To the Editor: Vitiligo is not a fatal disease; however, it can have strong social
and psychological impacts on the patients. Genetic susceptibility, autoimmunity, neural
dysregulation, melanin self-destruction, and oxidative stress may be involved in the
pathogenesis of vitiligo. Based on its clinical development, vitiligo can be divided
into the progressive vitiligo (PV) or the stable vitiligo (SV). To date, at least
50 susceptible genes had been found in vitiligo.[1] However, only a few genes presented
a clear association with the high inherent risk of vitiligo and the protein levels
of these genes were scarce. Recently, combination methods had been introduced in order
to obtain better results. Nevertheless, no validated tool could confirm on the stage
of vitiligo. Proteomics is a useful tool for large-scale screening of disease-related
proteins. It could provide a better understanding of the biological and molecular
events for this disease. Isobaric tag for relative and absolute quantitation (iTRAQ)
is a systematic protein quantitative analytical method. It has the highest flux, the
smallest system error, and the most powerful function for diagnosis, treatment, and
prognosis. In this study, we identified differentially expressed proteins using iTRAQ-based
proteomic technology and constructed an interaction network for SV and PV with the
aim to identify potential group proteins as markers to distinguish between SV and
PV.
All the patients and healthy controls were enrolled at the Dermatological Outpatient
Clinic of the First Hospital of China Medical University from 2015 to 2016. Vitiligo
was diagnosed clinically by experienced dermatologists. Staging of the disease was
performed according to the Vitiligo Disease Activity Score (VIDA) in the Consensus
of Vitiligo Diagnosis and Treatment (2014 edition) issued by the Dermatology Committee
of Pigmentary Disease of the Chinese Association of Integrative Medicine. Patients
with PV (VIDA score over 2 points) showed emergence of new skin lesions expansion
of the original skin lesions or occurrence of the Koebner phenomenon within three
months. Patients with SV were defined as those with stable lesions for at least one
year. The sites and progression of the lesions and the extent of cutaneous involvement
were documented.
Clinical information of the patients with PV and SV are presented in Supplementary
Tables 1 and 2. Ten serum samples from each group were pooled together for proteomic
experiments. The remaining 20 serum samples were used in Western blotting experiments
for verification of results.
Supplementary Table 1
Characteristics of patients with PV
Number
Gender
Age (years)
Time of new-onset
Site
Koebner phenomenon
Family history
Patient 1
Male
17
Nearly 1 month
e, f, k, l
Yes
No
Patient 2
Male
29
Nearly 3 months
a, b, c, e, f
Yes
Yes
Patient 3
Female
33
Nearly 1 month
a, b, c, e, f, g, j, k, l
Yes
No
Patient 4
Female
24
Nearly 1 month
e, f, k, l
Yes
No
Patient 5
Female
19
Nearly 1 month
a, b, c, f, k, l
No
Yes
Patient 6
Male
41
Nearly 4 months
a, b, c, g, k, l
Yes
No
Patient 7
Female
38
Nearly 2 months
a, b, d, e, f, k, l
Yes
No
Patient 8
Male
29
Nearly 1 month
g, i, j
No
No
Patient 9
Female
33
Nearly 3 months
a, b, c, d, e, f, g, k, l
Yes
No
Patient 10
Male
26
Nearly 6 months
e, f, k, l
Yes
No
The VIDA integral: Nearly 6 weeks appear new lesions or lesions expand (+4), nearly
3 months appear new lesions or lesions expand (+3), nearly 6 months appear new lesions
or lesions expand (+2); nearly 1 year appear new lesions or lesions expand (+1). Score
>1 points is progression, >4 points for the rapid progression. All patients have no
autoimmune disease. Vitiligo in the progressive stage included 12 cases of sporadic
vitiligo (40.0%), 10 cases of acrofacial (33.3%), and 8 cases of universal (26.7%),
they are 5 males and 5 females. a: Head (3%); b: Face (3%); c: Neck (3%); d: Upperarm
(7%); e: Forearm (6%); f: Hands (5%); g: Trunk (26%); h: Perineum (1%); i: Hip (5%);
j: Thigh (21%); k: Shin (13%); l: Feet (7%). VIDA: Vitiligo Disease Activity Score;
PV: Progressive vitiligo.
Supplementary Table 2
Characteristics of patients with SV
Number
Gender
Age
Time of stable phase (years)
Site
Koebner phenomenon
Family history
Patient 11
Male
27
>10
e, f, k, l
No
Yes
Patient 12
Female
38
>10
a, b, c, e, f, g, i, j, k, l
No
No
Patient 13
Female
43
>20
a, b, c, e, f, l
No
No
Patient 14
Female
20
>4
a, b, c, e, f
No
No
Patient 15
Female
16
>5
a, b, c, f, k, l
No
No
Patient 16
Male
33
>10
a, b, c, e, f, k, l
No
No
Patient 17
Male
47
>10
a, b, c, d, e, f, g, k, l
No
No
Patient 18
Female
34
>20
g, i, j
No
Yes
Patient 19
Female
26
>10
g, i, j, k, l
No
No
Patient 20
Male
29
>10
a, b, c, e, f, k, l
No
No
The evaluation of the criterion in SV is set by disease activity score (VIDA). Depigmentation
phase was stable for >1 year (0 score), at the same time, there is spontaneous pigment
regeneration (−1). All patients have no autoimmune disease. Vitiligo in the stable
stage included 14 cases of sporadic vitiligo (46.7%), 8 cases of acrofacial (26.7%),
8 cases of universal (26.7%), they are 4 males and 6 females. a: Head (3%); b: Face
(3%); c: Neck (3%); d: Upperarm (7%); e: Forearm (6%); f: Hands (5%); g: Trunk (26%);
h: Perineum (1%); i: Hip (5%); j: Thigh (21%); k: Shin (13%); l: Feet (7%). VIDA:
Vitiligo disease activity score; SV: Stable vitiligo.
Pooled serum samples from each group were prepared before proteomic analysis. The
ProteoPrep Blue Albumin and IgG Depletion kit (Sigma-Aldrich, Co., St. Louis, MO,
USA) were used to remove albumin, and IgG protein concentration was estimated using
the BCA Protein Assay Kit (Thermo Scientific, Rockford, California, USA). Total proteins
of each group were analyzed by iTRAQ (AB Sciex, Framingham, Massachusetts, USA), liquid
chromatography-mass spectrometry/mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). Protein samples (100
μg) were reduced, alkylated, and subjected to tryptic hydrolysis. iTRAQ labeling was
performed using iTRAQ Reagents manufacturer's protocol. Each sample was labeled with
the respective iTRAQ tags. All the labeled peptides were merged and evaporated to
dryness in a vacuum centrifuge.
