Chapter Three explores the relationship between corporeality and paint in Jusepe de Ribera’s Martyrdom of Saint Bartholomew (1644). By tracing the critical reception of Ribera’s art, the chapter identifies a common tread in locating the violence of his paintings in paint’s potentiality to become flesh. Ribera thus confronts beholders with a violence that is inflicted upon the painting as a body. This complicates the act of martyrdom to the extreme. For unlike in previous versions of the canvas where Bartholomew is shown facing a redeeming light, in this last surviving painting, Ribera shows facing us the beholders in an unresolved act of disturbing violence. For this is not a violence that will end soon with the saint’s demise – and the promise of divine redemption – but continues to be enacted forever on the painted canvas.