In comparisons of the pathogenicity of simian alphaherpesviruses in mice, two isolates of the baboon virus HVP2 were nearly as lethal as monkey B virus, a biological safety level 4 agent (J. W. Ritchey, K. A. Ealey, M. Payton, and R. Eberle, J. Comp. Pathol. 127:150-161, 2002). To confirm these results, mice were inoculated intramuscularly with 10(5) PFU of HVP2 isolates obtained from different baboon subspecies and primate centers. Some of the HVP2 isolates (6 of 13) caused paralysis and death in the mice, while 7 of 13 HVP2 isolates produced no clinical signs of disease. The apathogenic HVP2 isolates (HVP2ap) induced only low levels of serum antiviral immunoglobulin G relative to levels observed in sera from mice infected with the neurovirulent isolates of HVP2 (HVP2nv). Histological examination of tissues from mice inoculated with HVP2nv isolates showed extensive neural tissue destruction, while mice infected with HVP2ap isolates showed no lesions. Tissue samples collected at 48-h intervals postinfection suggested that HVP2ap isolates failed to replicate at the site of inoculation. There was no significant difference in the in vitro replication, plaque size, or cytopathic effect morphology of HVP2ap versus HVP2nv isolates. While HVP2 isolates replicated better in Vero monkey kidney cells than in murine L cells, plaquing efficiency of individual isolates did not correlate with the dichotomous pathogenic properties seen in mice. Phylogenetic analyses of both coding and intergenic regions (US4-6) of the HVP2 genome separated isolates into two distinct clades that correlated with the two in vivo virulence phenotypes. Taken together, these results demonstrate that two subtypes of HVP2 exist that are very closely related but differ dramatically in their ability to cause disease in a murine model.