The iTRAQ labelled samples were firstly diluted to 100 μl with H2O buffer (NH3•H2O,
pH=10) before high performance liquid chromatography on a Dionex Ultimate 3000 system
(Dionex, Sunnyvale, CA, USA) at 25°C on a Gemini NX 3u C18 110A; 150.0 mm × 2.0 mm
Phenomenex column, and Gemini 3u C6 Phenyl 110A; 100.0 mm × 2.0 mm column (all from
Phenomenex, Torrance, CA, USA). The flow rate used for reversed-phase column separation
was 0.2 ml/min with H2O (mobile Phase A) and 80% ACN (mobile Phase B). A solvent gradient
system was used: 0–15 min, 5–10% B; 15–48 min, 15–25% B; 48–60 min, 25–37% B; 60–65
min, 37–95% B; and 65–70 min, 95% B. The elution was monitored by absorbance at 214/280
nm, and fractions were collected every 50 s. In total, 10 fractions were combined
and dried.
Peptides were separated by a linear gradient according to the manufacture's instruction.
MS analysis was performed on a Q Exactive system (Thermo Fisher Scientific, California,
USA) in information-dependent mode. MS spectra were acquired across the mass range
of 350–1800 m/z in high-resolution mode (>35,000); a maximum of 20 precursors per
cycle were chosen for fragmentation from each MS spectrum with a 120-ms minimum accumulation
time for each precursor and dynamic exclusion for 10s. The tandem mass spectra were
recorded in high-sensitivity mode (resolution >175,000) with rolling collision energy
and iTRAQ reagent collision energy adjustments.
Proteins extracted from the serum samples of 20 patients with SV, 20 patients with
PV, and 20 healthy controls were separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide
gel electrophoresis (11–15% acrylamide). After transferring the blots onto PVDF membranes
and blocking overnight (5% skim milk and 0.05% Tween-20 in PBS), the primary antibody
was added for 1 h, followed by PBS washing, addition of a secondary HRP-conjugated
antibody, and development with a chemiluminescence detection system (ECL, Pierce,
USA). Anti-plasma serine protease inhibitor (SERPINA5), hepatocyte growth factor activator
(HGFAC), anti-leucine zipper protein 4 (LUZP4), and anti-phosphoinositide phospholipase
C (PLCH2) were used (Abcam, USA).
The interaction network of differentially expressed proteins was constructed by the
Cytoscape (National Institute of General Medical Sciences, USA), which is an open
source software platform for visualizing molecular interaction networks and biological
pathways and integrating these networks with annotations. The differentially expressed
proteins involved in biological processes, molecular functions, cell components, and
pathway enrichment were evaluated using the Cytoscape platform based on Gene Ontology
(GO) terms. The corresponding P value analysis was simultaneously obtained using ReactomeFIViz
(National Institute of General Medical Sciences).
The peptide data were analyzed with Protein Pilot Software 5.0 using the Paragon protein
database search algorithm (AB Sciex, Framingham, Massachusetts, USA). The resulting
MS/MS spectra were searched against the International Protein Index human sequence
database (version 3.83). The parameters for the analysis were set as follows: Cys
alkylation with methyl methanethiosulfonate, digestion with trypsin, and allowance
of up to one missed trypsin cleavage. The false discovery rate (FDR) analysis was
also performed using the integrated tools (FDR ≤0.01).
All the data were analyzed using Statistical Package for the Social Sciences Software
(SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) version 16.0. The significant difference was analyzed
by one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). The gray value ratio of each band compared
between the groups (SV or PV compared to control) was used to calculate the significant
difference by least significant difference as a post hoc test. A value of P < 0.05
was considered statistically significant.
In total, 171 differentially expressed proteins were identified through iTRAQ. Compared
with the control group, there were 80 (42 upregulated and 38 downregulated) and 89
(56 upregulated and 33 downregulated) differentially expressed proteins in the SV
and PV groups, respectively [Supplementary Tables 3 and 4]. Among these differentially
expressed proteins, 39 showed similar changes in both the SV and PV groups. Among
them, the differentially expressed upregulated and downregulated proteins were 19
and 20. When the progressive stage was compared with the stable stage of vitiligo,
71 (23 upregulated and 48 downregulated) proteins were found to be differentially
expressed [Supplementary Table 5].
