Pyrogen Transfer across High- and Low-flux Hemodialysis Membranes

Hemodialysis is a common but potentially hazardous procedure. From February 17 to 20, 1996, 116 of 130 patients (89 percent) at a dialysis center (dialysis center A) in Caruaru, Brazil, had visual disturbances, nausea, and vomiting associated with hemodialysis. By March 24, 26 of the patients had died of acute liver failure. A case patient was defined as any patient undergoing dialysis at dialysis center A or Caruaru's other dialysis center (dialysis center B) during February 1996 who had acute liver failure. To determine the risk factors for and the source of the outbreak, we conducted a cohort study of the 130 patients at dialysis center A and the 47 patients at dialysis center B, reviewed the centers' water supplies, and collected water, patients' serum, and postmortem liver tissue for microcystin assays. One hundred one patients (all at dialysis center A) met the case definition, and 50 died. Affected patients who died were older than those who survived (median age, 47 vs. 35 years, P<0.001). Furthermore, all 17 patients undergoing dialysis on the Tuesday-, Thursday-, and Saturday-night schedule became ill, and 13 of them (76 percent) died. Both centers received water from a nearby reservoir. However, the water supplied to dialysis center B was treated, filtered, and chlorinated, whereas the water supplied to dialysis center A was not. Microcystins produced by cyanobacteria were detected in water from the reservoir and from dialysis center A and in serum and liver tissue of case patients. Water used for hemodialysis can contain toxic materials, and its quality should therefore be carefully monitored.

Routine sodium bicarbonate-buffered dialysate is contaminated with predominantly gram-negative micro-organisms. These bacteria release pyrogenic substances such as endotoxins, peptidoglycans, exotoxins and fragments thereof. Pyrogens derived from contaminated dialysate either alone or in costimulation with activated complement components are the most important activators of circulating mononuclear cells in patients on chronic intermittent hemodialysis. Activated mononuclear cells release proinflammatory cytokines which are key mediators in acute and chronic inflammatory diseases associated with long-term hemodialysis therapy. Recent experimental and clinical data suggest that the use of pyrogen-free dialysate prevents activation of mononuclear cells and improves the state of chronic inflammation, as indicated by decreased plasma levels of C-reactive protein in chronic hemodialysis patients. Future clinical studies have to prove whether the use of pyrogen-free dialysate in combination with biocompatible dialyzer membranes and tubings reduces the incidence and severity of chronic inflammatory diseases (β 2 -microglobulin amyloidosis, muscle protein wasting, atherosclerosis) in long-term hemodialysis patients.

Repetitive exposure to cytokine-inducing substances (pyrogens) results in chronic inflammation, which may significantly contribute to some of the long-term complications in dialysis patients. On-line dialysis modalities, such as on-line haemodiafiltration (HDF), raise particular concerns because of the administration of infusate prepared from potentially contaminated dialysis fluid. Hence, great retention capability for pyrogens is of critical importance for the safe performance of on-line systems. The microbiological safety of a novel on-line system, ONLINEplus(TM), was assessed in clinical practice in five centres for 3 months. Infusate and dialysis fluid were regularly monitored for microbial counts, endotoxins, and cytokine-inducing activity. Levels of interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra) were determined in supernatants of whole blood incubated either under pyrogen-free conditions (spontaneous cytokine production) or following low-dose endotoxin exposure (LPS-stimulated cytokine production). We failed to detect microorganisms or endotoxin contamination of infusate during the entire study period. Moreover, neither infusate nor dialysis fluid demonstrated cytokine-inducing activity. Intradialytic IL-1Ra induction was not detected, as there was no difference between pre- and post-session values for both spontaneous and LPS-stimulated IL-1Ra production (115+/-26 vs 119+/-27 and 2445+/-353 vs 2724+/-362 pg/10(6) white blood cells (WBC), respectively). Neither the number of immunocompetent cells nor their capacity to produce IL-1Ra declined during this period, indicating that cells were not significantly stimulated during treatment. Spontaneous and LPS-induced exvivo IL-1Ra generation remained unchanged after 3 months of on-line HDF therapy as compared with the start of the study (71+/-30 pre- vs 48+/-14 post-study, and 2559+/-811 vs 2384+/-744 pg/10(6) WBC, respectively). The present on-line system performed safely from a microbiological view-point as both the dialysis fluid and infusate were consistently free of microorganisms, endotoxins, and cytokine-inducing substances. As a result, on-line HDF therapy had no effect upon the chronic inflammatory responses in end-stage renal disease patients.