effect is crucial, and the clinical approach must be tailored to the severity
of the condition. Pulmonary function tests were not performed in the reported case.
Of note, the use of diffusing capacity of the lung for carbon monoxide (DLCO) combined
with HRCT scan has been proposed in an algorithm for surveillance of fragile patients
(such as recipients of solid organ transplants), especially when more than one drug
with known pulmonary potential toxicity is simultaneously administered (9).
This is not the first reported case of everolimus-related pneumonitis in the literature,
however, it may suggest paying attention to some peculiar aspects: the severity of
presentation with alveolar haemorrhage and a late relapse after drug discontinuation.
Improvement of symptoms should not be overestimated since relapse is possible, and
the most severe cases, lithe the one here described, may require high dose intravenous
steroid administration to achieve complete remission.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Supplementary file1 (DOCX 13 kb)