Supplementary Table 3
Identification of differentially expressed proteins of SV samples versus control samples
Accession number
Protein name
Gene name
Mw
pI
Coverage (%)
Peptides (95%)
Unused protscore
SV ratio
B9DI82
Phosphoinositide phospholipase C (fragment)
PLCH2
134,778.10
7.64
3.15
1
1.8
5.73
P05154
Plasma serine protease inhibitor
SERPINA5
45,674.14
9.30
21.92
7
11.73
10.07
A0A0B4J2B7
Protein IGHV3-30 (fragment)
IGHV3-30
12,946.63
9.10
84.62
39
4
5.29
P23083
Ig heavy chain V-I region V35
N/A
13,008.57
9.59
73.50
28
6.08
3.27
P06331
Ig heavy chain V-II region ARH-77
N/A
16,228.27
8.45
26.71
29
2
3.56
A0A0C4DH31
Protein IGHV1-18 (fragment)
IGHV1-18
12,820.29
8.98
55.56
20
6.01
2.82
P01876
Ig alpha-1 chain C region
IGHA1
37,654.23
6.08
79.04
191
35.61
4.23
A0A075B6K4
HCG2043238 (fragment)
IGLV3-10
12,628.89
4.72
59.83
17
10.2
2.37
A0A0B4J2H0
Protein IGHV1-69-2 (fragment)
IGHV1-69-2
12,660.18
8.64
59.83
33
4
1.80
Q15485
Ficolin-2
FCN2
34,000.76
6.31
24.60
9
8.1
2.59
A0A075B6K9
Ig lambda-2 chain C regions (fragment)
IGLC2
11,236.38
6.91
99.06
84
20.51
3.40
A0A0B4J1V0
Protein IGHV3-15 (fragment)
IGHV3-15
12,925.64
8.84
78.15
20
8.1
1.98
A0A0C4DH67
Protein IGKV1-8 (fragment)
IGKV1-8
12,537.18
9.21
58.26
18
4.27
1.83
A0A075B6N7
Ig alpha-2 chain C region (fragment)
IGHA2
36,590.95
5.86
67.35
72
10.04
2.33
D6RF35
Vitamin D-binding protein
GC
53,020.02
5.38
84.45
81
4.01
1.81
P06319
Ig lambda chain V-VI region EB4
N/A
14,146.57
4.85
39.69
10
4.87
1.69
P81605
Dermcidin
DCD
11,283.74
6.09
20.91
1
2.04
1.51
Q08380
Galectin-3-binding protein
LGALS3BP
65,330.25
5.13
29.06
10
14.59
1.88
Q04756
Hepatocyte growth factor activator
HGFAC
70,681.11
6.99
20.00
14
16.16
1.82
P03951
Coagulation factor XI
F11
70,108.40
8.47
17.76
8
8.34
1.75
P01709
Ig lambda chain V-II region MGC
N/A
11,557.43
5.12
42.34
2
2
1.92
P06316
Ig lambda chain V-I region BL2
N/A
13,564.07
7.64
62.31
12
4.11
1.85
P35908
Keratin, type II cytoskeletal 2 epidermal
KRT2
65,432.11
8.07
24.10
13
17.64
1.65
A0A0B4J231
Immunoglobulin lambda-like polypeptide 5
IGLL5
23,150.06
9.08
55.35
63
4.32
2.09
A0A0C4DH41
Protein IGHV4-61 (fragment)
IGHV4-61
13,065.75
9.36
55.93
35
13.04
1.57
A0A0G2JN06
Ig gamma-2 chain C region (fragment)
IGHG2
35,900.23
7.66
79.75
142
14.68
1.51
A0A0C4DH38
Protein IGHV5-51 (fragment)
IGHV5-51
12,674.41
8.45
70.09
25
8.07
1.57
Q71DI3
Histone H3.2
HIST2H3A
15,387.84
11.27
34.56
3
3.9
1.74
A0A0B4J1U2
Protein IGLV7-43 (fragment)
IGLV7-43
12,450.88
6.52
16.24
5
3.06
1.57
B4E1Z4
Uncharacterized protein
N/A
140,941.20
6.82
54.58
104
101.59
1.57
P00734
Prothrombin
F2
70,036.12
5.64
72.19
69
56.96
1.70
P02042
Hemoglobin subunit delta
HBD
16,055.28
7.84
90.48
33
11.89
1.64
P01780
Ig heavy chain V-III region JON
N/A
12,319.98
9.39
60.87
10
2
1.70
A0A087WYJ9
Ig mu chain C region
IGHM
65,700.17
6.52
66.44
118
55.83
1.55
P02766
Transthyretin
TTR
15,886.83
5.52
72.11
23
18.87
1.58
P01703
Ig lambda chain V-I region NEWM
N/A
10,904.07
9.39
78.64
22
2.01
1.96
P04196
Histidine-rich glycoprotein
HRG
59,577.63
7.09
46.67
24
24.58
1.59
P00747
Plasminogen
PLG
90,568.09
7.04
62.35
94
74.79
1.67
P01031
Complement C5
C5
188,303.00
6.11
44.93
66
91.04
1.57
P14780
Matrix metalloproteinase-9
MMP9
78,457.32
5.69
12.31
6
10.76
1.58
A0A0C4DH68
Protein IGKV2-24 (Fragment)
IGKV2-24
13,078.87
8.74
55.83
20
4.71
1.63
P69905
Hemoglobin subunit alpha
HBA1
15,257.36
8.72
60.56
24
9.73
1.54
Q9P127
Leucine zipper protein 4
LUZP4
35,936.42
9.47
3.83
2
2
−4.09
P35527
Keratin, type I cytoskeletal 9
KRT9
62,063.62
5.14
19.90
13
14.49
−4.10
P02763
Alpha-1-acid glycoprotein 1
ORM1
23,511.27
4.93
53.73
57
22.45
−2.98
P69891
Hemoglobin subunit gamma-1
HBG1
16,140.27
6.64
45.58
14
4.7
−3.12
P19827
Inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain H1
ITIH1
101,387.90
6.31
50.27
87
53.78
−1.84
P0C0L4
Complement C4-A
C4A
192,783.20
6.66
71.90
219
181.76
−1.66
P27169
Serum paraoxonase/arylesterase 1
PON1
39,730.81
5.08
62.82
40
23.94
−2.23
P02748
Complement component C9
C9
63,172.73
5.43
49.37
32
35.29
−2.69
O75636
Ficolin-3
FCN3
32,902.61
6.20
36.12
15
13.22
−3.20
P35858
Insulin-like growth factor-binding protein complex acid labile subunit
IGFALS
66,034.20
6.33
30.08
13
23.34
−2.03
P02750
Leucine-rich alpha-2-glycoprotein
LRG1
38,177.44
6.45
37.46
15
17.79
−2.02
P07996
Thrombospondin-1
THBS1
129,381.40
4.71
30.94
37
50.97
−2.17
P04259
Keratin, type II cytoskeletal 6B
KRT6B
60,066.25
8.09
23.05
10
8.03
−2.16
P19652
Alpha-1-acid glycoprotein 2
