Generalisation about African politics and political systems is made difficult by the extent to which African states both differ from one another and have changed since independence. This article discusses whether it is nevertheless possible to understand African states as examples of the same political system, as some recent studies have asserted (or assumed). It argues that by comparing the historical patterns of political development in African states, one can identify a limited number of distinct historical paths, starting with the process of decolonisation (where there are two variants). Subsequently divergent paths arose from differing responses to early post‐independence political crises, producing contrasting forms of politics ‐ ‘centralised‐bureaucratic politics’ and ‘spoils politics’ ‐ and corresponding political systems. Further differentiation has arisen systematically from popular responses to the breakdown of these forms, giving rise to populist revolts, state collapse or to democratic challenges (and sometimes democratic restructuring). Each of these represents a distinct form of politics, and political systems, within Africa. A model of the process of political development in post‐war Africa is set out along these lines, and used to criticise several recent attempts at characterisation of African politics, in which either states belonging to one historical path (and thus one political system) are treated as representative of all African states, or in which states from different paths and belonging to different systems are seen as examples of the same political form and political process.
Allen C. . 1992. . ‘Restructuring an authoritarian state: democratic renewal in Benin’. . ROAPE . , Vol. 54:: 43––58. .
Allen C. . 1989. . Benin, the Congo, Burkina Faso . , London : : Pinter. .
Bayart J‐F. . 1993/1989. . The State in Africa: the Politics of the Belly . , Longman. .
Bromley C. . 1995. . ‘Making Sense of Structural Adjustment’. . ROAPE . , Vol. 65:
Chazan N. . 1992. . Politics and Society in Contemporary Africa . , (2nd edn). , Basingstoke : : Macmillan. .
Callaghy T. . 1984. . The State‐society Struggle: Zaire in Comparative Perspective . , New York : : Columbia University Press. .
Cox T S. . 1976. . Civil‐military Relations in Sierra Leone . , Cambridge , Mass : : Harvard University Press. .
Duffield M. . 1992. . War and Famine in Africa . , Oxford : : Oxfam. .
Gertzel C. . 1970. . The Politics of Independent Kenya 1963–68 . , Nairobi : : EAPH. .
Gertzel C. . 1984. . The Dynamics of the One‐party State in Zambia . , Manchester : : Manchester University Press. .
Hanlon J. . 1991. . Mozambique: Who Calls the Shots? . , London : : Currey. .
Ingham K. . 1990. . Politics in Modern Africa: the Uneven Tribal Dimension . , London : : Routledge. .
Jackson R H and Rosberg C G. . 1982. . Personal Rule in Black Africa . , Berkeley : : University of California Press. .
Jackson R H. . 1990. . Quasi‐states: Sovereignity, International Relations and the Third World . , Cambridge : : Cambridge University Press. .
Joseph R A. . 1987. . Democracy and Prebendal Politics in Nigeria; the Rise and Fall of the Second Republic . , Cambridge : : Cambridge University Press. .
Kaplan R. . 1994. . ‘The Coming Anarchy’. . Atlantic Monthly . , February;: 44––76. .
Kilson M. . 1966. . Political Change in a West African State . , Cambridge , Mass : : Harvard University Press. .
Leys C. . 1965. . ‘What is the Problem about Corruption?’. . Journa/of Modern African Studies . , Vol. 3((2)): 213––30. .
Luckham R. . 1967. . The Nigerian Military: a Sociological AnalysisofAuthority and Revolt,1960–67 . , Cambridge : : Cambridge University Press. .
Sandbrook R. . 1985. . The Politics of Africa's Economic Stagnation . , Cambridge : : Cambridge University Press. .
Tordoff W. . 1993. . Government and Politics in Africa . , (2nd edn). , Basingstoke : : Macmillan. .
Widner J A. , ed. 1994. . Economic Change and Political Liberalisation in Subsaharan Africa . , Baltimore : : Johns Hopkins University Press. .
Hodder‐Williams R. . 1984. . An Introduction to the Politics of Tropical Africa . , London : : Allen & Unwin. .
Zartman I W. , ed. 1995. . Collapsed States: the Disintegration and Restoration of Legitimate Authority . , Boulder : : Reinner. .