ORM2
23,602.35
5.03
54.23
33
9.59
−2.20
P0DJI8
Serum amyloid A-1 protein
SAA1
13,531.86
6.28
63.11
6
2.91
−2.19
P20742
Pregnancy zone protein
PZP
16,3861.00
5.97
37.52
119
31.65
−2.34
P02741
C-reactive protein
CRP
25,038.26
5.45
23.66
3
3.3
−2.07
P18428
Lipopolysaccharide-binding protein
LBP
53,382.97
6.23
18.09
9
12.92
−2.20
A0A0A6YYG9
Protein ARPC4-TTLL3
ARPC4-TTLL3
71,718.39
5.59
6.40
2
2
−1.57
Q14624
Inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain H4
ITIH4
103,356.20
6.51
65.59
110
85.05
−1.77
Q13201
Multimerin-1
MMRN1
138,108.60
8.15
8.63
5
5.48
−1.93
P01011
Alpha-1-antichymotrypsin
SERPINA3
47,650.31
5.33
66.19
86
43.42
−1.63
P04264
Keratin, type II cytoskeletal 1
KRT1
66,037.95
8.15
29.35
21
26.61
−1.82
A0A075B6K3
Protein IGLV2-11 (fragment)
IGLV2-11
12,643.88
6.69
51.26
5
4
−1.84
P23142
Fibulin-1
FBLN1
77,213.47
5.07
29.16
16
21.44
−1.89
Q16610
Extracellular matrix protein 1
ECM1
60,673.46
6.25
34.44
12
19.14
−1.68
P04275
von Willebrand factor
VWF
309,262.00
5.29
16.74
27
50.73
−1.57
P02647
Apolipoprotein A-I
APOA1
30,777.44
5.56
88.39
228
77.72
−1.53
E7ES19
Thrombospondin-4
THBS4
96,004.91
4.39
10.46
4
3.04
−1.62
P19823
Inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain H2
ITIH2
106,462.20
6.40
49.79
90
49.73
−1.58
P06681
Complement C2
C2
83,266.95
7.23
41.09
30
10.01
−1.73
P01009
Alpha-1-antitrypsin
SERPINA1
46,735.98
5.37
88.28
240
91.91
−1.49
P25311
Zinc-alpha-2-glycoprotein
AZGP1
34,258.30
5.71
64.09
35
37.02
−1.73
V9GYM3
Apolipoprotein A-II
APOA2
14,914.10
8.43
63.16
52
28.49
−1.62
A0A087WXI2
IgGFc-binding protein
FCGBP
44,5207.00
5.16
7.45
10
18.84
−1.63
P07339
Cathepsin D
CTSD
44,551.72
6.10
11.89
2
2.02
−1.61
Q06033
Inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain H3
ITIH3
99,848.02
5.49
38.20
24
22.37
−1.52
P55058
Phospholipid transfer protein
PLTP
54,738.80
6.53
31.03
10
15.38
−1.61
Mw: Molecular weight; PV: Progressive vitiligo; SV: Stable vitiligo; N/A: Not applicable;
pI: Isoelectric point.
Supplementary Table 4
Identification of differentially expressed proteins of PV samples versus control samples
Accession number
Protein name
Gene name
Mw
pI
Coverage (%)
Peptides (95%)
Unused protscore
PV ratio
A0A024R6I7
Alpha-1-antitrypsin
SERPINA1
46,707.93
5.37
87.80
230
2
39.25
P05154
Plasma serine protease inhibitor
SERPINA5
45,674.14
9.30
21.92
7
11.73
10.53
Q04756
Hepatocyte growth factor activator
HGFAC
70,681.11
6.99
20.00
14
16.16
2.55
P00739
Haptoglobin-related protein
HPR
39,029.11
6.63
81.03
100
14.38
2.41
P08779
Keratin, type I cytoskeletal 16
KRT16
51,267.25
4.98
27.27
9
9.89
2.91
P69905
Hemoglobin subunit alpha
HBA1
15,257.36
8.72
60.56
24
9.73
2.73
P03951
Coagulation factor XI
F11
70,108.40
8.47
17.76
8
8.34
2.08
Q15485
Ficolin-2
FCN2
34,000.76
6.31
24.60
9
8.1
2.89
A0A0B4J2H0
Protein IGHV1-69-2 (fragment)
IGHV1-69-2
12,660.18
8.64
59.83
33
4
1.70
P01876
Ig alpha-1 chain C region
IGHA1
37,654.23
6.08
79.04
191
35.61
4.58
P80108
Phosphatidylinositol-glycan- specific phospholipase D
GPLD1
92,335.35
5.91
28.45
17
30.27
1.84
P04114
Apolipoprotein B-100
APOB
515,598.30
6.58
66.10
550
468.39
1.89
K7ER74
Protein APOC4-APOC2
APOC4-APOC2
20,049.07
6.36
51.69
21
16
2.17
P06331
Ig heavy chain V-II region ARH-77
N/A
16,228.27
8.45
26.71
29
2
2.45
A0A0B4J231
Immunoglobulin lambda-like polypeptide 5
IGLL5
23,150.06
9.08
55.35
63
4.32
2.55
B0YIW2
Apolipoprotein C-III
APOC3
12,815.43
7.90
47.01
36
12.61
2.47
P02042
Hemoglobin subunit delta
HBD
16,055.28
7.84
90.48
33
11.89
2.10
P23083
Ig heavy chain V-I region V35
N/A
13,008.57
9.59
73.50
28
6.08
1.94
P0C0L5
Complement C4-B
C4B
192,749.20
6.89
71.56
220
8.82
2.77
P55056
Apolipoprotein C-IV
APOC4
14,552.90
9.19
49.61
6
5.38
2.10
P08697
Alpha-2-antiplasmin
SERPINF2
54,565.11
5.87
43.79
29
19.89
1.58
P06396
Gelsolin
GSN
85,696.47
5.90
53.07
53
47.75
2.02
A0A075B6N7
Ig alpha-2 chain C region (fragment)
IGHA2
36,590.95
5.86
67.35
72
10.04
2.24
P00734
Prothrombin
F2
70,036.12
5.64
72.19
69
56.96
1.81
P68871
Hemoglobin subunit beta
HBB
15,998.21
6.74
82.31
43
24.33
2.09
P10909
Clusterin
CLU
52,494.01
5.89
51.22
63
34.68
1.65
P04196
Histidine-rich glycoprotein
HRG
59,577.63
7.09
46.67
24
24.58
2.17
B4E1Z4
Uncharacterized protein
N/A
140,941.20
6.82
54.58
104
101.59
2.14
P19652
Alpha-1-acid glycoprotein 2
ORM2
23,602.35
5.03
54.23
33
9.59
1.77
F5H7G1
Complement component C8 beta chain
C8B
61,230.52
7.86
30.61
9
18.49
2.48
P00742
Coagulation factor X
F10
54,731.14
5.68
37.50
13
23.06
1.73
A0A0C4DH41
Protein IGHV4-61 (fragment)
IGHV4-61
13,065.75
9.36
55.93
35
13.04
1.60
P08519
Apolipoprotein (a)
LPA
501,314.20
5.58
39.78
20
29.93
1.56
A0A075B6K9
Ig lambda-2 chain C regions (fragment)
IGLC2
11,236.38
6.91
99.06
84
20.51
2.01
P08603
Complement factor H
CFH
139,095.00
6.21
59.38
138
120.45
1.76
P04259
Keratin, type II cytoskeletal 6B
KRT6B
60,066.25
8.09
23.05
10
8.03
1.55
Q12805
EGF-containing fibulin-like extracellular matrix protein 1
EFEMP1
54,640.10
4.95
14.81
5
8.01
1.69
E9PHK0
Tetranectin
CLEC3B
17,793.93
4.96
66.25
15
10.07
1.59
P08493
Matrix Gla protein
MGP
12,353.06
9.71
14.56
1
2
1.50
P43652
Afamin
AFM
69,068.41
5.64
58.93
46
52.35
1.99
O00391
Sulfhydryl oxidase 1
QSOX1
82,576.74
9.13
14.59
4
7.52
1.77
P20851
C4b-binding protein beta chain
C4BPB
28,357.18
5.05
38.89
7
9.3
1.68
P01031
Complement C5
C5
188,303.00
6.11
44.93
66
91.04
1.94
A0A087WTM7
Apolipoprotein B-100
APOB
489,827.10
6.69
67.61
536
2
1.61
P01011
Alpha-1-antichymotrypsin
SERPINA3
47,650.31
5.33
66.19
86
43.42
1.53
A0A075B6K4
HCG2043238 (fragment)
IGLV3-10
12,628.89
4.72
59.83
17
10.2
1.58
P14780
Matrix metalloproteinase-9
MMP9
78,457.32
5.69
12.31
6
10.76
1.66
P05546
Heparin cofactor 2
SERPIND1
57,069.95
6.41
58.72
52
41.5
1.75
P02765
Alpha-2-HS-glycoprotein
AHSG
39,324.24
5.43
64.31
72
35.09
1.73
P01019
Angiotensinogen
AGT
53,153.57
5.87
41.24
32
21.65
1.67
Q14624
Inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain H4
ITIH4
103,356.20
6.51
65.59
110
85.05
1.73
P19827
Inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain H1
ITIH1
101,387.90
6.31
50.27
87
53.78
1.62
A0A0C4DH68
Protein IGKV2-24 (fragment)
IGKV2-24
13,078.87
8.74
55.83
20
4.71
1.59
P02647
Apolipoprotein A-I
APOA1
30,777.44
5.56
88.39
228
77.72
1.56
P05160
Coagulation factor XIII B chain
F13B
75,509.92
6.01
50.08
31
42
1.53
P06316
Ig lambda chain V-I region BL2
N/A
13,564.07
7.64
62.31
12
4.11
1.66
Q14019
Coactosin-like protein
COTL1
15,944.79
5.54
11.27
1
2
−14.79
A0A087WYJ9
Ig mu chain C region
IGHM
65,700.17
6.52
66.44
118
55.83
−9.37
P01591
Immunoglobulin J chain
JCHAIN
18,098.40
5.12
70.44
15
9.66
−5.02
Q92820
Gamma-glutamyl hydrolase
GGH
35,963.95
6.66
29.25
4
6.3
−2.55
O43866
CD5 antigen-like
CD5L
38,087.45
5.28
44.96
18
21.83
−2.96
Q9P127
Leucine zipper protein 4
LUZP4
35,936.42
9.47
3.83
2
2
−3.96
P04278
Sex hormone-binding globulin
SHBG
43,778.68
6.22
34.33
10
13.7
−2.67
A0A0C4DH43
Uncharacterized protein (fragment)
N/A
13,312.31
8.50
35.29
2
2.07
−3.28
A0A0G2JPD4
Ig gamma-4 chain C region (fragment)
IGHG4
35,940.14
7.18
73.09
175
6.07
−2.35
P02750
Leucine-rich alpha-2-glycoprotein
LRG1
38,177.44
6.45
37.46
15
17.79
−2.36
A0A0B4J1X5
Protein IGHV3-74 (fragment)
IGHV3-74
12,839.47
8.91
83.76
104
3.38
−4.07
P05109
Protein S100-A8
S100A8
10,834.38
6.51
39.78
6
8.75
−2.39
P07996
Thrombospondin-1
THBS1
129,381.40
4.71
30.94
37
50.97
−2.06
P00738
Haptoglobin
HP
45,204.78
6.13
88.18
235
70.99
−1.85
P06702
Protein S100-A9
S100A9
13,241.85
5.71
49.12
4
7.05
−2.00
A0A0C4DH67
Protein IGKV1-8 (fragment)
IGKV1-8
12,537.18
9.21
58.26
18
4.27
−1.84
P40197
Platelet glycoprotein V
GP5
60,958.46
9.73
12.86
4
4.72
−1.92
Q06033
Inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain H3
ITIH3
99,848.02
5.49
38.20
24
22.37
−2.05
Q8IVF4
Dynein heavy chain 10, axonemal
DNAH10
514,834.70
5.64
6.15
3
2.03
−2.03
A0A087WUS7
Ig delta chain C region
IGHD
42,352.35
8.38
42.71
16
11.8
−2.75
P07339
Cathepsin D
CTSD
44,551.72
6.10
11.89
2
2.02
−2.02
O75636
Ficolin-3
FCN3
32,902.61
6.20
36.12
15
13.22
−1.64
P35527
Keratin, type I cytoskeletal 9
KRT9
62,063.62
5.14
19.90
13
14.49
−1.71
P02776
Platelet factor 4
PF4
10,844.83
8.93
29.70
2
4
−1.80
P02748
Complement component C9
C9
63,172.73
5.43
49.37
32
35.29
−1.50
P69891
Hemoglobin subunit gamma-1
HBG1
16,140.27
6.64
45.58
14
4.7
−1.52
P83593
Ig kappa chain V-IV region STH (fragment)
N/A
12,060.29
7.94
71.56
16
2.01
−1.77
P0DJI8
Serum amyloid A-1 protein
SAA1
13,531.86
6.28
63.11
6
2.91
−1.70
P18428
Lipopolysaccharide-binding protein
LBP
53,382.97
6.23
18.09
9
12.92
−1.51
P22792
Carboxypeptidase N subunit 2
CPN2
60,555.93
5.63
26.61
15
14.3
−1.70
P20742
Pregnancy zone protein
PZP
163,861.00
5.97
37.52
119
31.65
−1.53
P01770
Ig heavy chain V-III region NIE
N/A
12,898.45
9.75
54.62
24
6.02
−1.69
P06313
Ig kappa chain V-IV region JI
N/A
14,632.35
6.15
71.43
51
13.34
−1.60
Mw: Molecular weight; PV: Progressive vitiligo; N/A: Not applicable; pI: Isoelectric
point.
Supplementary Table 5
Differentially expressed proteins occurring in PV compared with SV
Accession number
Protein name
Gene name
Mw
Coverage (%)
Peptides (95%)
Unused protscore
PV/SV ratio
A0A087WYJ9
Ig mu chain C region
IGHM
65,700.17
66.44
118
55.83
12.47
Q14019
Coactosin-like protein
COTL1
15,944.79
11.27
1
2
19.41
A0A0B4J1X5
Protein IGHV3-74 (fragment)
IGHV3-74
12,839.47
83.76
104
3.38
5.97
P01591
Immunoglobulin J chain
JCHAIN
18,098.40
70.44
15
9.66
4.83
A0A087WUS7
Ig delta chain C region
IGHD
42,352.35
42.71
16
11.8
4.66
A0A0C4DH67
Protein IGKV1-8 (fragment)
IGKV1-8
12,537.18
58.26
18
4.27
2.78
O43866
CD5 antigen-like
CD5L
38,087.45
44.96
18
21.83
2.65
P04278
Sex hormone-binding globulin
SHBG
43,778.68
34.33
10
13.7
2.23
A0A0C4DH31
Protein IGHV1-18 (fragment)
IGHV1-18
12,820.29
55.56
20
6.01
2.75
P01770
Ig heavy chain V-III region NIE
IGHA1
12,898.45
54.62
24
6.02
2.09
D6RF35
Vitamin D-binding protein
GC
53,020.02
84.45
81
4.01
1.66
O43866
CD5 antigen-like
CD5L
38,087.45
44.96
18
21.83
2.65
P04278
Sex hormone-binding globulin
SHBG
43,778.68
34.33
10
13.7
2.23
A0A0C4DH43
Uncharacterized protein (fragment)
N/A
13,312.31
35.29
2
2.07
3.70
A0A087WUS7
Ig delta chain C region
IGHD
42,352.35
42.71
16
11.8
4.66
P05109
Protein S100-A8
S100A8
10,834.38
39.78
6
8.75
1.91
P01709
Ig lambda chain V-II region MGC
N/A
11,557.43
42.34
2
2
1.85
P23083
Ig heavy chain V-I region V35
N/A
13,008.57
73.50
28
6.08
1.58
P01780
Ig heavy chain V-III region JON
N/A
12,319.98
60.87
10
2
1.67
A0A0C4DH31
Protein IGHV1-18 (fragment)
IGHV1-18
12,820
55.56
45
6.01
2.75
P06702
Protein S100-A9
S100A9
13,241.85
49.12
4
7.05
1.54
P60709
Actin, cytoplasmic 1
ACTB
41,737
6
31
35.33
1.63
A0A075B6K9
Ig lambda-2 chain C regions (fragment)
IGLC2
11,236.38
99.06
84
20.51
1.91
A0A024R6I7
Alpha-1-antitrypsin
SERPINA1
46,707.93
87.80
230
2
−51.52
P0C0L5
Complement C4-B
C4B
19,2749.20
71.56
220
8.82
−2.86
P02763
Alpha-1-acid glycoprotein 1
ORM1
23,511.27
53.73
57
22.45
−3.94
P0C0L4
Complement C4-A
C4A
192,783.20
71.90
219
181.76
−1.82
P19652
Alpha-1-acid glycoprotein 2
ORM2
23,602.35
54.23
33
9.59
−3.91
P33908
Mannosyl-oligosaccharide 1,2-alpha-mannosidase IA
MAN1A1
72,969
13.17
4
6.27
−3.53
P04259
Keratin, type II cytoskeletal 6B
KRT6B
60,066.25
23.05
10
8.03
−2.99
P19827
Inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain H1
ITIH1
101,387.90
50.27
87
53.78
−2.58
P01011
Alpha-1-antichymotrypsin
SERPINA3
47,650.31
66.19
86
43.42
−2.13
P27169
Serum paraoxonase/arylesterase 1
PON1
39,730.81
62.82
40
23.94
−2.58
Q14624
Inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain H4
ITIH4
103,356.20
65.59
110
85.05
−3.49
F5H7G1
Complement component C8 beta chain
C8B
61,230.52
30.61
9
18.49
−3.162
P23142
Fibulin-1
FBLN1
77,213.47
29.16
16
21.44
−1.74
P04275
von Willebrand factor
VWF
309,262.00
16.74
27
50.73
−1.91
P08779
Keratin, type I cytoskeletal 16
KRT16
51,267.25
27.27
9
9.89
−3.22
P02741
C-reactive protein
CRP
25,038.26
23.66
3
3.3
−2.88
P69891
Hemoglobin subunit gamma-1
HBG1
16,140.27
45.58
14
4.7
−1.87
P08519
Apolipoprotein (a)
LPA
501,314.20
39.78
20
29.93
−1.82
P68871
Hemoglobin subunit beta
HBB
15,998.21
82.31
43
24.33
−1.87
P35527
Keratin, type I cytoskeletal 9
KRT9
62,063.62
19.90
13
14.49
−2.81
P19823
Inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain H2
ITIH2
106,462.20
49.79
90
49.73
−1.91
P36980
Complement factor H-related protein 2
CFHR2
30,651
41.85
7
6
−1.91
Q16610
Extracellular matrix protein 1
ECM1
60,673.46
34.44
12
19.14
−2.07
P04264
Keratin, type II cytoskeletal 1
KRT1
66,037.95
29.35
21
26.61
−2.29
P02647
Apolipoprotein A-I
APOA1
30,777.44
88.39
228
77.72
−2.94
P05546
Heparin cofactor 2
SERPIND1
57,069.95
58.72
52
41.5
−1.61
P06732
Creatine kinase M-type
CKM
43,101
5.512
1
2
−1.50
P55056
Apolipoprotein C-IV
APOC4
14,552.90
49.61
6
5.38
−1.80
Q9UHG3
Prenylcysteine oxidase 1
PCYOX1
56,640
15.45
5
8.78
−1.63
P01042
Kininogen-1
KNG1
71,957
55.12
106
54.98
−2.33
P06396
Gelsolin
GSN
85,696.47
53.07
53
47.75
−1.51
P02748
Complement component C9
C9
63,172.73
49.37
32
35.29
−1.91
A0A0A0MR46
RNA-binding protein 44
RBM44
118,116
4.848
2
2
−1.54
P29622
Kallistatin
SERPINA4
48,542
49.65
24
27.74
−1.74
P36955
Pigment epithelium-derived factor
SERPINF1
46,312
57.89
17
26.25
−1.85
B0YIW2
Apolipoprotein C-III
APOC3
12,815.43
47.01
36
12.61
−1.82
C9JF17
Apolipoprotein D (fragment)
APOD
24,158
33.49
25
16.88
−3.25
P00450
Ceruloplasmin
CP
12,2205
69.86
169
102.07
−1.89
P05155
Plasma protease C1 inhibitor
SERPING1
55,154
55.6
49
36.17
−1.54
P06727
Apolipoprotein A-IV
APOA4
45,399
78.79
71
53.32
−1.54
P20742
Pregnancy zone protein
PZP
163,861.00
37.52
119
31.65
−1.57
P01009
Alpha-1-antitrypsin
SERPINA1
46,735.98
88.28
240
91.91
−2.00
P05160
Coagulation factor XIII B chain
F13B
75,509.92
50.08
31
42
−2.27
O00391
Sulfhydryl oxidase 1
QSOX1
82,576.74
14.59
4
7.52
−1.53
O75636
Ficolin-3
FCN3
32,902.61
36.12
15
13.22
−2.70
P02751
Fibronectin
FN1
26,2625
55.28
186
151.63
−2.07
P02649
Apolipoprotein E
APOE
36,154
50.08
31
42
−2.05
P00739
Haptoglobin-related protein
HPR
39,029.11
81.03
100
14.38
−2.01
Mw: Molecular weight; PV: Progressive vitiligo; SV: Stable vitiligo; N/A: Not applicable.
The differentially expressed proteins in the SV and PV groups were analyzed based
on their GO clustering using the Cytoscape platform [Supplementary Figures 1 and 2].
The significance of the first 15 annotated functions was ranked according to the P
values. The differently expressed proteins were categorized based on their molecular
function, biological process, pathway enrichment, and cell component.
Supplementary Figure 1
Categorization of differentially expressed proteins of progressive vitiligo compared
to control. (a) The top 15 proteins with molecular function. (b) The top 15 proteins
involved in biological processes. (c) The top 15 proteins in pathway enrichment. (d)
The top 15 proteins of cell component. The log-transformed enrichment scores for molecular
function, biological process, pathway enrichment, and cell component are indicated
on the x axis.
Click here for additional data file.
Supplementary Figure 2
Categorization of differentially expressed proteins of stable vitiligo compared to
control. (a) The top 15 proteins with molecular function. (b) The top 15 proteins
involved in biological processes. (c) The top 15 proteins in pathway enrichment. (d)
The top 15 proteins of cell component. The log-transformed enrichment scores for molecular
function, biological process, pathway enrichment and cell component are indicated
on the x axis.
Click here for additional data file.
In the SV group, molecular function of the differentially expressed proteins included
immunoglobulin (Ig) receptor binding, antigen binding, phosphatidylcholine binding,
serine-type endopeptidase inhibitor activity, endopeptidase inhibitor activity, Ig
binding, protease binding, complement component C1q binding, serine-type endopeptidase
activity, oxygen transporter activity, glycoprotein binding, heparin binding, proteoglycan
binding, low-density lipoprotein particle binding, and laminin binding proteins, as
compared to the controls. PV group expressed the above proteins similar to those in
the SV group, except that had no differential expression of complement component C1q
binding, proteoglycan binding, low-density lipoprotein particle binding, and laminin
binding. In addition, hemoglobin binding, haptoglobin binding, arachidonic acid binding,
Toll-like receptor 4 binding, peptidoglycan binding, and heme binding proteins were
also differentially expressed in the PV group.
Enrichment in pathway showed that differentially expressed proteins for both the vitiligo
stages were involved in complement cascade, clotting cascade, sequestering of ions,
and reverse cholesterol transport. However, amb2 integrin signaling and retinoid metabolism
pathway were only identified in the progressive stage. The differentially expressed
proteins in the biological process were those involved in complement activation, B
cell and phagocytosis recognition, and innate immune response of both the vitiligo
groups. Differentially expressed proteins related to responses to bacterium and the
acute-phase process were detected in PV. The differentially expressed proteins related
to cell components included proteins involved in extracellular components such as
exosomes, Ig complexes, and the related matrix, in both the vitiligo groups. Functional
proteins involved in the acute-phase response, such as the sequestering of ions, reverse
lipid transport, and oxygen transport, were markedly highly expressed in the PV group,
indicating that these proteins and their molecular functions and pathways may play
primary roles in the pathogenesis of vitiligo.
Based on the results obtained from the iTRAQ-based proteomic analyses, the four most
prominent differentially expressed proteins were reexamined by Western blotting. The
two proteins (SERPINA5 and HGFAC) were upregulated in both the stages of vitiligo.
SERPINA5 expression was significantly different in both the stages of vitiligo (SV
vs. control, P < 0.05; PV vs. control, P < 0.05). In addition, PLCH2 expression was
upregulated in the SV (SV vs. control, P < 0.05) and LUZP4 was significantly downregulated
in the PV (PV vs. control, P < 0.01) [Figure 1].
Figure 1
The differential expression of four proteins in the different stages of vitiligo and
controls. (a) Each column represents one group, and the groups were as follows: controls,
patients with stable, and those with progressive patients. Beta-actin was used as
the loading control. (b) The gray value ratio of each band compared between the groups
(SV or PV compared with control) was used to calculate the significant differences
by one-way analysis of variance. *Represents that the difference is statistically
significant in PLCH2 (P < 0.05, SV vs. control);† represents that the difference is
statistically significant in LUZP4 (P < 0.01, PV vs. control); ‡represents that the
difference is statistically significant in SERPINA5 (P < 0.05, SV vs. control and
PV vs. control). SV: Stable vitiligo; PV: Progressive vitiligo; HGFAC: Hepatocyte
growth factor activator; LUZP4: Leucine zipper protein 4; PLCH2: Phosphoinositide
phospholipase C; SERPINA5: Plasma serine protease inhibitor.
To better understand the mechanism underlying the pathogenesis of vitiligo, a protein
interaction network for the differentially expressed proteins identified in the SV
and PV groups was constructed using Cytoscape. The proteins marked with circles and
different colors were identified in our analysis, and those marked with boxes are
the linker proteins added by the Cytoscape platform [Supplementary Figure 3].
Supplementary Figure 3
Protein interaction network of vitiligo. (a) Protein interaction network in stable
vitiligo; (b) protein interaction network of progressive vitiligo. The proteins marked
with circles and different colors were identified, and those marked with boxes are
the linker proteins added by the Cytoscape platform.
Click here for additional data file.
Vitiligo is a common chronic acquired disease characterized by depigmentation. Currently,
no specific curative therapy and no satisfactory method are available to predict or
control the progression of the disease. Proteomics is a feasible approach for large-scale
screening of vitiligo-related proteins to elucidate its pathogenesis. The present
study employed iTRAQ-based quantitative proteomic tools to identify vitiligo-related
proteins in the serum of patients with vitiligo. Disadvantage of this method is that
the differentially expressed proteins identified might not fully represent the differentially
expressed proteins in the independent sample. However, we generally choose the intersection
of different proteins identified in the mixed samples and then selected individual
samples to validate the proteomic results by Western blotting experiment. This method
has also been proved to be reasonable and feasible in several reports. Our results
revealed differentially expressed proteins in the vitiligo samples. Among them, 39
differentially expressed proteins were detected in both the vitiligo groups.
Autoimmunity is believed to be the primary cause of vitiligo. In our study, we identified
many Ig heavy chain V proteins and Ig chain C proteins that were differentially expressed
in SV and PV compared with the controls. We also identified the IgA complex significantly
differentially expressed in both the stages of vitiligo compared to the controls from
the cell component analysis. Therefore, the increased or decreased plasma levels of
Ig heavy chain V or chain C might be potential group proteins requiring further investigation.
Our proteomic analysis also showed increased levels of apolipoproteins (i.e., apolipoprotein
A1, apolipoprotein A2, and apolipoprotein B) and decreased levels of serum paraoxonase/arylesterase
1 (PON1). These proteins were also analyzed to relate with lipid digestion, mobilization,
and transport pathway. Pietrzak et al.[2] reported that lipid metabolism was disrupted
in vitiligo-affected children, possibly resulting from disrupted metabolic processes
in the adipose tissue as well as oxidative stress. In our study, we found that PON1
levels were decreased in SV but not in PV. This finding indicates that PON1 may decrease
when patients are in a stable condition.
Zinc-alpha-2-glycoprotein, an essential component of numerous proteins involved in
biological defense mechanisms and functioning against oxidative stress, is differentially
expressed in patients with SV. Some of these identified proteins are Zn(2+) dependent,
such as the plasma protein histidine-rich glycoprotein.[3] Thus, we propose that zinc
ion-binding proteins may play a role in the pathogenesis of vitiligo. In addition
to the proteins involved in zinc ion binding, some of the identified proteins were
involved in calcium ion binding, such as PLCH2 and vitamin D-binding protein. The
results of Western blotting test revealed that PLCH2 levels were increased in both
the stages of vitiligo, especially in SV. These results showed that proteins with
functions related to sequestering calcium ions and reverse cholesterol transport were
expressed at markedly high levels in the PV group. There are reports in the literature
that polymorphisms in the vitamin D receptor are associated with vitiligo.[4] Clinical
trials have also shown that the plasma levels of 25-hydroxy vitamin D and calcium
are significantly decreased in patients with vitiligo. Ongoing studies continue to
uncover potential roles for the components of the neurosensory system in the skin
homeostasis and disease states.
In addition, interestingly, proteins involved in other pathways were identified and
further verified through Western blotting. SERPINA5 protein, a negative regulator
of the Toll pathway, was increased in both SV and PV. It seemed to be associated with
micropapillary growth and the invasive phenotype of serious vitiligo that had protease
inhibitor-independent activity. The expression and role of serine-type endopeptidase
inhibitors in the differentiation of human skin pigmentation remains elusive. Some
studies have identified a serine-type protease inhibitor related to palmitoyltransferase
that has an effect on melanogenesis.[5] Among other known serine protease inhibitors
(SERPINs), the enhanced stability of PAI-1 might play a role in the development of
autoimmune disease and the pathophysiology of vitiligo.
Moreover, another protein HGFAC was identified and validated in the serum of patients
with vitiligo. This protein has serine-type endopeptidase activity and was found to
play a role in malignant melanoma progression. Interestingly, LUZP4 levels were found
to be decreased in both the vitiligo stages compared to those in the controls. Although
LUZP4 was not associated with vitiligo, it has been frequently reported to be activated
in melanoma, where it is required for growth.[6] LUZP4 may function to promote the
export of mRNAs, which would normally function to export proteins. Thus, it is possible
that LUZP4 could also affect melanocyte cell growth.
In conclusion, our findings indicated that the autoimmunity proteins, lipid metabolism,
oxidative stress proteins (Ig heavy chain V and C, HBB, HBG1, and HBA1), ion-dependent
proteins (zinc-alpha-2-glycoprotein, PLCH2, and vitamin D-binding protein), and serine-type
inhibitor proteins (increases in SERPINA5 and decreases in LUZP4) might be involved
in the pathogenesis of vitiligo. Even though the sample size was small, the differentially
expressed proteins that were identified might provide useful information for the diagnosis
of early-stage vitiligo prior to the appearance of severe symptoms or for the elucidation
of the pathophysiological mechanism.
Declaration of patient consent
We certify that we have obtained all appropriate patient consent forms. In the form,
the patients have given their consent for their clinical information to be reported
in the journal. The patients understand that their names and initials will not be
published and due efforts will be made to conceal their identity.
Supplementary information is linked to the online version of the paper on the Chinese
Medical Journal website.
Financial support and sponsorship
This work was supported by grants from the Public Welfare Program, Ministry of Health,
China (No. 201202013), and the Innovative Research Team in Universities, Liaoning
Bureau of Education (No. LT2012012).
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.